Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be furious about sudden change?

139 replies

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 12:08

I have a lovely SIL who lives in Canada and visits every few years. After Christmas she let us know she'd be over here in May and June, catching up with family and friends before her partner comes over and they embark on six weeks in Europe.

She's due to arrive here (south coast) on Sunday after several days in London. She'll spend two nights here, then take off with DH and his other DS to various points in Devon and Cornwall, ending up staying with friends in their holiday home in Fowey for four nights. A trip to Lundy has been booked and paid for, overnights in three nice hotels have been booked. They're all getting older and they want to have a really great week together.

DH is under a lot of pressure at work and has been moody and fed-up in the last few months. He went into dither mode at the point we needed to start preparing for SIL's visit so I've been slowly getting on with it on my own, including redecorating the spare bedroom, buying new linen and towels, getting a leaking en suite tap replaced etc. I've paid a local handywoman to sand down and paint garden furniture and we have a gardener coming in on Friday to mow the lawns and do a little weeding and trimming. The window cleaner's coming tomorrow. I'm planning to valet the car on Friday. I just want the place to be as clean, fresh and as comfortable as possible — for her, but also for us when she's gone.

I've been really looking forward to seeing her again but am also longing for the moment when they all pile into the car and head west and I have the house to myself. I've got a lot of freelance work piling up and DH and I really need a short break from each other: he's been bringing his work home too frequently.

Then last night, as we were going to bed, he announced that he thought it would be far better if, instead of doing a road trip, they all just stayed here for most of the week and then went to Fowey for a couple of days. That would mean having guests for five or even six nights: extra dinners: extra days trying to work with them around the house, extra days walking the tightrope of trying to be hospitable while also finding a bit of space for me. I said no, everything was booked and they'd have a great time. This morning he's had a conversation along the lines of he doesn't understand me, I've made such a ridiculous fuss about his DS coming to stay and I didn't need to, she'd have taken us as she found us and anyway what difference would it be having him and his sisters around all week, they'd go off for a few hours each day exploring and walking and all it really meant was two extra for dinner each evening...

AIBU? It's really come home to me how desperate I am to have a week's break away from him and the domestic duties that come with hosting. I'm tempted to say I'll go on the road trip and they can stay here and look after themselves.

OP posts:
Swishhh · 17/05/2023 15:05

YANBU, could you take yourself off for a couple of days and leave them to it then your DH will learn what’s involved with hosting and you’ll get your quiet time?

ButterCrackers · 17/05/2023 15:04

Why don’t you go on a road trip to a lovely hotel and relax for a week whilst your dh and his siblings stay at your house?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 17/05/2023 15:01

Allschoolsareartschools · 17/05/2023 13:29

YANBU, I'd be pretty miffed too.
Firstly because you've gone to a bit of effort to have a sort out before SIL visits & he's ridiculing it after doing nothing for his own sister's visit.
Secondly hosting IS an effort no matter who it is, it sounds like he's planning on leaving everything to you. I agree he's planning on working!
Lastly, I feel very sorry for his sisters who are probably really looking forward to the trip.
I think you should firmly but kindly tell him that he's out of order & spoiling things for everyone here. There might be hurt feelings but I don't think you can just say or do nothing.

I agree.
He has sat back and watched you rush around preparing for the visit.

Now he decides on a whim (he doesn't seem to have given a particular reason) that he's going to cancel the rest of the tour and have everyone stay at your house for 5 days.

He hasn't accompanied this at any time with offers to help out with Breakfast etc. He's just downgraded your efforts - and minimized them so that he can say it's really no trouble for you. But what effort is he putting into this?

Is he concerned about cost.. he should have brought that up earlier before all the plans were booked. If its not cost - what is it? He can't be bothered and would rather stay at home?

I think its relatively easy to entertain guests for two days - but for five when they were expecting a road trip and Lundy Island has already been paid for and will be disappointed. I expect the burden of finding entertaining things for them to do for the extra 3 days will fall on you.

He needs to re think this. Its inconsiderate to both you and your SIL who has travelled so far, expecting a road trip.

I'd be saying no, but I get that it may not be that easy. I hope you find a good solution.

Quitelikeit · 17/05/2023 15:00

Gosh I thought you were hosting royalty when I read about your efforts 🤣🤣🤣

compromise and say three nights although I’m confused as to why your husband thinks he is in charge of her itinerary? Perhaps she is looking v forward to going to fowey

also get a takeaway one night

DanceMonster · 17/05/2023 14:59

Has your DH even raised this with his sister’s yet? Because I suspect they may say ‘no, we want to go on the road trip we’ve booked and paid for and our looking forward to’.

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 14:58

your 'greying wooden table that has been hastily wiped of bird poo, lichen and general grot'. My guests sit at that sort of table if they come to mine and sit outside and no one minds; you're there to spend valuable time together, not to judge an interiors competition.

Perhaps I'm peculiarly picky, but I don't want to be in direct contact with bird poo if I can help it. It marks clothing. I suspect it's considered a health hazard. But then I had a pigeon poo on my forehead and ended up with birdshit in my eyes as a child visiting Warwick Castle on a school trip. It wasn't something I want to experience again. I'm not phobic but I avoid park benches covered in bird poo in case I mark my clothing and I wouldn't want to eat off a table covered in bird poo.

OP posts:
TokyoSushi · 17/05/2023 14:55

Op, you sound really lovely and I suspect you might be a bit posher than some of us which is why the standards are a bit different!

I think that the real issue here is DH, he sounds quite difficult and it seems from the outside that a lot of things are dictated by him and you seem to be swept along/relied on to sort things out. I can see that you were looking forward to a bit of free time and now that's been scuppered.

If I were one of the visiting sisters, I wouldn't be very impressed if we had a lovely trip planned and now my DB wanted to basically stay at home. Can you persuade your DH to go saying that the others will be disappointed?

Nordicrain · 17/05/2023 14:54

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 17/05/2023 12:33

She's such a beloved guest that you've paid to have furniture sanded down and the car valeted, but you can't stand the thought of her being there more than two days? This is one of the weirdest things I've read.

I agree with this. The whole thing sounds insane, and I agree with your DH that you've made a huge unnecessary fuss out of it.

It's his home too (I assume?) and I would be annoyed if my DH told me I couldn't have my family visiting to stay for longer than a night or two, especailly if the house has been especailly prepared.

Re the hosting and working, stop doing it all and let your DH pick up the slack. It's his family. "No olives? We didn't buy any, why don't you pop out and get some"

Hairpinleg · 17/05/2023 14:53

Yes, be completely firm. Tell him plans are made and hotels paid so he goes along with it (and you get your break).

averythinline · 17/05/2023 14:52

he doesn't want to take tome off work and is being a dick about it..... tell him absolutely not or your going away to work on your stuff...

you do sound like you've been a bit ott but equally for longer term benefit so not completely martyr... i too am not a great impromptu host so get the planning

MsRosley · 17/05/2023 14:52

Your husband sounds like the kind of man who needs someone to put their foot down, albeit with a very patient explanation attached. Just do it, OP. Make it clear these are your terms, and that's the end of it. If he doesn't like it, go off and please yourself.

ecuse · 17/05/2023 14:49

Most (non-COVID) years my husband takes the kids to his parents for a week in summer and I stay behind at home alone. I look forward to that week more than I can possibly explain.

If you're anything like me I'm assuming it's not really the idea of your SIL staying that's bumming you out, it's the idea of not having your blissful time at home alone. I hear you !

Toddlerteaplease · 17/05/2023 14:48

I would not be happy if I was a sibling,to have all those lovely plans cancelled. Because one person doesn't want to go.

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 14:48

Op could have welcomed her sil into her home and said “Sorry you’ve got no towels, I didn’t buy any you’ll have to share with dh, the tap doesn’t work in the en suite either and be careful of splinters and birdshit if you use the garden table.
Ive cooked for dh and I, you can rustle up your own meal.

Exactly. Why invite people to stay if they're not going to be comfortable? Not 5* Claridges comfortable, just modestly comfy.

OP posts:
TellySavalashairbrush · 17/05/2023 14:46

I'd be less than impressed. It sounds like you have had a lot to cope with of late. I'd be encouraging dh to travel with his family and allow you to have some peace and quiet at home.

