Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can we start a poverty solidarity thread?

260 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 16/05/2023 05:27

It often feels like MN is a different world and I can't actually talk to anyone in real life as people either don't get it or assume I'm trying to gain sympathy or ask for money.

I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now

  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo
So worried that I'll need to drive somewhere and have to explain that I have no petrol. Currently walking everywhere. I know it's partly my fault as I went a bit far on the last payday and bought a shed, but obviously no one is going to offer me a 0% interest or repayment scheme due to my credit. Wish I could budget better. I think these dry spells make it worse though. You live with weeks with nothing and then my wages come in and I go a bit crazy. Another downside of being skint. Could ask father of children but I can't take the smugness. He took them out for pizza last night and they brought some home! Ravenously ate it in the kitchen whilst they weren't looking. It's mad that this is the reality. No one knows. I have a full time job, nice house, car in drive, dress well (charity shops), the kids look ok. How no one gets what it's like, waking up to nothing in the bank, dry cereal, panicking about if there's a non school uniform day. Please let me know what's going on for you so I don't feel so alone!
OP posts:
AngryBirdsNoMore · 16/05/2023 22:29

Cheesyfootballs01 · 16/05/2023 19:20

When you say a week of frivolity what do you mean exactly?

What I would do if I was bad with money is make sure all bills are paid on payday and then I would do a months shop.

Obviously you wouldn’t be able to get a months worth of fresh veg/meat but you can get plenty of frozen ( which is sometimes cheaper) and dry goods to fill up the cupboard. I don’t know if you have one but Iceland do some really good deals.

You can buy UHT milk, pasta and rice to last.

Pasta and rice are ideal to buy cheap and you can base quite a lot of meals around it.

At least by doing this you will at least always have food.

Sounds like you aren’t in this position and haven’t been for months and months like OP.

So your ‘what I would do’ is purely hypothetical 30p Lee lecturing.

mydogisthebest · 16/05/2023 21:14

3dogsandarabbit · 16/05/2023 15:46

Raingo - So you're saying that the scrap man would come into your back garden via a locked gate and take bikes?

We have had several scrap men come into our back garden and steal stuff. We now have a high back fence and gate and the gate is padlocked. I am not sure OP said her back garden has a locked gate has she?

Dutch1e · 16/05/2023 20:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Grapewrath · 16/05/2023 20:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 16/05/2023 19:23

ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 16:13

It baffles me that in 2023, in the 6th richest nation in the world, people feel it acceptable to argue over whether a working mother should be able to afford a bike shed and milk and shampoo.

WTF is wrong with people? There is something very, very wrong if someone working full-time cannot afford to make a purchase of something like a shed and still manage basics for the month.

OP hasn't gone and bought a pony ffs. She bought a small shed. She should be able to buy a small shed without having to go without essentials.

I agree with you 100%.

There are some really nasty people in this thread .

If someone is feeling down and asking for support from other people who understand where she's coming from , why would you stamp all over her ?

Cheesyfootballs01 · 16/05/2023 19:20

Welcometotheterrorzone · 16/05/2023 07:30

@Sissynova I would just take the cash out of the envelopes... I don't see how anyone doesn't.
I think you can be low income and bad with money. The two are not mutually exclusive. I am not just on a low income and I do not struggle solely because I'm bad with money. I have two children a car and a mortgage, I earn £1400, I get £250 UC. Most would struggle but some would struggle less with better budgeting. I guess the decision is whether you want a week of slight frivolity and then three or four weeks of misery or just a month of milder misery.

When you say a week of frivolity what do you mean exactly?

What I would do if I was bad with money is make sure all bills are paid on payday and then I would do a months shop.

Obviously you wouldn’t be able to get a months worth of fresh veg/meat but you can get plenty of frozen ( which is sometimes cheaper) and dry goods to fill up the cupboard. I don’t know if you have one but Iceland do some really good deals.

You can buy UHT milk, pasta and rice to last.

Pasta and rice are ideal to buy cheap and you can base quite a lot of meals around it.

At least by doing this you will at least always have food.

EightChalk · 16/05/2023 19:14

Another thing is that there's a lot of sanctimony around the idea of buying other things and forgoing food. Obviously no one should need to do that, but in our society it's just an ugly truth when you're poor for a long time. Food is not the only necessity - for instance, if your one pair of work shoes wears out, then you need another pair, and if that means going without dinner for a week or two, then that might be what you decide to do.

Also, for lots of people, the grocery budget is the only place within the budget where there's any flexibility at all. You can't just not pay your rent, council tax, etc., for the month, so if you need something else that's not food, then where else is that money coming from? If you're buying other things instead of needed food, you're not going to be in a situation where you can just cut down on your savings contribution or going-out budget for the month. Something has to give, and often it's food because that's where the only wiggle room in the budget is.

It's something that people say as though it's so completely out of the bounds of acceptability ("I would never go without FOOD for x"), but the sad reality is that that is sometimes a choice people find themselves making. I certainly have made that choice in my life, in the past. To me it shows a lack of familiarity with living in ongoing poverty, rather than showing the poster as any kind of authority on it.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 16/05/2023 19:12

2bazookas · 16/05/2023 13:13

  • I cannot wait until payday. Things I am doing without right now
  • petrol
  • squash
  • milk
  • biscuits
  • shampoo*

when I was very poor, there was no question of a car, squash, biscuits or shampoo. We went without. "Going a little bit crazy" was not an option.

Those are luxuries.

You're not in poverty. Don't insult those who are.

On what planet is milk a luxury ?
And many/most people need petrol to get themselves to work - not many people live in walking distance of their workplace . And generally if you can't afford milk then you can't afford bus fare .

And to those still banging on about the shed . It cost £200. if your money is pretty much fully spent each month it's difficult to save even a small amount , and with rising prices and the expectation of being worse off in a few months perhaps it was easier to get it now .

holaholiday · 16/05/2023 19:06

Whammyyammy · 16/05/2023 18:35

I'm appalled by this thread, shampoo, tea bags and biscuits called luxuries?
As for a small garden shed? Hardly a luxury, a swimming pool, tennis court or helicopter pad yes, buy a bloody shed!

It's a race to the bottom

Likewise people are forgetting this is an AIBU thread! To spend £200 on a shed and leave yourself unable to provide milk or shampoo for your kids is, in many people’s opinions, unreasonable. If the op wants to ask if it’s AIBU to think it’s horrible to try and live in the current climate on a low income and horrible to be a single parent working full time and trying very hard to make ends meet then she would have many people empathising with her as that’s what lots of people are having to do.

Theskyoutsideisblue · 16/05/2023 18:50

That was hard reading. Some of you should be ashamed. OP good luck

Whammyyammy · 16/05/2023 18:35

I'm appalled by this thread, shampoo, tea bags and biscuits called luxuries?
As for a small garden shed? Hardly a luxury, a swimming pool, tennis court or helicopter pad yes, buy a bloody shed!

It's a race to the bottom

MsMcBeal · 16/05/2023 18:23

I genuinely despair at the number of people jumping on the OP. It's not like she bought a fucking expensive candle or something to treat herself - it was a shed ffs!

OP, if you're comfortable with it I'd like to send you a small token for you and your DC to treat yourselves to a takeaway or something. (Before anyone jumps on me, i think they deserve to have a little enjoyment in life). Hopefully it goes some way to restoring your faith in humanity. PM me if you want to take me up on it.

NEmama · 16/05/2023 18:23

@ashamedmum007 you are working so hard. Zarach is a charity which will help with beds or check local Freecycle pages on Facebook for furniture you need?
Which region are you in as other members may be able to signpost you? 🙏

CreationNat1on · 16/05/2023 18:12

Please stop with the chastising comments. People can make choices in the spur of a moment. She didn't buy designer bag or new earrings, she bought something that there was a practical need for, give the woman a break. She may not have the same level of poverty training as someone who grew up in abject poverty, it doesn't mean she isn't deserving of empathy.

This mother is skipping meals and walking everywhere, she is really trying, give her a break. Op go to your local community centre, there might be supports available for you.

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 17:54

I very much doubt OP bought the shed knowing she wouldn't be able to eat. It's far more likely she bought it while she had the money hoping to make cutbacks elsewhere in the month to mitigate the impact of her spend.

She's not the first person to have done such a thing and she certainly won't be the last.

EightChalk · 16/05/2023 17:54

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:51

Fair enough but I just find it hard to comprehend buying a shed when you know you won't have enough food. I can't get my head around that.

This is speaking for the OP and she might have completely different reasons, but to quote my own post from upthread:

"It's MUCH, MUCH easier to set aside money for a rainy day or save up for big purchases when you know that you'll have a surplus every month. If you never have a surplus, and can only make savings by doing without and by scrimping and saving on every penny (and then getting those savings, which you managed to save up by living a boring, hard existence for months, wiped out by a single expense or, at the moment, by a couple of rapidly rising expensive food shops or energy bills), then it stops seeming like it's worth it. You buy the treats anyway, because otherwise your life is BLEAK. You buy the shed and go without other things until payday, because if you save up the money over months then something else will come along and use it up, and the bikes are still in the kitchen."

Even though buying the shed has left her in a bad position, I understand why she did it.

