Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can we start a poverty solidarity thread?

260 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 16/05/2023 05:27

It often feels like MN is a different world and I can't actually talk to anyone in real life as people either don't get it or assume I'm trying to gain sympathy or ask for money.

I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now

  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo
So worried that I'll need to drive somewhere and have to explain that I have no petrol. Currently walking everywhere. I know it's partly my fault as I went a bit far on the last payday and bought a shed, but obviously no one is going to offer me a 0% interest or repayment scheme due to my credit. Wish I could budget better. I think these dry spells make it worse though. You live with weeks with nothing and then my wages come in and I go a bit crazy. Another downside of being skint. Could ask father of children but I can't take the smugness. He took them out for pizza last night and they brought some home! Ravenously ate it in the kitchen whilst they weren't looking. It's mad that this is the reality. No one knows. I have a full time job, nice house, car in drive, dress well (charity shops), the kids look ok. How no one gets what it's like, waking up to nothing in the bank, dry cereal, panicking about if there's a non school uniform day. Please let me know what's going on for you so I don't feel so alone!
OP posts:
Sissynova · 16/05/2023 12:21

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 12:06

@Sissynova exactly ,I grew up with my mum writing everything down in a book, which she does to this day,any money in ,any money out she was exactly aware of what was going on. The challenge with online banking now is that money is no longer as “real” so it’s far easier to spend it.

It is definitely different with so many things being online and paid by card etc!

I'm a massive fan of banks like Monzo that let you separate everything out into different pots. You can split all your money immediately on pay day, put the amount for all your direct debits into one pot, food and daily spending goes in another, it is better if you split this to weekly or at least by weekly as it is easier to not go over if it isn't available, and so on and so on. The more pots the better imo!
So many people struggle with visualising how much money they actually have for the money when their bills all come out on different dates, so you might have hundreds in your account but really only £90 is spare or for food or whatever.

Emeraldrings · 16/05/2023 12:20

I feel for you OP. We rarely have any spare money. DD has been trying for almost a year to get a part time job which mean she wouldn't need to ask us for money all the time as we just can't afford it.
I can't go and see my elderly parents much as petrol is too expensive and going by bus would be impossible.
Food is stupidly expensive. We buy the basic range but still struggle. Nursery fees for DS are ridiculous and although I get more than the fees cost it's not by much.
We get working tax credits and child benefit but it just doesn't go very far and I really worry about an unexpected bill coming our way

ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 12:19

Oh, another tip, if you have a salon supply shop within reach go and buy shampoo and conditioner by the gallon. A gallon of generic salon shampoo around here costs roughly £25 and will last for at least 6 months.

ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 12:16

I understand why OP bought the shed. When you live month to month you can't really save up. There's not usually enough left over to save anything substantial. It could take years to save for a shed if all you can put away is a few quid a month and you usually have to dip into it every few months to buy unplanned essentials like school shoes etc. Of course, in those circumstances, it's more than tempting to think "fuck it, I'm buying the shed and we'll figure it out later."

I've done it before, and I'm sure hundreds of others have. I don't think OP actually chose between milk and shampoo and a shed.

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 12:13

Lovemylaminator · 16/05/2023 12:07

OP, I know what you mean, I think.

We are not at the stage you are at, but our life has become increasingly miserable over the last few years.

Two decent wage earners, one child, one dog.

I find my overdraft is increasing every month, and every month one extra thing that is ' nice' has to go.

What I find hard to take is that there is no money left for savings or to pay for a week abroad, something that on our wages was possible five or six years ago.

It's not poverty as such - there's always food in the cupboards ( although of a reduced quality) , and the odd night out here and there.

If we didn't do a single social thing, no treats - just living mega frugal - all month we could probably save £200.

Just writing it down sounds stupidly entitled, but if this is what is happening to us, God knows how people on a lot less than us are coping.

I think that’s really common at the moment ,it’s actually easier to come from a low income background even if you then earn more in later life as when times get hard again you don’t forget the lessons you learnt when there was very little to go around. For those affected by the cost of living crisis many are going from an income that allows spontaneous spending to having to tighten their belts and that’s a lot more challenging. I imagine for many parents who split up its even more difficult to give up a lifestyle that you had as a couple and become a single parent.if you recognise that your income is shrinking its a good time to sit down and go through all your spending and try to decide your family priorities.

FancyasFuck · 16/05/2023 12:12

lightand · 16/05/2023 11:32

Why on earth people reported this thread, I have no idea.

Because kind (or naive) MNetters send goods and money to people who post about being poor.

I'm not sure how often it happens now but it happened a lot in the past, and some people were outed as scammers.

So some posters are wary and MNHQ send out the standard warning.

Lovemylaminator · 16/05/2023 12:07

OP, I know what you mean, I think.

We are not at the stage you are at, but our life has become increasingly miserable over the last few years.

Two decent wage earners, one child, one dog.

I find my overdraft is increasing every month, and every month one extra thing that is ' nice' has to go.

What I find hard to take is that there is no money left for savings or to pay for a week abroad, something that on our wages was possible five or six years ago.

It's not poverty as such - there's always food in the cupboards ( although of a reduced quality) , and the odd night out here and there.

If we didn't do a single social thing, no treats - just living mega frugal - all month we could probably save £200.

Just writing it down sounds stupidly entitled, but if this is what is happening to us, God knows how people on a lot less than us are coping.

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 12:06

@Sissynova exactly ,I grew up with my mum writing everything down in a book, which she does to this day,any money in ,any money out she was exactly aware of what was going on. The challenge with online banking now is that money is no longer as “real” so it’s far easier to spend it.

Sissynova · 16/05/2023 12:02

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 10:56

Do you understand the title of this thread?

Are you able to respectfully adhere to it, or otherwise pipe down?

No I'm not going to "pipe down". Why do you think your comments are more valid?
Please tell me one thing I have said that wasn't respectful or in keeping with the discussion...

I was responding to a poster who suggested you needed a computer and expensive software to budget!
That is so far from reality. Hundreds of thousands of people across the country would be much better off if they took some time to practice budgeting techniques, particularly from the likes of Dave Ramsey.

You don't need a computer to budget, you don't need excel, you don't need anything fancy. Most people have a phone with a calculator already and if thet don't like using an app they can just use a notepad.

I did a monthly paper budget for years and it helped massively.

I don't subscribe to the 'well too bad guess I'm too poor to budget because I don'y have a computer' It isn't helpful and it doesn't lift people out of their current situation.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 16/05/2023 11:55

Everyone manages money differently. Some use envelopes, some use spreadsheets. I pay off all my bills at the beginning of the month when my check comes in. Electric, gas, water, phone, a monthly grocery shop ($400), then some on my credit cards. I "splurge" on a life insurance policy to provide for my son in case the stress gets me. Whatever money is left goes on gas for his truck. (There are no buses in our county, no trains in our state and his work is 20 miles away!) When he isn't working he is taking on-line Uni courses and helping me at home. He cleans, cooks, and is an unpaid carer. His girlfriend broke up with him because he never had any money to take her out or buy her gifts. His only outlet is the church youth group and mine is our dogs who keep me company when he is gone. When he leaves the house I turn off the lights and the fans and skip meals during the day. And still it is like sinking into quicksand - the more you struggle the faster you sink.

My2pence2day · 16/05/2023 11:49

Welcometotheterrorzone · 16/05/2023 06:00

I don't know what else to call it, I mean being skint month after month, having money for one day of the month before the bills come out? I needed a shed to store our bikes so they're not in our kitchen all the time. Apologies if this seems dramatic.

I don't think you know what actual poverty is 😒

Floralie · 16/05/2023 11:42

Wish I could budget better

You need to invest time finding a way to make this work, it is important and you wouldn't be buying a big purchase followed by not having enough for basics. You don't need excel or complex spreadsheets, you need to get a handle on your incomings and your outgoings.

Timeisallwehave · 16/05/2023 11:41

Spending priorities vary from person to person. I have bikes in the house and need to buy a shed.

Despite being a 1% high income family it hasn’t been on my priority list.

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 11:39

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 16/05/2023 11:21

Did you read that the bikes are being stored in the kitchen? Not for you or anybody else to say that a shed isn't a priority purchase actually.

Your comment about squash and biscuits not being on your list just make you sound sneery and clueless. I mean, why would poor people want biscuits? High calorie, cheap food that is quickly available to eat without preparation? It's a stumper, isn't it?

What do you think, if you actually do?

That’s a mumsnet comment if I ever saw one…god forbid that anyone would ever have to store a bike in their kitchen! The horror! People live in all sorts of conditions and I presume the op isn’t living with her kids in 1 room seeing as she “lives in a nice house” (kids have their own bedrooms do they?)and no, we live in a country where we have clean ,healthy tap water,squash is not an essential !

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 11:39

No sorry I can't. I would rather fall over bikes in the kitchen and wash my children's hair and put milk on their cereal.

Th OP herself admits it's bad budgeting and she goes mad on payday. There is a huge difference there. Willingly going mad KNOWING you won't have the basics for your children is just reckless.

CreationNat1on · 16/05/2023 11:37

Don't be ashamed to use a food bank. You are doing your best, maybe also check out St. V de P.

Don't go hungry xx

CaramelicedLatte · 16/05/2023 11:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LakeTiticaca · 16/05/2023 11:34

Okunevo · 16/05/2023 09:46

I do think we've lost a lot of skills people used to make do in older generations. My aunt built a rough shed from pallets in her seventies a few years ago, I wouldn't know where to start!

I think you've nailed it there.
Many of the old fashioned skills of previous generations have been lost.
Make do and mend was my late mums (born in 1936) favourite saying.
My parents had next to nothing but we never went without.
It did help that my mum was a skilled dressmaker and knitter, and we had a garden for growing vegetables.

lightand · 16/05/2023 11:32

Why on earth people reported this thread, I have no idea.

Fimofriend · 16/05/2023 11:31

We are doing really well now but were skint for so many years that I hate buying things that are not absolutely necessary. I find it stressful if my DH buys me things. Even when I have coveted the item for years and we have plenty left over in the bank. I think poverty leaves marks that last for a very long time and I don't blame you for buying that shed. Going without is really tough and draining.

I bought three pairs of trousers in December as I needed something nice to wear at the office. For once I didn't buy them from a charity shop or a discount shop. They are nice trousers but I somehow resent them for having been "expensive". Even though I know they weren't. They just weren't dirt cheap.

lightand · 16/05/2023 11:31

Lcb123 · 16/05/2023 11:29

Poverty means not being able to meet basic needs. You are not living in poverty.

Not sure you are right there.
Joseph Rowntree Foundation might disagree with you there.
And governments take notice of them, from what little I know.

gogohmm · 16/05/2023 11:29

It's worth seeing if there's a community larder or surplus group in your area, ours gives away surplus items 3 times a week, no proof of need needed, no cap on how often you go. I often get sourdough bread, really expensive stuff, because nobody wants it and they are closing as I leave work (we are associated with them), they had short date uht milk in abundance this morning

Lcb123 · 16/05/2023 11:29

Poverty means not being able to meet basic needs. You are not living in poverty.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 16/05/2023 11:26

You aren't in poverty.......you just aren't managing your money. There's a difference.

cannaecookrisotto · 16/05/2023 11:26

StrawberryMoore · 16/05/2023 10:07

I wonder if it would be allowed to start a thread where people can offer things like out grown shoes, coats, school uniform, toiletries they can’t use and a family in need receives them? It’s all well and good donating stuff to a charity shop but people still need to have the money to buy the items from the charity shop.

I think this is a great idea, I'd happily cover postage to send stuff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread