Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ignore DSS a little?

112 replies

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:31

A bit of background without going into to much detail or drip feeding.

SS has just turned 8 and stays with me and DH EOW and one night in the week (mum won't agree to 50:50 because of in her words her 'benefits will reduce').

SS can be lovely and caring at times, bless him, but is also incredibly entitled, spoilt and is prone to HUGE meltdowns and attention seeking behaviour if he doesn't get what he wants exactly how he wants it.
My DS 12 and and DD 6 just aren't like that so I'm stumped how to deal with it? Hence why I'm here and also reading every parenting website I can!!
Don't get me wrong, my DC have their moments and have had tantrums themselves, aplenty. But it felt very manageable for the most part and 'normal' I guess?

I empathise with DSS as parents had a messy break up which must've been hard and confusing for him (his mum left DH) and though they've made some headway, they really don't get on.

Mum is of the opinion that DSS needs come before everyone else's. DH has tried to explain on several occasions that yes DSS is very important but so is everyone within the family; we're all special and important. She doesn't listen and continues to pedal the narrative that we're not putting DSS first. Very tiring to hear that in 101 different versions.

I try to always be kind and loving to DSS when he's here (much easier when he's not in a strop!), do his homework with him and spend time with him. But we did have a chat a couple of weeks ago in which I -gently- told him that life isn't always fair and it's an important lesson that's helpful to learn (I think I used the words 'when I was little, my Dad told me something very important and I still remember it now...yada yada'). Anyway, because I said something along the lines of 'grown ups need to make decisions sometimes, it's not always the choice of children, but we do really care how you feel'. He's gone back to his mum, told her what I said and she's hit the roof. Saying we don't care about his feelings.

Added to that, the current issue seems to be jealously about DH's relationship with my DC, particularly my DD. Look - I completely get that - it's normal for him to possibly feel a bit hurt that they're very close, he's had his Daddy to himself before we were on the scene a couple of years ago. He gets lots and lots of special daddy time, like camping just the two and activity days out but it doesn't seem to alleviate the jealously. Which, like I said, I get. And we're trying everything to help with that. But he still stomps his feet and almost demands that his dad isn't close to my DC!

Question is, I can't seem to do any sort of parenting/discipline/explaining without it being misreported to mum. He cries to mum and she gets angry. And the tantrums are exhausting, so when he's here, shall I just sit in the corner on my laptop quietly humming to myself and minding my own business?? Is it wrong to distance myself??

For info: DH has tried strict parenting, hasn't worked, now it's therapeutic parenting and is trying to reward good behaviour and ignore bad..we haven't found anything that works yet..

OP posts:
CalmYourThunder · 17/05/2023 12:28

Poor boy. He’s had a lot of change in his life already and is dealing with having 2 homes, knowing his dad spends more time with someone else’s children than with him and his own parents not getting on. It’s a lot and at 8 years old, he doesn’t have adult coping mechanisms and so the result is his behaviour.

Let his dad do more of the parenting. You can just be a trusted adult in his life but big speeches about how life isn’t fair are not going to go down well from you when he’s feeling left out and jealous. Believe me, he doesn’t need you telling him life isn’t fair, he’s worked that out by now!

All this changing tactics constantly aren’t good either and aren’t necessary if you’re being reasonable. After all the changes, he needs consistency not more changes because you’re trying a new way that you’ve read about.

You know how to provide a stable loving home presumably? Just do that, be consistent, reassure him, and with time, he’ll start to feel more settled.

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:27

Nanny that's the million dollar question. Firstly we dont have the money for court (DSS is worth it, it's just not there). They've been through mediation and DH has had quite a bit of legal advice. When he tired to get a CAO following lots of mediation sessions (to get more access), the solicitor said it's not worth it as it's not at all binding without the full court process. His mum is adamant she doesn't want 50:50, though she's admitted she really struggles with DSS at times. At the moment she calls the shots with access. I know that probably sounds pathetic to anyone reading this, but we're trying to avoid a war at the moment...

OP posts:
porridgeisbae · 17/05/2023 12:26

I mean, you can be nice and everything but don't do parenting/lecturing yourself if it's just causing issues.

porridgeisbae · 17/05/2023 12:24

I can't seem to do any sort of parenting/discipline/explaining without it being misreported to mum

@Pullinghairout81 I suggest just leaving it to his dad.

BCCGoAway · 17/05/2023 12:24

I agree on ignore the ex and her rants. Her saying she shouts at DSS is troubling as it sounds like he’s not in a good living situation with his mum.

You and DH can give the DSS a bit of a stable normal home. So keep treating him consistently as you both treat your DC. Don’t ignore as that is isolating/ostracism and would be picked up on by your DC and DSS will feel even more left out from his dads life.

The tantrums are pretty normal at 8 only two years after a family split. Just manage as best you can. Give him an outlet or safe space to get his frustrations out. As his mum shouts at him, the tantrums could me more at your place because he feels safe with you guys. He may be letting off negative feelings from how his mum treats him while at yours because you are safe and understanding and do not shout.

He may be obliged to tell his mum something negative about you, the OW, so don’t feel like he is being disloyal or backstabbing you. The child is in a difficult position.

If you and DH suspect his mum’s shouting and such are verbal abuse, then really your DH needs to fight in the courts for his son to get him to live with you all instead of his mum. Her benefits don’t matter as much as what is best for DSS.

I think you are a really good step mum and I can see you are trying really hard to do what you can for your DSS. Your love and concern for this child really do shine through.

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:23

I get that Cloud. It's not perfect here but I think he genuinely does like it when he's here...

OP posts:
Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:22

Thanks Hank - I'll look out for that course! I did the tuning into teens course at my eldest DC's school and it was utterly mind blowing. I'm not suddenly an absolutely amazing parent (clearly!!), but it did give me such a different perspective about how teens and pre-teens think.
A course about the younger brain would be really helpful..

OP posts:
Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:20

Thanks Arucana, I love your thinking. We have to start using the point system! Having been brought up my quite a damaging narcissistic mother (she did her best with the tools she had at the time yada yada) I remember doing a similar thing with her just to keep my sanity!!!

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 17/05/2023 12:17

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:11

Some good points tea, thanks. And yes - I get a lot of what you're saying. 8 is very young and he's had a lot to deal with. I think I mentioned that a couple of times in my long OP. I know big emotions sit underneath behaviour a lot of the time.

When he started staying we made him a beautiful little bedroom with special lights, and loads of bits just for him. What you'd expect really - I'm not saying we did anything that anyone shouldn't be expected to do. And we always make him welcome, this is his home too, we've made that clear. I'll have a think what else we can do though to make him feel more welcome..

DH is trying to ignore ex when she's being unhelpful and making snide remarks and engage with her when she's being reasonable.

So why doesn't he go for 50/50?

Crumpleton · 17/05/2023 12:17

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:53

I don't think we/DH is flip flopping (harsh?) between parenting strategies. We/ he has tried something for a while that seemed to be a good method, didn't work, so now trying to factor in alternative more therapeutic methods..
There are good and healthy boundaries here, that's what DSS doesn't like I think...

TBF any healthy boundaries you put in place while DSS is at yours will only work if the EX is also reading from the same page, which it sounds like she isn't.

As PP have said you're doing your best but by the sound of it the EX is intent on making life difficult.
Sit back and leave the parenting to DSS parents if that's how she feels.

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:17

Give over whilst I can understand your perspective, I think it's more balanced and accurate (in this particular situation) to say that his mother isn't the whole problem here. She's an element in the bigger picture and I wouldn't call her a 'problem' anyway. There's no blame, the situation is what it is.

I only compared to my children, not to disrespect DSS, but just to highlight how inept I have been at managing the situation so far. And also - maybe you're more innately 'better' at handling it when it's you're own DC as you know them better and understand their thought processes? I don't know, I'm thinking as I'm typing...

OP posts:
Cloud9Super · 17/05/2023 12:16

Poor child. I’d work with your DP to gain full custody. Of course he’s jealous as his good parent has a new family. He’s left with his wildcard mum. I’d be annoyed too in his shoes.

RoseMartha · 17/05/2023 12:16

I would continue to treat him the same as your dc, maybe you all ( as in you and dh and your kids and dss), have a sit down and go through family rules that apply to all of the kids, and carry on with dh and dss doing activities together and do some as a group of 5.

I think you need to be really clear on the boundaries and stick with it. As another poster said you can not reason with a child mid tantrum, he will need to leave the room or be left in the room to calm down and then when calm have a chat with him.

Does he have any little responsibilities when he is with you eg lay the table? As this might help him feel part of the family as well.

ArucanaWing · 17/05/2023 12:13

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:55

Thanks Pot, damned if I do and damned if I don't in a way, but yes - I agree with you - ignoring (and I wouldn't really properly ignore him ever) seems a bit mean and potentially damaging. Ignoring her rants, even more than we do now, seems a good strategy. Though she can get very personal and it's hard not to let it get you down at times

The advice we got when my MIL wanted to be bitchy towards me was that ultimately you couldn’t stop her wanting to be bitchy so score her instead. Worked a treat. We used to give a score out of 10 for effort (ooh, she put a lot of work into that stinging comment) and a score out of 10 for impact. It helped leave her behaviour with her somehow.

I think all you can do for your DSS is love him. Be there for him no matter how badly he behaves. Don’t tolerate the inappropriate behaviour (because as I say to my kids, it’s important to think about what sort of adults they’ll become if I allow that behaviour to become their norm) but make sure each day that you have opportunities whether his Dad and you make him feel loved. I think he needs professional help with his. Some age approach counselling through play would likely really benefit him.

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:11

Some good points tea, thanks. And yes - I get a lot of what you're saying. 8 is very young and he's had a lot to deal with. I think I mentioned that a couple of times in my long OP. I know big emotions sit underneath behaviour a lot of the time.

When he started staying we made him a beautiful little bedroom with special lights, and loads of bits just for him. What you'd expect really - I'm not saying we did anything that anyone shouldn't be expected to do. And we always make him welcome, this is his home too, we've made that clear. I'll have a think what else we can do though to make him feel more welcome..

DH is trying to ignore ex when she's being unhelpful and making snide remarks and engage with her when she's being reasonable.

OP posts:
kirinm · 17/05/2023 12:08

He sees his dad a couple of days a fortnight and your kids - not his siblings - live with his dad. You can see why that is going to cause some issues and I think suggesting life isn't fair isn't really seeing it from a child's perspective - or an adult to be fair.

It's probably best to stop caring what he tells mum? Can't Dad actually correct things with her or does it even matter what she thinks?

Don't know how you / your DP solve the tantrums. You've called him several names but it could just be that he feels pissed off his dad isn't as interested in him as he is somebody else's children (regardless of whether that is actually the case).

Hankunamatata · 17/05/2023 12:07

I rave on about it but try the incredible years course. There's a website and you can can the book or audiobook. I did one via zoom and found it really helpful.
You can have house rules and house consequences so all kids abide by them.

GiveOverRover · 17/05/2023 12:05

It's futile to compare DSS to your own children, they aren't the same kids and they are not in the same situation. You're comparing him in his EOW home getting some confused at best parenting, and your kids in their own home with their mum.

It's unfair, and shortsighted. Happy well adjusted heard 8 year old children do not tantrum. In terms of how to handle it, let your DH take the lead, you need to take a back seat and remain kind and try to see it from his perspective. His mother isn't the problem here.

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:04

Abba I know that, and I'm not throwing my toys out of the pram and saying it's not fair!
I just haven't known best how to deal with the situation so that I'm helping both DSS and also doing justice to my DC so that everyone's happy. Obviously no one's happy all the time! But it's about making the best of it and doing the best you can with what you've got

OP posts:
Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:01

Sounds sensible Seulement, I can still be kind and loving to DSS whilst disengaging with certain parts, which are down to DH and his mum as his parents..

OP posts:
teabycandlelight · 17/05/2023 12:00

Also - you say everyone is equal, but from his point of view, that’s not true is it?

Your DH spends every day of the week living with your kids and he only gets one day a week with his dad. Maybe it is worth making him feel welcomed ?

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:59

Thanks Scats, we have asked him to go to another room and it seems to work at least some times so that's a positive. I get that about the child-tantrum brain and how it's hard for them 'in the moment'

So, when his mum has been more calmer and relatable, DH asked her about DSS behaviour and she admitted he can be challenging and she does shout at him a lot. But any 'nice' conversation they have usually then gets thrown back with her saying 'no wonder he behaves like that with you if you don't put him first'. Her stance/mood seems to change quickly/daily so you don't always know which version you'll get..

OP posts:
teabycandlelight · 17/05/2023 11:57

Hmm - he is only 8, and some kids are just more jealous/ difficult than others. Everyone has different personalities.

thing is if you disengage with him, it’ll only bite you in the backside in the future.

I think you just need to ignore ex- partner- that’s the problem. Parent as you see fit.

Also acknowledge that it might be tough for DSS ( and possibly his mum) to see his Dad parenting someone else’s kids. Think he maybe needs more reassurance from dad- and don’t expect instant results. Keep up the 1-1 time and he’ll calm down eventually.

It must be really tough for kids.

AbbaG12 · 17/05/2023 11:57

Just like you said to him, sometimes life isn't fair and you have to put up with some tantrums.
He's eight. He's struggling to process some stuff at the moment. He's dealing with some big emotions. He's only at yours once a week and that's not a lot of time to get use to the setup.

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:55

Thanks Pot, damned if I do and damned if I don't in a way, but yes - I agree with you - ignoring (and I wouldn't really properly ignore him ever) seems a bit mean and potentially damaging. Ignoring her rants, even more than we do now, seems a good strategy. Though she can get very personal and it's hard not to let it get you down at times

OP posts: