Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister committing benefit fraud

111 replies

ellie09 · 16/05/2023 19:53

I have a sister who has been with a guy now for a year. The relationship progressed quickly and he was moved in within weeks. She had a 3 year old from a previous relationship and became pregnant within 3 months and just gave birth.

He is living with them permanently and had a full time, stable job making around 30k a year.

My issue is that she is still claiming benefits as a single parent.

I work full time on 35k a year with a child on my own, having to pay full childcare and other things while my tax money is finding their living.

They don't live outrageously, but they have a much better standard of living than me. She's bragging that he is saving most of his wages in his savings. They live in a housing executive flat which is fully paid for with her benefit so he isn't paying any rent etc.

The two of them plead poverty, constantly asking me or my mum for a lend of money etc yet neither of them drive and he works from home.

I honestly wish they would get reported, and at times as a tax payer, feel like doing it myself.

AIBU?

OP posts:
itsrainin · 17/05/2023 03:40

As a civil servant, I’d have to say report her. It’s a shit situation but ultimately the DWP have an entire fraud department deducted to this; living with a partner is the most common case of fraud. She will eventually get caught and the longer this goes on, the likely worse the consequences will be. It’s hardly crime of the century and the DWP has repayment plans that could be super low so it’s not necessarily going to ruin her to repay this. I’m sure she’ll be fuming about the money she is not entitled to claim but there really is no such thing as free money and it’s better to have to repay £1k vs £10k

Myfuckingredtrousers · 17/05/2023 03:21

Sounds like she’s being financially abused…probably why she has to ask for money as he’s keeping all his money.

SkyandSurf · 17/05/2023 00:33

It sounds like she is being financially abused.

He is living off her single parent benefits while pocketing his entire wage into his own savings?

He is accumulating savings while she assumes the risks. What is in it for her if all the excess is going into an account of a man she isn't married to and has no claim on?

I'd talk to my sister about how precarious her situation is.

I wouldn't report, if only for the sake of the children in the situation.

Unsure33 · 16/05/2023 23:50

thecatsmeows · 16/05/2023 23:25

My best friend works for the DWP.

Benefit fraud accounts for 1.2% of the welfare budget. More - 4% - is lost in DWP errors. Those figures are from gov.uk.

If caught, both will be prosecuted.

The chances of them being caught at the moment are extremely slim - my friend says virtually no fraud investigations are being done unless someone reports.

This is only a figure of those that are caught , how do you know the total figure if those people are not reported ? It could be much higher ?

gloriawasright · 16/05/2023 23:35

Fiddlerdragon · 16/05/2023 23:01

I wouldn’t report my own sister and potentially ruin her and her children’s lives over something that doesn’t affect me at all, because I’m not an utter dickhead.

I agree .I would never report my sister ,what kind of person would ?

thecatsmeows · 16/05/2023 23:25

My best friend works for the DWP.

Benefit fraud accounts for 1.2% of the welfare budget. More - 4% - is lost in DWP errors. Those figures are from gov.uk.

If caught, both will be prosecuted.

The chances of them being caught at the moment are extremely slim - my friend says virtually no fraud investigations are being done unless someone reports.

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:22

How many of you saying report would do it if you were going to find yourself on the street?

I'll tell you now I wouldn't report anything living on a council estate in Northern Ireland. You keep your head down and your nose clean.

ilovesooty · 16/05/2023 23:20

JaneyGee · 16/05/2023 23:14

I agree. Benefit cheats are one of the biggest problem we face. Look at a pie chart of government expenditure. It’s shocking. The vast majority goes on welfare. And I would guess that at least a third, if not half, of those receiving the money don’t need or deserve it. Christ, I know SO many people who exploit the system. My friend’s brother, for example, has raised three kids on benefits. I just do not know how he’s got away with it. He’s a super fit gym freak, and there are goddam potholes everywhere, yet he is sat on his arse claiming benefits. Repairing potholes would be beneath him, you see. I could offer at least five more examples of people I know, some in my family, who pretty much live on benefits when there is f-all wrong with them. They contribute nothing to society, and I’m sick of it. The left are always banging on about greedy, selfish bankers. Fine, I agree. But what could be more selfish than sitting around playing video games and claiming benefits while other people get up at six (like me) work hard and pay their tax?

The money that is wasted on benefit cheats could be better spent elsewhere. It could be used to buy cancer drugs for the NHS, or to improve literacy, or to repair the roads, or to produce more STEM graduates, or to restore a beautiful cathedral. There are countless things it would be better spent on. God, it makes me furious.

Good grief. It must be exhausting living your life thinking like this.

truthhurts23 · 16/05/2023 23:20

I know its technically wrong but please don't do that to your sister, think about her kids
she will get caught eventually,
DWP do actually notice when women have children and they do question where the father is , and do their little investigations ,I know because it happened to me!

I was young and we were in an on/off relationship, he was not contributing to my bills or even groceries and he was only staying a few nights a week on the sofa! we weren't even having sex ffs

but they still classified that as cohabiting and I got in trouble, they just deducted his earnings from the previous entitlements and I had to pay some of it back
and they forced us to have a joint claim , despite us not being together

I could have challenged it but I just wanted it to be over with, it was so unfair because my ex wouldn't even buy nappies but yh..
please don't insert yourself into their mess

Secondwindplease · 16/05/2023 23:19

Your sister makes shit decisions. You don’t need to report her, she will dig her own grave in the end.

Deathbyfluffy · 16/05/2023 23:19

Wowzerdowzer · 16/05/2023 20:12

  1. You are not 'funding' them by paying tax.
  2. THAT IS YOUR SISTER

ffs

Where does the money come from then? There’s not some giant money tree at Westminster, as shocking as that might be

IHadADreamBut · 16/05/2023 23:16

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:11

Equivalent of a council flat in northern Ireland.

Ah okay thank you. Thought it was a different kind of council flat that's for a select few or something.

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:16

I'm sorry but all those people saying report - this is Northern Ireland.

If the op is on a council estate then it's likely to be run by one of the groups of paramilitaries.

If she reports and it gets out then she could get a knock at her door and be given 24/48 hours to leave the area. Kids or not.

If she doesn't leave, they'll put her windows in or burn out her car.

It's really not the same as other parts of the uk.

IHadADreamBut · 16/05/2023 23:15

Also I have a problem with people who only want to report because they think the other person is doing better than them. That's how it looks from your OP.

If you were doing much better than your sister or if they weren't earning anywhere near as much but still cheating the system, would you report?

In other words, there's no need to write about yourself and your situation in your OP. Your sister is cheating the system and that's it. Will you report or not? Do you think what they're doing is wrong or not? Would there have been a good excuse in your opinion for them to cheat or not? What you have or don't have doesn't matter.

DeeperMeaning · 16/05/2023 23:14

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:09

It means you get a knock at the door and given 24/48 hours to get out Leave the area

Thanks. That sounds terrifying, but not quite as bad as some things that came up when I looked up paramilitaries Northern Ireland.

JaneyGee · 16/05/2023 23:14

UpaladderwatchingTV · 16/05/2023 20:20

Just do it OP! I'm sick of reading stories about people making false claims. You know what she and her DP are doing is wrong, so stand up and be counted. If only more people in this country were honest, including members of the government, we wouldn't be in half the shit we're in now, but it seems that as long as you can get away with it, the vast majority are prepared to sit back and let you get on with it. IT IS FRAUD! Alternatively, if you don't want to report her, then tell her to her face, that she's committing fraud and if she doesn't stop, you will report her, at least that way you're giving her the chance to do the right thing.

I agree. Benefit cheats are one of the biggest problem we face. Look at a pie chart of government expenditure. It’s shocking. The vast majority goes on welfare. And I would guess that at least a third, if not half, of those receiving the money don’t need or deserve it. Christ, I know SO many people who exploit the system. My friend’s brother, for example, has raised three kids on benefits. I just do not know how he’s got away with it. He’s a super fit gym freak, and there are goddam potholes everywhere, yet he is sat on his arse claiming benefits. Repairing potholes would be beneath him, you see. I could offer at least five more examples of people I know, some in my family, who pretty much live on benefits when there is f-all wrong with them. They contribute nothing to society, and I’m sick of it. The left are always banging on about greedy, selfish bankers. Fine, I agree. But what could be more selfish than sitting around playing video games and claiming benefits while other people get up at six (like me) work hard and pay their tax?

The money that is wasted on benefit cheats could be better spent elsewhere. It could be used to buy cancer drugs for the NHS, or to improve literacy, or to repair the roads, or to produce more STEM graduates, or to restore a beautiful cathedral. There are countless things it would be better spent on. God, it makes me furious.

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:11

IHadADreamBut · 16/05/2023 23:10

What is a "housing executive flat"?

Equivalent of a council flat in northern Ireland.

IHadADreamBut · 16/05/2023 23:10

What is a "housing executive flat"?

Garethkeenansstapler · 16/05/2023 23:09

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2023 20:47

What happens to her kids if she ends up in jail and please don't come out with the old "That's not my problem" chestnut. They are after all your niblings. How will you feel when they're sobbing for their mother.
If you think her life is such a birdsong then give up your job and go on benefits.

Oh I’m so tired of the ‘why don’t you do it’ refrain. Maybe because OP has standards and morals and doesn’t want to sack off her job and claim when she doesn’t need to? Equally it doesn’t mean she can’t complain if somebody is milking the system at all our expense.

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:09

It means you get a knock at the door and given 24/48 hours to get out Leave the area

DeeperMeaning · 16/05/2023 23:08

dumple · 16/05/2023 22:50

If it's housing executive you're in NI?

Would you be ok reporting it - as in if it ever got out in the estate you live in would you get bother from the paramilitaries?

I used to live in an estate and I wouldn't have grassed anyone up because I'd have got a knock and been put out. A girl that lived on the next row to me was put out for grassing up a neighbour.

What does put out mean please? I googled but it didn’t help.

StarDolphins · 16/05/2023 23:07

I would report anonymously.

If I knew of anyone committing benefit fraud I would report them. Someone was telling me today their sister wants to go OP & claim UC so has moved all her savings out of her bank!

Equalitea · 16/05/2023 23:05

dumple · 16/05/2023 22:50

If it's housing executive you're in NI?

Would you be ok reporting it - as in if it ever got out in the estate you live in would you get bother from the paramilitaries?

I used to live in an estate and I wouldn't have grassed anyone up because I'd have got a knock and been put out. A girl that lived on the next row to me was put out for grassing up a neighbour.

I thought about this.

If anyone found out you’d grassed, what impact might it have for you.

I personally just try to stay in my own lane and be as good a person as circumstances allow me to be, in this situation I wouldn’t involve myself, I suspect that karma would catch up at some point!

scoobydoo1971 · 16/05/2023 23:05

Like others have said, I would be more worried about her long term prospects. She has latched onto a cock lodger who is happy to see her take the risk of being caught for benefit fraud, and faced with a Government bill asking for repayments. If she brags about this, she is not the brightest bulb and someone will tell the authorities. Even if they don't, electronic record matching between council, DWP, HMRC and credit records is quite sophisticated these days. All the while, Mr Bargain saves all that money in his savings and can run off with no penalty. He could deny knowing she continued to claim. She sounds like a mug to take all this risk for a man who hasn't got any respect for her if he is happy for her to put in fraudulent claims, and potentially ruin her life and the kids future.

Fiddlerdragon · 16/05/2023 23:01

I wouldn’t report my own sister and potentially ruin her and her children’s lives over something that doesn’t affect me at all, because I’m not an utter dickhead.