Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can we start a poverty solidarity thread?

260 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 16/05/2023 05:27

It often feels like MN is a different world and I can't actually talk to anyone in real life as people either don't get it or assume I'm trying to gain sympathy or ask for money.

I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now

  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo
So worried that I'll need to drive somewhere and have to explain that I have no petrol. Currently walking everywhere. I know it's partly my fault as I went a bit far on the last payday and bought a shed, but obviously no one is going to offer me a 0% interest or repayment scheme due to my credit. Wish I could budget better. I think these dry spells make it worse though. You live with weeks with nothing and then my wages come in and I go a bit crazy. Another downside of being skint. Could ask father of children but I can't take the smugness. He took them out for pizza last night and they brought some home! Ravenously ate it in the kitchen whilst they weren't looking. It's mad that this is the reality. No one knows. I have a full time job, nice house, car in drive, dress well (charity shops), the kids look ok. How no one gets what it's like, waking up to nothing in the bank, dry cereal, panicking about if there's a non school uniform day. Please let me know what's going on for you so I don't feel so alone!
OP posts:
bakewellbride · 16/05/2023 15:57

I'm sorry for your situation but 'poverty' is not the right word for it and it's insensitive to call it that. My dh grew up in poverty, there were never any purchases like sheds and no car ever.

EightChalk · 16/05/2023 15:54

I think people who haven't been in the situation of an ongoing lack of money (careful phrasing here as "poverty" now seems to only mean "abject poverty/complete destitution" according to several posters) don't understand what it's like. It's MUCH, MUCH easier to set aside money for a rainy day or save up for big purchases when you know that you'll have a surplus every month. If you never have a surplus, and can only make savings by doing without and by scrimping and saving on every penny (and then getting those savings, which you managed to save up by living a boring, hard existence for months, wiped out by a single expense or, at the moment, by a couple of rapidly rising expensive food shops or energy bills), then it stops seeming like it's worth it. You buy the treats anyway, because otherwise your life is BLEAK. You buy the shed and go without other things until payday, because if you save up the money over months then something else will come along and use it up, and the bikes are still in the kitchen.

It is perfectly understandable that if people haven't been in this situation, then they might not get this, and will think "but why don't OP and people like her just make better choices with the money they have?" What is NOT understandable is coming here and posting all over the thread from your position of ignorance, haranguing her and telling her how much better you would manage in her position when you haven't been in it.

3dogsandarabbit · 16/05/2023 15:46

Raingo - So you're saying that the scrap man would come into your back garden via a locked gate and take bikes?

lakesummer · 16/05/2023 15:41

It absolutely shouldn't be a race to the bottom teabags, shampoo and milk are all very much basics in my eyes.
Squash and biscuits shouldn't be crazy luxuries either.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 16/05/2023 15:40

2bazookas · 16/05/2023 13:13

  • I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now
  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo*

when I was very poor, there was no question of a car, squash, biscuits or shampoo. We went without. "Going a little bit crazy" was not an option.

Those are luxuries.

You're not in poverty. Don't insult those who are.

They absolutely aren’t luxuries. Shampoo? Milk??

don’t punch down.

Raingo · 16/05/2023 15:36

If you left bikes under tarpaulins where I am, the scrap man would have taken it. Or someone else would have stolen them.
I live in a nice area too.
Also who wants to drink water all the time!
I would be in poverty if I couldn’t afford tea bags/shampoo.
I agree it’s shouldn’t be a race to the bottom.

lakesummer · 16/05/2023 15:33

Having grown up very poor and raising dc who are really pretty comfortable I think the element of choice is really important.
Growing up we had a strictly rationed amount of squash and it was very desirable.
My dc only have water in house but they can buy a Starbucks etc whenever the mood takes them outside of the house.
So they never complain about only having water because they can choose other high sugar things if they want and they understand it is a health issue.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/05/2023 15:24

Wasntpartoftheplan · 16/05/2023 14:59

We live in the 6th richest country in the world and you are saying that shampoo and squash are luxuries? I am so sick of this absolute race to the bottom - maybe if we questioned where the wealth in the country is actually going instead of some competitive view of poverty we might be able to all enjoy a nice biscuit Biscuit

I don’t disagree with this. My comment was more that I don’t think squash / juice etc as a main drink should be normalised for health reasons - squash can be very cheap but it’s so much better to drink water

defi · 16/05/2023 15:03

We live in the 6th richest country in the world and you are saying that shampoo and squash are luxuries? I am so sick of this absolute race to the bottom - maybe if we questioned where the wealth in the country is actually going instead of some competitive view of poverty we might be able to all enjoy a nice biscuit

^^ indeed

Wasntpartoftheplan · 16/05/2023 14:59

2bazookas · 16/05/2023 13:13

  • I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now
  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo*

when I was very poor, there was no question of a car, squash, biscuits or shampoo. We went without. "Going a little bit crazy" was not an option.

Those are luxuries.

You're not in poverty. Don't insult those who are.

We live in the 6th richest country in the world and you are saying that shampoo and squash are luxuries? I am so sick of this absolute race to the bottom - maybe if we questioned where the wealth in the country is actually going instead of some competitive view of poverty we might be able to all enjoy a nice biscuit Biscuit

MyMachineAndMe · 16/05/2023 14:51

Flipflop23 · 16/05/2023 10:24

@MyMachineAndMe
i have some brand new next school trousers, think they still have the tag on if there is a way to get in touch I will happily post them to you xx

Thank you, that's a very kind offer. Since I took his trousers down they fit and are in fairly decent nick and next month (I think?) the school are doing a uniform swap thing where parents bring items that no longer fit and can collect ones that do. Also, we are close to a Next warehouse and they kindly donate a lot of brand new uniform items that parents can then pick up free if we're lucky enough to get there first, so they might be more use to someone more in need?

Mammyloveswine · 16/05/2023 14:47

I'm technically on a good wage however two maternity leaves in two years and childcare means we have fuck all left.. it's a week until payday (luckily child benefit hits sat!).

Ive a full fridge, full cupboards and full freezer so food wise we are fine but it's just bloody depressing!!

I pay everything though and do think there may be some unintentional financial abuse from DH so tonight we are sitting down together and having an honest chat about finances as I run out of money midway through the month which isn't right on our two salaries!

MrsTwiggy · 16/05/2023 14:32

Hi OP, I'm another who wouldn't describe myself as living in poverty as in the grand scheme of things everything is ok but things are just very depressing right now.

I am very good at budgeting, I'm militant about it in fact. I know we will get the bills paid each month. But it's just not stretching as far as it used to even just a year ago. Even a few months ago things felt better, but a combination of changes at my husband's workplace meaning that he now brings home ~£400 less per month than he used to and also some bad luck that meant we had to take a loan to pay for something unexpected, means that life is just depressing at the moment. Going to get some food later as we're nearly out and we only have £12.80 left until the weekend. This is doable and it will be fine, but it's just bloody depressing looking at all the food you'd love to buy and knowing you just can't. Not even anything totally crazy, I just gaze longingly at the own-brand "up" from the absolute cheapest one 🤣

My children will eat well (well, one of them is pre-weaning anyway so no worries there) as I always ensure they do, but I've been skipping meals when I can.

I can't even remember the last time I had my hair cut, I've been hacking away at it myself for at least four years I'd say. I haven't bought any new clothes in two years minimum I'd guess - except for a pair of maternity leggings in my third trimester - and when I say new, I mean new to me. I've only been buying second hand for years and years, at first just for ethical reasons but it's necessity now.

I totally understand why you bought the shed. Was it sensible, I don't know. But I understand. Sometimes you just want one thing in your life to be just a little bit nicer.

I definitely think a solidarity thread is a good idea.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 16/05/2023 14:30

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/05/2023 13:06

Agree with this! No one needs sweet and sweetened drinks in their life - they’re so bad for you and your teeth.

They really are. Orange juice etc is so expensive and it isn't good for you.

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 14:30

Poverty is relative.

I am sorry that anyone is struggling.

Worrying so much about money with no hope in sight is wearing mentally. That’s one reason why poor people often have worse health outcomes.

Yes we could all budget better. But it’s soul-destroying on lower incomes.

I have never been poor like this and probably won’t ever be. I have lots of sympathy for those in that situation.

Maybe a random comparison but it is interesting that when it comes to diets, people are a little bit more understanding. They understand that it can be hard to keep to a diet and you often have blips and can’t always commit to the regime every day despite being aware of the benefits. An occasional ‘binge’ is forgiven and understood. Even encouraged. When it comes to budgeting however, there is not quite the same understanding for how difficult it is to stick to a strict budget day after day with no treats or respite in sight.

3dogsandarabbit · 16/05/2023 14:25

It was the OP's choice to prioritise a shed over other stuff. Why are you worried OP about having to explain to people why you are walking and not driving, if anyone asks just tell them the truth, but don't plead poverty.

Lannielou · 16/05/2023 14:23

I am down to under 1/4 tank of diesel, we live in rural Devon so can't manage without a car. Universal credit hits tomorrow so will have a bit of breathing space. It's just exhausting worrying about money.

megletthesecond · 16/05/2023 14:22

A shed is essential.
We lived with bikes in the house over the winter of the pandemic. The amount of times we were injured tripping or smashing our ankles on them..... gives me flashbacks.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 16/05/2023 14:15

MintsPi · 16/05/2023 14:00

I can't believe the posters talking about shampoo and squash being luxuries. It is not a race to the bottom.

That's the phrase I see here all the time when high earners bemoan how little they have left after their bills. I've seen far more sympathy on threads where people 'only have £1000 spare a month'.

Seems like you can only moan about being in poverty on here if you live on the streets or have had to cancel Jacinta's horse riding lessons to still afford Aspen.

Squash isn't a luxury.
But it's about as necessary as Coke or any other fizzy drink.

Agree with you in regards to the rest of your comment. (And shampoo is definitely a necessity imo.)

BrokeAssMum · 16/05/2023 14:15

MintsPi · 16/05/2023 14:00

I can't believe the posters talking about shampoo and squash being luxuries. It is not a race to the bottom.

That's the phrase I see here all the time when high earners bemoan how little they have left after their bills. I've seen far more sympathy on threads where people 'only have £1000 spare a month'.

Seems like you can only moan about being in poverty on here if you live on the streets or have had to cancel Jacinta's horse riding lessons to still afford Aspen.

Exactly, shampoo isn't a fucking luxury.

If you send your kids to school unclean you will quite possibly be flagged as neglecting them.

If you go to work unclean you can be disciplined etc.

Hoppingmad231 · 16/05/2023 14:13

febrezeme · 16/05/2023 05:30

How important was it to buy a shed??

Doesn't matter its done now.

MintsPi · 16/05/2023 14:00

I can't believe the posters talking about shampoo and squash being luxuries. It is not a race to the bottom.

That's the phrase I see here all the time when high earners bemoan how little they have left after their bills. I've seen far more sympathy on threads where people 'only have £1000 spare a month'.

Seems like you can only moan about being in poverty on here if you live on the streets or have had to cancel Jacinta's horse riding lessons to still afford Aspen.

purpleboy · 16/05/2023 13:46

Ahh thanks for the heads up @LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

I can understand that, I did wonder if the thread would even stay up but figured it was worth a shot if I can ease someone's burden.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 16/05/2023 13:40

purpleboy · 16/05/2023 13:32

FREE ITEMS http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4807306-free-items

I've just started this and added a few items, if anyone else wants to contribute please do. I'm happy to gift all items and will cover the cost of postage.

purpleboy, I would be very happy to contribute to this. I tried once with sanpro once my HRT had kicked in (finally). MNHQ were really helpful but they told me that posters might not want to give addresses. The poster I was going to send them too asked where I was and then declined as they thought I might know them. Sad

I so wish people would feel comfortable putting their hands up for things that people don't want and would be glad to give. There are so many nicer people around than judgemental twats... and even judgemental twats can relapse now and again perhaps?

I will add that link to my watched threads... thank you!

WuTangGran · 16/05/2023 13:37

febrezeme · 16/05/2023 05:30

How important was it to buy a shed??

None of your fucking business.