Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate the modern trend of replacing ‘th’ with ‘v’ or ‘f’?

162 replies

Guiltridden12345 · 15/05/2023 22:41

It’s everywhere. All age groups from middle age downwards (not heard in older people yet). My child’s teachers (primary and secondary), presenters on tv and radio, my kids trying to adopt it from their mates. Not cockney or accent related (ie like a Nottingham accent that does replace th with f a lot), just pan regional sloppy speech that seems to have caught on. I fink, I fort, bruvver, uvver. Why?

OP posts:
UrsulaBelle · 16/05/2023 12:14

LadyMary50 · 16/05/2023 12:07

The OP isn’t talking about young children or accents or impediments,it’s about grown adults trying to talk like ‘gangsta’.It’s irritating to say the least…

My DS3 is 21 actually.

limitedperiodonly · 16/05/2023 12:11

Bluegrass · 16/05/2023 11:52

I for one am super annoyed that people no longer seem to be able to pronounce the “k” and “gh” in “Knight” and instead go with this “nite” nonsense!

It is just laziness, or an affectation of the young perhaps. If it is good enough for Chaucer though it is good enough for me, so I am taking a stand against the dumbing down of our language!

@Bluegrass for A level Chaucer our teacher would read aloud in a Middle English accent and laugh at the dirty bits. Her name was Miss Inglis. Most people would pronounce it Ingliss but because of her and her excellent lessons, I know it is Ingalls and we used to say kerniggut.

LadyMary50 · 16/05/2023 12:07

UrsulaBelle · 16/05/2023 12:02

My DS3 can't pronounce the TH sound, It's either F or V depending on whether the TH is voiced or unvoiced. He can't hear the difference either. DS1 and DS2 have no such problem. I don't like how it sounds, but he can't help it. Lovely to hear that you'd judge him. 🤔

The OP isn’t talking about young children or accents or impediments,it’s about grown adults trying to talk like ‘gangsta’.It’s irritating to say the least…

Havanananana · 16/05/2023 12:06

This "modern trend" was in existence 70 years ago or longer, as this song from the 1950's 'Forty Fahsend Fevvers on a Frush' demonstrates:

The Billy Cotton Band - 'Forty Fahsend Fevvers on a Frush'

I don't have a date for this recording but it was frequently played on the wireless in the 1950's.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6bpsrWpjjQ

PicturesOfDogs · 16/05/2023 12:04

LadyMary50 · 16/05/2023 11:58

I agree it’s more to do with slang not regional accents.It’s everywhere now and I can’t stand it.Also a lot of TV presenters are starting to sound like Jamaicans even though they are white British as in “arrr pleyer”instead of Iplayer.Its getting ridiculous…

You can agree, but you’d be wrong.

As I’ve posted, it’s usage has been documented in London since the 1700/1800s.
If only they had the foresight to change it so in a few hundred years LadyMary50 off mumsnet wouldn’t be annoyed.

These kids and their ‘modern’ ways, eh?

TheOrigRights · 16/05/2023 12:04

We live in Essex. The way my son speaks is not a modern trend, it's the dialect he speaks with.

UrsulaBelle · 16/05/2023 12:02

My DS3 can't pronounce the TH sound, It's either F or V depending on whether the TH is voiced or unvoiced. He can't hear the difference either. DS1 and DS2 have no such problem. I don't like how it sounds, but he can't help it. Lovely to hear that you'd judge him. 🤔

LadyMary50 · 16/05/2023 11:58

RichPetunia · 16/05/2023 00:38

For goodness sake, the OP is talking about slang - not speech impediments.

I agree it’s more to do with slang not regional accents.It’s everywhere now and I can’t stand it.Also a lot of TV presenters are starting to sound like Jamaicans even though they are white British as in “arrr pleyer”instead of Iplayer.Its getting ridiculous…

limitedperiodonly · 16/05/2023 11:57

@lissie123 the aitch and haitch example trotted out by people who think they know what's proper, is a perfect example of a shibboleth.

As everyone who's read their Bible knows, it derives from two ancient Hebrew tribes, one who could pronounce the "ssh" sound, and one who couldn't and said "sss".

It was used as a password and if you got it wrong, they didn't just correct your pronunciation. Given all that's happened over the years you can see how Irish people who say haitch are a bit sensitive about English people telling them it's pronounced aitch.

These days the meaning has expanded but it's essentially an example of people who want to sort sheep from goats, which is something else I read in the Bible. Anyway, it's not a very nice or even clever thing to do.

MereDintofPandiculation · 16/05/2023 11:57

People say that they can’t hear the difference, but they know how a word is spelled which is so helpful in English, isn’t it?

Panapan · 16/05/2023 11:57

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/05/2023 11:41

Wouldn't be a cause for concern at that age regardless - voiced and unvoiced th (I'm not trying to type the IPA for it on here!) are the last sounds to be typically acquired at late infant type age.

Also a huge movement within SLT to make sure that an individual's speech community and their home accent/dialect are not devalued in some kind of push to make everyone go back to trying to sound like they've escaped a BBC broadcast from the 1950s. If the home environment all use f/v and the child is aware that fish does not start with the same phoneme as thin - would not be flagging many causes for concern, even if it is driving you as a parent mildly mad.

Mind you - the mess NHS paeds SLT is in - you'll be lucky to get much of anything! (I work with adults!)

Thanks for your reply. I’m interested in what one of the PPs said about accent being used to oppress those from lower socio-economic classes. Presumably a child from a home where RP is spoken is going to be at an advantage when learning phonics when compared with a child from a home where one of the strong regional variations is spoken. So right from the start a child whose parents “have an accent” has an inherent hurdle to overcome. Maybe it’s a drawback of the particular system of phonics that’s taught, and I suppose it’s probably an advantage that doesn’t last for long as of course spelling is visual as well as aural but presumably there’s still some correlation between the children who catch on faster and those who speak RP at home?

CoalCraft · 16/05/2023 11:54

I find this thread fascinating. My two year old can say 'th' just fine but cannot manage 'f' at all. She replaces it with 'sh'. There are other consonants she replaces/muddles too but 'th' is usually there.

So it seems weird to me that 'f' is generally considered easier than 'th'.

Bluegrass · 16/05/2023 11:52

I for one am super annoyed that people no longer seem to be able to pronounce the “k” and “gh” in “Knight” and instead go with this “nite” nonsense!

It is just laziness, or an affectation of the young perhaps. If it is good enough for Chaucer though it is good enough for me, so I am taking a stand against the dumbing down of our language!

SisterAgatha · 16/05/2023 11:48

I’m a cockney. This is my reality and my voice and I’ll use it how I like :)

Alwayswonderedwhy · 16/05/2023 11:46

I don't know one single person that does this.
I've overheard teens doing it. Assuming they think it makes themselves sound cool.

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/05/2023 11:45

CaffeinateMeNow · 16/05/2023 11:34

Hello! I'm a phonetician and accent specialist. I've written books about English pronunciation, it's regional variants and how accent is used to oppress those from lower socio-economic backgrounds. I've spent years researching and analysing accents of the UK.

It's so funny to me how the phrase 'The Queens English' is used to arbitrarily define a 'correct' way to talk, when lovely Liz herself evolved her speech system over the years - just listen to the Queen's speech in the 50's versus the noughties. Did you know speech was only standardised in a dictionary of Received Pronunciation in 1869? And then it was based on the speech patterns of the elite in the South, where we have our capital and centre of political power (at least at the time...!).

The reality is this 'PROPAH' speech exists only due to a series of invasions and marriages and reeks of the desperation of historical social climbing. No one cared about accent before people could escape their class.

Accents move and shift and they always, always will. There is no 'correct' when it comes to speech UNLESS meaning is lost. Swapping a TH for an F now and again will not likely make you misunderstood, whereas swapping an L for an X would be pretty tricky.

Please, PLEASE try and understand how accent is muscular. If I asked you right now to do the splits/a backflip - could you do it (anyone saying 'yes' I am v jealous!)? If the answer is 'no' that is the level of muscular shift you are asking a person to make to change a lifetime of swapping any speech sound for another. It's literal oral gymnastics. If I asked those of you who hate the F swap to do it for a whole day, how would you find it. It's really hard!!

Try and be tolerant. I realise this is a pointless plea to many, but try! These are just regional accents, they are not incorrect speech.

Incidentally, the next future evolution of Global English is merging into an international sound anyway. We now have a world where English is a common language for many speakers of different languages, so they communicate through English. This means "mispronunciations" are being cemented across speakers and countries. English speakers are starting to find themselves reinforcing these mispronunciations in the name of speed (think different stresses/over-pronouncing unstressed syllables) and these will become the norm.