GodSaveTheClean · 16/05/2023 17:54

sorry, you lost me at biscuits and squash and buying a shed. This thread is insulting to people who are actually struggling.

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:54

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 17:51

Regardless. Her posts are clearly from someone is struggling and feeling worn down by life. Can you not read tone? You could have said the same thing but more sensitively.

Or are you proud of being one of those ‘tell ‘em like it is’ types?

Honestly I'm not but I did find the OP's posts quite flippant about being bad with money and letting herself literally starve because she bought a shed to house bikes rather than food.

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:51

EightChalk · 16/05/2023 17:46

Another great point. We ALL make impulsive decisions from time to time, and make choices that aren't the absolute best optimal sensible thing to do. Not having enough money doesn't mean you are suddenly immune to this. You do have to be more careful out of pure necessity, but if you haven't been in this position, try to think about it with some empathy - imagine not being able to make any mis-steps, day in day out, for months and years. Never any impulse, emotion-driven purchases; your hierarchy of "necessary" items must be completely correct before you're allowed any sympathy and not deemed to be in a situation of your own making (even though OP really did need the shed so as not to have bikes in the kitchen).

It's asking a huge amount of someone who is ALREADY in a tough situation, and whose decision-making processes are under more stress than those of someone who can end each month with a spare couple of hundred pounds without any real effort.

Fair enough but I just find it hard to comprehend buying a shed when you know you won't have enough food. I can't get my head around that.

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 17:51

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:43

She is not living in true poverty, she PUT herself into poverty by purchasing something that she could have done without. There is a huge difference between having bikes in your kitchen and not being able to afford to eat. She needs support for budgeting which she admits she has a problem with but is she in true, bones of her arse poverty...no. She makes silly financial decisions.

Regardless. Her posts are clearly from someone is struggling and feeling worn down by life. Can you not read tone? You could have said the same thing but more sensitively.

Or are you proud of being one of those ‘tell ‘em like it is’ types?

EightChalk · 16/05/2023 17:46

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 17:37

She is simply being human. Just existing every day on the breadline is tough. Have a heart. No need for the unpleasantness towards someone who has relatively little and is struggling. I can’t imagine why people are so mean.

Another great point. We ALL make impulsive decisions from time to time, and make choices that aren't the absolute best optimal sensible thing to do. Not having enough money doesn't mean you are suddenly immune to this. You do have to be more careful out of pure necessity, but if you haven't been in this position, try to think about it with some empathy - imagine not being able to make any mis-steps, day in day out, for months and years. Never any impulse, emotion-driven purchases; your hierarchy of "necessary" items must be completely correct before you're allowed any sympathy and not deemed to be in a situation of your own making (even though OP really did need the shed so as not to have bikes in the kitchen).

It's asking a huge amount of someone who is ALREADY in a tough situation, and whose decision-making processes are under more stress than those of someone who can end each month with a spare couple of hundred pounds without any real effort.

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:43

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 17:37

She is simply being human. Just existing every day on the breadline is tough. Have a heart. No need for the unpleasantness towards someone who has relatively little and is struggling. I can’t imagine why people are so mean.

She is not living in true poverty, she PUT herself into poverty by purchasing something that she could have done without. There is a huge difference between having bikes in your kitchen and not being able to afford to eat. She needs support for budgeting which she admits she has a problem with but is she in true, bones of her arse poverty...no. She makes silly financial decisions.

HereAndNowAgain · 16/05/2023 17:37

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:16

She may as well have, you can't eat a fucking handbag and you can't eat a fucking shed.

She made a stupid choice KNOWING what would happen. So now she finds herself starving and snarfing leftover pizza down, not washing her kids hair, giving them dry cereal and has no petrol in her car if an emergency happened.

But at least the bikes are dry eh?

She is simply being human. Just existing every day on the breadline is tough. Have a heart. No need for the unpleasantness towards someone who has relatively little and is struggling. I can’t imagine why people are so mean.

Fourpeasinapodcast · 16/05/2023 17:35

ItWillWash · 16/05/2023 17:31

You don't need shampoo to wash your hair. It's nice to have and I do class shampoo as an essential item but going without it for a few days isn't going to kill anyone.

Hair can be washed with water, conditioner, shower gel, washing-up liquid, and a myriad of other soap or water-based products.

I can see the dry cereal comment now, I apologize, although I don't think it will harm the kids to eat dry cereal. Mine do it willingly sometimes. Dry Cheerios are eaten like crisps in this house.

How no one gets what it's like, waking up to nothing in the bank, dry cereal, panicking about if there's a non school uniform day

Doesn't sound like she enjoys it much.

Swipe left for the next trending thread