Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off with the number of people asking to pay even less for a secondhand item?

119 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 16/05/2023 21:13

Got a thing for sale on Facebook marketplace. £30, in great condition, not a mark on it- costs £65 brand new.

It’s only been a few hours, and so far I’ve had half a dozen messages asking if I’ll accept £20. That’s not just a couple of quid off, that’s a third of the asking price! AIBU to think there’s haggling and there’s just taking the piss?

OP posts:
stuckinthelastcentury · 17/05/2023 05:30

And I don't think the offer is that cheeky! I recently had something up for £30 and very happily parted with it for £20 - in those magnitudes, I don't think 1/3 is that important.

stuckinthelastcentury · 17/05/2023 05:27

I've been both buying and selling lately, and think a lot of people are really out of touch with what their stuff is worth.

One cheeky offer is annoying, but if you've had half a dozen it probably says more about your price than the potential buyer...

Ponderingwindow · 17/05/2023 04:37

People almost always offer the next convenient cash increment down. So always price accordingly.

if I want 30, I ask for 35 and expect people will offer 30

SkyandSurf · 17/05/2023 04:25

Depends what the item is, but 50% of retail might not be reasonable or typical. Paying 50% of retail is my absolute ceiling when buying second hand, and I'd only do it for some types of items.

If you don't want to negotiate, write on your post:

"This is the price and it's not negotiable. If you can see this post then the item is still available. If you want to purchase it, please message me with the time and day that would suit you for collection."

Then just respond to people who contact you saying 'does Tuesday 10 work?'

Marchitectmummy · 17/05/2023 01:25

Ha marketplace is a nightmare, its full of people messing around. If you are getting that much interest that quickly, hold out the right person will come, ignore those who are contacting you personally any ridiculous haggling, not showing etc and I block them.

Put it on ebay and pay the fee but live a lssz hassled life.

RobertaFirmino · 17/05/2023 01:15

Always overprice. That's what I do on Vinted, means I can send offers when I get a 'like'. Agree with PP, 'worth' is meaningless. At work (charity shop), we'd rather sell the Karen Millen dress for £5 and have it in the cat's bowls straightaway than ask for a tenner and have it lingering on the rail, taking up space and getting crumpled.

RosaCaramella · 17/05/2023 01:09

I always offer the price advertised unless I think the seller is really out of touch with what something costs.
What really gets me on FB marketplace is arranging to buy something - setting a time and place- and then receiving a message saying someone else has offered more! This when it wasn’t even an “offers” listing. There’s a lot of time-wasters on these types of sites - both buyers and sellers.

Holly60 · 16/05/2023 23:00

AngeloMysterioso · 16/05/2023 21:22

I just couldn’t have the audacity to ask someone to take such a huge chunk off- not just 5 or 10% but a third off!!

So what do you do? Just pay more than you want to, or miss out all together?

Both of those seem crappy options.

If a number of people have offered you £20 for the item, it seems the item is worth £20. It doesn't really matter what you paid for it, it's only worth what people are willing to pay for it now.

mainsfed · 16/05/2023 22:18

Sell on eBay, you can set a minimum threshold for offers.

Marketplaces are fair game for bargaining.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 16/05/2023 22:14

thelionthewitchtheaudacityofTHISbitch · 16/05/2023 22:05

I am now totally hard on what I will sell an item for. Too much effort otherwise, particularly for time to pack securely. So on ebay recently items had reasonable amounts of views, a few watchers, but no offers and no bids. I let it roll for a few weeks, then changed the listing headings to be final listing. Closing date came, eventually I took the items off to the charity shop. I closed the listings that evening. So many messages - do you still have the item? It's been quite amusing directing all the posters to the local charity shop that will inevitably post online individually for much more than my reasonably priced bundle. No longer my problem. I am sure that financially my gift aid "benefit" will be more than the sales price on line. And no packing - hooray!

Love this! Agree - life's too short to be faffing around sometimes and I'd rather give to charity than mess about with silly offers. I won't sell anything for less than £5, not worth the effort.

thelionthewitchtheaudacityofTHISbitch · 16/05/2023 22:05

I am now totally hard on what I will sell an item for. Too much effort otherwise, particularly for time to pack securely. So on ebay recently items had reasonable amounts of views, a few watchers, but no offers and no bids. I let it roll for a few weeks, then changed the listing headings to be final listing. Closing date came, eventually I took the items off to the charity shop. I closed the listings that evening. So many messages - do you still have the item? It's been quite amusing directing all the posters to the local charity shop that will inevitably post online individually for much more than my reasonably priced bundle. No longer my problem. I am sure that financially my gift aid "benefit" will be more than the sales price on line. And no packing - hooray!

StarDolphins · 16/05/2023 22:04

Awful isn’t it, I’ve stopped doing it as of this weekend….

  1. I advertised a boot full of dog food to anyone that collects for a rescue - had 4 abusive or rude inboxes

  2. last weekend advertised a kids bike FREE buyer to collect, out of the 17 messages I had, only 4 said please & 1 of them asked me to drop it off😡 no please or anything.

  3. advertised a Ted baker dress (a while back now but it was an unusual sought after one that was expensive) for £10 & the girl turned up & started picking faults with the print & offered £5

I will now only ever give things to people with manners!

Digitallis · 16/05/2023 22:01

Aren’t you missing the point that whilst it’s brand new, they lose all consumer rights buying from you. Can’t return it, no guarantee etc.

Also ‘price’ is what someone is willing to pay for it as it’s value to them not you. You can choose not to sell it for less but that doesn’t mean it’s worth more.

WandaWonder · 16/05/2023 21:57

I always add a little more than I want as I know people will offer less

SillyMe101 · 16/05/2023 21:44

Jessiecaroline22 · 16/05/2023 21:39

Same on vinted.
I offer discounts on bundles e.g. 10%.
Still got someone today buying a bundle with a discount ask what the lowest is I would sell for. I just replied it's the price already stated. Jesus, I'm already only selling items for a few quid!

I had the opposite on Vinted, I put together a bundle using the seller’s bundle discount (ie set by the seller) and asked her to calculate shipping.

She refused to sell and offered me a higher price for the bundle.

Uh, you were the one who set the prices in the first place?!? 😂

I love Vinted and other selling sites, they are a neverending source of odd behaviour, cheeky fuckery and purchase psychology case studies. With some lovely interactions and great bargains thrown in!

Straightsidedcircle · 16/05/2023 21:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Jessiecaroline22 · 16/05/2023 21:39

Same on vinted.
I offer discounts on bundles e.g. 10%.
Still got someone today buying a bundle with a discount ask what the lowest is I would sell for. I just replied it's the price already stated. Jesus, I'm already only selling items for a few quid!

LilyLemonade · 16/05/2023 21:39

I would expect a 'brand new condition' item to sell about 30% of its listed price when selling second-hand, so I think you are being U to expect fully 50%. It is way more hassle and risk to buy second-hand from an individual and that has to be factored in to the price.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 16/05/2023 21:36

I read somewhere that, for something in very good used condition you should expect about 1/3 of the original price . Keep in mind that people are savvy to the fact that they might well be able to get 15-20% off on the new product
If they wait around for the retailer to offer a discount code, so that could make buying second hand less appealing.

It depends though, children's brands such as boden for example hold their value quite well and some of the discontinued most popular items sell for close to the original price or more. Next second hand tends to go for 1/3 of the original price unless it's a particularly sought after item.

Addymontgomeryfan · 16/05/2023 21:35

Facebook marketplace is a nightmare for selling things, everyone has a sob story of why they need it really cheap, or when you are giving things away for free you get the ones asking you to deliver it miles away from you.

Corkcobain · 16/05/2023 21:31

I could have equally made a thread complaining about how people try and flog their old shit for ridiculous prices and think even though they don't want it that it's magically worth way more than it actually is.
Irrespective of what you paid for it OP second hand items are probably worth 30-40% max of the new price (even if you bought it yesterday)

gogohmm · 16/05/2023 21:30

If I'm buying secondhand I offer what I'm willing to pay. If that doesn't meet your expectations then say no. Just like with houses, it is only worth what someone is willing to pay

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 16/05/2023 21:28

They are allowed to offer and you are allowed to decline....

I always try my luck, but if I really want it I'll pay the asking price (if I feel it is fair) before someone else does!

EnglishRose1320 · 16/05/2023 21:27

I expect people to haggle but I do think some people take it too far and can be really cheeky.
Did a car boot at the weekend- hate the things but was doing a favour for a friend. Most things I'd suggest slightly higher than I was happy for it to go for and then we meet in the middle somewhere.
However by the end of the day, we'd stuck prices on somethings and were letting things go really cheap just to shift as much as possible.
Had a nearly new baby item, in full working conditon- retails between £30-£35 new. Someone asked for a price, we said £2 is the lowest we can go and they still tried to haggle, suggested 50p or £1.

User12310 · 16/05/2023 21:26

I was selling a really good brand of kids bike for £70. Someone offered me £20! When I told him it was a joke of an offer, he came back with ‘yes or no’! He then said ‘I am very poor, you would be helping me’ after I said no! The bloody cheek of it. Plenty of £20 bikes on there too.