Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there is still such a stigma on only children?

193 replies

BettyBoopBetty · 15/05/2023 15:47

DC is 3 and will most likely stay an only. For a mix of reasons really but mainly we both don’t particularly desire another one and the financial burden for full time childcare x2 (London) is something we are not willing to compromise on again. We’d have much more time, energy and resources to dedicate to our DC this way and we are very loving and involved parents. Still, when I tell people about our choice, they often judge and can’t wait to start telling us stories of how unhappy X’s childhood was as an only, how nice it is to have siblings etc etc.
I know some people who didn’t particularly want a second but did it anyway to give number 1 a sibling - I think it’s nuts!
If you have an only, have you found that people in general tend to judge you for it?

OP posts:
Wenfy · 15/05/2023 16:44

BettyBoopBetty · 15/05/2023 15:47

DC is 3 and will most likely stay an only. For a mix of reasons really but mainly we both don’t particularly desire another one and the financial burden for full time childcare x2 (London) is something we are not willing to compromise on again. We’d have much more time, energy and resources to dedicate to our DC this way and we are very loving and involved parents. Still, when I tell people about our choice, they often judge and can’t wait to start telling us stories of how unhappy X’s childhood was as an only, how nice it is to have siblings etc etc.
I know some people who didn’t particularly want a second but did it anyway to give number 1 a sibling - I think it’s nuts!
If you have an only, have you found that people in general tend to judge you for it?

DD was born after a huge infertility struggle. When she was young we thought her SEN was going to be severe & we decided we needed to give her a sibling if only so she had someone to visit occassionally and champion for her when we’re gone. But we had secondary infertility too & our DS came at a time when DD started thriving - she went from non-verbal & in nappies at 5 to top of class by 8, to olympics sports scholarships and a good friend circle by 11.

I love DS to bits but if I had a crystal ball when DD was 5 I would not have tried so hard to have him for the reasons I did.

I think most parents have siblings from a similar place of fear we did. We see our kids as babies and dependant on us - but actually raising them properly meana making them less reliant on us. So if we do this well siblings don’t make a difference.

PurplePineapple1 · 15/05/2023 16:39

I have one. I wanted none but my husband at the time convinced me to continue the pregnancy. I've had comments for yeeeeears. Mostly people telling me I didn't know my own mind and would change my mind. She's 20 now and the comments have changed to mostly well it's too late for you now, you'll regret it. No, I won't. I have no interest in children!

Oh and my only child is the life and soul. Hugely extroverted. Loads of friends.

I am one of 4 and am shy, introverted, not good at making friends.

The no of siblings you do or don't have has fuck all to do with your personality.

Climbles · 15/05/2023 16:38

CountMushroom · 15/05/2023 16:07

They may not care, but they’re certainly quite free with their opinions. Not everyone, or everywhere — I never got it in London, or the city I live in now, but during my seven years in a village in the Midlands (which was admittedly the most insular, conformist place I’ve ever lived), a significant number of neighbours, friends of friends, people at parties and other parents at the village school could not get their heads around having one child by choice, and I was treated to all the classics:

‘You can’t only have one child!’

’That’s so selfish!’

’Oh, the lonely only!’

That must get really annoying

usererror99 · 15/05/2023 16:37

Because a lot of people consider being deliberately "one and done" fairly selfish - but then again many people would say having any child is selfish - you can't please everyone - there are always going to be opposing views. It's not a choice i would have made for my child personally - I think if you are prepared to bring one child into the world then you should be prepared to have a sibling - cost of raising a child shouldn't come as a surprise and if age isn't a factor you time things so that you're not paying out for 2 children at the same time. Some people prioritise where they live and holidays and so on others don't. Have none have one have 5 doesn't matter if you are comfortable with the choice you have made for your child doesn't mean anyone's choice is better than anyone else's - I don't live your life and you don't live mine (mum of 3)

Wenfy · 15/05/2023 16:36

BashfulClam · 15/05/2023 15:55

My husband is an only child, he has social phobia and is really shy. I have a sibling and I’m better at being outgoing, I’ve even been on tv lol.

the main thing is now everything widowed MIL need falls on DH and it’s really stressful. She doesn’t drive and has slight reading and writing difficulties and is a natural worrier. As I have a sibling we can share any issues with my mother and have two heads to put together. If I can’t get to her or my brother can’t, hopefully the other will be free. DH was I’ll from stress during lockdown because of mil but she is a manipulative old bag too.

He should be able to share the burden with you. Isn’t that the point of having a spouse?

BashfulClam · 15/05/2023 16:34

Mutabiliss · 15/05/2023 16:08

I'm an only child and am not shy, no social anxiety. I am an introvert - as are both of my parents - but it really annoys me when people assume introverts are socially anxious. I love being around my friends, I just need time alone to recharge afterwards!

One of the most outgoing people I know is an only child. She's life and soul of the party, has always done jobs that involve networking, conferences, socialising and schmoozing, was on TV a bit in her youth (not sure what this has to do with anything) and currently travels constantly for work (i.e. travel and meeting new people is her job).

Being an only child does not create a personality type.

I also see no problem with being the only person needing to deal with elderly parents. It usually seems to fall to just one sibling anyway. It's easier, I reckon - no-one to disagree with or expect more from, you just get on with it yourself (or not).

I’m not assuming that he’s socially anxious. He has been diagnosed and in counselling it was suggested that a sibling may have been a benefit. I have seen the stress he has had dealing with mil, I have much less of it as both me and my brother help out. I am only putting out there our experience and why I am quite glad to have that sibling support.

Lcb123 · 15/05/2023 16:34

Well if you're forthcoming with your reasons etc, then of course they'll respond. I can't see many scenarios where you'd have to even bring it up? I don't have kids, and if someone asks, I just ask "no I don't". I'd never say anything else, and rarely someone asks further.

PaintDiagram · 15/05/2023 16:33

peoples opinions differ depending on their relationship with their own siblings.

I’ve got a bond with my siblings that could never be replicated with anyone else.

but then you get others who can easily take their siblings or leave them.

I’m currently pregnant with our first and will be trying in the next couple of years for the next. But that’s because I’m part of the first camp. In all honesty I’ve always had more of a bond to my siblings that my own parents. It would feel like id be depriving this baby that relationship.

But on the other hand, only children with two loving parents also have great childhood too.

caringcarer · 15/05/2023 16:29

It's really no one else's business how many DC you decide to have. I can see advantages of being an only child in terms of attention and resources. I invite my niece to go on holiday with my youngest son because they are both quite a bit younger than their siblings so although not only children they are growing up in the family home with no other siblings there. Their relationship is more like brother and sister than cousins. When parents get older I was very relieved to have 4 sisters to help with my Mum's care. She didn't have to go into a home for the final 6 weeks of life because we all helped her in different ways in her own home.

Amore2023 · 15/05/2023 16:26

I don’t think there is such a stigma attached to it so much anymore. But we have encountered a few. My DM was a bit worried that we would regret our decision to stop at one and did put some of our DD’s behavioural traits down to being an only child but this was genuine concern.

The worst I have had was someone at the school gates ask, ‘what would you do if your only died?’ To this, I was flabbergasted for a moment but then said, ‘I think I would respond in the same way as you would if one of your DC died, heaven forbid!’

This comment was pretty bad but I think these are individual extremes. It really depends if you are ‘one and done’ by choice, circumstances not to do with infertility or due to infertility problems and how you feel as a couple and family that counts. Also, I have learnt not to let other people’s received ideas affect me too much. There was one woman who was kind of implying I wasn’t as much of a mother as her as she had three, I just kind of ignore it and say ‘it works for us!’ It’s hard to deal with these kinds of judgemental comments but it says more about the other person than you in a way. Smile, hold your head up and be proud…and get on with your life.

RandyMiceDavies · 15/05/2023 16:23

I think the majority have no interest at all in how many children another person has and are just making conversation. If you had lots of children, they'd comment on that. I have a very standard 2 children, one boy one girl, and people still have something to say about it because you can't just say "oh".

Turfwars · 15/05/2023 16:21

I have an only DS. We would have liked more but it never happened. People assume that because you managed one, that you will have more kids but I kept miscarrying. I got a few comments that hurt at the time from arseholes who should have known better.

I did feel guilty for a while but my FIL was an only child too and had the biggest circle of friends I have ever seen. His funeral was the biggest I think I've seen.

Some of us cant have more than one. Some of us choose to have one. And life turns out the way it turns out. DM had several of us. Only two of us live in the same country as her now and one of those is a full time carer so when DM is increasingly needing care, it's falling to me alone anyway! I know plenty who do have siblings and are NC, and others that have no family and are very happy.

Switchingup · 15/05/2023 16:20

I've never had any comment about having 1dc who is 7,

I have had the general "will you have any more" and the answer is just "no were done" and that's it

But I feel amongst people I know any "stigma" around only children doesn't exist and there are quite a few only children in my friendship group

Annoyingwurringnoise · 15/05/2023 16:20

Is there really a stigma about only children though? I’ve never encountered it in real life, only on here.

CountMushroom · 15/05/2023 16:18

skippy67 · 15/05/2023 16:11

Exactly this. 3 of my close friends have decided they only want one child. It's the least interesting thing about them.

I certainly never volunteered any information about my offspring — people specifically asked me, and then emoted about it!

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 15/05/2023 16:16

The default is two children, 3 if you’re perceived as being well-off. So people who have no children, 1 child or 3+ if you’re poor or 4+ if you’re well off come under scrutiny. However, people with 2 children of the same sex will then be asked if they want the opposite sex, that’s the only acceptable scenario to have a third.

People will tell you how lonely they were or how the care is falling to one adult child now. For every story like that there is another story to counter it. For example, PP whose husband is an only and very shy but she’s been on TV. I’m an only on my mums side but only saw my half-siblings once a month and I’m 10 years older them so more like an only than not, I’ve been on TV and I’m not an extrovert but I’m but extroverted than DH who has a brother. The care for DH’s parents will also fall to us because DH’s brother is a selfish arse. DH’s experience with a sibling is a major driving factor in why he doesn’t want another child and wants DD to be an only.

PollyIndia · 15/05/2023 16:16

I don't think there is either... maybe depends where you live - definitely isn't in London. DS is 10 - I agree with PP who said 3 is peak second child age gap territory so probably feels more of an issue at that age. DS has never wanted siblings - they'd mess up his lego - and we are so close. It would definitely be different if I had more children. The main downside is when I get old and decrepit and it just being him, but there's no guarantee of siblings getting on well enough to split that job equally, and I know of lots of situations where it all falls on one person to care for their parent.

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:14

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 15/05/2023 16:10

I don't think there is a stigma. I never judge about child number choices; actually I lie, I judge people (specifically men) who have more children than they can provide for, financially or emotionally. I know plenty of people who have one very happy, well adjusted, sociable child.

Why men more than women out of interest?

skippy67 · 15/05/2023 16:11

PollyPeptide · 15/05/2023 15:52

I think people are only giving their (unwanted) opinion because you've brought up your decision. Other than that I don't think people are bothered one way or another. I've never heard people express any sort of condemnation about one child families.

Exactly this. 3 of my close friends have decided they only want one child. It's the least interesting thing about them.

mrlistersgelfbride · 15/05/2023 16:11

@CountMushroom Is right, I'm in the north west and I get it too. I used to get defensive, get upset and everything in between.
But now it amuses me and I do my best to make the asker uncomfortable :

"Thanks for volunteering to be my night nanny!"
"I like kids, but I couldn't eat a whole one"
"You have to have sex to get pregnant last time I checked" (best said to nosey colleagues 😂)

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 15/05/2023 16:10

I don't think there is a stigma. I never judge about child number choices; actually I lie, I judge people (specifically men) who have more children than they can provide for, financially or emotionally. I know plenty of people who have one very happy, well adjusted, sociable child.

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:10

CadburyDream · 15/05/2023 16:00

Exactly. I have 4 and avoid mentioning usually on here as people are very rude about it. Much more than only children.

God, yes, hell hath no fury like MN posters towards women with 3+ children. Don’t you care that the planet is burning and it’s all your fault?? 😉 (but it’s fine for them to have their 2 of course, rather than 1 or none)

evuscha · 15/05/2023 16:10

People just love to judge and have an opinion! You get comments when you have an only. You get comments when you have more than 2-3. I don’t understand how that is anyone’s business. I once got yelled at by an elderly aunt of a friend that “you have to have a second one or this one will be spoiled rotten”…wtf why?

I spent a long time thinking we would be one and done - traumatic pregnancy, in the end we are going for the second one - but we’re also in a privileged position where we can do that. Many can’t have more than one kid, infertility, finances etc - just how painful is it having these comments thrown in your face all the time when you’re already struggling? Don’t people realize that?

(obviously not having another one by choice is totally fine too…there are pros and cons to both having/not having siblings and there’s absolutely no study suggesting that the only kids are more miserable)

Mutabiliss · 15/05/2023 16:08

BashfulClam · 15/05/2023 15:55

My husband is an only child, he has social phobia and is really shy. I have a sibling and I’m better at being outgoing, I’ve even been on tv lol.

the main thing is now everything widowed MIL need falls on DH and it’s really stressful. She doesn’t drive and has slight reading and writing difficulties and is a natural worrier. As I have a sibling we can share any issues with my mother and have two heads to put together. If I can’t get to her or my brother can’t, hopefully the other will be free. DH was I’ll from stress during lockdown because of mil but she is a manipulative old bag too.

I'm an only child and am not shy, no social anxiety. I am an introvert - as are both of my parents - but it really annoys me when people assume introverts are socially anxious. I love being around my friends, I just need time alone to recharge afterwards!

One of the most outgoing people I know is an only child. She's life and soul of the party, has always done jobs that involve networking, conferences, socialising and schmoozing, was on TV a bit in her youth (not sure what this has to do with anything) and currently travels constantly for work (i.e. travel and meeting new people is her job).

Being an only child does not create a personality type.

I also see no problem with being the only person needing to deal with elderly parents. It usually seems to fall to just one sibling anyway. It's easier, I reckon - no-one to disagree with or expect more from, you just get on with it yourself (or not).

CountMushroom · 15/05/2023 16:07

Climbles · 15/05/2023 15:51

People just make small talk about babies and children. Are you having another? Wouldn’t you want a girl? Etc it’s not personal and I doubt anyone, other than maybe grandparents, actually care about how many kids you have.

They may not care, but they’re certainly quite free with their opinions. Not everyone, or everywhere — I never got it in London, or the city I live in now, but during my seven years in a village in the Midlands (which was admittedly the most insular, conformist place I’ve ever lived), a significant number of neighbours, friends of friends, people at parties and other parents at the village school could not get their heads around having one child by choice, and I was treated to all the classics:

‘You can’t only have one child!’

’That’s so selfish!’

’Oh, the lonely only!’

Swipe left for the next trending thread