Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ignore and block childminder?

269 replies

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:18

Several months ago we started looking for childcare and nursery options were not looking great. We managed to find a woman who would come to the house and babysit from 9-5. 2 months before starting she said she would agree to £11.50 an hour to baby sit 1 yr old. The week before she was due she told us her husband said she couldn't work for less than £13 so we agreed. As we were pretty stuck at that point, I was back at work in 5 days with no alternative.

She hasn't been great. At one point she told us on the Sunday she wouldn't be available that week. Then would get annoyed when we told her there were school holidays so we wouldn't need her. We have been looking for alternative care and managed to get a nursery place starting next week. We told her as soon as we knew, end of April that wed only need her 3 more weeks. So this week should have been her last week. Except we have covid. So told her we wouldn't need her.
We were intending to send her a gift to thank her for her help and send her this week's money.

EXCEPT she has just sent a message to DH saying that we need to pay for June and July as we had a contract. There was no contract. We never specified when we would need her until. She also said she was a single mother and has three children. She has repeatedly told us about her husband.

We are now inclined to not offer to pay this week just ignore and block now. But just wanted thoughts that this is reasonable and reassurance that she hasn't got a leg to stand on.

OP posts:
anyolddinosaur · 18/05/2023 07:31

She was not a babysitter, she was your nanny.

Of course you should pay her the full notice period you had given her, being sick doesnt mean you dont pay.

Nursery will often refuse to take a sick child and you may need emergency child care in future.

Morally you should have given her 4weeks notice, you dont have the moral high ground you think you have.

Scirocco · 18/05/2023 07:20

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/05/2023 22:34

Also what difference does covid make? Are people really still using that as an excuse? Surely most employers would just tell you to go to work regardless

If people are off work sick, their childcare needs will change.

If people know they're ill with what can still be a nasty, nasty virus, they might still want to minimise opportunities for it to spread, through reducing social contacts.

One of my relatives has just spent a month in and out of hospital due to COVID and complications arising from it. Just because a virus has become endemic, doesn't mean it can't still be very unpleasant.

Rather than just sharing our germs with each other, the responsible thing to do with any contagious illness (eg norovirus, COVID) is to risk assess our own circumstances and look for ways to reduce the risk of spreading germs unnecessarily.

Ilovelurchers · 18/05/2023 07:17

She may not have been an easy person to work with, but nontheless it must be pretty horrible and scary to suddenly find yourself out of a job with only 3 weeks notice.

You definitely need to pay her this next week, I would think, and personally I would give her more notice/pay that also if I could possibly afford to without my own family suffering. Whatever the legal technicalities, I think that is the compassionate and just thing to do, IF you are in a position to (you may not be).

Good luck OP.

Houseupdate · 18/05/2023 07:14

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:26

It was cash in hand. She was essentially a babysitter. It was a bit of a disaster but we basically put up with it until we could find alternative care.

And this is why what happens when you try to defraud the government and care so little for your child you ‘employ’ someone with out DBS check and choose not to pay NI, pensions, holiday and sick pay. If you don’t treat others fairly you can only expect the same back.

Fiddlefall · 18/05/2023 07:11

And yes under the table includes cash in hand, taxes not paid, no contract etc

Fiddlefall · 18/05/2023 07:09

Yes good idea to pay the one week pay and forget her other demands. Though I don't think it's about taking the "high road" as you've said, but the bare minimum. You can't just randomly revoke salary because she sent an annoying text.

I've not hired a nanny in the UK but have in the US (this arrangement would count as a nanny, even under the table) and they're very big on something called 'guaranteed hours'. Basically you've asked them to set aside certain timeslots for you, so if you cancel at the last minute, you're still obligated to pay them for that reserved time. Of course there's reciprocal flexibility on both sides (eg you've said she gave you 2 days notice for a day's absence), but it sounds like there was little to no notice of a whole week's lost income.

SunflowerTed · 18/05/2023 07:08

There’s a lot of nasty judgement on here. OP’s husband was there the whole time and this lady was recommended and dbs checked. Some of you are making out this babysitter is has been treated as a slave where it sounds like a mutual agreement (which OP regrets) . The babysitter is holidaying in Florida and was happy to accept cash!!!!

amymumoftwo · 18/05/2023 07:04

you did NOT have a childminder you hired a nanny! It’s so ignorant that people still do not educate themselves on this considering you are giving them responsibility of your children. I have been both a nanny and childminder and it’s by far the most insulting thing when parents don’t even educate themselves on this.
Because she was a nanny you employed her. I would never have accepted a job with no contract and no notice period, but because she has then she has left herself open to potentially not being paid notice. But also it’s immoral to just not pay her what she is owed and blocking her is just childish. End things in a civil way and move on with a lesson learned.

SpringIntoChaos · 18/05/2023 06:56

AIbaa · 17/05/2023 07:07

You're on very dodgy ground you've been paying her cash in hand for a regular agreement. I would have paid her 4 weeks notice from when you gave the notice.

Oh behave! 🤦‍♀️ You really wouldn't in these circumstances! Both of them dodging HMRC, cash in hand, no contract, weekly paid!

I agree that the whole set up is beyond dodgy, but so much bloody virtue signalling on this thread!!

SpringIntoChaos · 18/05/2023 06:51

Ladybug14 · 17/05/2023 05:33

You can say what you like, OP, but if she reports you to HMRC, then you will be fined.

I'd pay her for her final month and learn from this.

Seriously though...what are the chances of the 'nanny' reporting OP to HMRC, when she herself is quite flagrantly dodging HMRC?? I would guess zero chance! 🤷‍♀️

Bogeyes · 18/05/2023 06:18

I wouldn't pay a penny and threaten her with benefits office and hmrc if she won't give up.

Starlitestarbright · 18/05/2023 06:16

You haven't covered yourself in glory. I agree you did exploit her you can change the narrative to say it was a casual arrangement but that wasn't the case when she went away with 2 days notice and you were annoyed. It was a regular nanny service for 2 days. Nanny's cost alot more than what you paid. I'm gobsmacked you basically had an unqualified unlicensed stranger take care of your baby. I think you knew full well she was picking up extra in cash and hand which is why you were wanting to pay her when you were sick.

Zanatdy · 18/05/2023 06:04

You should pay her yes for this week but not until July when you had no contract. You should have also made clear if you were paying her in the holidays or not (and if you needed her in holidays as doesn’t sound like she knew that). But yeah, cash in hand is not good, you’re lucky nothing bad happened as she doesn’t sound like she’s very good if not even registered etc

AuntMarch · 18/05/2023 04:54

SingleMumStruggling · 17/05/2023 10:25

Yes you are allowed to pay someone to look after your child - people give money to family members all the time to look after their kids on a regular basis. Also many nannies are self employed.

Where are you getting this information?

I think you can only claim UC/tax free for registered providers, which may have caused confusion.
Nannies themselves don't have to be registered though.

cyncope · 17/05/2023 23:23

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 22:13

I’d put it in the same category as asking a nursery worker or a neighbour’s teenage daughter to do a bit of casual baby sitting once or twice a week and paying them cash?

The nursery workers at my niece’s nursery regularly get asked to do this.
Both parties benefit don’t they?

Obviously no formal agreements are agreed so any disputes over pay are a civil matter.

9-5 two days a week isn't the odd bit of casual babysitting.

LadyJ2023 · 17/05/2023 23:08

Sounds like you got a real child minder for your very young child...Not!!!

SophieBu · 17/05/2023 22:33

Legally with or without a written contract you have a weeks notice (until 2 years employment), you gave her 3 and tbh she didn’t deserve that. I would pay her final week personally because I feel guilty about everything. I think from there block her and hope she takes them win.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 22:13

I’d put it in the same category as asking a nursery worker or a neighbour’s teenage daughter to do a bit of casual baby sitting once or twice a week and paying them cash?

The nursery workers at my niece’s nursery regularly get asked to do this.
Both parties benefit don’t they?

Obviously no formal agreements are agreed so any disputes over pay are a civil matter.

SuchandSuchandSuch · 17/05/2023 21:50

No it isn't a case of 'needs must in a difficult situation' as a justification for using ' 'cheap casual labour'. The OP was employing someone to look after her baby. 'Cheap casual labour' is amoral in any context - it inhumanises and commodities people - but it's a no-brainer in this context. 'Cheap casual labour' is exploitative. Exploiting people to look after your baby is not very sensible.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 21:43

It sounds like this woman worked for a while in a school, hence the DBS check and reference from an education setting,
and is now doing a bit of casual baby sitting in the local area off the back of that?

It sounds like she was capable and provided the ad hoc baby sitting you required and others vouched for her, but she’s shockingly unprofessional in any sort of business sense.

I don’t think you’ve made any huge error of judgment. Presumably you knew she was a cash in hand baby sitter and resorted to using her fully aware that she was cheap casual labour?
It was a case of needs must in a difficult situation.

Avatari · 17/05/2023 17:18

Thinkingpod · 17/05/2023 17:04

Why the heck would you leave your baby with someone you don't know have no formal contract with, who has no db's or safeguarding proof and no references

A few people have made comments like this. She does have a DBS and I got two references, including one from an education setting, and she was never left alone with baby. DH works from home and the baby and childminder were in full view and earshot of him the entire time.

OP posts:
Thinkingpod · 17/05/2023 17:04

Why the heck would you leave your baby with someone you don't know have no formal contract with, who has no db's or safeguarding proof and no references

Dingdong90 · 17/05/2023 16:54

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:26

It was cash in hand. She was essentially a babysitter. It was a bit of a disaster but we basically put up with it until we could find alternative care.

If its cash in hand ,you really have no obligation to pay her any notice really unless this was berbally agreed at the start .She can't legally do anything if she possibly hasn't been declaring the income either . I'd probably pay for the week you had covid as that isn't her fault then tell her she's not getting anymore as she isn't needed

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 15:57

That's true @evuscha

Just don't know why OP hides
still behind the fiction that she didn't know the employment situation. She knew well.

evuscha · 17/05/2023 15:55

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 15:44

Also decided to text doctor about how they did NI/Tax that we'd fucked up. Turns out they understood her to have set herself up as a limited company so she should be self employed and providing a service and have it in writing. She has provided temporary childcare/help/babysitting/nannying for other families in same way.

If that was the basis on which you assumed she was working, based on the doctor's information, then you'd have expected invoices, paperwork & a contract to issue. Of course you would.

It's clear you employed her casually without thinking what that meant. You were unhappy & dismissive of the way she performed, without recognising that you didn't treat her well, either. Not paying her when you didn't need her, when you were sick.

I don't mean even regarding employment law, or HMRC. Just morally or ethically I can't imagine that you thought any of this was ok, either from your side or hers.

At least you've a new arrangement in place now & matters are concluded with the minder.

“The doctor” isn’t going to openly admit that he’s evading employing her properly, of course he’s going to be saying he thought she was self employed, just like OP.

The nanny most likely isn’t even doing any benefit fraud etc, she just knows she would have a lot smaller pool of jobs to choose from if she insisted on proper contracts, NI/tax etc.