Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you how to achieve my farming dreams?

67 replies

cavecrystal · 17/05/2023 08:42

All I’ve ever wanted was to start my own small (very small) farm. Enough to grow food to live off of, with a few bits to sell. I’m tired of my job but am currently renting, and was very disappointed to find small holdings cost about £400,000+

Any advice towards buying (obviously apart from saving money) and living on a piece of land?

OP posts:
Thinkingaloudcloud · 17/05/2023 19:01

It’s mostly inherited wealth even small holders are usually trust fund babes however hippyish they may look!?

I second the bills for animals is high.

Also as you get older it’s a tough life unless you get lucky with your health.

Large garden with veg patch and a few chickens?

KnutonHardz · 17/05/2023 18:48

I'm living back on family farm while my father is undergoing some medical treatment. The prices for land here (Northern Ireland) are really staggering compared to a decade ago. https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/northern-ireland-land-prices-at-record-highs-in-all-counties-says-annual-report/1825349275.html

There are so many barriers if you come from outside. As others have pointed out, the expenses are very significant. You'd need an accountant that is specialized in the area to guide you, and talk you through likely scenarios, costs, grants, etc.

I'm enjoying my time doing this again, but I've grow up with it. My father has a good network of support, a lifetime of reliable contacts and contractors, and some scale in a the right area at the moment (dairy). I've been unfortunate to have encountered a lot of other troubles I'd never see in my real day job (software engineer) including trespassing, theft, some illegal dumping. Fun :(

Northern Ireland land prices at ‘record highs in all counties’ says annual report

Agricultural land prices in Northern Ireland are at ‘record highs’ in every county, an annual report by the Irish Farmers Journal has found.

https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/northern-ireland-land-prices-at-record-highs-in-all-counties-says-annual-report/1825349275.html

PaperNests · 17/05/2023 18:40

I dream like this sometimes. Try looking into permaculture https://www.permaculture.org.uk/ this is a link to the permaculture association which is a good place to start. It's full of inspiration for how to be a bit more self sufficient in a small space. I have an allotment and have a 'patio orchard' in my rented back garden and I realised that this fulfills most of my dreams. Growing fruit and veg is far more tedious and exhausting than I realised until I got the allotment space to go larger scale. Never thought I'd leave fruit on the bushes but I've never managed to actually pick 8 bushes worth of gooseberries so I would never cope with a field of them!

Chocchops72 · 17/05/2023 18:38

my sister wants to do this. she has had a sizeable allotment for many years, so she’s got a lot of those kinds of skills. Plus we grew up on a farm, our dad is from farming.

Financially though, she needs her wealthy partner to buy into the dream as in reality they will live off his large pension while she plays at farming (she wants to retire early, he’s quite a bit older. He’s been a senior software engineer for 40+years, has a great pension plus they would be selling his lovely big house that they currently live in to fund it. You need a lot of money to sustain hobby farming these days.

UndercoverCop · 17/05/2023 18:27

Keep your job save up and buy something with a decent size garden, grow your own veg and keep a few chickens, as a hobby. What you're dreaming of has no basis in reality

KrisAkabusi · 17/05/2023 18:25

Have you actually done anything like this before? Because what you're describing is probably way, way harder than you think if you've no experience.

Comfortingpigeon · 17/05/2023 18:23

Subsistence farming isnt really a thing in the uk as you have to service astronomical bills and land cost, but only economies of scale will get you turning a profit.

BMW6 · 17/05/2023 18:20

Get an allotment (if you can - mine has a 12 year waiting list.....)

Growing food is hard work. You are at the mercy of bugs, pigeons (greedy fuckers) and of course, the weather.

There is a reason why thousands of people starved to death regularly in past times in this country - and why millions of people around the world can't grow enough food to sustain themselves even now, no matter how much work they put in.

mumonthehill · 17/05/2023 18:18

I live in an area where people come and do this and it is hard work and is relentless. You can never have a day off, winter is long, you need often to hire people in to cut crops and manage land. Fencing alone is a huge expense. Vets bills huge. They all end up having to have another income source. I would really think about the practical things, do you have contingency funds, who would deal with animals if you are ill etc. however if you are passionate and hard working and have a fall back plan you could give it go.

