Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister committing benefit fraud

111 replies

ellie09 · 16/05/2023 19:53

I have a sister who has been with a guy now for a year. The relationship progressed quickly and he was moved in within weeks. She had a 3 year old from a previous relationship and became pregnant within 3 months and just gave birth.

He is living with them permanently and had a full time, stable job making around 30k a year.

My issue is that she is still claiming benefits as a single parent.

I work full time on 35k a year with a child on my own, having to pay full childcare and other things while my tax money is finding their living.

They don't live outrageously, but they have a much better standard of living than me. She's bragging that he is saving most of his wages in his savings. They live in a housing executive flat which is fully paid for with her benefit so he isn't paying any rent etc.

The two of them plead poverty, constantly asking me or my mum for a lend of money etc yet neither of them drive and he works from home.

I honestly wish they would get reported, and at times as a tax payer, feel like doing it myself.

AIBU?

OP posts:
QuacketyQuack · 16/05/2023 23:00

She's your sister for goodness sake! There is a lot more thieving going on from the rich of this country and people always want to target the benefit "fraudster"

squidgybits · 16/05/2023 22:59

Saucemonkey · 16/05/2023 22:05

Report anonymously. You’ll be doing her a favour. Eventually she will get found out and the longer it goes on for the more she will have to pay back. Better now than when he leaves her in the lurch and she has to pay it all back . And they do find out! I have known a few people who have been caught , gone to court and then had to pay it all back over a series of years.

I know somebody who narrowly missed a custodial sentence for it

Mookie81 · 16/05/2023 22:55

Tinkerbyebye · 16/05/2023 22:10

I would report, you can do it anonymously. I don’t care if it’s my sister, and all those saying it’s your sister, would you say the same if it’s your neighbour? Or Billy on down the street? No didn’t think so

and I bet those saying don’t report are also those slating the Tories for not spending on benefits. Millions is lost each year on benefit fraud and each and every person should be reported and made to pay it back

I don't equate my own sister with Billy down the street, only a twat would do so.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 16/05/2023 22:51

dottypencilcase · 16/05/2023 22:37

I reported a relative who was forever crying poverty, claiming benefits yet paid for her unemployed son to have an £80,000 wedding (I know because she openly told everyone). There was no inheritance, etc. but she'd 'borrowed' (I'm yet to see the £5000 she borrowed from me) from so many people while squirrelling away her benefit money to have a big bash to make herself look good.

I’m assuming if you reported her there’s some evidence of wrongdoing you’ve not mentioned, as saving your benefits up isn’t an offence, neither is paying towards something for a relative.
what is suspicious is how long she must have been saving benefits to get 80k…yet benefit cap is 25k.,.. so even if she saved every penny, she must have been saving for years for that wedding.

🤷‍♀️

dumple · 16/05/2023 22:50

If it's housing executive you're in NI?

Would you be ok reporting it - as in if it ever got out in the estate you live in would you get bother from the paramilitaries?

I used to live in an estate and I wouldn't have grassed anyone up because I'd have got a knock and been put out. A girl that lived on the next row to me was put out for grassing up a neighbour.

Unsure33 · 16/05/2023 22:45

lilacbunny · 16/05/2023 22:39

Yep. I wouldn't report my neighbour or a stranger. Why? Because it doesn't and wouldn't affect me or improve my circumstances. Nobody knows what anyone is going through and I think people need to stick their fucking noses out. Go work for the dwp if you feel so strongly about it and be an investigator.

but if that was repeated thousands of times over the whole country it might be that the money could be diverted more to people like my DIL a who has two children under hospital treatment and a long term very difficult medical condition but still manages to work . Personally I think they deserve more money than those who are committing fraud . It does not mean the money would go back into my pocket .

lilacbunny · 16/05/2023 22:39

Tinkerbyebye · 16/05/2023 22:10

I would report, you can do it anonymously. I don’t care if it’s my sister, and all those saying it’s your sister, would you say the same if it’s your neighbour? Or Billy on down the street? No didn’t think so

and I bet those saying don’t report are also those slating the Tories for not spending on benefits. Millions is lost each year on benefit fraud and each and every person should be reported and made to pay it back

Yep. I wouldn't report my neighbour or a stranger. Why? Because it doesn't and wouldn't affect me or improve my circumstances. Nobody knows what anyone is going through and I think people need to stick their fucking noses out. Go work for the dwp if you feel so strongly about it and be an investigator.

dottypencilcase · 16/05/2023 22:37

I reported a relative who was forever crying poverty, claiming benefits yet paid for her unemployed son to have an £80,000 wedding (I know because she openly told everyone). There was no inheritance, etc. but she'd 'borrowed' (I'm yet to see the £5000 she borrowed from me) from so many people while squirrelling away her benefit money to have a big bash to make herself look good.

WishIwasElsa · 16/05/2023 22:25

Consider this, he saves all his money yes she gets benefits but has to pay for everything for 4 people not 3 as all his money is being saved. Benefits are not overly generous and living is expensive now hence her needing to borrow money.

I wouldn't report her nor would I threaten to do it. But I would warn her of the consequences because someone will report her and then I doubt he will be helping her to repay the debt with all that money he's saved.

VyeBrator · 16/05/2023 22:16

Why can no-one on Mumsnet report benefit fraudsters without starting a thread about it first?

These threads seem to go in spates and this is about the 3rd in a couple of days.

Just do it if it makes you feel better, although as your post seems to be focused mainly on jealousy rather than taxpayers money, I can't see it making you feel better for long.

The green-eyed monster will rear its ugly head again over something else no doubt.

Tinkerbyebye · 16/05/2023 22:10

I would report, you can do it anonymously. I don’t care if it’s my sister, and all those saying it’s your sister, would you say the same if it’s your neighbour? Or Billy on down the street? No didn’t think so

and I bet those saying don’t report are also those slating the Tories for not spending on benefits. Millions is lost each year on benefit fraud and each and every person should be reported and made to pay it back

lilacbunny · 16/05/2023 22:07

He's saving money and she's spending all her money on their life.

And you want to report her? Make her life harder.

Why not be a supportive sister and help your sister see this man is taking her for a ride living in her place letting her pay for everything while he saves up his money in his bank account.

It's your fucking sister.

Saucemonkey · 16/05/2023 22:05

Report anonymously. You’ll be doing her a favour. Eventually she will get found out and the longer it goes on for the more she will have to pay back. Better now than when he leaves her in the lurch and she has to pay it all back . And they do find out! I have known a few people who have been caught , gone to court and then had to pay it all back over a series of years.

Wowzerdowzer · 16/05/2023 21:59

And..... if he's saving all of his money.
Then how is she committing benefit fraud ?? She is not financially better off with him there if he's saving all of his wages?! She's living off her benefits?! And struggling at that.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 16/05/2023 21:31

Brieandme · 16/05/2023 20:08

Op your tax money isn't paying for their living. So if that is your main motivation, leave it alone. You would have to earn treble what you earn to be a net contributor (put in more than you take out - schooling and state pension)

If you're concerned about your sister id be encouraging her to declare. DWP have complex data sharing systems to link people to the same address. It's likely she'll be caught out at some point and will owe the lot back, along with risking a prison sentence.

This!!!

I don’t think people understand that most people are not net contributors and are not paying for anyone else’s lifestyle aside from MPs

Confusion101 · 16/05/2023 20:56

I voted YABU for a few reasons.

She is still claiming benefits as a single parent. I work full time on 35k a year with a child on my own, having to pay full childcare and other things. If you reported her you would not be any more financially well off, in fact you would prob be less well off because she will be asking to borrow more money.

Constantly asking me or my mum for a lend of money you need to nip this in the bud. Stop giving if you do and tell them to stop asking.

he is saving most of his wages in his savings. You should probably advise your sister to get access to this account. It's a relatively new relationship. If he clips it with all these savings she's fucked.

YANBU to feel annoyed they they are claiming benefits fraudulently. It's so difficult watching people get away with it when others are struggling. But I don't think you should do anything about it in this case.

whumpthereitis · 16/05/2023 20:52

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2023 20:47

What happens to her kids if she ends up in jail and please don't come out with the old "That's not my problem" chestnut. They are after all your niblings. How will you feel when they're sobbing for their mother.
If you think her life is such a birdsong then give up your job and go on benefits.

Don’t point out a basic truth, you mean?

if the sister ends up in jail, which is unlikely, it would be as a direct result of her own actions.

PollyAmour · 16/05/2023 20:52

He's taking her for a mug, saving all his earnings while she claims benefits. It's her that will be prosecuted for fraud, not him. He'll walk away with a healthy bank balance and she'll have a criminal record for fraud, and two children to care for.

Daisypain · 16/05/2023 20:51

Tell her to stop asking you for money

Tell her you think she’s at risk of being done for fraud.

So not report her. You might be cross with her and even feel hard done by but why on earth would you want your own sister to be in trouble with the law and at potential great cost to her and her kids?

Babyroobs · 16/05/2023 20:49

The longer it goes on the worse it will be for her when she gets caught ( which she will do).

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2023 20:48

Also she may not be doing it for greed it could be for survival

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2023 20:47

What happens to her kids if she ends up in jail and please don't come out with the old "That's not my problem" chestnut. They are after all your niblings. How will you feel when they're sobbing for their mother.
If you think her life is such a birdsong then give up your job and go on benefits.

peachespeachespeaches · 16/05/2023 20:36

I'd probably look after my sister considering she's in a relationship with a prick who will up and leave with all his savings at some stage.

Casilero · 16/05/2023 20:32

So HE'S saving HIS money and your sister is the one committing benefit fraud and taking all the risks. Not daft is he?

MakesMeFeelSad · 16/05/2023 20:31

Sounds more like he's financially abusing her, if he's saving all his wages then her benefits must be paying all the living expenses and she's asking you and your mum for money

If he fucks off she won't be getting any of his savings

Swipe left for the next trending thread