Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers leaving and long term sickness

194 replies

Jennybeans401 · 16/05/2023 06:18

Middle moved school last year due to bullying. She settled well into the new school and things have been okay for her.

About 5 weeks ago the lovely, long term TA left the school. The TA worked in dds class, dd liked her a lot and she provided a lot of stability. The class has a lot of children with SEND requirements. The HT hasn't replaced the TA, dd said the class was difficult but she loves the class teacher so tried to get on with it.

The class teacher took sick leave 2 weeks ago, she seemed very stressed and now the class just have a TA from Reception teaching them (no other TAs to support this young lady). The class is very disruptive now, dd can't concentrate and doesn't understand the work anymore.

I spoke to the HT yesterday who said they don't have any other options but to continue like this until the teacher is back.

AIBU to think of moving dd again if the problem doesn't get resolved?

OP posts:
napody · 16/05/2023 20:49

noblegiraffe · 16/05/2023 10:13

The worst teacher shortages are in secondary where there are way more men than primary.

The problem isn’t men not wanting to be primary teachers, historically there has been an oversupply of primary teachers. The problem is that it’s now so shit they can’t even get women to do it anymore.

This.
Lol at the idea that there all these qualified talented young men dying to be teachers. If they apply, they'll get their hand bitten off. And the % of men not completing initial teacher education (or in secondary shortage subjects, taking the generous bursary but never working as a teacher) is much higher than for women. Over a dozen posts by InnocentSongs making the same, bizarre, irrelevant, ill informed point.

Thisismyusernameforthetimebeing · 16/05/2023 20:43

I'm a T.A (1:1 behavioural) and in our academy school the T.A's cover lessons such as music, computing and R.E when teachers do their PPA. They use an external company to provide sports coaching for P.E lessons during PPA. Last year we had supply teachers but now the T.A's do it. Those who do cover get a slightly higher rate of pay for those hours.

Zonder · 16/05/2023 20:22

The point of the degree is that it is a gateway. It shows that the person has successfully studied and got a higher qualification, with all the transferable skills that involves.
A key thing about a good teacher is that they are able to continue their learning, keep up with research, adapt their practice accordingly. A degree shows they have a level of education and understanding to be able to do that.

Spicysock · 16/05/2023 20:19

Why would no degrees be such a bad thing though? Teaching apprenticeships could work well. Lots of people I know didn’t go to university because they couldn’t afford to, or were in difficult positions at that time but they are bright and could make great teachers. Obviously there would need to be minimum standards but a teacher with a sports degree can teach primary school - hardly superior to a primary teacher with an apprenticeship. Likewise someone with an English degree can teach RE alongside it at secondary, their degree won’t be too helpful towards that. So surely there’s ways to recruit teachers without them getting into masses of debt?

educationisscrewed · 16/05/2023 18:13

Even my DD says that she'd never be a teacher.
The shit you have to put up with from parents sometimes is unreal. The lack of support from SLT because they're scared to put consequences in place for behaviour.
The crap parenting we have - complaints that their precious gems are in a detention to begin with. Dad's shooting their mouths off to female teachers.
It's a shit show already, but the shit will hit the fan in a big way soon.
I'm only in this job for the school holiday childcare until I can find a WFH job. I'm not choosing teaching as the hill to die on.

LotsOfBalloons · 16/05/2023 18:05

Yup - teaching apprenticeships.

Ita already happening that a significant proportion of kids are being taught by TAs it's already happened really. But for all noblegiraffe and others posts nobody hears it!

Redlocks28 · 16/05/2023 17:41

PyjamaFan · 16/05/2023 11:13

It's not just that teachers don't want to be selfless anymore. The job has completely changed and the workload is just ridiculous. It doesn't matter how much teachers care for their pupils, they are just not capable of doing everything that is demanded of them.

Add to that changed attitudes from parents, worsening behaviour, cost of living etc and the job is just not worth it.

I don’t know a single one of my DC’s friends (all leaving university and planning careers) who want to teach. Loads of them also have mums who are teachers, so it wouldn’t be unreasonable to expect a few to head in direction, but not one wants to do it.

I expect the government’s new plan will be that you don’t need a degree to teach, to fudge the recruitment figures. Of course they’ll sell it (to the Daily Fail) by saying there are loads of fabulous scientists, mathematicians etc waiting in the wings, who would make amazeballs teachers but who for some inexplicable reason couldn’t do a degree and will solve the teacher recruitment crisis. In reality, you’ll just get a load of school leavers.

Zonder · 16/05/2023 11:16

Twiglets1 · 16/05/2023 08:48

Lots of people liked him... the electorate would beg to disagree

I still think that's because such a hatchet job was done on him by the MSM.

PyjamaFan · 16/05/2023 11:13

It's not just that teachers don't want to be selfless anymore. The job has completely changed and the workload is just ridiculous. It doesn't matter how much teachers care for their pupils, they are just not capable of doing everything that is demanded of them.

Add to that changed attitudes from parents, worsening behaviour, cost of living etc and the job is just not worth it.

Innocentsongs · 16/05/2023 10:42

@HereAndNowAgain . I think MN is powerful and I think you get a feel for common opinions held by many posters. There are threads which highlight typical views held by MNers.
I think many posters want to blame teacher recruitment and retention on politics. I am sûre that has something to do with it but there are significant reasons in addition to politics explaining why, post Covid, there is a huge problem with teacher retention and recruitment.
Many posters on here want the experience they had at school to be repeated for their children. It's like Julia from Motherland saying that she wanted her children to be brought up the same way that she was - by her mother. Lots of posters want the same selfless female teachers at primary school that they remember. But those teachers don't want to do it anymore. They want to be working from home and picking up their own children from school. So many posters do not acknowledge that the reasons why teachers are leaving, and it's not just a question of money, need to be addressed
The Government has invested a lot of money in Oak Academy. I think the future will include a lot of online classes for older children

MullerInk · 16/05/2023 10:38

I have 7 children in my class with EHCPs. I haven't got a TA so all the interventions come down to me. While running a usual school day with 30 children in a class. I also run lunchtime clubs most days. There are many children in my classroom with emotional problems which can disrupt the lesson. A few weeks ago a child kept shouting out because I referred to a whiteboard as just the board. I said sorry I misspoke but she kept going on and on so in the end I told her that she was being disruptive and I got complained about.

I work in a school where we are not allowed to reward behaviour 🙃 that also makes it tricky.

noblegiraffe · 16/05/2023 10:13

The worst teacher shortages are in secondary where there are way more men than primary.

The problem isn’t men not wanting to be primary teachers, historically there has been an oversupply of primary teachers. The problem is that it’s now so shit they can’t even get women to do it anymore.

Lostmum2407 · 16/05/2023 09:44

PyjamaFan · 16/05/2023 09:36

All those who told teachers to stop moaning and leave if they don't like it, well we have. And here are the consequences.
I taught primary for 22 years and will not be returning. I'm currently a supply TA but quite honestly am just fed up with the whole system.

Yes I left too after 15 years. I could no longer work 100 hour weeks and feel like I was paying my own children enough attention. The work load is unsustainable. I now work less than half the hours and earn triple the pay. It’s not about the money though, it’s about my health. Teaching is incredibly difficult and even after sweating blood, it’s still not enough and you get constantly criticised.

PyjamaFan · 16/05/2023 09:36

All those who told teachers to stop moaning and leave if they don't like it, well we have. And here are the consequences.
I taught primary for 22 years and will not be returning. I'm currently a supply TA but quite honestly am just fed up with the whole system.

toomuchlaundry · 16/05/2023 09:23

Exactly @Blahblahaha it’s not just Tories who send their children to private schools or state schools in wealthy catchment areas

Blahblahaha · 16/05/2023 09:13

I wonder if a newspaper published a list of MPs and whether their children were privately taught or at an 'elitist' schools (like the ones in London where you have to live within 1/4 mile in multimillion pound houses, but school is technically not a private school eg Tony Blair's children?? or grammars) and maybe even those who lead the teaching unions and academy CEOs or equivalent to get an idea of who exactly in positions of influence actually have any skin in the game to improve the situation.

Premiumchange · 16/05/2023 09:01

This would be quite unusual, even in an academy. Are you sure this TA isn't a HLTA (Higher Level) and that they are working completely unsupported by other teachers or maybe the leadership team? It's really not good at all, but as others have said, it's reality in schools. I don't know how any future government is going to wave a magic financial and motivational wand over this either.

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 08:55

toomuchlaundry · 16/05/2023 08:53

@HereAndNowAgain private schools are also having issues with teacher retention/recruitment

And the leaders still do nothing 🤯

toomuchlaundry · 16/05/2023 08:53

@HereAndNowAgain private schools are also having issues with teacher retention/recruitment

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 08:52

Innocentsongs · 16/05/2023 08:44

An awful lot of mothers look at MN and it is so unfriendly to the idea of men teaching in infant class settings.
However some of you are so confident that a bit of extra money will solve teacher recruitment. It won't. The world is changing. Young people don't want to be teachers, nurses, carers or nursery nurses anymore. Teaching will need to widen access in terms of recruitment and lots of MN will not like that.

I agree people can be weird about male caregivers. We were the minority and used older teen boys as sitters.

But do you think mumsnet is that powerful? It doesn’t always have a diverse set of views that represents the masses.

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 08:50

The top private schools still have a lot of trained teachers. Won’t there be a negative trickle-down effect if people don’t train as teachers? Because presumably a large number of private school teachers come from UK teacher training and the state system. If people do not train as teachers in the first place, then the private and public school system will be affected too surely?

Same goes for private medical care. Eventually everyone will be affected, even the wealthy. Idiots.

Good education is needed for every profession and for the economic growth, mental health etc of a country. Why are we not investing in it??

Twiglets1 · 16/05/2023 08:48

Zonder · 16/05/2023 08:44

I really disagree here. Corbyn was very popular. Increased party membership, lots of people liked him. Then there was a mighty smear campaign - his clothes, his perceived antisemitism, his jam-making. Msm went for him and he stood no chance.

Lots of people liked him... the electorate would beg to disagree

Twiglets1 · 16/05/2023 08:46

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 08:42

My 16y gets £10 an hour for folding clothes in a London fashion shop. TA and care workers’ pay is disgusting.

It is - and that is one reason they shouldn't be asked to cover for teachers. Also, they have no training to do the job because it's not their actual job.

What next? Maybe the staff cooking the school dinners could lend a hand?

tiredhadenough · 16/05/2023 08:46

@toomuchlaundry I agree.

I think too much focus of the strike for teachers has been about pay but really it's the conditions which are the issue and it is the children that suffer!

QuizzlyBear · 16/05/2023 08:45

My DS has his first GCSE exam today. It's in Economics, a subject for which they've had two years without an Economics teacher. They had a sub for a few months, then a pe teacher, then eventually were told to 'read from their textbook'. For some subjects they just have to go and study in the school hall all together as several classes don't have cover.

It's a grammar school that's in the top 10 schools in the country. If they can't recruit teachers I shudder to think how local primaries and comps are managing. This government have run our country into the ground.

Swipe left for the next trending thread