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 18:08

My dad to in to breeding milking sheep in the eighties and he often sold them to yoghurt weaving small holders. They were almost always downsizers from city jobs or very very posh people with family money.

LouisaMayAlcott · 17/05/2023 17:58

My parents bought a small holding back when living the good life was all the rage (late 1970s). My dad retired young to do all the farming stuff but my mum had to carry on working full time. They still had to pay for fuel for heating/electric, council tax, water etc etc.

soberfabulous · 17/05/2023 17:43

OnTheHamsterWheelOfDoom · 17/05/2023 09:15

Have you considered going WWOOFing?
https://wwoof.org.uk/en/

Not a permanent solution, but a good way to dip your toes in the water.

This looks incredible, thanks for sharing!

fyn · 17/05/2023 11:23

SIL has 40 acres and is completely funded by her parents. You’d be able to make a living on 40 acres through diversification, not by farming though.

If you want to do this, look for county holdings or National Trust farms, competition is incredibly fierce and realistically those tenancies usually go to young farmers who have worked incredibly hard and have the experience and business plans to back it up.

Otherwise you could rent a few acres but you’ll be up against equestrian uses. Contact your local estates, they’ll probably have scrappy fields they don’t use which they may consider renting to you.

Farmageddon · 17/05/2023 11:10

OP have you thought of saving up and buying somewhere much cheaper abroad - i.e. rural Ireland or Portugal - you could get much more for your money. There are a few people I follow on youtube who are doing something similar - they have a couple of acres, some chickens and maybe other animals, grow a lot of their own food, have a small cottage or farmhouse they are slowly renovating etc.

HOWEVER, the caveat is that I believe most of them have some sort of other income (even a small amount) coming in, either from renting out their property back in the UK, or from youtube itself. The smallholding on it's own isn't self sustaining. They are happy enough to live very cheaply, but they still need some money to live. But they seem content enough just enjoying the day to day chores.

But it is doable, if you found some other income stream, you could save up for a few years, buy somewhere cheap and maybe work part time from home online or something, I'm sure there is a way if you really want it. But be realistic about the level of work involved and the fact that you will probably struggle for money.

Thatladdo · 17/05/2023 11:00

Other unseen or unthought about issues will be People.
Trespassing "only walking their dog" or whatever excuse you like, causing damage to fences / gates - you be suprised how much time and money this would cost you, damaging your crop, scaring whatever animals you have, which are guarenteed to either injure themselves (costing you money) or escaping through open gates and taking you hours to catch and whatever damage they do while out.
People dropping rubish - not an odd crisp packet but flytipping. Private property = your problem.
Crops are HARD to grow productively and animals will find new and interesting way of dying ( injuries and vaccinations aside ) they are a money pit.

Dream - looking out your window at the fruits of your labour, happy lambs running playing, chickens scratching around on your lush grass for food.

Reality - Looking out your window and seeing a thousand jobs, knowing what they cost and wondering how you can find the money to pay for them, or hearing an engine and your first though is what is someone stealing / dumping this time.

It is a life, not a job or side hustle.
Doom doom doom 😆😉

Therandomtrekker · 17/05/2023 10:56

There are lots of Facebook sites which would help you more than mumsnet.
if you start with a small patch of land which you grow seasonal crops on ( garden/allotment) and keep a few chickens for eggs rather than go for larger farm animals you can at least start finding out if it’s viable to you. Perhaps get a pig or bees next as they need less space.
You could go lambing in the spring, take a bee keeping course and enjoy the good bits!

I farmed for 25 years for others all over the world and would love to farm myself but also now have a life outside it and better general mental health, it was very rewarding but also incredibly draining.

I had Children and could no longer do the 5 am start to 10 pm finishes or night lambing or call outs at 2 am night/ weekends when something went wrong or check you weren’t being burgled again with the alarms going off. Lots of Dog attacks losing sheep and lambs( another thread on here I could write reams about)
It’s also pretty much ( sometimes) 24 hours a day (lambing/farrowing etc) but definitely 365 days a year!
( For all my moans- I still miss it like crazy)

Outofthepark · 17/05/2023 10:51

bridgetreilly · 17/05/2023 09:38

I’m afraid your dream is utterly unrealistic nonsense. You need a solid dose of reality.

