Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to share anymore baby news with brother/SIL - AIBU?

110 replies

RozaBaby · 15/05/2023 18:43

Hi all!

I announced to my family that I’m 14w, I told my dad and step mum in person as they live in the same city as I do, they had an absolutely heartwarming reaction, it was lovely!

I then text my brother as he lives 4 hours away, I told him by sending the scan photos and something along the lines of “a happy and welcome surprise!” He immediately called me and asked what it was, whose it was, and how many weeks. After this, he tells SIL he’s on the phone with me and I hear an annoyed “why?” In the background, he says “because of this” and (I assume) shows her the photos, her voice gets more irritated as she says “whose is that?!” And he responds with my name, she asks again in a more annoyed voice, “how many weeks?” He tells her 14w and she, once again, even more annoyed says, “no it isn’t! What’s the f- due date then?!” He asks me, I respond, and he repeats it, she goes silent and he follows up with “I’ll call you back” and hangs up.

My partner, dad, and step mum thought this was a disgusting and ridiculous response! I was baffled with the reaction!

Later that night, I receive a text from my brother saying something like “are you planning on keeping it or what?” My partner was instantly annoyed with this as he felt it was pure disrespect due to my past miscarriage which my family knows about. I responded yes, and we haven’t had contact since.

I really do not want to interact with either my brother or SIL after this, I’m not sure if I want to cut contact completely but after this I do not wish to give anymore updates on the baby or my pregnancy journey. Is this an unreasonable way to feel?

More context as I feel some might wonder: me and brother had a decent relationship with no animosity, he and my SIL have 6 children together.

OP posts:
Zee1345 · 15/05/2023 21:28

Congratulations on your pregnancy!

I guess you never really know what's going on with people but I feel as if they have suffered a loss it's still not an excuse to react in such a way and even go as far as to say "are you keeping it" it's such an weird reaction, many people have losses and find out a relative or friend is pregnant and even though it is painful you still feel happy for the other person and congratulate them.

I personally think if your brother and sil kids are the only ones who have grandchildren right now then maybe they feel jealous ( more so your Sil) as other people have suggested maybe she feels her kids won't be as "important" now or something.

I would either ask your brother privately or just don't share any further updates from now on about the baby and the pregnancy, if he brings it up you can always bring up his reaction to when you told him you was pregnant.

qanapoo · 15/05/2023 21:20

Unbelievably weird

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/05/2023 21:10

Unless you have faked pregnancies in the past I don't understand the reaction it was like they didn't believe your actually pregnant

TiaraBoo · 15/05/2023 21:05

@RozaBaby Congratulations!

did the last message sound like something your brother would write? Because it does make more sense if it came from your SIL instead of someone who read your first message and had a short conversation with.

I ‘think’ I would message him back at a time when he’s at work so only he sees it, with something short along the lines of “what was that last message about?”

But no YANBU to feel that way

MountainChalet · 15/05/2023 20:44

You should have a word with your brother, preferably at a time he's not at home. Their attitude was absolutely disgusting. Hope he apologizes for their reaction.

Godlovesall26 · 15/05/2023 20:43

Godlovesall26 · 15/05/2023 20:40

I would bet on your SIL being at the source of that message. And your brother (understandably, in a way) not wanting to rock his wife’s feelings with 6 kids together. If you have an otherwise good relationship with him, I’d take ‘I’ll call you back’ as a way to try to protect you from whatever else she might have been about to say.
Id try a private conversation with your brother when you’re sure she isn’t present, maybe mention you found her reaction weird to give him an opportunity to explain if he wants, but otherwise sounds like you’ll have to separate the two of them in your mind for the time being. At the end of the day, SIL I imagine isn’t the most significant person in your life, and after 6 kids your brother’s decision to stay seems clear, so I’d try not to burn unnecessary bridges with him for now.
If the behavior repeats sure, or if he stands by sending that message strongly, but sounds like he was put on the spot, if he’s otherwise been great, you can give time to see how things evolve.

Otherwise, you definitely don’t have to send any updates in the meantime or for the whole duration, your well-being matters more

Godlovesall26 · 15/05/2023 20:40

I would bet on your SIL being at the source of that message. And your brother (understandably, in a way) not wanting to rock his wife’s feelings with 6 kids together. If you have an otherwise good relationship with him, I’d take ‘I’ll call you back’ as a way to try to protect you from whatever else she might have been about to say.
Id try a private conversation with your brother when you’re sure she isn’t present, maybe mention you found her reaction weird to give him an opportunity to explain if he wants, but otherwise sounds like you’ll have to separate the two of them in your mind for the time being. At the end of the day, SIL I imagine isn’t the most significant person in your life, and after 6 kids your brother’s decision to stay seems clear, so I’d try not to burn unnecessary bridges with him for now.
If the behavior repeats sure, or if he stands by sending that message strongly, but sounds like he was put on the spot, if he’s otherwise been great, you can give time to see how things evolve.

LindorDoubleChoc · 15/05/2023 20:40

Well that's all very mystifying. I think I would have a go at asking DB why he and DSIL were so underwhelmed/irritated by my happy news before cutting contact.

Zone2NorthLondon · 15/05/2023 20:37

Congratulations on your happy news, you & your partner must be thrilled
Look after yourself, don’t get into any débâcle arguments about this,it’s a strange reaction. Potentially something going on they’re not disclosing

Thatsridiculous · 15/05/2023 20:31

If you previously had a good relationship then why not ask him?

If my sister responded like that to me I would ask her.

DowntonCrabby · 15/05/2023 20:31

That’s disgusting. Even if they’ve had a sad loss/ are planning more and it’s not going well it’s a horrible reaction that I’d struggle to get past.

takealettermsjones · 15/05/2023 20:28

Congratulations!

Wow, what a bizarre reaction. Even if there is a loss or infertility issue, it seems strange to react with what looks like anger rather than sadness. Is there any reason why they would be angry at the thought of you having a baby? Are you really young? Will pregnancy be really dangerous for you medically? Are you a serial killer? 😆

I would wait until things have calmed down and then ring your brother and ask what that was all about.

PuffinMcStuffin · 15/05/2023 20:28

OP you are going to need to speak to your brother before you can know what to do - there has got to be something else going on if this is so out of character of him.

Hopelesscynic · 15/05/2023 20:27

Whatever their "reasons" (if any) their reaction is overly rude and disgusting. If they'd follow up with a kind text (which they should have done after feeling ashamed of themselves), that might have saved the situation. But after the nasty comment about keeping or not keeping "it" (your child!) No way I'd be in any further communication with them.

They must know full well you wouldn't be sending them a scan photo if you were planning an abortion and certainly wouldn't be telling them the "due date"!

Starlitestarbright · 15/05/2023 20:26

She sounds threatened by your baby taking time away from her dc

KinderCat · 15/05/2023 20:25

Like a lot of other my SIL (DH's sister) was a bit like this when we announced our first. After a lot of issues we finally managed to concieve purely by chance. Rest of the family happy and normal messages, she refused to message us just messaged MIL to confirm if she knew, if its true, when it's due. Hers is 100% fear ours will take the attention away as hers are the only grandchildren in a big family and DH is very much apple of his mum's eye to boot (last part against my will).... probably similar OP. Used to being the family and center of it, now like you said a first after some issues and more locally has put her nose out of joint.

Congrats OP! Enjoy it and ignore them!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/05/2023 20:22

Does she tend to wail 'I've got SIX CHILDREN!' in connection with wanting

Money
Babysitting
Sympathy
Pats on the head
The red carpet rolled out when she honours everybody with the opportunity to lavish gifts and attention upon the cherished fruits of her womb?

  • so she's seeing your due date as potentially affecting her kids' birthday and Christmas presents?

Or is she incredibly possessive of BIL and seems convinced that he and his cock of gold are like catnip to anything with ovaries, so instantly assumed the scan image was from some random woman at his workplace?

Wtfishappeningandwhy · 15/05/2023 20:20

Do they accept a lot of childcare from your parents? Maybe worried that you having dc will make parents less available to them. Whatever the reason, it’s a rude and obnoxious response to your happy news. Congratulations on your pregnancy 🎉

diddl · 15/05/2023 20:19

SIL might be thinking that yours will be the preferred GC?

Very odd (imo) that your brother asked whose scan it was!!

Nocutenamesleft · 15/05/2023 20:18

Rather than us strangers who don’t know either of you wouldn’t really have a clue

maybe ring them and ask? I take it you aren’t that close to your brother? If you’re not close is it a big deal and if you are close. The. Ask him why he and her reacted like that?

then let us know 😂

Thundercats77 · 15/05/2023 20:14

Congratulations op how exciting for you both! I hope you have a really smooth pregnancy. As previous pp have said, don't give them any updates and just don't bother with them. You concentrate on enjoying your pregnancy and don't waste your energy on them.

MollyRover · 15/05/2023 20:13

Very strange reaction. My brother phoned me to tell me about their DC2, I disclosed earlier than I planned to about my DC2, my DH and his DW came on the phone and we whooped and giggled for eachother, the end. They've got 6 children fgs, they couldn't be jealous or shocked that someone else might decide to have one!!

LunchBoxPolice · 15/05/2023 20:09

How weird and hurtful.
Congratulation op !

LimeCheesecake · 15/05/2023 20:06

my gut reaction is they are shocked you are having a baby now for some reason - as you have been with your dp for 3 years it can’t be that it’s a new relationship, are you much younger than your brother? (As in, under 21) so they haven’t quite got round to seeing you as an adult?

or could you be in an insecure financial /housing situation? Still in education/training etc?

Do you/your SIL have family cultures where having a baby unmarried isn’t the done thing?

“are you keeping it?” Does read like there’s a good reason in their minds to think you wouldn’t be.

Runningcrew · 15/05/2023 20:04

There’s no excuse OP, they have 6 kids and you have none yet, but at least one miscarriage and presumably you’ve shown joy and support to your brother when SIL was pregnant. So even if in worst case scenario she has sadly recently suffered a loss she shouldn’t be making you feel uncomfortable like that as you didn’t when it was them having babies.

A lot of people have jealous siblings and it’s a real shame. There are people in my life I refuse to share good news with because their reaction is always so negative and puts a dampener on things! I may tell them eventually but I drag it out or let them find out through someone else.