Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can we start a poverty solidarity thread?

260 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 16/05/2023 05:27

It often feels like MN is a different world and I can't actually talk to anyone in real life as people either don't get it or assume I'm trying to gain sympathy or ask for money.

I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now

  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo
So worried that I'll need to drive somewhere and have to explain that I have no petrol. Currently walking everywhere. I know it's partly my fault as I went a bit far on the last payday and bought a shed, but obviously no one is going to offer me a 0% interest or repayment scheme due to my credit. Wish I could budget better. I think these dry spells make it worse though. You live with weeks with nothing and then my wages come in and I go a bit crazy. Another downside of being skint. Could ask father of children but I can't take the smugness. He took them out for pizza last night and they brought some home! Ravenously ate it in the kitchen whilst they weren't looking. It's mad that this is the reality. No one knows. I have a full time job, nice house, car in drive, dress well (charity shops), the kids look ok. How no one gets what it's like, waking up to nothing in the bank, dry cereal, panicking about if there's a non school uniform day. Please let me know what's going on for you so I don't feel so alone!
OP posts:
ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 13:35

Yes I’m sure all the people on here who are in insecure rental housing and will never achieve a home of their own

That's me. I still don't see the need to kick those who are down, no matter what their circumstances are. Making someone else feel shitty does exactly zip to make my life any better or easier.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 16/05/2023 13:35

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 13:25

So many 30p Lees on here.

Do some people even know what the word solidarity means?

I suppose not, because they've never needed any.

Isn't there just, Begsthequestion.

I'm not in the position now but I have been very short of money at some points in my life and it's not that difficult for me to remember how different my 'choices' were back then as to how they are now when I actually have them.

OP hasn't asked for instructions as to how to do poverty better, she's asked for solidarity. I can give that because I'm not a mindless numbskull without the wit to see and understand what's being asked for.

I can remember moving direct debits here and there, my husband paying me £5 from his account and me paying him £5 from mine to 'show payment' in the account.

I can remember not eating lunch and making random 'weird' (sorry, kids!) 'messes' from ingredients that I had, trying to make them nutritious but just hoping they were going to be filling.

I do recall times when it was so relentlessly tedious having to count pennies that when I did get paid, the temptation was so strong to have a break from being hard-up.

The posters banging on about squash and biscuits and sheds... can you just stop it please? When you have choices to buy other things, better things, and you have the money in the bank to buy them even if you choose not to, IT IS NOT THE SAME. Have the wit to see that.

FrogsWormsandButterflies · 16/05/2023 13:35

I don’t know if this is allowed so MN please delete if not.

if anyone wants some solidarity away from the judgement we are getting from some people ok here, feel free to PM me and we could maybe start a WhatsApp group? Only for those of us that truly understand.

purpleboy · 16/05/2023 13:32

FREE ITEMS http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4807306-free-items

I've just started this and added a few items, if anyone else wants to contribute please do. I'm happy to gift all items and will cover the cost of postage.

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 13:31

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 13:25

So many 30p Lees on here.

Do some people even know what the word solidarity means?

I suppose not, because they've never needed any.

Yes I’m sure all the people on here who are in insecure rental housing and will never achieve a home of their own in their lifetimes or are unable to work because they are il or have disabled children they are caring for are remiss for not showing solidarity to someone who is in a “nice house” they are paying a mortgage on, with a car in the drive and and ex who they are too proud to ask for help from because they “don’t want to see the smug look on their face” even though their kids are going without milk and shampoo.

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 13:25

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 16/05/2023 12:25

Also, ItWillWash's post and Emeraldrings', thank goodness for them. I'm sure I've missed a few but they're drowned out by moronic, tone-deaf posts.

So many 30p Lees on here.

Do some people even know what the word solidarity means?

I suppose not, because they've never needed any.

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 13:24

Sissynova · 16/05/2023 12:02

No I'm not going to "pipe down". Why do you think your comments are more valid?
Please tell me one thing I have said that wasn't respectful or in keeping with the discussion...

I was responding to a poster who suggested you needed a computer and expensive software to budget!
That is so far from reality. Hundreds of thousands of people across the country would be much better off if they took some time to practice budgeting techniques, particularly from the likes of Dave Ramsey.

You don't need a computer to budget, you don't need excel, you don't need anything fancy. Most people have a phone with a calculator already and if thet don't like using an app they can just use a notepad.

I did a monthly paper budget for years and it helped massively.

I don't subscribe to the 'well too bad guess I'm too poor to budget because I don'y have a computer' It isn't helpful and it doesn't lift people out of their current situation.

As I thought.

Another careless, ignorant poster punching down.

BrokeAssMum · 16/05/2023 13:15

It's all well and good being advised to "just budget better". This works if you've got the money to do so.

Yes, a shed may not have been an essential purchase in some peoples eyes but the fact the OP had the bikes in her kitchen all the time this would not have been practical and if she had left them outside they could have been stolen which would have been even more expensive.

Life is shit when you have no money.

PucketyPuckPuck · 16/05/2023 13:14

For anyone really struggling with money management, I second the earlier Monzo recommendation. It's honestly the best thing we've ever done for our finances.

We're not in poverty - but by God, things are very tight. Everything is paid every month but we have no savings and DH is self employed so we're not exactly secure.

I understand why you bought the shed op. People who are judging can get to fuck.

We spent £200 on a new laptop this month - an upgrade on the very small, very slow old netbook we had. And in the same month, DH stuck the soles of ds2's trainers together with superglue because we couldn't afford to get him a new pair.

It's easy to judge from a distance without being immersed in the full reality of someone's situation. On the face of it, upgrading your laptop over a child needing shoes seems utterly ridiculous - but we didn't have enough money for both and a laptop was needed for ds1s upcoming Gcses. Scoff away you 1%-ers who would never make such an unwise choice.

2bazookas · 16/05/2023 13:13
  • I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now
  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo*

when I was very poor, there was no question of a car, squash, biscuits or shampoo. We went without. "Going a little bit crazy" was not an option.

Those are luxuries.

You're not in poverty. Don't insult those who are.

purpleboy · 16/05/2023 13:13

StrawberryMoore · 16/05/2023 10:07

I wonder if it would be allowed to start a thread where people can offer things like out grown shoes, coats, school uniform, toiletries they can’t use and a family in need receives them? It’s all well and good donating stuff to a charity shop but people still need to have the money to buy the items from the charity shop.

I was literally just thinking the same thing. I have loads of old clothes that I need to get rid off, I'd much rather they went to people in need.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/05/2023 13:06

IMustDoMoreExercise · 16/05/2023 12:42

I used to spend a lot of money on fruit juice and squash. We only drink water now. It is so much cheaper and much better for us.

You just get used to it.

Agree with this! No one needs sweet and sweetened drinks in their life - they’re so bad for you and your teeth.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/05/2023 13:05

I know how you feel OP.

I have struggled to be sensible too, and then have money worries.

I’m improving. I have downloaded a budgeting app that helps me.

Everything is harder on one income - it’s not the same as two incomes that add up to the same figure, due to tax allowances etc. Single person council tax discount should be 50%. One higher income can disqualify you from lots of things two smaller incomes allow.

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 12:58

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 12:48

Do you understand the title of this thread?

Are you able to respectfully adhere to it, or otherwise pipe down?

I think you’ve already told another poster that! I think i would feel a lot more sympathy if the op hadn’t titled it as a poverty solidarity thread! You can be in poverty and have absolute nothing else left to try but if you are understandably struggling for cash and equally need to learn about budgeting then people are going to make suggestions, no?

Turfwars · 16/05/2023 12:49

ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 12:19

Oh, another tip, if you have a salon supply shop within reach go and buy shampoo and conditioner by the gallon. A gallon of generic salon shampoo around here costs roughly £25 and will last for at least 6 months.

OMG I just checked my local salon supply shop - 5 litres of shampoo for €8.96 ex VAT. Even with VAT it's about €10.77!

Begsthequestion · 16/05/2023 12:48

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 11:09

Tbh it’s a fair point, there’s nothing about a shed thats a priority purchase and impulsivity in purchasing is something that does needs tackling, the op themselves has acknowledged this.

Do you understand the title of this thread?

Are you able to respectfully adhere to it, or otherwise pipe down?

IMustDoMoreExercise · 16/05/2023 12:42

I used to spend a lot of money on fruit juice and squash. We only drink water now. It is so much cheaper and much better for us.

You just get used to it.

70sDuvet · 16/05/2023 12:38

Just a note to let anyone know who is revieving DLA for a child. You are now entitled to a pretty good raise in child tax credits (approx £400 or more a month)

We weren't told this when our DS began receiving DLA and it took a while for a friend to let me know so it's not done automatically- but omg it really really helped, especially as DS's disability cost a lot in extra daily bits and pieces.

Hope I'm not showing anyone how to suck eggs but just in case...

I've been here and luckily now am doing OK, I run a 2nd hand clothing business so if anyone needs anything specific please DM as I may have what you need and can post to you at my expense. I wouldn't have got through life 16 years ago without the kindness of others.

Turfwars · 16/05/2023 12:36

Lovemylaminator · 16/05/2023 12:07

OP, I know what you mean, I think.

We are not at the stage you are at, but our life has become increasingly miserable over the last few years.

Two decent wage earners, one child, one dog.

I find my overdraft is increasing every month, and every month one extra thing that is ' nice' has to go.

What I find hard to take is that there is no money left for savings or to pay for a week abroad, something that on our wages was possible five or six years ago.

It's not poverty as such - there's always food in the cupboards ( although of a reduced quality) , and the odd night out here and there.

If we didn't do a single social thing, no treats - just living mega frugal - all month we could probably save £200.

Just writing it down sounds stupidly entitled, but if this is what is happening to us, God knows how people on a lot less than us are coping.

Same. We are VERY fortunate that DH inherited our house. And when he lost his job in October and a couple of years of poor health to contend with, at least we knew that with a roof over our heads and my salary to pay groceries, we were in a better position than many. We struggled in the recession before we inherited the house so I know that I can be frugal - but I also remember how grinding and demoralising that frugality can be.

This month I'm broke two weeks before payday. We had DS's birthday, so gift, party etc. Plus DH is hoping to start work again so we had to get a car. I logged my spending to a tracker and I can see where I thought I was being moderate but really, I made a few poor choices. But thanks to my spreadsheet, I've now a list of online subscriptions to cull to the minimum, I'm going to make a takeaway a less frequent treat for us, and save on lunches by bringing my own, and be much more careful with impulse purchases. But again, compared to many, we are lucky!

I've booked my hair appointment as my treat for after I get paid for mid June. My roots were last done in December, so I'm telling myself that a bi-annual haircut and colour is a reasonable treat... but still feel really guilty!

KarmaStar · 16/05/2023 12:35

Sending not denying 😀🌻

KarmaStar · 16/05/2023 12:33

💐 for you op.it's shite isn't it?
Things do improve,nothing stays the same forever.can you get any old stuff together to do a car boot sale nearby that you could wheelbarrow stuff to or advertise as a job lot for a car booter to collect from you just to get you a bit of cash for milk and basics?
I've been in your shoes many times and ,it may sound daft,but I kept the positives in my mind,like health,ability to improve things and anything else that was a plus.
Keep thinking of the future you want,it's denying it out to the universe.🌈

AreMyDucksinarow · 16/05/2023 12:25

I completely understand - dh and I have been in the same situation it was good or fuel to get to work (no public transport)

It’s so fucking hard and the daily grind really gets you down! I don’t begrudge you buying the shed as previous posters have said you’d never be able to save up for one.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 16/05/2023 12:25

Also, ItWillWash's post and Emeraldrings', thank goodness for them. I'm sure I've missed a few but they're drowned out by moronic, tone-deaf posts.

tuvamoodyson · 16/05/2023 12:24

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 12:06

@Sissynova exactly ,I grew up with my mum writing everything down in a book, which she does to this day,any money in ,any money out she was exactly aware of what was going on. The challenge with online banking now is that money is no longer as “real” so it’s far easier to spend it.

My parents done exactly same! All money in and out was written down in a book. Anything spare at the end of the week after bills were paid (paid weekly at the time) was saved to go towards anything that they would be saving towards/Christmas/birthdays/house maintenance etc, they continued this throughout their lives. Never needed spreadsheets etc!

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 16/05/2023 12:22

Lovemylaminator · 16/05/2023 12:07

OP, I know what you mean, I think.

We are not at the stage you are at, but our life has become increasingly miserable over the last few years.

Two decent wage earners, one child, one dog.

I find my overdraft is increasing every month, and every month one extra thing that is ' nice' has to go.

What I find hard to take is that there is no money left for savings or to pay for a week abroad, something that on our wages was possible five or six years ago.

It's not poverty as such - there's always food in the cupboards ( although of a reduced quality) , and the odd night out here and there.

If we didn't do a single social thing, no treats - just living mega frugal - all month we could probably save £200.

Just writing it down sounds stupidly entitled, but if this is what is happening to us, God knows how people on a lot less than us are coping.

I think your post was exactly what the OP was looking for, a bit of human solidarity.

Sadly, this thread is peppered by 'that's not poverty' twats and self-declared 1%-ers who think that because buying a shed isn't priority for them... blah blah. Sickening.

But anyway, thanks for your post, Lovemylaminator, I thought it so articulate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread