Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too much hard work being friends with a mentally ill person?

119 replies

jumanjigertrude · 16/05/2023 12:52

According to lots of people. Mentally ill people should only associate with professionals and should not seek help from friends or family, lest they cause them too much distress or disruption in their lives. The bad times outweigh the good times when dealing with people suffering with mental illness. It is too draining to deal with them. If that is the case, what are people going through mental illness supposed to do? If nobody wants to associate with them and treats them like a pariah, then what's the point?

OP posts:
Feelslikespring2 · 16/05/2023 19:05

Agree with degree of mental illness being a determining factor. Someone with depression or anxiety is relatively easy to support in comparison to say someone with BPD, severe anorexia nervosa or psychosis who spend a lot of time in and out of mental health units.

My sibling has lost all their friends, it's too distressing for even close family to deal with sometimes let alone a friend who isn't as obligated or invested.

I don't know what the answer is. I feel like the media although bringing mental health into the limelight has somehow minimised how debilitating and traumatising a severe crisis can be. They want to tie it in a bow and with 'reach out and talk. Problem solved'.

DRS1970 · 16/05/2023 18:51

YABU, a true friend would not think a friend in need is too much hard work.

NotAHouse · 16/05/2023 18:49

Depends, really. I have had mental health struggles. But If you're talking about someone with a personality disorder that makes them lie to and manipulate everyone around them, then they should be seeking help rather than using people as pawns in their need for attention.

Kool4kats · 16/05/2023 18:46

One of my close friends has fairly severe MH issues, which included a suicide attempt and being sectioned twice.
I can honestly say that she is one of my most favourite people in the world. I'm her friend, not her therapist, and she's been there for me just as much as I've been there for her over the years.
I'm grateful to have her in my life, she is so much more than her mental illness to me

WeeOrcadian · 16/05/2023 18:03

jumanjigertrude · 16/05/2023 12:52

According to lots of people. Mentally ill people should only associate with professionals and should not seek help from friends or family, lest they cause them too much distress or disruption in their lives. The bad times outweigh the good times when dealing with people suffering with mental illness. It is too draining to deal with them. If that is the case, what are people going through mental illness supposed to do? If nobody wants to associate with them and treats them like a pariah, then what's the point?

What is this actually based on? Who has said this? I think that's important, to give some context

Reasonableadjustments · 16/05/2023 18:01

DeadSea95 · 16/05/2023 17:54

That's a sweeping statement. It depends entirely on the mental illness, how its managed and what the person's expectations are.

I have bipolar II and have friends.

However, I avoid people with untreated cluster B personality disorders if I see evidence of them individually making others unhappy.

Exactly.

Shoxfordian · 16/05/2023 18:01

I’m sure there was a similar thread a few months ago. Nobody said that people with mental health issues shouldn’t have friends; just that we need to maintain our own boundaries and sometimes that includes stepping back

DeadSea95 · 16/05/2023 17:54

That's a sweeping statement. It depends entirely on the mental illness, how its managed and what the person's expectations are.

I have bipolar II and have friends.

However, I avoid people with untreated cluster B personality disorders if I see evidence of them individually making others unhappy.

maddening · 16/05/2023 17:47

Surely it depends on the person, the relationship and the illness for each case.

Nintendogal · 16/05/2023 17:35

Half of the people I know have mental health issues of one kind or another. I would be severely limiting my life if I refused to be friends with them, they are wonderful people.

emanresu000 · 16/05/2023 17:32

Informal networks of support, including and perhaps primarily friends and family are so important for people with MH challenges, just as they are important to people with no MH challenges.

When I had very poor MH, I valued the opinions of friends and family somewhat more than the opinions of professionals (except when it came to advice about the mental illness itself). My friends and family did not have to be nice, for example, but I felt the support workers, social workers and other professionals were sort of expected to be and even paid to be kind (this reflected my thought processes at the time, not reality).

pandarific · 16/05/2023 14:28

It depends, there is a line where the severely ill person’s illness impacts others significantly, and at that point I don’t blame anyone for stepping right back.

Kanaloa · 16/05/2023 14:24

Who says that people with mental health problems shouldn’t have friends? Who are the ‘lots of people?’

Are you maybe misrepresenting threads where people say it isn’t right to constantly unload into friends or expect friends to provide constant support to you at cost to their own health and comfort?

User1432423532 · 16/05/2023 14:21

Depends a lot on what type of MH issue it is. Transient depression/anxiety is hugely different to severe schizophrenia. MH issues are also far more prevalent in the neurodiverse population due to inherent struggles of trying to fit into a neurotypical world. So what extent of the "hard work" is due to neurodiversity and entirely unrelated to MH? People with ADHD have time blindness and low object permanence which makes them do things like being chronically late or dropping contact with friends without meaning to.

Quveas · 16/05/2023 14:19

jumanjigertrude · 16/05/2023 13:14

Yes it is a balance and not a case of "All In or All Out". However, it does seem to be the latter most of the time.

I have never heard anyone, ever, say these sorts of things. I have seen nothing in the media at all saying this. In fact the only place I have seen anything like this level of stupidity is on this site - not often, but there was a thread a couple of days ago, for example, where a poster, whose husband was expressing suicidal ideation was told he was a petulant child (and other abusive / derogatory comments) and that she should tell him to buck up / leave him / let him!

Yes, you can't take on the burden of someone else's mental ill health, but that certainly doesn't mean you cut them off or ignore their pain. You also can't break your leg for someone else, but it doesn't mean you suggest they get up and walk on it!

JulieHoney · 16/05/2023 14:15

@jumanjigertrude Every one of the replies has said they’ve never heard people say what you’re claiming “many” people say.

Do you have context? Where are you hearing this blatantly untrue popular opinion?

The consensus here is that sometimes it’s necessary to pull back a bit but not to “not be friends” with people with MH issues.

DollyParkin · 16/05/2023 14:15

I used to work quite closely with a colleague with a pretty serious and chronic mental illness. They were in denial even when sectioned involuntarily to a secure locked ward.

We were quite friendly outside of work, but I had to step away from that because I realised how complicit I was becoming in their consolatory fantasy that they weren’t really severely bipolar, but it was “hormones.”

I couldn’t support this person as a friend and be a good colleague to all my colleagues.

sonjadog · 16/05/2023 14:14

I have never met anyone who thinks that. And I am both old (therefore have met many people during my lifetime) and have worked for many years with large numbers of people.

I think you are taking one incident and generalizing wildly, OP. I suggest you start a new thread and explain what has happened to you with your friend(s) and maybe you can get advice and perspectives on what has happened and why.

Overthebow · 16/05/2023 14:12

I’ve never heard anyone say that, however there does need to be a balance. People have lots of things going on in their own lives, their own mental health problems, family issues etc. so whilst talking to friends is good, people need to be careful to not rely on them too much. I had to step away from a friend who was using our group as another therapy essentially and I was also suffering with my own mental health issues and it all became too much.

Blossombathing · 16/05/2023 14:11

Why don’t you tell us what has happened op? It might offer some insight and more support if we understand why you feel like that. Do you feel let down and isolated because you are unwell at the moment?

LaDamaDeElche · 16/05/2023 14:02

As long as friends aren't substitute therapists and there are boundaries which are respected, then absolutely no reason people can't be. Reaching out should be seen as asking for someone to help you help yourself though. Friends are not mental health professionals, and it can be very emotionally draining to have a friend who is always in crisis and only ever talking about themselves and their problems.

potniatheron · 16/05/2023 13:49

I don't think I've ever heard anyone say that. However, one of my friends is biploar with an alcohol issue. When she's bad I have to step way back because I'm a recovered alcoholic and it's triggering (horrible word but hopefully you know what I mean) for me.

When I was much younger and had a bad eating disorder, some of my friends stepped back and I don't blame them. I was very difficult to be around and looking back, things that young women do together e.g. clothes shopping, going to get food, were a bit of a minefield.

Reasonableadjustments · 16/05/2023 13:43

Peppermint81 · 16/05/2023 13:19

Yes professional help is important but Being able to talk to friends and family is essential if you have MH issues. Withdrawing leads to more problems.

If the friend doesn't want to know then it's up to them but not really a good friend if they cut off someone in need.

That isn't necessarily true.

LooseFit · 16/05/2023 13:43

I’ve had MH issues myself so I am compassionate towards people but there is a limit. I’ve had to distance myself from people who were a constant, long term drain on my emotions and who expected too much from a friendship. I’m not a therapist or anyone’s saviour. It’s important to know one’s own limits.

Bababear987 · 16/05/2023 13:27

Never heard that.

However I think sometimes people who are mentally unwell can be a bit draining and sometimes be selfish friends- not deliberately but sometimes it can be very one sided friendship. And it's very difficult to sustain that and feel responsible for someone when really they need some professional help which I just can't give them.

Its absolutely not that people don't want to help and support their friends but that it can sometimes be a very fine line before the helper is struggling and feeling like they need some help. It's ok at that point to put yourself first and put boundaries in place. For example I had a friend who would literally phone at all hours of the night and expect me to just drop everything at a moments notice and have the same conversations for months on end without actively making any positive changes. She would want to meet up almost every other day and it became exhausting and wasn't actually benefitting either of us at all.

I'm sure she maybe thinks I was very selfish or I wasn't there for her and we aren't as close now but the truth is I was starting to develop MH problems because of her reliance on me and I had to create some distance.