Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ignore and block childminder?

269 replies

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:18

Several months ago we started looking for childcare and nursery options were not looking great. We managed to find a woman who would come to the house and babysit from 9-5. 2 months before starting she said she would agree to £11.50 an hour to baby sit 1 yr old. The week before she was due she told us her husband said she couldn't work for less than £13 so we agreed. As we were pretty stuck at that point, I was back at work in 5 days with no alternative.

She hasn't been great. At one point she told us on the Sunday she wouldn't be available that week. Then would get annoyed when we told her there were school holidays so we wouldn't need her. We have been looking for alternative care and managed to get a nursery place starting next week. We told her as soon as we knew, end of April that wed only need her 3 more weeks. So this week should have been her last week. Except we have covid. So told her we wouldn't need her.
We were intending to send her a gift to thank her for her help and send her this week's money.

EXCEPT she has just sent a message to DH saying that we need to pay for June and July as we had a contract. There was no contract. We never specified when we would need her until. She also said she was a single mother and has three children. She has repeatedly told us about her husband.

We are now inclined to not offer to pay this week just ignore and block now. But just wanted thoughts that this is reasonable and reassurance that she hasn't got a leg to stand on.

OP posts:
eveoha · 18/05/2023 12:14

I’d just hope she wasn’t privy to your private info 🙄👍🏿☘️

SmileyClare · 18/05/2023 11:46

I also think posters are quick to demonise the “baby sitter” and label her a tax dodging benefit fraudster. One poster advising to change your locks-she might come back to rob you.

It sounds as though she has worked in a child education setting, is DBS checked, and op checked references.
Im sure she proved to be a good baby sitter but just has an appalling grasp on professional conduct and little business acumen.
She may be as naive as op but she’s fallen into some ad hoc baby sitting jobs locally without being aware of the complicated legalities and definitions of baby sitter vs nanny.

Whatever the case, she’s accepted the notice and the week’s money owed and has no further dispute with op.

chickenlickensarnie · 18/05/2023 11:30

Motherbear07 · 18/05/2023 11:22

is this lady a registered childminder? As this sounds totally unprofessional. Has she even had background checks? Her husband said no lower than £13 an hour. A registered childminder only charges around £5-£6 an hour.
this lady sounds like a baby sitter rather than a childminder.
what you had said already doesn’t sound good. I would pay her for her last week and that’s it. In any registered childcare setting you have to give a minimum of 4 weeks notice. Why are you having to pay for two months after? It doesn’t make sense. This doesn’t sound legit. Who have you left your child with? How did you find her? Explain to her. You have seeked legal advice and no contract was signed with notice period. However any registered childcare requirements requests a minimum of 4 weeks which you have provided. Pay her for the last week and then leave it at that. If it gets out of hand then contact 101. I got a feeling she will cause a lot of trouble. And I wouldn’t trust a person like this around my child. So don’t block unless it gets out of hand. As they may escalate. She hasn’t a leg to stand on. She isn’t registered and no doubt claiming benefits. So if this goes further she will land on her face.

I find it interesting that people have assumed this lady is claiming benefits and are bashing her for that (rightly so if it is the case), but are siding with the OP who has employed someone illegally and avoided tax and NI payments as a direct result. Two wrongs and all that...

OP, I'm interested to know why you chose the nanny in the first place. Was nursery always your longer term plan, or were you hoping to find a more permanent nanny?

Motherbear07 · 18/05/2023 11:25

The reason she is saying about the last week is because they’re demanding them to pay June and July.
also she is asking advice about is it the right thing to do.

Motherbear07 · 18/05/2023 11:22

is this lady a registered childminder? As this sounds totally unprofessional. Has she even had background checks? Her husband said no lower than £13 an hour. A registered childminder only charges around £5-£6 an hour.
this lady sounds like a baby sitter rather than a childminder.
what you had said already doesn’t sound good. I would pay her for her last week and that’s it. In any registered childcare setting you have to give a minimum of 4 weeks notice. Why are you having to pay for two months after? It doesn’t make sense. This doesn’t sound legit. Who have you left your child with? How did you find her? Explain to her. You have seeked legal advice and no contract was signed with notice period. However any registered childcare requirements requests a minimum of 4 weeks which you have provided. Pay her for the last week and then leave it at that. If it gets out of hand then contact 101. I got a feeling she will cause a lot of trouble. And I wouldn’t trust a person like this around my child. So don’t block unless it gets out of hand. As they may escalate. She hasn’t a leg to stand on. She isn’t registered and no doubt claiming benefits. So if this goes further she will land on her face.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 18/05/2023 11:17

@Avatari seems like you came into this thread with a "kick me" sign on your virtual back. You've done nothing wrong, just been a bit naive.

I formally employed a registered childminder and she pulled similar stunts, not being available at short notice but saying we had no grounds to object etc., then made all sorts of threats regarding legal action. I paid her one weeks notice. At the time I took advice from the National Childminders' Association I don't know if they still exist but they were very helpful regarding her T&Cs (although obviously this wasn't a childminder situation, just saying).

Ellyess · 18/05/2023 11:02

Avatari
I am so sorry you and your husband have suffered this horrible experience. I do hope it's resolved now. From what I read it sounds as though you have sorted it out.
I am so moved by the difficulties young parents face with child care arrangements when they return to work. I realise that returning to work is not always a choice either but a necessity today when two wages are needed to maintain a home and pay for everything. It is a tough life.
That is one reason why I am so disgusted when people come on MN to say acid things to people, especially to the OP, speaking as though they know everything and have the right to condemn people in the nastiest of language.
I was glad you said "If you are going to make comments like this you should at the very least to have the decency to read all my posts." to one of them. I used to come here and point out to these ignorant and hateful people what the OP had said which rendered their condemnatory rant completely ungrounded.
Good luck with everything. I hope your child loves Nursery and all goes well from now onwards.

mincedtart · 18/05/2023 10:44

I’m amazed that the majority think you’re being reasonable. Try telling your nursery that you won’t be paying for a week because you’re ill, see what they say…

WomanUnknown · 18/05/2023 10:38

Avatari · 16/05/2023 22:34

Just to expand. She is not a nanny. She only came two days a week and DH was working from home so actually did most of the lunch prep, putting down for nap etc. She basically kept baby busy so he could focus on work.

She is definitely more a babysitter than a nanny.

2 days a week? I’d pay her 2 more days as a weeks notice, then ignore her tbh. Whole thing is a clearly a convenient, cash in hand, verbal agreement.

Prepare yourself for stringent contracts going forward, a nursery or childminder will still expect payment when your child is not there due to sickness, holidays, etc.

Raels · 18/05/2023 10:21

I would suggest contacting the Citizens Advice Bereau if you're very concerned.

JusthereforXmas · 18/05/2023 10:00

People are arguing over semantic with regard to what to call her.

Nanny = a person, in particular a woman, employed to look after a child in its own home.

Babysitter = a person who looks after a child or children while the parents are out.

Childminder = a person who looks after children in their own home for payment.

And people are completely making stuff up, there is absolutely no definition/law that says babysitters 'only work at night' or 'can't work between 9-5' or 'can't work for you weekly' etc...

Babysitters are usually self employed and work on an 'as needed' basis at any hour agreed and without contract. Usually unqualified and as a non full time job... that seems like exactly what OP has set up. No contract and the ability for both sides to cancel last minute as suits.

The only thing you could pull for finickiness if you want the dictionary definition would be that the dad is home not out.

JusthereforXmas · 18/05/2023 09:43

HateLongCovid · 16/05/2023 22:38

Covid can still make lots of people feel very poorly. It's not an excuse, it's a reality!

Yes I got covid the week they lifted everything, dispite being fully vaccinated I caught it, even after the infection was gone the symptoms just stayed and ended up on steroids with breathing issue for 6 months after and still occasionally struggle to breath.

Samlewis96 · 18/05/2023 09:42

Krustykrabpizza · 17/05/2023 11:23

Employment stuff aside, I can't believe you would put your baby in the care of a complete random with no proof of DBs, first aid training, insurance, anything! That is complete insanity.

The child's father was present the whole time e.

stichguru · 18/05/2023 09:30

You've got to make a decision. You've basically provided someone with regular employment, but kept it causal to avoid being subject to employment law. At this point I'm guessing you paid cash in hand to help her tax dodge as well. You say you've been annoyed when she's called out at later notice, but again you've allowed this by avoiding having a contract, which you've presumably done to avoid needing to abide by employment law. I've never heard of childcare where you don't have to pay when your child is sick, so again you are hugely taking advantage of your "casual" babysitter. At this point I would suggest that paying her money that you'd owe her if you chosen not to use an illegal set up, and not giving her reason to take you to court is probably a good option. Otherwise you deny the money which you should owe her, but don't due to the lack of legal contract, and hope that she is scared to take you to court because she has also broken tax laws, so will stop complaining.

Bamaluz · 18/05/2023 09:17

Please don't keep calling her a childminder, you're giving them a bad name.
Cildminder's work from their own home and are regulated and inspected.

SmileyClare · 18/05/2023 09:05

I urge you to contact HMRC as soon as possible

I don’t.
Over dramatic to spout the law and talk ominously about employment tribunals.

This sort of casual temporary childcare agreement where some cash changes hands goes on all the time. I’m not making it right but it’s a fact and usually both parties benefit.

Op has paid for the last week of this woman’s notice and they’ve come to an amicable agreement now.

Its done.
Neither party has come out of this looking great but op has now secured and is paying for registered childcare.

Divorcedalongtime · 18/05/2023 08:56

Daffodil92 · 16/05/2023 22:30

Cash in hand. There’s no way she will take OP to a tribunal, she’s almost certainly not paying tax or claiming in the side.

But it sounds like the OP has actually employed a nanny and are therefore responsible for paying her tax, pension, NI

hppo · 18/05/2023 08:52

Why wouldn't you have a contract for someone you left with sole responsibility for looking after your 1 year old???????

Utter madness and totally irresponsible

Wheresthebeach · 18/05/2023 08:50

Best to pay her a months notice and be done. Lots of lessons learnt about setting things out carefully before starting, but I understand the pressure on getting child care is huge and she came recommended. Also with your DH at home it all probably sounded sensible at the time.

notwhatsoever · 18/05/2023 08:29

You have both behaved poorly in having no written contract, and neither of you seem to understand how professional childminding services work.

Having said that, you have behaved shabbily in offering such a short notice period ( three weeks is less than the basic minimum standard of a month) and seeking to reduce it further is just terrible. You should pay her the notice period of at least a month even if you tell her not to work during that time. That would be the decent thing to do.

Happyasalamb · 18/05/2023 08:28

You may have employed her wrongly or not. If you've gone through HMRC employment status indicator tool and that is showing she should have been self employed then save a copy of that judgement if she does try anything HMRC usually stand by that if you have answered the questions truthfully.

As there are no contracts in place from either party, just go with the statutory notice pay 1 week for each year of service. Pay however you want.

If she wants to be difficult, you could always report her to HMRC yourself if you are concerned that she is defrauding the tax office by not paying tax on her earnings.

Newestname002 · 18/05/2023 08:14

Hello @Avatari. As your husband WFH I'm assuming your childminder didn't have any keys to your home, as otherwise I'd recommend changing the barrels of your locks. 🌹

Sbera · 18/05/2023 08:03

A note about a DBS checks.
Anyone can have a DBS check. Including a murderer. However what you should be looking for (and checking) is a clean DBS on the update service. If an individual has a DBS completed in 2020 who is to say they haven’t committed a crime since then. A piece of paper is never enough and you should either check their DBS status on the update service or request a new up to date check.

Secondly there are multiple types of DBS certificate. A basic certificate me which is available to anyone but will not give you a full history and for working with children the top level is recommended. An enhanced DBS check with adults and children’s barred lists. This will ensure you see any pending convictions or indictments along with any additional information which the local authority, police service or social services feel relevant.

As an example I have seen a clean basic DBS check but when we ran an enhanced with barred lists it transpired that the individual had had 5 children removed from her care due to neglect. No prosecution so no disclosure on a basic but of course, no one wanted to employ this nanny as a result.

You can only request an enhanced certificate if you are an employer so it is unlikely this nanny has an up to date version.

Sbera · 18/05/2023 07:46

OP I have read the whole thread and your replies but couldn’t read and run as I work in payroll for a nanny agency so thought some advice may be useful.

Firstly, I am sorry that you have been burnt and had a poor experience. The lack of accessible knowledge along with affordable childcare led you here but ultimately there are a few legal matters you should consider.

Even without a contract, you have been employing a nanny. The regular hours, the fact you made payment (cash or otherwise) the communication that will have been agreed over text all suggest an employment contract and this is how a court of law would interpret it.

As an employer, regardless of the nanny’s apparent comfort with your casual arrangement, it is your legal duty to ensure that your employee’s tax, national insurance and pension contributions are completely satisfied. You can back date this as she only has been in your employment for 2.5 months but would urge you to do this asap.

HMRC have an employers line that I would urge you to contact.

Secondly, as a paid employee you are legally required to pay her holiday pay. Roughly worked out at 12.5% on top of their hourly rate. Again you can back pay this as a lump sum following the termination of her employment.

The week you did not require her due to Covid you are legally required to pay her. But I think that has been covered.

The times that your nanny was unavailable to work for you you should have followed some kind of return to work process. If she was sick then a calculation for Statutory Sick Pay should have been completed (easily accessible on gov.Uk). If she just didn’t show up because of unagreed holiday you should have taken her through a disciplinary scenario.

The notice period was not formally recorded and so I think I’m the eyes of the law you should be fine. However, to dismiss anyone you have to provide a reasonable reason. Going to nursery would be one of these, you should be fine.

Your obligations above stand regardless of what you believe the nanny is personally comfortable with. By not completing these you are, unfortunately, exploiting cheap labour however you may feel and I’m sorry that this may be a shock.

Alongside this you should have had employers liability insurance incase of an accident at the place of work (your home).

Regarding the unprofessionalism you experienced, as an employer you should have had a clear disciplinary process in place, allowing for improvement.

ACAS offer a free employer helpline which I strongly suggest you contact to help with all the above.

Lastly, it is not down to the nanny to dictate her employment status. You have employed someone whether she or you knew it. However, she will have until at least January 2024 to declare earnings from you, for any payment made up to and including April 5th 2023 and the following January for anything after that. So at this point, you are the only one breaking the law not her.

Should she declare this later on, you potentially will face a heavy fine and prison sentence.

Again, I’m sorry this has been so crap for you all. I hope that the above is useful and that your little one enjoys nursery.

for everyone else
childminder is someone who works in their own home, has to have a DBS and be Ofsted registered.

nanny/babysitter none of the above legally applies though it is good recourse to have them.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 18/05/2023 07:38

I'm surprised that you don't need her services this week. You and your husband are both so unwell with covid that you are unable to work yourselves. Surely being so terribly unwell would mean you need her help with your DD more than ever this week, while you rest and recuperate from the ravages of covid.

Are you claiming money from your employer (AKA sick pay) for this week? The irony. You won't work and expect payment. She will work, but you will not allow her to and suck up the wage loss.

You're expending an awful lot of energy in trying to cheat this woman out of a week's wages.

Swipe left for the next trending thread