Accents are a form of spoken oral history. We mustn't judge them (yes, even when the speaker is a teacher).

Ooooh squeals with geeky delight here! I bloody miss phonetics so damned much... and sociolinguistics! Phonetics made most people cry but I bloody loved it.

The other bit is that human connected speech is a whole glorious hodge hodge of your articulators taking all kinds of short cuts to jump to the next sound and clock off the one they're on early.

And if you're ever wanting to be fascinated - look up the videos of beatboxing in an MRI scanner - it's fucking amazing what goes on inside your head!

ShimmeringShirts · 16/05/2023 11:44

You actually asked someone with a speech impediment to explain why they have it…? Would you ask someone unable to walk and in a wheelchair why their legs don’t work? The idiocy and entitlement of some people never fail to astound me.

Nordicrain · 16/05/2023 11:44

CaffeinateMeNow · 16/05/2023 11:34

Hello! I'm a phonetician and accent specialist. I've written books about English pronunciation, it's regional variants and how accent is used to oppress those from lower socio-economic backgrounds. I've spent years researching and analysing accents of the UK.

It's so funny to me how the phrase 'The Queens English' is used to arbitrarily define a 'correct' way to talk, when lovely Liz herself evolved her speech system over the years - just listen to the Queen's speech in the 50's versus the noughties. Did you know speech was only standardised in a dictionary of Received Pronunciation in 1869? And then it was based on the speech patterns of the elite in the South, where we have our capital and centre of political power (at least at the time...!).

The reality is this 'PROPAH' speech exists only due to a series of invasions and marriages and reeks of the desperation of historical social climbing. No one cared about accent before people could escape their class.

Accents move and shift and they always, always will. There is no 'correct' when it comes to speech UNLESS meaning is lost. Swapping a TH for an F now and again will not likely make you misunderstood, whereas swapping an L for an X would be pretty tricky.

Please, PLEASE try and understand how accent is muscular. If I asked you right now to do the splits/a backflip - could you do it (anyone saying 'yes' I am v jealous!)? If the answer is 'no' that is the level of muscular shift you are asking a person to make to change a lifetime of swapping any speech sound for another. It's literal oral gymnastics. If I asked those of you who hate the F swap to do it for a whole day, how would you find it. It's really hard!!

Try and be tolerant. I realise this is a pointless plea to many, but try! These are just regional accents, they are not incorrect speech.

Incidentally, the next future evolution of Global English is merging into an international sound anyway. We now have a world where English is a common language for many speakers of different languages, so they communicate through English. This means "mispronunciations" are being cemented across speakers and countries. English speakers are starting to find themselves reinforcing these mispronunciations in the name of speed (think different stresses/over-pronouncing unstressed syllables) and these will become the norm.

Accents are a form of spoken oral history. We mustn't judge them (yes, even when the speaker is a teacher).

👏

There's your answer @Guiltridden12345 Or have you left so noone interferes with your judgement?

potniatheron · 16/05/2023 11:43

fairycakes1234 · 16/05/2023 11:28

Definitely an English thing, although a lot of Irish cant pronounce the TH and say DE,instead of the, and dose instead of those....drives me nuts.

It's not that Irish people 'can't pronounce' 'th'. They DO pronounce it. They just pronounce it 'dh'.

Some of the shite people are spouting on this thread verges on out and out racism.

crabbyoldappletree · 16/05/2023 11:43

Panapan · 16/05/2023 11:18

It’s interesting to hear that SLTs now see this as just cosmetic. My three year old confuses f and th and it means at the moment that he can’t say whether eg thumb starts with “f” or “th”. I’m not concerned as he’s only 3, but can imagine that for school age children this kind of speech impediment has the potential to make learning phonics a bit more difficult. I’m surprised therefore to read that it’s not something a SLT would help with.

I don't think SaLTs do see it as cosmetic, but they work with disruptions to the spoken (not written) communication chain.
/f/ /v/ substitution is not a breakdown in communication and therefore wouldn't meet the NHS threshold. Remember spelling uses the visual as well as auditory route.
A private speech therapist could probably sort it in a couple of sessions for most (but not all children) if the parent wanted it sorted, just the same with a lisp, or other minor speech 'errors' (using the term 'error' very loosely here).

potniatheron · 16/05/2023 11:42

CaffeinateMeNow · 16/05/2023 11:34

Hello! I'm a phonetician and accent specialist. I've written books about English pronunciation, it's regional variants and how accent is used to oppress those from lower socio-economic backgrounds. I've spent years researching and analysing accents of the UK.

It's so funny to me how the phrase 'The Queens English' is used to arbitrarily define a 'correct' way to talk, when lovely Liz herself evolved her speech system over the years - just listen to the Queen's speech in the 50's versus the noughties. Did you know speech was only standardised in a dictionary of Received Pronunciation in 1869? And then it was based on the speech patterns of the elite in the South, where we have our capital and centre of political power (at least at the time...!).

The reality is this 'PROPAH' speech exists only due to a series of invasions and marriages and reeks of the desperation of historical social climbing. No one cared about accent before people could escape their class.

Accents move and shift and they always, always will. There is no 'correct' when it comes to speech UNLESS meaning is lost. Swapping a TH for an F now and again will not likely make you misunderstood, whereas swapping an L for an X would be pretty tricky.

Please, PLEASE try and understand how accent is muscular. If I asked you right now to do the splits/a backflip - could you do it (anyone saying 'yes' I am v jealous!)? If the answer is 'no' that is the level of muscular shift you are asking a person to make to change a lifetime of swapping any speech sound for another. It's literal oral gymnastics. If I asked those of you who hate the F swap to do it for a whole day, how would you find it. It's really hard!!

Try and be tolerant. I realise this is a pointless plea to many, but try! These are just regional accents, they are not incorrect speech.

Incidentally, the next future evolution of Global English is merging into an international sound anyway. We now have a world where English is a common language for many speakers of different languages, so they communicate through English. This means "mispronunciations" are being cemented across speakers and countries. English speakers are starting to find themselves reinforcing these mispronunciations in the name of speed (think different stresses/over-pronouncing unstressed syllables) and these will become the norm.

Accents are a form of spoken oral history. We mustn't judge them (yes, even when the speaker is a teacher).

Brilliant

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/05/2023 11:41

Panapan · 16/05/2023 11:18

It’s interesting to hear that SLTs now see this as just cosmetic. My three year old confuses f and th and it means at the moment that he can’t say whether eg thumb starts with “f” or “th”. I’m not concerned as he’s only 3, but can imagine that for school age children this kind of speech impediment has the potential to make learning phonics a bit more difficult. I’m surprised therefore to read that it’s not something a SLT would help with.

Wouldn't be a cause for concern at that age regardless - voiced and unvoiced th (I'm not trying to type the IPA for it on here!) are the last sounds to be typically acquired at late infant type age.

Also a huge movement within SLT to make sure that an individual's speech community and their home accent/dialect are not devalued in some kind of push to make everyone go back to trying to sound like they've escaped a BBC broadcast from the 1950s. If the home environment all use f/v and the child is aware that fish does not start with the same phoneme as thin - would not be flagging many causes for concern, even if it is driving you as a parent mildly mad.

Mind you - the mess NHS paeds SLT is in - you'll be lucky to get much of anything! (I work with adults!)

limitedperiodonly · 16/05/2023 11:40

lissie123 · 16/05/2023 11:32

And Not pronouncing H as “aitch” and instead saying “haitch”drives me insane

Don't say that out loud in parts of Ireland. Saying "haitch" is acceptable pronunciation, especially in some communities, and English people (if that is what you are) declaring that it's wrong is a sure-fire way of getting their backs up.

CaffeinateMeNow · 16/05/2023 11:38

Oooh - fun accent test. People who are obsessed with speaking 'properly' will SWEAR they don't do this, but they absolutely do (unless they talk permanently like actors in a Noel Coward film).

Ask them to say 'vodka and tonic'.

In British English we insert a little R sound between the end of vodka and start of and:

Vodka-ran(d)-tonic (d generally not released because it assimilates in speech with T).

It drives people mad to know that 'correct' connected spoken speech includes sound insertion. I love showing people this. Generally highlights how unaware people are about speech.

limitedperiodonly · 16/05/2023 11:34

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 16/05/2023 10:55

if some people can't do the "th" sound they can't; just like most people from England do not get the Scottish "ch" on Loch but say Lock it is very very difficult to learn new sounds after childhood

True. I speak Spanish and can be easily understood in Spain or Spanish-speaking countries even though I cannot roll my Rs. No matter how hard I try, I can't do it because I am an English English speaker. I wonder if Scottish people, with rhotic pronunciation, find that easier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread