Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ignore DSS a little?

112 replies

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:31

A bit of background without going into to much detail or drip feeding.

SS has just turned 8 and stays with me and DH EOW and one night in the week (mum won't agree to 50:50 because of in her words her 'benefits will reduce').

SS can be lovely and caring at times, bless him, but is also incredibly entitled, spoilt and is prone to HUGE meltdowns and attention seeking behaviour if he doesn't get what he wants exactly how he wants it.
My DS 12 and and DD 6 just aren't like that so I'm stumped how to deal with it? Hence why I'm here and also reading every parenting website I can!!
Don't get me wrong, my DC have their moments and have had tantrums themselves, aplenty. But it felt very manageable for the most part and 'normal' I guess?

I empathise with DSS as parents had a messy break up which must've been hard and confusing for him (his mum left DH) and though they've made some headway, they really don't get on.

Mum is of the opinion that DSS needs come before everyone else's. DH has tried to explain on several occasions that yes DSS is very important but so is everyone within the family; we're all special and important. She doesn't listen and continues to pedal the narrative that we're not putting DSS first. Very tiring to hear that in 101 different versions.

I try to always be kind and loving to DSS when he's here (much easier when he's not in a strop!), do his homework with him and spend time with him. But we did have a chat a couple of weeks ago in which I -gently- told him that life isn't always fair and it's an important lesson that's helpful to learn (I think I used the words 'when I was little, my Dad told me something very important and I still remember it now...yada yada'). Anyway, because I said something along the lines of 'grown ups need to make decisions sometimes, it's not always the choice of children, but we do really care how you feel'. He's gone back to his mum, told her what I said and she's hit the roof. Saying we don't care about his feelings.

Added to that, the current issue seems to be jealously about DH's relationship with my DC, particularly my DD. Look - I completely get that - it's normal for him to possibly feel a bit hurt that they're very close, he's had his Daddy to himself before we were on the scene a couple of years ago. He gets lots and lots of special daddy time, like camping just the two and activity days out but it doesn't seem to alleviate the jealously. Which, like I said, I get. And we're trying everything to help with that. But he still stomps his feet and almost demands that his dad isn't close to my DC!

Question is, I can't seem to do any sort of parenting/discipline/explaining without it being misreported to mum. He cries to mum and she gets angry. And the tantrums are exhausting, so when he's here, shall I just sit in the corner on my laptop quietly humming to myself and minding my own business?? Is it wrong to distance myself??

For info: DH has tried strict parenting, hasn't worked, now it's therapeutic parenting and is trying to reward good behaviour and ignore bad..we haven't found anything that works yet..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jamjaris · 02/01/2024 11:33

I should imagine your dss feels very insecure after the break up, he has two homes and a stepmum and step siblings, I bet after he returns home after being at yours he get’s interrogated and she then has a go at you and dp. He is in a no win situation as his mum is angry about his dad, you and your dc and angry at him too.
He feels jealous of your dc as not only do they live full time with his beloved dad but they don’t live in the chaos of anger that is his home. He also feels conflicted as although he gets on with your daughter he dreams of having his parents living together.
He is really struggling bless him, I would suggest therapy and lots of love and routine to make him feel safe

Equalitea · 17/05/2023 20:02

I find it really sad that people disengage from their DSC. I understand it but it’s got to make for a lot of unhappy people.

If the parent isn’t addressing the issues and people feel that they need to disengage for their own mental health then it doesn’t sound like the best relationship, not being on the same page.

I can’t imagine not being a united front, DH and I have 8 children (now mostly grown up) between us that are not both of ours so we’d had our share of ex and child issues from every direction, over the years. I kind of feel had I needed to protect my mental health from someone I wouldn’t have them in my home so the relationship would end. I just don’t think it’s a nice way to live, I’d have dreaded every visit and that would have done nothing for my mental health.

I am just not sure how sustainable disengaging long term is for sanity, wouldn’t it breed resentment? It’s got to be better to just address all the issues rather than ignore them, obviously a lot harder though.

Beadyeyes91 · 17/05/2023 19:02

I have a DSS and I could have written your post! I used to be very involved and now for my own sanity have disengaged. Always food in the fridge. Clean clothes. Family time with games etc however, I don't get involved in discipline anymore to protect my mental health.

MzHz · 17/05/2023 19:00

How long have you been together? You’ve both got young kids so it can’t be that long?

why on earth would you (a) marry him and (b) have him and his ds move in with you and your kids all so fast when i dare say he’s always been like this so you knew what you were going to inflict on your kids

your h needs to move out, spend time with his kid alone and parent him properly

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 18:36

kirinm · 17/05/2023 15:40

He doesn't feel like he has to share. Your kids are living with his dad full time and he sees his dad a couple of days every fortnight. We often see on these boards posts about step kids and the divorced parents having gone on and has another child. That isn't the case here. Dad has simply moved in with other kids. That is massive for this little boy.

Exactly and her husband is telling his mum and him that everyone is important. Regardless of the arrangement you have to make the best of it for the child's sake. If I was the step child the op would call me devil child if I felt that my dad was putting another woman and her children before me on my visits. You rather discipline me than love me well discipline this.

fUNNYfACE36 · 17/05/2023 16:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Aaaaandbreathe · 17/05/2023 16:34

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 15:00

Call it what you want he doesn't see his dad as often as he should because of his mother. The time he does spend with him should be quality. You stating it's her house yes it is but I think your response to my post shows you don't get it. Ss most probably wants to spend alone time with his dad the op did say he was moaning that he doesn't get much attention from his dad. I think that is sad and you don't have to agree with me if you don't want to it's only my opinion.

Just want to add, I do agree with spending one to one time and perhaps at the moment that could be increased. I just feel strongly that he should feel part of the family and it really bothers me when resident parents limit contact time and the child/children suffer. EOW and a night a week isn't enough. Poor boy will obviously struggle with other children living with his Dad and the limited time will not help him feel secure within his new family. Dad should be doing all he can to to fully involve him because clearly Mum isn't bothered about how it's affecting him.

Also agree with PP who mentioned OP's children. They also do not live with their Dad and have had to get used to a new family dynamic where they're potentially being told that at certain times they are less important because of adults decisions that are out of their hands.

OP I know you've said you can't afford court, but would you be able to afford current maintenance payments but still see him more? So ex can't use benefits as an excuse (although, as far as I'm aware CM doesn't affect benefits at all, just amount of CM). You could go closer to 50/50 but give her same amount.

Aaaaandbreathe · 17/05/2023 16:12

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 15:00

Call it what you want he doesn't see his dad as often as he should because of his mother. The time he does spend with him should be quality. You stating it's her house yes it is but I think your response to my post shows you don't get it. Ss most probably wants to spend alone time with his dad the op did say he was moaning that he doesn't get much attention from his dad. I think that is sad and you don't have to agree with me if you don't want to it's only my opinion.

Yes, it is because of his mother and OP is trying her best.

I said that ALL children should spend one to one time with their parents, even if they live with them full time. OP has said they do this already.

I do 'get it' as I'm a step child (check my previous post on how it worked for us as children) and have been a step parent. We treated them all equally when together, and like my children, they also had one to one time. No one felt left out as we were a family unit.

I do not agree that the SS spending only time with the Dad is best for him or the family because it creates a divide and that won't help SS long term. The Mum is the problem here and the amount of time he spends with his Dad and extended family should be increased.

kirinm · 17/05/2023 15:40

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 13:08

Thank you to all the really helpful replies. Lots flying round my brain and really sorry if I haven't replied to everyone individually after you've taken the time to post, I read it all through again.

I think I'm coming away with more of an appreciation of how DSS feels. That although we've been softly-softly with many things, it's still is hard for him, and that's to be expected. He's been an only and now he feels like he has to share which must be incredibly difficult. He's a good kid, I think more time here would help, then he wouldn't get FOMO as much either - he'd probably realise we're actually pretty boring and he's not missing much!!

He doesn't feel like he has to share. Your kids are living with his dad full time and he sees his dad a couple of days every fortnight. We often see on these boards posts about step kids and the divorced parents having gone on and has another child. That isn't the case here. Dad has simply moved in with other kids. That is massive for this little boy.

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 17/05/2023 15:07

Notice how nobody is talking about your children's 'trauma' @Pullinghairout81 . That their parents have separated, a man who isn't their father living with them and a child who comes every other week who's behaviour isn't great. I hope your kids are dealing with all this change as well as they can.
I think you are doing the right things but I don't think it will do any harm for you to step back. Leave all the parenting to his dad, dont get involved with anything that can come back on you. Is it shit and does ot make the logistics harder? Yes, bit his ex is never going to become reasonable, she isn't going to change so I would take myself out of the firing line. Life is too short to take shit off your partners ex. Do not take on any additional stress. YOUR kids don't need it either.

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 15:00

Aaaaandbreathe · 17/05/2023 14:44

So further treat SS differently? All children need one to one time with their parents whether they live with them or not, but what your suggesting is a divide within a family. 'You're not his mother'...no she is not but it is her household and her family. And I'm also sure he's already bonded with his Dad given he used to live with him and he's 8.

Lots of projection here I think.

Call it what you want he doesn't see his dad as often as he should because of his mother. The time he does spend with him should be quality. You stating it's her house yes it is but I think your response to my post shows you don't get it. Ss most probably wants to spend alone time with his dad the op did say he was moaning that he doesn't get much attention from his dad. I think that is sad and you don't have to agree with me if you don't want to it's only my opinion.

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 15:00

Aaaaandbreathe · 17/05/2023 14:44

So further treat SS differently? All children need one to one time with their parents whether they live with them or not, but what your suggesting is a divide within a family. 'You're not his mother'...no she is not but it is her household and her family. And I'm also sure he's already bonded with his Dad given he used to live with him and he's 8.

Lots of projection here I think.

Call it what you want he doesn't see his dad as often as he should because of his mother. The time he does spend with him should be quality. You stating it's her house yes it is but I think your response to my post shows you don't get it. Ss most probably wants to spend alone time with his dad the op did say he was moaning that he doesn't get much attention from his dad. I think that is sad and you don't have to agree with me if you don't want to it's only my opinion.

Fink · 17/05/2023 14:50

You've had a lot of advice about parenting, which is great.

Wrt the ex-wife/mother, I would suggest:

  1. you not to have any contact with her at all. Let your husband deal with her.
  2. husband to keep contact with her factual. Text (or WhatsApp, email, whatever as long as it's written) to arrange pick up and drop of of their son and other necessary arrangements. Don't engage in any other conversation. Text is better (IME) anyway, because then there's a record of what was agreed, if one person tries to claim that they were never told something or that something different was agreed. When picking up, just say hello and goodbye, no need to get chatting. If they need a longer conversation, over their son's needs, he should ignore any attempt to turn the conversation onto emotional issues, blame, recriminations etc. Just blank it and carry on with the factual point.
Whitebeamtreelover · 17/05/2023 14:47

I’m so surprised by the extremely harsh line towards little children posters can take on here.

ignoring is immature and abusive. It clearly isn’t the answer. Where as I agree giving life lessons isn’t your place,that’s up to thr parents, I certainly don’t agree with ignoring the child. Unless you’re all good with your partner ignoring yours.

personally if I was with someone who felt that the way forward was to ignore my child I would end the relationship and I guess that’s where yours is headed.

Aaaaandbreathe · 17/05/2023 14:44

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 14:37

You're not his mother you have to allow dad to bond with his child.

So further treat SS differently? All children need one to one time with their parents whether they live with them or not, but what your suggesting is a divide within a family. 'You're not his mother'...no she is not but it is her household and her family. And I'm also sure he's already bonded with his Dad given he used to live with him and he's 8.

Lots of projection here I think.

MeridianB · 17/05/2023 14:41

For what it's worth... I'd:

Back off - let DH address this.
Ignore, ignore, ignore the ex. Giving her way too much headspace and power is pointless. This includes DH not passing on her gripes.
Up the 1:1 time between DSS and his dad.
Go to court - I have no idea what the ex means about more contact impacting her benefits. If she means she will get less child support from your DH, then yes, that's true, but this doesn't impact her benefits. DH should be fighting for more time with his son.
Protect your own children from the current issues - and make sure they are not being pushed in to blending all the time - make sure the three of you go our without DH and DSS.

Aaaaandbreathe · 17/05/2023 14:39

JMSA · 17/05/2023 12:59

My God, we're going to end up with a generation of damaged kids because of these 'blended family' set-ups. No wonder the kid is jealous and playing up! Your own kids live with his father, and see him a hell of a lot more than his own son does!

My step mum is the best thing that happened to us. She gave us a stable, normal life when with her and my Dad. My parents stayed far too long together and we all have MH issues due to the toxic home life and are now NC with my mother.

Perhaps the SS mother should put her own son first and allow 50/50 so he doesn't feel this way instead of blaming the OP for trying her best with a child that isn't her own?

@Pullinghairout81 could you look into the possibility of DH representing himself? Or have you looked at whether he would be entitled to any legal aid? Can ex afford a solicitor? Maybe posting on legal will help.

I know no one wants a fight, I'm just thinking of SS having been a step child myself. Things need to be sorted during childhood because they can be life long. I didn't meet my step mum until my teens so the damage was already done.

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 14:37

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 11:55

Thanks Pot, damned if I do and damned if I don't in a way, but yes - I agree with you - ignoring (and I wouldn't really properly ignore him ever) seems a bit mean and potentially damaging. Ignoring her rants, even more than we do now, seems a good strategy. Though she can get very personal and it's hard not to let it get you down at times

You're not his mother you have to allow dad to bond with his child.

Humanbiology · 17/05/2023 14:32

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:20

Thanks Arucana, I love your thinking. We have to start using the point system! Having been brought up my quite a damaging narcissistic mother (she did her best with the tools she had at the time yada yada) I remember doing a similar thing with her just to keep my sanity!!!

Does your dh spend quality time with his son without you and your children. I can imagine it's hard on him to know his dad is playing happy families without him. You blaming his mother is not helping him. You dh needs to be a father to his child and spend quality time with him he maybe able to get more out him and guide him on what's going on.

You have to put yourself to one side and not take offence.

Mirabai · 17/05/2023 14:30

I saw this from the inside as a kid. My friend’s mum remarried and her stepfather moved in with her, her mum and her sister. His son used to visit EOW. He always looked shellshocked and I think it was just really, really hard for him that his dad had a new family who were with him all the time. No amount of camping trips made up for that. He was sad, envious, heartbroken. Although as adults we know it would be difficult, I don’t think we realise just how painful the situation is for kids.

Unfortunately in this scenario DS’s mum is also nuts which makes it even harder.

allthebeautifulflowers · 17/05/2023 14:24

allthebeautifulflowers · 17/05/2023 14:18

This poor child. He's been through the divorce, his mum sounds less than nurturing and his dad (however well intentioned) hasn't found a consistent parenting style. When he has a meltdown, he's left alone with his emotions, as if no one wants him around when he's hurting.

He needs some consistent love and attention, not for you to show him that yet another adult is inconsistent and withdraws attention at will. I'd avoiding engaging with his mum, but please don't disengage from him

Adding also - I can see you have genuine affection for him and he really needs this.

allthebeautifulflowers · 17/05/2023 14:18

This poor child. He's been through the divorce, his mum sounds less than nurturing and his dad (however well intentioned) hasn't found a consistent parenting style. When he has a meltdown, he's left alone with his emotions, as if no one wants him around when he's hurting.

He needs some consistent love and attention, not for you to show him that yet another adult is inconsistent and withdraws attention at will. I'd avoiding engaging with his mum, but please don't disengage from him

Addymontgomeryfan · 17/05/2023 14:10

Pullinghairout81 · 17/05/2023 12:27

Nanny that's the million dollar question. Firstly we dont have the money for court (DSS is worth it, it's just not there). They've been through mediation and DH has had quite a bit of legal advice. When he tired to get a CAO following lots of mediation sessions (to get more access), the solicitor said it's not worth it as it's not at all binding without the full court process. His mum is adamant she doesn't want 50:50, though she's admitted she really struggles with DSS at times. At the moment she calls the shots with access. I know that probably sounds pathetic to anyone reading this, but we're trying to avoid a war at the moment...

Court doesn't have to be expensive, your DH can represent himself so the only costs would be the court fee. I'm not 100% sure if the price now but it was around £200-£250. I think you need a c100 form for the child arrangement order, but the gov.uk website gives you all the information you need and will tell you which form you need.

Goldbar · 17/05/2023 14:01

I agree that you should continue as you do already with DSS, rather than disengage with him, and just ignore his mum. Make sure she only contacts your DH, not you, and he can respond with different versions of "There are three children in our house and we try to meet all their different needs as fairly as we can". Just get him to repeat like a broken record.

CountZacular · 17/05/2023 14:01

Mum is of the opinion that DSS needs come before everyone else's. DH has tried to explain on several occasions that yes DSS is very important but so is everyone within the family; we're all special and important. She doesn't listen and continues to pedal the narrative that we're not putting DSS first. Very tiring to hear that in 101 different versions.

Well I don’t think she’s wrong. You’ve highlighted that DSS feels jealous. His father spends 100% of his time with your children and about 15% of his time with his own son. Of course he’s going to feel neglected. Shortly after a messy divorce he needs more attention, especially from his father who is now mostly absent from his life. Obviously DSS is relaying how he feels and his mum seems to be sticking up for him which I would expect you would do if it were your children we were talking about.

I’m not sure you should be doing anything here exactly other than showing him kindness. Leave your DH to spend regular 1-2-1 time bonding with his son and sort out the discipline if required.