Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to still expect them to pay their share of the holiday?

494 replies

somethingunpredictable2012 · 16/05/2023 15:57

We have booked a holiday for 4 families (been booked and planned for over a year), however one couple have announced they are expecting and so won’t be coming on the holiday as baby will be 2/3 months old when holiday comes round so they don’t want to go. The couple have paid the deposit but the balance of the holiday is now due. They haven’t mentioned paying their share of the rest of the cost of the holiday and when asked about the holiday at the time of their pregnancy announcement they simply said “oh yeh, we won’t be coming now, which is a shame, but never mind there will be other holidays”. Their conception and pregnancy has been difficult (no one was aware they were even trying for a baby previous to the announcement) and so bringing up the money/holiday has been difficult due to the issues they have had as there never seems to be a good time. But with the balance of the holiday now due and myself and DH having booked the holiday we are liable for the full amount if the other couple don’t pay their agreed part of the holiday. (Lesson learned never to do that again!). One couple have already paid their share in full and don’t want to pay anymore to split the cost of the 4th couple not coming. The other couple think we should just split the cost between us and suck up the extra cost (£800) so as not to put any more pressure on the couple not coming. The couple have ignored all messages relating to paying the final payment, but DH thinks they should pay up and I should contact them directly and insist they pay their share as agreed. I hate confrontation and don’t want to add to their issues if they are having a difficult pregnancy, but at the same time I don’t think it’s fair they just assume we will all now pay their share, as that wasn’t the cost we all agreed to and we could have actually found somewhere smaller which would have been cheaper. Obviously trying for a baby isn’t always easy or predictable but they would have known this may happen when we booked the holiday, but didn’t mention anything and they seem to have just washed their hands of it like it’s no longer their problem it’s now ours to sort out. It’s obviously causing a lot of tension between everyone involved. What would you do? Is it unreasonable to still expect they pay their share even if they don’t want to come anymore?

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 18/05/2023 14:41

Balfour vbslfour is the leading case of trying to prove a legal contract existed (between married people)

You need to show there was an intention to create legal relations -so clear agreement ms on amount to pay and when due.

This is why if you ever loan money to friends or family you should definitely draw up a simple loan agreement of terms that you both sign and date.

cstaff · 18/05/2023 14:37

Regardless of whether you get the money or not, this friendship is doomed unfortunately. The only way I see the friendship being upheld is if they pay their part and are able to acknowledge that the money is theirs to pay and see it as fair. That does seem unlikely though as they have been ignoring your whatsapp messages - deliberately I would imagine.

For the above reason, I would set your DH on them and at least then you are not left short if he can do a good "bull in a china shop act" and have them pay their part of the accommodation costs.

What a waste of a good (I presume) friendship...

burnoutbabe · 18/05/2023 14:33

There are 2 separate conto here

1 is op with villa company. Only she can cancel and she owes the money. (All if it) this will be in writing somewhere

2nd is an informal one between op and other 3 couples. Not in writing but there are some texts agreeing to pay deposits and a 4 way split.

So legally you could try and sue them in small claims for smaller of
Total deposit lost or total unpaid by them (£800) as you should mitigate your losses.

shammalammadingdong · 18/05/2023 14:30

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 14:16

That’s the point though. They can. All they have to do is not pay. And if the balance isn’t paid the holiday will be cancelled unless the other parties pay.

They REALLY can't. They literally can't, they have no contract with the provider to cancel. OP CAN cancel, if they can;t afford the balance. CF cannot.

You're not getting the basics here.

It wouldn't be hard to prove a contract between OP and CF'ers in a court. I doubt OP would bother, but it wouldn't be that hard to force payment.

ButterCrackers · 18/05/2023 14:24

They should pay up but if there’s nothing signed they can just walk away. If they don’t pay up then don’t speak to them again.

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 14:23

shammalammadingdong · 18/05/2023 14:15

You know you're using a lot of words just to say you don't know how life or money works.

They CAN'T cancel and lose the deposit. It isn't their booking. It's not theirs to cancel, or decide about the deposit.

Which bit of this are you so confused by?

Also you’re missing they have cancelled. They’ve said they’re not going. How do you think the OP is going to get the money out of them?

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 14:16

shammalammadingdong · 18/05/2023 14:15

You know you're using a lot of words just to say you don't know how life or money works.

They CAN'T cancel and lose the deposit. It isn't their booking. It's not theirs to cancel, or decide about the deposit.

Which bit of this are you so confused by?

That’s the point though. They can. All they have to do is not pay. And if the balance isn’t paid the holiday will be cancelled unless the other parties pay.

shammalammadingdong · 18/05/2023 14:15

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 13:22

They haven’t though. The deposit was relating to the contract with the provider. Which is you cancel you lose the deposit. Not that you cannot cancel because it’s a group booking.

You know you're using a lot of words just to say you don't know how life or money works.

They CAN'T cancel and lose the deposit. It isn't their booking. It's not theirs to cancel, or decide about the deposit.

Which bit of this are you so confused by?

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 13:42

GingerNutMe · 18/05/2023 13:35

I would doubt very much that each individual family paid deposits direct to the company, it would normally be dealt with by one person collecting the deposits centrally then paying it on behalf of the group. Regardless, their payment of the deposit is a clear indication to the rest of the group that they had planned to go and had accepted their proportion of the costs.

They don’t have to. That’s not how it works

GingerNutMe · 18/05/2023 13:35

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 13:22

They haven’t though. The deposit was relating to the contract with the provider. Which is you cancel you lose the deposit. Not that you cannot cancel because it’s a group booking.

I would doubt very much that each individual family paid deposits direct to the company, it would normally be dealt with by one person collecting the deposits centrally then paying it on behalf of the group. Regardless, their payment of the deposit is a clear indication to the rest of the group that they had planned to go and had accepted their proportion of the costs.

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 13:22

GingerNutMe · 18/05/2023 12:53

Questionable !! By paying the deposit they have effectively entered into a contract with the other parties. But we are talking more morals than legal proceedings here, 'my lady'.

They haven’t though. The deposit was relating to the contract with the provider. Which is you cancel you lose the deposit. Not that you cannot cancel because it’s a group booking.

GasPanic · 18/05/2023 13:17

ThatWardrobe · 18/05/2023 13:02

Unleash the DH. They don't care what you think, so you need to stop worrying about the other way round.

This.

To me clearly they don't value your friendship. Or they live in some sort of dream world where they expect people to suck up these sorts of financial losses without any sort of consequence.

Despite what you may or may not think, these people are not your friends.

Friends simply don't do that to you, and you're just being a doormat if you are willing to let them get away with it without consequence.

If you want to find out who are your real friends, look to the couple who are willing to share the extra cost with you. These are the people that are saying :

"hey it's not fair that you should get dumped on with this because those people are being arseholes, and we're willing to share the consequences because we don't agree that you should get screwed over just for being willing to organise."

These are decent people - these are your friends.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 18/05/2023 13:12

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 18/05/2023 10:18

I’d send in the bull in the china shop

Me too. The couple are being really rude. They should be offering to pay in full, they're pulling out. I certainly wouldn't be doing anything with them in the future.

ThatWardrobe · 18/05/2023 13:02

Unleash the DH. They don't care what you think, so you need to stop worrying about the other way round.

SquaresandStarlings · 18/05/2023 12:59

The other couple think we should just split the cost between us and suck up the extra cost (£800) so as not to put any more pressure on the couple not coming.

I've heard of this happening quite a lot when group holidays are booked so far in advance, and the other couple's suggestion above is really your only polite option.

I don't think the couple not coming are really in the wrong, they are just handling it really badly by not communicating with you all about - it's this that would make me question my friendship with them rather than the money itself.

GingerNutMe · 18/05/2023 12:53

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 12:28

Legally they aren’t liable.

Questionable !! By paying the deposit they have effectively entered into a contract with the other parties. But we are talking more morals than legal proceedings here, 'my lady'.

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 12:28

GingerNutMe · 18/05/2023 12:21

So is their anyone else that could be invited to attend that would be acceptable to everyone, seems the easiest solution if their is!

If not then leave someone else to talk to this couple about it, like your husband. Maybe this couple need the straightforward approach if they haven't taken the hint already.

The reality is that they are liable for the cost, they agreed to go and agreed to pay that cost. By paying the deposit they effectively 'sealed the deal'. Whilst people can appreciate the reasons they have chosen to now not go that doesn't mean these other people should be burdened with the financial responsibilities of their decision.

Legally they aren’t liable.

GingerNutMe · 18/05/2023 12:21

So is their anyone else that could be invited to attend that would be acceptable to everyone, seems the easiest solution if their is!

If not then leave someone else to talk to this couple about it, like your husband. Maybe this couple need the straightforward approach if they haven't taken the hint already.

The reality is that they are liable for the cost, they agreed to go and agreed to pay that cost. By paying the deposit they effectively 'sealed the deal'. Whilst people can appreciate the reasons they have chosen to now not go that doesn't mean these other people should be burdened with the financial responsibilities of their decision.

XelaM · 18/05/2023 10:51

Literally just booked a holiday with a friend of mine. She did the booking. If I cancel I will still have to pay her. Otherwise it's total cheeky-fuckery

billy1966 · 18/05/2023 10:50

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 18/05/2023 10:18

I’d send in the bull in the china shop

This.

They should pay what they owe.

Their change of circumstances and choice has nothing to do with you.

Really shabby behaviour.

Clearly they place zero value on the relationships involved.

Very short sighted.

Jumpingthruhoops · 18/05/2023 10:48

Datgal · 16/05/2023 16:19

I would definitely say something about them paying the rest (or like pp have suggested and paying your list deposits if you cancel). How selfish can you get?? I can't get my head around this. What if they'd made the booking? Would they just suck up the extra cost? I'd be prepared to lose a friendship over this. Friends don't shaft each other!

THIS!

The amount of friendships I've known to break down over these group 'holidays' has put me off ever wanting to book/go on one.

JenWillsiam · 18/05/2023 10:46

shammalammadingdong · 18/05/2023 09:58

Only if its your own booking, just for you. You decide not to go, you cancel, you lose your deposit.

But this is not their booking, its OP's. They can't cancel. The others are still going. They made an agreement to go on the holiday, there is no option to cancel and just lose the booking. The only option is to pay.

You can't be actually serious? Do you really not see that they owe the balance?

It doesn’t work like that I’m afraid, if a person decides to cancel there’s not much you can do. The terms of the contract with the provider stand unless you’ve reached a separate agreement.

it’s not about what I think, if it was me I would absolutely pay, it’s what you can enforce in law. You cannot make them pay, you would have to go through the courts and they would refer back to the original contract which is a cancellation means loss of deposit. The only exception to this would be if the parties had come to an enhanced agreement which it doesn’t sound like they have. This is precisely why whenever I do a group booking I make everyone pay up front and state clearly no refunds.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 18/05/2023 10:18

I’d send in the bull in the china shop

MarkWithaC · 18/05/2023 10:13

EcoChica1980 · 17/05/2023 19:55

Really? You’d just bin them off forever because they were preoccupied with their difficult pregnancy and hadn’t read your mind about paying for a holiday?

Probably they’d see that they have an obligation to pay if it was
pointed out to them.

And they didn’t you can say good riddance at that point.

Do YOU find it impossible to realise when you owe money because you can't read people's minds?
Do you only realise when you have an obligation if someone spells it out to you?

Give your head a wobble, eh. They're blatantly taking the piss.

QueefQueen80s · 18/05/2023 10:07

Are they replying to other messages OP? They're hoping it'll all blow over and be magically sorted if they keep quiet. But it'll just cause more resentment and this might be the end of the friendship.