I also can't see why people are so outraged at you making things look nice for her arrival either.

chaosmaker · 17/05/2023 14:45

@purplevipersgrass I really hope they stick to their original plans and you get your needed break. x

MeridianB · 17/05/2023 14:45

I'm not surprised you need a break from your DH if this is what he's like!

I've been slowly getting on with it on my own, including redecorating the spare bedroom, buying new linen and towels, getting a leaking en suite tap replaced etc. I've paid a local handywoman to sand down and paint garden furniture and we have a gardener coming in on Friday to mow the lawns and do a little weeding and trimming. The window cleaner's coming tomorrow. I'm planning to valet the car on Friday.

You did all this. He did sod all. So now, if he wants to change the plans, you can tell him to have a great time but you will be away that week and he needs to host.

Then watch as he decides it's not a good idea after all.

Is he always so dismissive of you and your time?

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 17/05/2023 14:41

Why don't you break it down to him, day by day.

"So DH, on Monday, where will you be taking the kids and your DSis? What are you going to have for lunch? And what are you going to cook for dinner?

On Tuesday, where do you plan to go?

Oh, you were planning to work then? So who will be watching the kids and entertaining your DSis as I had planned to work that day?

I'm also working Wed through to Fri and will need you to take the kids and your sister out every day to allow me some peace to work, so why don't you mock up a timetable of where you'll be going and on which days and what you're planning to cook each night?"

Essentially, explain that you're happy for it to be "easy" for his sister to visit and you will be relaxed about it, but that means HIM doing all the hosting, driving, food shopping, cooking, cleaning and entertaining that comes with it. If he doesn't find that easy to mix with work, why on earth would you?

Mikimoto · 17/05/2023 14:37

"Of COURSE they can come, I love them. Just remember, though, I have that work coming in: would it be ok if I do breakfasts and then you see to everyone's dinner?"
(then close the door to whatever room you work in during the day)

FortofPud · 17/05/2023 14:36

I'd be peeved too if my week alone was swapped for hosting.

But I'd also be peeved if I changed the plans for my sister coming to stay and DH moaned about it.

If it's about the extra hosting falling to you specifically then just don't do it. "I dont mind them coming but I'm going to leave you in charge of meals for those days DH because you've stolen my rest days!" You can ping it back to him in a lighthearted way. And when the SILs arrive - "just to be clear, we've agreed DH is on meal duty so feel free to take over or order take away if its not looking good!".

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 14:36

come on that just silly, there’s a middle ground

ok yes I was being a bit silly and hyperbolic.

I get the impression that dh just expects his wife to just get on with hosting for a lot of extra days without any consideration of the work involved.
He’ll probably be the first to open the fridge, turn to his wife and declare Oh is there no orange juice for sil? Oh we don’t have enough plates and do we have another pillow for bil? Oh dear the local restaurants all booked for Sunday what shall we do?

So, maybe not towel buying but you can’t just carry on as normal and not go to effort accommodating people staying- thought has to go into what people would eat, drink, making sure there are enough chairs, beds, making time for them.

I would put effort into ensuring guests were comfortable and enjoying themselves.

So it’s a bit more than Meh, run the hoover round and chuck wine in the fridge. I think that’s a silly comment too.

Hes being rather selfish I think. He should have put more thought into this earlier than a couple of days before hand.

WildfirePonie · 17/05/2023 14:35

Stop listening and helping his work issues. Sounds like a right bore chore.

bluebeck · 17/05/2023 14:34

YANBU

I would take myself off somewhere for those additional days you were expecting to be alone. Let him host and manage everything.

He sounds selfish.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2023 14:31

Your dh sounds like a real pain in the arse, op. It's telling that you have been clinging to a date when he'd just leave and now you are left crestfallen that your holiday from his bad mood is ruined.

I get making the house nice for guests, by the way. It makes for a focussed deadline and then you get to enjoy your home afterwards. But no amount of tidy lawn and swish garden furniture is adequate compensation for living under your dh's cloud.

TheSpottedZebra · 17/05/2023 14:31

I think youve mentioned 4 times that he 'brings his work issues home' , and also that he's stressed about work and that he tries out ideas on you. So it's clearly having a big Impact on you.

But what do you mean, exactly, how does this manifest? What is going on with him and work?

Swipe left for the next trending thread