Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ignore and block childminder?

269 replies

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:18

Several months ago we started looking for childcare and nursery options were not looking great. We managed to find a woman who would come to the house and babysit from 9-5. 2 months before starting she said she would agree to £11.50 an hour to baby sit 1 yr old. The week before she was due she told us her husband said she couldn't work for less than £13 so we agreed. As we were pretty stuck at that point, I was back at work in 5 days with no alternative.

She hasn't been great. At one point she told us on the Sunday she wouldn't be available that week. Then would get annoyed when we told her there were school holidays so we wouldn't need her. We have been looking for alternative care and managed to get a nursery place starting next week. We told her as soon as we knew, end of April that wed only need her 3 more weeks. So this week should have been her last week. Except we have covid. So told her we wouldn't need her.
We were intending to send her a gift to thank her for her help and send her this week's money.

EXCEPT she has just sent a message to DH saying that we need to pay for June and July as we had a contract. There was no contract. We never specified when we would need her until. She also said she was a single mother and has three children. She has repeatedly told us about her husband.

We are now inclined to not offer to pay this week just ignore and block now. But just wanted thoughts that this is reasonable and reassurance that she hasn't got a leg to stand on.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 17/05/2023 08:53

She doesn’t sound great but I think you don’t have experience of hiring people - you are just saying you don’t need her is during covid so you won’t pay her. Can you imagine if your boss did that to you - actually don’t come in next week and you won’t be paid for that week. People have set bills each month and need to rely on a set income.

Avatari · 17/05/2023 08:45

SuchandSuchandSuch · 17/05/2023 08:35

I think the general consensus is that you found someone you could exploit to look after your baby and that you employed her illegally. You are now planning to further exploiting her in avoiding paying her for the notice period. It's extraordinary that you have so little self awareness that you have posted on a public thread expecting that your actions would be endorsed. She wasn't a baby sitter - no one baby sits for 8 hours a day. You wanted cheap childcare and you found someone vulnerable and open to exploitation to achieve it. Shame on you.

She was not exploited. She told us what days she could work, what pay she wanted and was very clear that she was able to work when she could just as we were clear that she was only needed when I wasn't available.

It was not cheap, we were paying her more per day than any other person I know and we couldn't claim the tax free childcare. Our nursery costs will be cheaper for 3 days than she was for 2. She was an expensive short term option which suited her as it has done with multiple other families.

I didn't expect my actions to be endorsed, I felt the not paying her this week was unfair and an emotional response to a threatening text from her. I have accepted the consensus on here and we have offered to pay her this week. Seeing out the end of her notice period which was three times longer than one week as would be expected.

I have also said we are happy to report it to HMRC admit our fault/naivety and pay any NI due.

OP posts:
CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 17/05/2023 08:45

Meeting · 17/05/2023 08:27

Seriously? Because someone on Mumsnet said she is probably on benefits but you have absolutely zero evidence.

If she isn’t then she’s got nothing to worry about 👍

GreenWheat · 17/05/2023 08:45

Avatari · 17/05/2023 07:29

To clear up a couple of things. She was made aware that it would be term time only and for a limited time. It was a casual agreement and it suited her to, if she couldn't come, she just told us as well.

There's no such thing as a "casual agreement" when it comes to regular daytime childcare. I am amazed you thought this would work.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 17/05/2023 08:43

SuchandSuchandSuch · 17/05/2023 08:35

I think the general consensus is that you found someone you could exploit to look after your baby and that you employed her illegally. You are now planning to further exploiting her in avoiding paying her for the notice period. It's extraordinary that you have so little self awareness that you have posted on a public thread expecting that your actions would be endorsed. She wasn't a baby sitter - no one baby sits for 8 hours a day. You wanted cheap childcare and you found someone vulnerable and open to exploitation to achieve it. Shame on you.

Absolutely. You’re illegal as hell and now claiming to be a victim.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 17/05/2023 08:39

It was a bit of a disaster but we basically put up with it

you’re paying the woman cash in hand. You made your bed, stop complaining your slave isn’t up to standards.

Maltedmilk23 · 17/05/2023 08:37

I'd pay her the week wage, block her and move on.
I can't see her reporting you as she is clearly claiming all sorts of benefits hense only wanting cash in hand.

Shroedy · 17/05/2023 08:37

@Dedodee that's actually the appropriate thing for them to have done - usually a solicitor is considered as administering swears / witnessing signatures in their personal capacity and so they are paid, not the firm. It's the policy of every firm I know (even large city firms) that the individual is paid. Unlikely he'd be set up to take cards!

3luckystars · 17/05/2023 08:35

Pay her for the week. Definitely.

SuchandSuchandSuch · 17/05/2023 08:35

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:38

We just wanted to be sick alone in our own home without having to feel awkward with her here.
We were using it as an excuse for anything, like I said we were going to pay her and think we will offer to now as it seems general census is to go with that.

I think the general consensus is that you found someone you could exploit to look after your baby and that you employed her illegally. You are now planning to further exploiting her in avoiding paying her for the notice period. It's extraordinary that you have so little self awareness that you have posted on a public thread expecting that your actions would be endorsed. She wasn't a baby sitter - no one baby sits for 8 hours a day. You wanted cheap childcare and you found someone vulnerable and open to exploitation to achieve it. Shame on you.

feeedmeee · 17/05/2023 08:35

Just pay her the last week when you had covid. Don't pay her June or July. Sounds like she doesn't declare any of the cash she receives from any of her work so most likely not paying any tax or NI. Also sounds like she is not really a single mum. The likelihood of her contacting HMRC to report you is approximately nil as she would be dropping herself in it and if she did that you can just report her back, to both HMRC and benefits and she would be in trouble with both. Also, if you have been paying her in cash then likely she has no concrete proof (such as receipts of invoice) and any text messages etc would land her in it with HMRC/benefits so don't worry. Sounds like it would be a much bigger risk for her than you to be honest as she has likely been not declaring for a lot longer than you may have failed to pay tax and would affect her ongoing work with other families.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 17/05/2023 08:31

Sounds like she is cash in hand to avoid tax or to maximize benefits top ups/income. Does with another family too.

You liked cash in hand since cheaper and saved you doing it correctly. The black economy is thriving.

You should pay her the last week since she worked and then that's it. No idea about contracts but if she is 'working on the side' and not declaring then she won't take it further.

Your children are precious don't go cheap. The McCanns went cheap, in an apartment unsupervised and unlocked each night whilst they wined and dined and looked what happened to them. They will forever regret not paying someone to sit them properly.

Holidayheaven2 · 17/05/2023 08:29

To clarify, in certain situations. Not all!

Holidayheaven2 · 17/05/2023 08:28

Not RTFT but in the eyes of the law it is my understanding that where no written Contract exists, if payment can be traced, even by cash withdrawal or proven by text exchange, this can be considered as employment.

AngelinaFibres · 17/05/2023 08:28

CreeperBoom · 16/05/2023 22:28

I actually think you are on dodgy ground. It sounds like she is not a childminder, but a nanny. You should be employing her, paying NI, tax and holiday pay, etc, etc.

You (and she) should have been clear upfront about holidays and notice period. I actually think you have treated her pretty badly, though she hasn't been professional either.

Probably for the best you have found something else, and I think you should pay until one full month after you gave her notice as a minimum.

I hope you are prepared for nursery charging when you are not there, they are closed for xmas, etc.

This. You trusted someone enough to look after your precious child but didn't want to pay her for school holidays or illness. She can't pop another child into your place when you aren't there. Nursery will charge you for absolutely everything . Brace yourself for a rude awakening.

Meeting · 17/05/2023 08:27

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 17/05/2023 08:22

Agree.

I’d also anonymously shop her for benefit fraud to the DWP.

Seriously? Because someone on Mumsnet said she is probably on benefits but you have absolutely zero evidence.

Viviennemary · 17/05/2023 08:24

This sounds all very haphazard and there are faults on both sides. She isn't a childminder she is a nanny on an hourly employed rate. The contract should have been clear from the start about holiday arrangements. Pay her the extra week. Not her fault you have Covid.

Spiderboy · 17/05/2023 08:23

Pay her. I think you messed up here - you don’t actually get to decide if she is a nanny or not. It is defined and in that case you needed to be paying tax etc. from the gov website.
You’re usually considered the employer of a nanny, housekeeper, gardener or anyone else who works in your home if both:

  • you hire them
  • they’re not self-employed or paid through an agency
This means you have certain responsibilities, like meeting the employee’s rights and deducting the right tax. You cannot ask your employee to become self-employed.

Employment status

Employment status (worker, employee, self-employed, director or contractor) affects employment rights and employer responsibilities in the workplace

https://www.gov.uk/employment-status/selfemployed-contractor

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 17/05/2023 08:22

focuslocus · 17/05/2023 08:19

Are you paying her in cash? She's probably claiming all sorts of benefits as a single mother, plus the money from you (does she pay tax/ni)?, plus her husband living with her without declaring. I'd pay for the covid week and then block.

Agree.

I’d also anonymously shop her for benefit fraud to the DWP.

focuslocus · 17/05/2023 08:19

Are you paying her in cash? She's probably claiming all sorts of benefits as a single mother, plus the money from you (does she pay tax/ni)?, plus her husband living with her without declaring. I'd pay for the covid week and then block.

caringcarer · 17/05/2023 08:16

I'd just pay her final week then block.

Thirty5 · 17/05/2023 08:12

Yeah she isn’t a childminder at all, she is a babysitter with no contract.
Hopefully both of you learnt from this shambolic arrangement.
You should pay what you originally agreed. There is no legal ramifications if you don’t, it would just be really shitty of you.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 08:06

DH has just gone through previous messages and at the very start he asked her about a payslip and registering and she said no need it's only a temporary favour that she would record and submit.

Massive drip feed - conveniently after you've had your arse handed to you.

Regardless, it is your responsibility to observe employment and tax legislation

What does 'record & submit' mean? Of course she didn't say this!

I don't think you need to worry about HMRC. But you do need to be more concerned about who you have looking after your DC & the way you treat them.

Nowdontmakeamess · 17/05/2023 08:05

Gazelda · 17/05/2023 07:37

I'm staggered that you'd leave your baby in the care of someone you know so little of, with no attempt at a contract and agreed terms. With no clarification of responsibilities on either side. With no thought to insurance.

Did she ever take baby outside of the house? Did she take her to playgroups, shops, park etc.

You've been happy to use her while it suited you. But based on one text from her are seriously considering not paying money you morally owe her.

This. I can’t believe you would leave your baby with someone who isn’t a registered professional. You were the employer as she was working in your home. You should have had a contract, paid NI contributions, holiday and sick pay. She’s dodging tax/claiming benefits she’s not entitled to by working cash in hand. You are both BU.

Cantstaystuckforever · 17/05/2023 08:04

mightymam · 17/05/2023 07:35

She's wasn't employed though? Seems like this was a casual verbal agreement/arrangement without a contract. The minder/nanny sounds like she couldn't be arsed minding OPs child and OP sounds like she was just using her until something better came along. They shouldn't pay her anything more than they already have and tell her to stop harassing them or they'd report her. I'd also be prepared to be ostracised by the other parents she minds for as she'll go in all guns blazing and speak really badly of the OP and they'll side with her because they rely on her for childcare!

Legally, you're incorrect. Verbal or written, you can't opt out of your responsibilities as an employer - and in this case, with regular employment at the OP's choice of time and at her house, this is employment.

The nanny (because she is a nanny) sounds like a difficult employee and with a written contract could have been in breach anyway with no notice for leave etc. But the OP has more responsibility - she's meant to have paid NI, organised insurance and given paid leave, and paid all year unless agreed. That's why there are written contracts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread