Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 15 is too old for a babysitter?

161 replies

LadyGodiva4 · 16/05/2023 15:02

My sister has asked me to babysit my 15 year old (who has no disability/learning difficulties) this weekend. It's not terribly convenient for me, but I will do it as I generally think it's nice to be helpful to family where possible, but what rubs me up the wrong way is that I don't think a 15 year really needs supervision.

They heavily supervise all her homework which I find bizarre, as I think she really is old enough to be getting on with it herself. When we were her age we were making our money babysitting. AIBU to think it's a bit annoying to ask for a favour like that, when it's not really necessary, and would you let your 15 year old stay in for the evening (not overnight, just till say 11pm)?

OP posts:
pinkyredrose · 17/05/2023 17:10

Florenz · 16/05/2023 19:58

I was working at 15, as were many, maybe most kids I grew up with. What on earth has happened?

I hear ya!

Arniesleftleg · 17/05/2023 16:14

I wouldn't let my 15 year old stay home alone overnight but have no problem with her being home alone in the evening if we're out.

WindUpPenguin · 17/05/2023 15:56

Could it be that your niece gets nervous being in the house alone, and just wants the company, rather than needing looking after? I think that's understandable at that age.

Fruitful82 · 17/05/2023 15:52

Perhaps something very distressing has happened to your niece that you are unaware of.

has that occurred to you?

Sorryyoufeelthatwayy · 17/05/2023 15:45

Hahahhahha I was the babysitter at this age. Poor girl. No wonder kids have a bad rep these days all trigger warnings galore. Jeez

ParadoxicalHippy · 17/05/2023 15:36

Interesting. The gap between helicopter/mollycoddle parents, whose 18 year olds won’t have a scooby when they find themselves having to cook their own tea, wash their own pants and remembering to do the green cross code before they cross the road, versus 12 year olds, who can efficiently manage their own finances and leave the house at 9am on a Saturday not returning until 9pm having hung out with their mates, been shopping, replied to parental texts with singular letters or acronyms, and bought their own lunch, tea and snacks. Unless this 15 year old has SN or challenging behaviour that renders them untrustworthy, then hell no they do not need a sitter.

During the summer hols, my then 11 year old had an issue going to the childminder (with my then 7 year old) who lived over the road. We agreed that he could stay at home while I was at work provided he checked in with CM for lunch and tea and if he wanted to play out he had to check with CM first and be back at the given time. Another parent who’s 13 year old was forced to attend the same CM objected to my ‘lax’ parenting. Granted she was a police officer, thus was cautious of her childcare choices. Once I explained to her how bored out of her mind her daughter was for 10 hours a day with a CM who predominantly cared for toddlers, and that she got off the school bus four stops away to pretend she was going home so her friends wouldn’t laugh at her, the parent reassessed her view and realised she could trust her very sensible 13 to be home alone for three hours.

MathiasBroucek · 17/05/2023 15:22

As 15 I was the babysitter for neighbours. YANBU

Drfosters · 17/05/2023 15:20

At 15 I was babysitting all the local neighbourhood kids. I made a fortune in my last 3 years of school. I don’t think a 15 year old needs babysitting but they would need their phone on and all the close neighbours numbers to hand.

AnnieSaxophone · 17/05/2023 15:16

They need to get her trained up t be as independent as she can be by the time she’s 18. They aren’t doing her any favours by doing everything for her. eg lifts when she should be using public transport etc.

Cherrypossum · 17/05/2023 15:14

LadyGodiva4 · 16/05/2023 15:33

They are very coddling and overprotective, and she is a bit young for her age. She's an only child which may come into it? She's absolutely not one for boys or drinking though, she's very well behaved, and already a very sweet girl (although very used to being the centre of attention).

Why would an only child come into it?
Do you normally stereotype so badly.

PurpleWisteria1 · 17/05/2023 15:11

I have a just turned 14 year old. I wouldn’t worry about her being left for the evening but she would hate it as it’s quiet and in the dark. She’s fine on her own in the day but even then only for a few hours.

jellybe · 17/05/2023 15:09

My 14 year old has started babysitting. At 15 it's time to let them grow up a bit and have some responsibility for themselves. Sounds very OTT to me.

Changes17 · 17/05/2023 15:06

Of course she should be fine to be left, but maybe your DN or your DSis doesn't have the confidence because they've never tried. My 12yo gets herself into our city and back on the bus. I'm sure your DN could as well. Just say you can't one time - maybe when the weather's good and it's not too late. Suggest she could get the bus, or stay in, on her own. Once she realises she can, there'll be no stopping her.

PS I once stood behind a uni student in the post office who wanted to send a parcel and had literally no idea how to – learned helplessness can go on for years.

Strawberrydelight78 · 17/05/2023 15:05

Very odd I assumed you ment a whole weekend. Could she not invite a friend around or go to a friend's if she doesn't want to be alone? I'm sure most mature NT 15 year olds with no additional needs would be embarrassed if they're friends find out they need a sitter for a few hours.

jimmyjammy001 · 17/05/2023 15:03

20 years ago when I was 15/16 I was going out into town with mates for a Night out getting back at 2am, how times have changed! Having a babysitter at 15, that poor 15 year old!

RHOShitVille · 17/05/2023 15:03

I was definitely left alone at 15.

But.

I have a 15 year old and they and their friends are definitely much less independent than I was. Covid hit just as they were going off independently - shopping, walking around alone, preparing to use public transport. Now, most of my teen and their friends seem to have lost a lot of confidence and skills in terms of independence. They all retreated with Covid and have sort of stayed there.

I see a lot of other kids of similar age out and about though, so it is obviously not universal.

My 15 year old probably wouldn't like a whole night alone - perhaps an evening for a couple of hours, but they really have got used to us being home a lot more. They do have mental health issues though, so I pick my battles.

FlounderingFruitcake · 17/05/2023 15:02

They sound completely insane. My 15YO niece babysits my 5YO and 2YO!

Trees6 · 17/05/2023 15:02

I feel so sorry for her. Poor kid

Sunflowers80 · 17/05/2023 14:58

At 15 I worked my own little job and went to Central London with friends regularly. Looked after myself in the morning when parents were working and even evenings. 1 month after my 16th birthday I went on holiday abroad , flying all by myself paid for by my little job I had, yes I stayed with relations but pretty much did everything myself, going to the beach , town , eating out in the evenings, they werent always home 😆 seriously is this what we've come to? babysitting 15 year olds?

FrostyFifi · 17/05/2023 14:57

You get parents like this. An ex had a younger half-sister who was totally coddled by his step-mum, at 15 her mum would keep her sanitary towels for her and she'd ask if she needed one. At nineteen she decided to stay over at her boyfriend and the mum hit the roof and phoned the police, it was a big drama.
Bizarre people.

crazycrofter · 17/05/2023 14:54

This is very strange! Ours were left at home together one evening a week from when they were 13 and 11. We were back around 10.30/latest 11pm and it was a school night, so they just chilled out/played xbox/did homework and then got ready for bed.

Fansandblankets · 17/05/2023 14:51

We’ve left our 15/16 year old overnight. We have cameras at home but she’s happy to be home alone. She did have our two dogs for company. I lived on my own at 16, getting myself to college everyday and everything!

ASimpleLampoon · 17/05/2023 14:48

Normally I would say it's fine to leave them.

How does the child feel?
Anxious and would prefer company?
Or suffocated and controlled at being infantalised.

Depends on the child.

chaosmaker · 17/05/2023 14:48

One of my friends was very overprotective and planned all her only child's activities and now that child - 22 this year is really not resilient at all. Your sister, OP is not doing your niece any favours and may be harming her as the real world won't be so accomodating as you know.
Don't babysit.

Snapdragonsoup · 17/05/2023 14:47

My 15 year old sometimes babysits his younger sister. Unless he was going to be out at the time or there was some other exceptional reason would not now book a babysitter.