God that's a bit negative 😄. OP take a job in a farm for a while if you can, enjoy the life, enjoy the experience then plot your next move. Might be that that's enough for you.

Or have you thought about whether there are aspects of your dream you could achieve without farming? For example, moving somewhere small out in the middle of nowhere, semi off grid, much more nature, find some kind of work from home job to keep the bills covered, and keep a couple of chickens? I'm sure I'm simplifying it but you get my point!

I'm sure you can make a change even if it doesn't end up being multi acres back breaking farming land ownership!

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 10:18

Also something to consider is farming isna life not a job. We had a great childhood on a farm - freedom, space etc.. but everything is secondary to the needs of the farm - holidays, school pick ups, days out, birthdays, even Christmas day.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 17/05/2023 10:18

If you’re going to keep any animals you’ll need a lot of land and a lot of money. I hope you enjoy buying fencing when the little fuckers break it every 20 minutes…
Again you need to rest grazing so need room to rotate.
2/3 acres just won’t cut it!

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 17/05/2023 10:17

I grew up on a farm and subsidence farming will be harder and more expensive than you think. You’ll need (lots) more than a couple of acres as you need to rest soil so need to rotate growing areas.
Crops get blighted and die.
Different parts of the country will work better growing different things.
Keeping chickens (as an example) is a very expensive way to get eggs. All livestock animals seem to conspire amongst themselves to make sure the vet will have very very nice holidays at your expense.

EVERYONE I still know in the farming community has either given up and up to a big multinational or converted outhouses into holiday lets and that is the only thing keeping farming vaguely financially viable.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 17/05/2023 10:13

I would start off by looking for any community supported agriculture type groups in your area, or share farming or co-ops or something like that.

Also investigate care farms and city farms - a different approach to a similar lifestyle?

You could also look into perhaps applying for tenancies on council farms or something? Even the more conventional farm set ups are really competitive but sometimes small units or smallholdings come up, or sometimes councils are looking for new and innovative ideas.

Start to work up a really convincing business plan, looking at what grants and stuff could help you, get some training in horticulture and land management (I'd definitely steer clear of any livestock ideas until you're well established - even poultry is incredibly tricky now because of avian flu) and just get started gradually on the journey!
Even if that s just starting to manage an allotment or two (god knows it's hard enough to even secure one of those at the moment) but anything that gives you experience.

THisbackwithavengeance · 17/05/2023 10:03

My retired grandparents (long since deceased) had a smallholding with an apple orchard, chickens, a couple of goats and rabbits etc plus my granddad grew a lot of fruit and veg, the surplus of which was sold or given to friends and family /neighbours in the village.

I have lovely memories of growing up and helping my grandad with the chickens and rabbits. My grandad used to wring their necks and we would eat said chickens and rabbits so it's not for the faint hearted. So it is a lovely life but I don't know if you would be able to sustain a living from it. My grandad inherited the land and he and my grandmother lived off their pensions rather than any profit from the small holding.

crackofdoom · 17/05/2023 09:49

Hmmm. Perhaps start with an allotment and see how you get on OP?

Are you a workaholic- always having to be doing something- or do you like to take it easy when not working? The only people I know who have made any kind of success with this lifestyle are the former.

Another thing I notice is that people have an obsession with owning, but then often find they can't manage a smallholding on their own. So there are often people crying out for help/ willing to host someone, often in a caravan or similar.

Have a look at the Diggers and Dreamers website for opportunities both with helping out smallholders or possibly joining intentional communities. These usually have a lower buy in than buying a place on your own, and you get the support and economies of scale of doing it with others.

Living this lifestyle would probably make you MORE dependent on having a vehicle, not less- those rolls of roofing felt and sacks of chicken feed aren't going to transport themselves!

Reality25 · 17/05/2023 09:47

Your best bet is to move to a 3rd world country after saving enough in the UK.

Definitely the dream is achievable that way.

Might not be so pleasant as you think though haha.

Nestpasenville · 17/05/2023 09:45

Some people manage it. I’d like to do that as well. It is disappointing you could find them for that before the pandemic, they’ve definitely shot up in price. I guess this is lots of people’s dream now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread