Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ignore and block childminder?

269 replies

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:18

Several months ago we started looking for childcare and nursery options were not looking great. We managed to find a woman who would come to the house and babysit from 9-5. 2 months before starting she said she would agree to £11.50 an hour to baby sit 1 yr old. The week before she was due she told us her husband said she couldn't work for less than £13 so we agreed. As we were pretty stuck at that point, I was back at work in 5 days with no alternative.

She hasn't been great. At one point she told us on the Sunday she wouldn't be available that week. Then would get annoyed when we told her there were school holidays so we wouldn't need her. We have been looking for alternative care and managed to get a nursery place starting next week. We told her as soon as we knew, end of April that wed only need her 3 more weeks. So this week should have been her last week. Except we have covid. So told her we wouldn't need her.
We were intending to send her a gift to thank her for her help and send her this week's money.

EXCEPT she has just sent a message to DH saying that we need to pay for June and July as we had a contract. There was no contract. We never specified when we would need her until. She also said she was a single mother and has three children. She has repeatedly told us about her husband.

We are now inclined to not offer to pay this week just ignore and block now. But just wanted thoughts that this is reasonable and reassurance that she hasn't got a leg to stand on.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 17/05/2023 09:49

HaveSomeIntrospect · 16/05/2023 23:07

using Your description, she meets the legal definition of a nanny.
You were employing her illegally by not paying her minimum wage plus tax and ni.
She was not a childminder

If she was being paid minimum wage then tax and national insurance are deducted from the salary. So she would have ended up with less

Mumsanetta · 17/05/2023 09:45

Ladybug14 · 17/05/2023 05:33

You can say what you like, OP, but if she reports you to HMRC, then you will be fined.

I'd pay her for her final month and learn from this.

“You will be fined”. Who died and made you the official voice of HMRC?

@Avatari ignore the scaremongering. You’ve learned the lesson and you’re fine not to pay for June and July. I wouldn’t give it another thought as this woman is highly unlikely to be declaring her income to HMRC let alone trying to report you!

gamerchick · 17/05/2023 09:44

FFS. Some by the book people don't live in the real world. This shit goes on all over.

I have also said we are happy to report it to HMRC admit our fault/naivety and pay any NI due

Start with that when you tell her you're paying for the week you didn't need her. You'll not see her for dust.

Learn your lessons and do it properly next time, rather than a random.

Kennykenkencat · 17/05/2023 09:37

Ladybug14 · 17/05/2023 05:33

You can say what you like, OP, but if she reports you to HMRC, then you will be fined.

I'd pay her for her final month and learn from this.

She might report and op and her husband might get fined but that is nothing to the fine she will receive for not declaring her cash in hand earnings

Myalternate · 17/05/2023 09:34

Fairly simple solution to this.

Ask for her Tax Code, NI number. Use a salary calculator (google them) enter her details and her weekly payment. It will calculate what tax/NI is due, if any. Payment to HMRC can be made quarterly if you’re a ‘small employer’
Under 2 years employment you don’t have to have a reason to dispense with her services. If she’s paid weekly, you are only required to give her one weeks notice unless an agreement exists that longer notice is required.

I’m sure she’ll provide the necessary.

maddening · 17/05/2023 09:32

Allbymyself44 · 17/05/2023 05:24

You only gave her 3 weeks notice? That's appalling. It's someone's livelihood and life regardless of how flaky someone is. Bills still have to be paid and food needs to be put on the table.

She has only worked there for a few months 2 days a week and paid weekly - 3 weeks is ample imo

Muu · 17/05/2023 09:25

It sounds like there was wrong on both sides and now it’s a mess. You need to properly employ a nanny (as you now know!)

I sympathise. I have a nanny because I can’t use a childminder or nursery. She is great but it took me a while to find her. Much easier to use a nursery if you can.

whowhatwerewhy · 17/05/2023 09:22

Personally I would pay her for this week then block.
Should she kick up a fuss I would mention sending your payment records to HMRC , I doubt if she's been been declaring any income.

Fighterofthenightman1 · 17/05/2023 09:21

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/05/2023 09:12

The term Cash in hand means cash is paid without records kept and won't be declared to HMRC, have vat paid etc. This is illegal.

It's obviously not illegal to pay someone in cash as long as there's an invoice or payslip, or it's for very occasional low value work such as genuine babysitting

The term 'cash in hand' doesn't just mean that at all

It means being paid in cash

ejbaxa · 17/05/2023 09:15

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/05/2023 22:34

Also what difference does covid make? Are people really still using that as an excuse? Surely most employers would just tell you to go to work regardless

Please stop thinking this. It is just not true for a fair number of people. Covid took me down for several weeks and put my db in intensive care (triple jabbed). I have no health conditions or risks and am 45 and had all jabs.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/05/2023 09:12

Fighterofthenightman1 · 17/05/2023 09:07

Cash in hand isn't illegal lol

The term Cash in hand means cash is paid without records kept and won't be declared to HMRC, have vat paid etc. This is illegal.

It's obviously not illegal to pay someone in cash as long as there's an invoice or payslip, or it's for very occasional low value work such as genuine babysitting

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 17/05/2023 09:11

sleepingdragon · 16/05/2023 22:24

How often did you pay her? You did have a contract even if it wasn't a written one, and so need to pay her notice period. It sounds like you were her employer, so whatever reasons you have for not wanting her to work for you anymore I would be careful not to end up in an employment tribunal especially if you have not properly set up the contract.

😆😆😆

”An employment tribunal”! Over a bit of casual babysitting over the course of a few weeks!

MN never fails to deliver.

Whenharrymetsmelly · 17/05/2023 09:09

CreeperBoom · 16/05/2023 22:28

I actually think you are on dodgy ground. It sounds like she is not a childminder, but a nanny. You should be employing her, paying NI, tax and holiday pay, etc, etc.

You (and she) should have been clear upfront about holidays and notice period. I actually think you have treated her pretty badly, though she hasn't been professional either.

Probably for the best you have found something else, and I think you should pay until one full month after you gave her notice as a minimum.

I hope you are prepared for nursery charging when you are not there, they are closed for xmas, etc.

I agree with this, you pay for what you get unfortunately and it's probably karma for trying to avoid paying tax etc

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/05/2023 09:08

Cattenberg · 17/05/2023 09:02

The rules surrounding this are so complicated. I thought that if a nanny or cleaner worked for more than one family, she was classed as self-employed and responsible for paying her own income tax and NI. Is that incorrect?

There are several things - whether the worker provides their own equipment, whether they can send someone else in their place if they want, whether they have choice over their working hours, there are more that I can't remember. Generally if you work regular hours and don't provide your own equipment and it has to be you that turns up (all of which apply to nannies) you would be considered employed.

It's not straightforward to decide - there's no single rule.

samestyle · 17/05/2023 09:08

No contract, no pay, after changing her hourly rate and times with you last minute, she's seeing what else she can get away with, tell her to do one.

Fighterofthenightman1 · 17/05/2023 09:07

cyncope · 16/05/2023 22:37

She's not a babysitter or a childminder.

You were employing her 9-5 to work in your home.
Sounds like you were doing so without fulfilling your legal responsibilities by registering as an employer and deducting tax and NI.

I think you should pay her a month's notice and next time do some research before you employ someone. Cash in hand is illegal.

Cash in hand isn't illegal lol

SherbetDips · 17/05/2023 09:04

Ok first it all she’s not a babysitter she’s a nanny if she’s providing care in your home whilst children are awake and needing care she is a nanny.

you have to employ a nanny and pay her tax and Ni,

and nannys don’t have to be ofsted registered by law. Only childminders.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/05/2023 09:04

Avatari · 17/05/2023 09:00

We pay the nursery 50 weeks a year regardless of whether baby is in or not. I thought that was standard?

With ours you can have a term time only contract where you pay for at least one day during every week of the year but you only pay the rest of the days during term time.

You would need to ask though - they don't advertise it

Cattenberg · 17/05/2023 09:02

The rules surrounding this are so complicated. I thought that if a nanny or cleaner worked for more than one family, she was classed as self-employed and responsible for paying her own income tax and NI. Is that incorrect?

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/05/2023 09:01

Presumably the whole thing is a result of there being a huge shortage of nursery places. And from the sound of it this woman is regularly employed by desperate parents. I guess the alternative is OP loses her job.
Yet another result of the inadequate Tory government.

Avatari · 17/05/2023 09:00

Butchyrestingface · 17/05/2023 08:58

She sounds a bit flakey and unreliable but you are worse. Best for everyone, not least your child, that you're knocking the nanny (not "babysitter") arrangement on the head and going the nursery route.

Btw, what arrangements do nurseries have in place vis-a-vis parents not wanting to use/pay for childcare during school holidays, the summer, etc?

We pay the nursery 50 weeks a year regardless of whether baby is in or not. I thought that was standard?

OP posts:
MrMucker · 17/05/2023 09:00

Contact HMRC , say
"Dear HMRC I have decided on a person I would like to engage to care for our child during working hours. Please could you clarify my obligations re payment of tax and any other deductions.
As I have used this person already a few times on a casual basis, could you also clarify if any payments by me are outstanding for this period? I am happy to provide any details you require"

That covers you.

Then write to childminder/whatever she is job-title wise, say
"Dear Childminder
Thanks for your message. I have contacted HMRC to clarify both our obligations, and apologise if there is a delay. I am of course paying you for hours worked, but also need to wait to hear back from them so that I can organise correct pay records for what you have earned. "

You wont be in any trouble whatsoever if you do this, but she might.
Hey ho. That's how she chose to work.

Butchyrestingface · 17/05/2023 08:58

She sounds a bit flakey and unreliable but you are worse. Best for everyone, not least your child, that you're knocking the nanny (not "babysitter") arrangement on the head and going the nursery route.

Btw, what arrangements do nurseries have in place vis-a-vis parents not wanting to use/pay for childcare during school holidays, the summer, etc?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/05/2023 08:54

She told us what days she could work, what pay she wanted and was very clear that she was able to work when she could just as we were clear that she was only needed when I wasn't available.

I really struggle to believe that you'd pay through the nose for something as unreliable and inconsistent as this. And if it is true, why do you then describe it in your OP as her "not being great", if it's what you agreed to in the first place?

SeasonFinale · 17/05/2023 08:54

cyncope · 16/05/2023 22:38

Babysitters look after children in the evenings while they're in bed.

It doesn't really matter what title you give her, she was working for you as a 'home childcarer', regular days and hours so this should have been an employment.

Babysitters can work at any time of the day

Swipe left for the next trending thread