Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister committing benefit fraud

111 replies

ellie09 · 16/05/2023 19:53

I have a sister who has been with a guy now for a year. The relationship progressed quickly and he was moved in within weeks. She had a 3 year old from a previous relationship and became pregnant within 3 months and just gave birth.

He is living with them permanently and had a full time, stable job making around 30k a year.

My issue is that she is still claiming benefits as a single parent.

I work full time on 35k a year with a child on my own, having to pay full childcare and other things while my tax money is finding their living.

They don't live outrageously, but they have a much better standard of living than me. She's bragging that he is saving most of his wages in his savings. They live in a housing executive flat which is fully paid for with her benefit so he isn't paying any rent etc.

The two of them plead poverty, constantly asking me or my mum for a lend of money etc yet neither of them drive and he works from home.

I honestly wish they would get reported, and at times as a tax payer, feel like doing it myself.

AIBU?

OP posts:
coolnice · 17/05/2023 12:33

Casilero · 16/05/2023 20:32

So HE'S saving HIS money and your sister is the one committing benefit fraud and taking all the risks. Not daft is he?

THIS

I'd stay out of it op

Her "partner" sounds dodgy as fuck man

He's getting all the benefits (pardon the pun) ie no rent and saving his money, while she risks prison and a massive fine

GluedOnWobblyHead · 17/05/2023 12:18

thecatsmeows · 16/05/2023 23:25

My best friend works for the DWP.

Benefit fraud accounts for 1.2% of the welfare budget. More - 4% - is lost in DWP errors. Those figures are from gov.uk.

If caught, both will be prosecuted.

The chances of them being caught at the moment are extremely slim - my friend says virtually no fraud investigations are being done unless someone reports.

This gets trotted out all the time.

In their figures they only record as frauds those that have been reported/ uncovered and proved. The fact that 1.2% of the budget is successfully prosecuted frauds means that the actual percentage will be an order of magnitude higher. Look at this thread and how many people are condoning it! Then there will be many more who aren't actually breaking the law but playing the system e.g. deliberately working part time instead of full time so they can claim more, when they are perfectly capable of a full time job. So yes: a huge amount of money is being spent, which could be funding far more worthwhile things like the education and health budgets.

ConsuelaHammock · 17/05/2023 11:58

I wouldn’t report my own sister. Make sure she has contraception sorted. If she is struggling with two children she’ll be so much worse off with three.
Tbh she doesn’t sound very intelligent if she moved a new man into a house with a very young child. I’d help her to get back into work when her children are older. She needs to acquire the skills to be able to look after herself should /if/ when this cocklodger leaves her.

dumple · 17/05/2023 11:55

It depends on the estate but it's certainly been my experience.

When I had an issue, I had to get it cleared by the paramilitaries before I could report it to the police.

(I don't live there anymore but do have friends who still do and it's still the same as far as I'm aware and news reports would indicate similar)

Fifthtimelucky · 17/05/2023 11:43

dumple · 16/05/2023 23:16

I'm sorry but all those people saying report - this is Northern Ireland.

If the op is on a council estate then it's likely to be run by one of the groups of paramilitaries.

If she reports and it gets out then she could get a knock at her door and be given 24/48 hours to leave the area. Kids or not.

If she doesn't leave, they'll put her windows in or burn out her car.

It's really not the same as other parts of the uk.

This amazed me. Do paramilitaries still really "run council estates"?

If this is true (and I have no reason to disbelieve you utter than sheer incredulity) it's appalling.

SequinDiscoBiscuits · 17/05/2023 11:03

So he's a freeloading c* with his feet under the table to the extent he's saving his own money & she's going without, but she's the issue?
Ok.

JaneyGee · 17/05/2023 10:31

Unsure33 · 16/05/2023 23:50

This is only a figure of those that are caught , how do you know the total figure if those people are not reported ? It could be much higher ?

Exactly. I have known SO many people who exploit and cheat the system. Not one of them has ever been ‘prosecuted’. I don’t know how you’d even go about it. How can you prove someone is lying about their depression or their bad back? My cousin is on disability for his ‘bad back’, yet somehow manages to go on fishing trips to France. Never been caught or investigated. My friend’s brother is on benefits for depression, yet still manages to lift weights at the gym and use fake tan (presumably on days when his depression has lifted a bit, bless him). Never been caught or investigated. I could list example after example of people who cheat the system. Often, they are a burden on the NHS as well. I can think of several people who are constantly at the doctors or the hospital for the most trivial things. None of them work, and they go as a sort of day out. It gives them something to talk about for the rest of the week.

I don’t know why people on the left are so quick to defend these people. They seem to think that those of us who point this out are rabid Thatcherites, or that we want to stick kids back up chimneys. I am all for a welfare state. I sincerely want to help good people who are struggling. I knew a girl who’d been sexually abused as a child, for example, and ended up a broken mess living on welfare. She hated her life and desperately wanted to work. Now I’m happy to see my taxes spent helping her. And I’m all for investing in education, adult literacy programs, counselling services in prisons, all that kind of thing. But there is no magic money tree. There is a limit to how much a government can spend. If you tax the rich, they’ll just leave the country, and they’ll take their money and businesses with them.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 17/05/2023 07:21

Deathbyfluffy · 16/05/2023 23:19

Where does the money come from then? There’s not some giant money tree at Westminster, as shocking as that might be

😂😂 unless you’re earning more than 60k per year, you’re not funding anything, you’re a taker. Whether you claim benefits or not, you pay less in tax than you get back in grants, benefits, healthcare, education, tax relief.

The money comes from corporation tax and higher rate earners and vat. Income tax payments from working and middle class earners have never covered the basics. this is basic economics and can be verified by hmrc ad they release the actual figure every year.

so theres absolutely no need to get knickers in q twist about "your" tax money ad you get most of it back in tax relief, nhs, education, and other services

TizerorFizz · 17/05/2023 07:21

I actually think he does spend some of his money. If he doesn’t it does explain lack of money as the benefits are not designed to include him! Bigger fool the sister!!

LakieLady · 17/05/2023 07:15

I'd be more concerned that she's being financially abused by this cocklodger than by the "fraud" tbh.

WilkinsonM · 17/05/2023 07:14

I was in an emotionally and financially abusive relationship once and 'let' him move back in after he'd left and I'd initiated a solo claim. He came and went a few times over the next year and I continued to claim as solo the whole time. He never paid me anything towards rent and bills in that time and if I'd claimed as a couple I'd have been fucked. Yes I should have ended it properly and not 'let' him move back in but emotionally abusive relationships aren't that easy. Having read what she said about him saving his wages I wonder if she's bankrolling them both on her solo benefits while he witholds his wages. Is that possible?

Antisocialfluffmonster · 17/05/2023 07:13

JaneyGee · 16/05/2023 23:14

I agree. Benefit cheats are one of the biggest problem we face. Look at a pie chart of government expenditure. It’s shocking. The vast majority goes on welfare. And I would guess that at least a third, if not half, of those receiving the money don’t need or deserve it. Christ, I know SO many people who exploit the system. My friend’s brother, for example, has raised three kids on benefits. I just do not know how he’s got away with it. He’s a super fit gym freak, and there are goddam potholes everywhere, yet he is sat on his arse claiming benefits. Repairing potholes would be beneath him, you see. I could offer at least five more examples of people I know, some in my family, who pretty much live on benefits when there is f-all wrong with them. They contribute nothing to society, and I’m sick of it. The left are always banging on about greedy, selfish bankers. Fine, I agree. But what could be more selfish than sitting around playing video games and claiming benefits while other people get up at six (like me) work hard and pay their tax?

The money that is wasted on benefit cheats could be better spent elsewhere. It could be used to buy cancer drugs for the NHS, or to improve literacy, or to repair the roads, or to produce more STEM graduates, or to restore a beautiful cathedral. There are countless things it would be better spent on. God, it makes me furious.

the Vast majority of the welfare bill is spent on pensions because rightly or wrongly that is the pot of money it comes out of.

everyone claims that they know a ton of people fiddling the system, but despite how many people are willing to report it, funnily enough the actual assessed levels of fraud especially on things like disability benefits are very low.

given the amount of hoops disabled people go through again it comes down to people looking from the outside in making assumptions without genuinely understanding someone’s life.

But again given the number of reports and the lack of prosecutions, I very much doubt the evidence some of the people doing the reporting actually exists.

I also despise when people feel the need to mention cancer like this is the magic word that wins every argument. Cancer had vast sums of money spent on it, vast, and 3/4 of that money goes to multi billion corporations who take public ally funded research and patent it. Creating treatments with limited efficacy that cost obscene amounts of money. It’s a massive massive scam designed to funnel money from the NI pot to private organisations. The sums are so casts that the odd sister living with a boyfriend is actually immaterial

maybe if more money was spent on researching things like chronic fatigue, pain relief, and kinder mental health treatments more people would be in work?

WilkinsonM · 17/05/2023 07:08

Ilovetea42 · 16/05/2023 20:03

I mean, no it's not great but if she's moved him in after dating for only a few weeks and she has two children to think of I can see why she wouldn't want him to have an equal claim to her children's home. I personally wouldn't be reporting them purely out of consideration for your neice(s)/nephew. Its obviously unethical what they're doing but I don't see how leaving her with a huge bill to repay would benefit those kids in any way. I would question how healthy the relationship is if he's moved in that fast and if it's not a great relationship then I wouldn't be fighting for his name on a tenancy which could end up leaving her and her kids homeless and him with cheap rent and a house in his name. I certainly wouldn't be loaning her any money though unless you think he's financially exploiting her and keeping his wage for himself and her to pay for everything. If he's putting all his money in his own savings then she might be tight and not able to access it.

Claiming benefits as a lone parent has nothing to do with adding a partner's name to the tenancy. She probably wouldn't be able to do that if she wanted to but she should still be declaring that he lives there.

Weedoormatnomore · 17/05/2023 07:02

Missingmyusername · 17/05/2023 03:41

^ This.

He sounds like a keeper!

I would be worried about this than the claiming ! Guessing it's why she us asking to borrow money as hers is all gone.

LolaSmiles · 17/05/2023 06:11

He moved in within weeks, by 3 months she was pregnant.
He has your sister paying for everything via her benefits whilst he builds his savings.
He has a nice lump sum and she takes the risk of fraudulently claiming benefits.

My concern would be this isn't a healthy relationship at all and she needs to wake up.

ThankYouMama · 17/05/2023 06:02

I think you need to mind your own business, it's no concern of yours, focus on your life and your money not hers!

user1492757084 · 17/05/2023 05:37

Advise your sister to come clean and to change her status with authorities or she could be pinged and have to pay back.
Don't report her but talk reality.
Never lend her money while she is being dishonest.

frankgu · 17/05/2023 05:31

Also I thought 35k did make someone a net contributor?

frankgu · 17/05/2023 05:29

Look at a pie chart of government expenditure. It’s shocking. The vast majority goes on welfare. And I would guess that at least a third, if not half, of those receiving the money don’t need or deserve it.

Doesn't the majority go on pensions?

autienotnaughtym · 17/05/2023 05:17

If you want to screw your sister over that's your call. Clearly she needs to learn the hard way not to trust you with her private information. On 35k you should still be entitled to some benefits have you done an online calculator? Also you can get tax relief on child care saving you 20%. And if your child is 3 they would be entitled to 30 funded hours.

Goodread1 · 17/05/2023 05:02

@Ilovetea42
It's must be bloody exhausting being taking for a mug,
by someone milking the system, like a dairy warehouse factory farm .!

Begsthequestion · 17/05/2023 04:24

Tinkerbyebye · 16/05/2023 22:10

I would report, you can do it anonymously. I don’t care if it’s my sister, and all those saying it’s your sister, would you say the same if it’s your neighbour? Or Billy on down the street? No didn’t think so

and I bet those saying don’t report are also those slating the Tories for not spending on benefits. Millions is lost each year on benefit fraud and each and every person should be reported and made to pay it back

No, I doubt most people would say the same about 'Billy down the street' ... And that's precisely point they're making - you don't report your own SISTER for something like this.

You'd have to be a real lowlife to put your own family through that.

barmycatmum · 17/05/2023 04:23

Oh my God, leave her alone. This is your sister and her kids - he may not be reliable or safe.

I truly cannot believe people sometimes.

someoneisalwaysintheloo · 17/05/2023 04:13

It sounds like your sister has issues.

Is be more concerned about that and your niece/nephew than any benefits fraud.

Missingmyusername · 17/05/2023 03:41

PollyAmour · 16/05/2023 20:52

He's taking her for a mug, saving all his earnings while she claims benefits. It's her that will be prosecuted for fraud, not him. He'll walk away with a healthy bank balance and she'll have a criminal record for fraud, and two children to care for.

^ This.

He sounds like a keeper!