Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there is still such a stigma on only children?

193 replies

BettyBoopBetty · 15/05/2023 15:47

DC is 3 and will most likely stay an only. For a mix of reasons really but mainly we both don’t particularly desire another one and the financial burden for full time childcare x2 (London) is something we are not willing to compromise on again. We’d have much more time, energy and resources to dedicate to our DC this way and we are very loving and involved parents. Still, when I tell people about our choice, they often judge and can’t wait to start telling us stories of how unhappy X’s childhood was as an only, how nice it is to have siblings etc etc.
I know some people who didn’t particularly want a second but did it anyway to give number 1 a sibling - I think it’s nuts!
If you have an only, have you found that people in general tend to judge you for it?

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 17/05/2023 16:25

If you have an only, have you found that people in general tend to judge you for it?

No, not at all.

I only read about only child stigma on mumsnet, which says a lot about the parents on here.

CountMushroom · 17/05/2023 16:17

TheaBrandt · 17/05/2023 15:54

Very rude response! I say again no one actually is particularly interested people do spout cliches about family size mainly just for something to say and sensitive new parents take the inane comments to heart.

But what you said is demonstrably nonsense. You’re still saying it.

Saying ‘Have you only the one?’ or ‘Do you plan to have more?’ could be ‘spouting clichés about family size’, if the interlocutor is unimaginative and has run out of clichés about the weather.

Telling someone they’re selfish, or exclaiming that they simply can’t just have a lonely only, it’s not fair on the child, and what will they do when you’re old/dead, or trotting out some stereotype about only children being spoilt and unable to share, isn’t, by any stretch of the imagination, ‘making conversation’. Unless you have the social skills of a Neanderthal.

And I’ve never been remotely sensitive about my decision, only bemused at some people’s rudeness or weirdness.

TheaBrandt · 17/05/2023 15:54

Very rude response! I say again no one actually is particularly interested people do spout cliches about family size mainly just for something to say and sensitive new parents take the inane comments to heart.

CountMushroom · 17/05/2023 15:54

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 17/05/2023 15:48

Is there a stigma? I've not noticed.

Lots of people I know, myself included, have just the 1 child.

Never heard anything disparaging towards it.

In my experience, it’s heavily geographically-dependent. As I said up the thread, of the three places I’ve lived longterm since having my (only) DS, I never had the slightest comment in London or the city in which we live now. About 95% of the negative comments I’ve ever had were from the seven years we lived in a large village where people seemed deeply suspicious of deviations from their ‘norm’.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 17/05/2023 15:51

I have one due to secondary infertility. I felt very judged when dd was little. Lots of people told us that we were selfish not to "give" her a sibling. Others warned that we were making a rod for our own backs. That she would grow up unable to share or lacking in social skills etc. That she would be isolated and lonely. I was quite honestly astonished at how freely people felt that they could share their views and it made me really worry for dd's future.

I haven't heard any of those comments for years. The fact is, dd is not the sad, selfish loner that those people predicted - quite the contrary, in fact. She is very confident, exceptionally thoughtful and generous, and absolutely fabulous at connecting with other people and making friends. Far more so, as it happens, than many of her friends with siblings.

Just ignore the prejudice. It will not be relevant after the first few years in the slightest because your dc will be judged for who they actually are rather than for the stupid fucking stereotypes.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 17/05/2023 15:48

Is there a stigma? I've not noticed.

Lots of people I know, myself included, have just the 1 child.

Never heard anything disparaging towards it.

spiderlight · 17/05/2023 15:44

I hate comments like this. My teen DS is an only because I have long-term health problems, was very seriously ill twice in the years after having him, spent a long time looking after my dad when he was very ill, and then lost baby no. 2 in a very traumatic miscarriage (which admittedly not very many people know about), which caused a massive flare-up of my autoimmune condition. I feel horrendously guilty about it because I was a very lonely only and hated it, but I have always gone out of my way to encourage his friends to come round, take friends on days out etc., and he's old enough to understand now that a lot of the things he's had in his relatively privileged upbringing would not have been possible if we'd had more than one. He has never really expressed much desire for a sibling, bar the occasional throwaway comment when he was very young.

CountMushroom · 17/05/2023 15:40

TheaBrandt · 17/05/2023 15:04

Honestly? No one cares. Bar possibly granny. Any comments are made to make conversation.

Nonsense. When I ‘make conversation’, I talk about the weather or something, I don’t say ‘A lonely only? You can’t only have one — that’s really selfish?
!’

Retrain12345 · 17/05/2023 15:40

It doesn’t matter how many you have someone will comment about something. I had an only for 5 years. He would be lonely, shy, when I’m dead he will have nobody.

I then had 2. That was the perfect number, one of each. How lucky I was.

Then DC3. Did I not own a TV. The world is burning and ive contributed etc etc etc.

I just nod and move on now!

luckylavender · 17/05/2023 15:21

I think prejudice against only children is real. I'm an only & am also the mother & daughter of an only. People are very judgemental.

skyeisthelimit · 17/05/2023 15:19

DD is an only child. When she was a baby, people would comment on it, but I pointed out that I had horrendous SPD, a horrendous back to back birth, was 36 years old and my consultant advised me not to have any more. Then XH walked out just after DD turned 4. It usually shuts people up.

DD now 15, would have loved a sister growing up, but she had a good friend who lived across the road, and they spent a huge amount of time together and I took her on holiday with us etc. She had a great childhood playing with all the kids in our road, riding their bikes, paddling pools etc. I made sure that she was never lonely. We spent our holidays in caravan parks when she was younger so that there were other children around her and she loved it and always made a friend.

As a teen she chooses to spend time with me, watching tv and playing on the switch etc and not closeted in her room on her mobile texting friends.

(For transparency DD does have a half-sibling 7 years younger however she didn't see them that often growing up and now she sees maybe once a year, but as much as she would love to spend more time with them, its out of her hands).

TheaBrandt · 17/05/2023 15:04

Honestly? No one cares. Bar possibly granny. Any comments are made to make conversation.

Mutabiliss · 17/05/2023 15:01

spaghettimaretti · 17/05/2023 13:06

One drawback about being an only can be if you as an adult go on to have multiple DC. I’m my case, both of my parents are only children but had a big family themselves.

They have been amazing, devoted, loving parents to all of us (and our own families) and we all adore them both BUT they are not the best at dealing with disagreements between their children as adults. Sadly there have been a fair few of those in the last few years.

To be honest this one of many reasons why I decided to stick at one. I grew up in such a quiet, calm house as an only child, the thought of having the constant noise and stress of bickering children (as I have experienced as a child when visiting friends and as an adult when visiting friends with multiple small children) fills me with horror.

My partner constantly fought with his brother and hated it too, so neither of us wanted to experience that.

spaghettimaretti · 17/05/2023 13:06

One drawback about being an only can be if you as an adult go on to have multiple DC. I’m my case, both of my parents are only children but had a big family themselves.

They have been amazing, devoted, loving parents to all of us (and our own families) and we all adore them both BUT they are not the best at dealing with disagreements between their children as adults. Sadly there have been a fair few of those in the last few years.

Poopoolittlekitten · 17/05/2023 12:58

You do you. Siblings are great but if you want one have one.

70sDuvet · 17/05/2023 12:57

My DS is now 10. Rude People still ask why on earth is he an only child when he is such a good child and we are good parents (this is the lead up to the rude question)

I then go into long detailed facts about my gynaecological history, other (ir)relavant medical details and DS's unseen medical history.

They never ask again.😎

DS does go through stages where he would love to be a big brother- but I've told him as well there's no more babies coming to this house. And 3 is our magic number.

SchoolShenanigans · 17/05/2023 09:59

I don't think acknowledging that there are cons is judging you. I personally don't think having an only child is a big deal, but then I've never been one.

I've known a few only children, one hated it, the other wasn't bothered. Obviously these pros and cons will change over life.

It's ok for people to acknowledge negatives about any lifestyle, as long as they aren't rude with it. Providing all of your positives doesn't negate the negatives, that do exist (as with any choice there's always pros and cons).

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 17/05/2023 09:47

*Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:14
Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 15/05/2023 16:10

I don't think there is a stigma. I never judge about child number choices; actually I lie, I judge people (specifically men) who have more children than they can provide for, financially or emotionally. I know plenty of people who have one very happy, well adjusted, sociable child.

Why men more than women out of interest?

I would never judge a single mum (or dad) with full or majority pr who is struggling to make ends meet. Its a fact of life though that single women with children are the ones most likely to live in poverty. Behind many single parents struggling alone there is an absent father living his best life, being Disney Dad every other weekend.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 16/05/2023 14:29

CountMushroom · 15/05/2023 16:18

I certainly never volunteered any information about my offspring — people specifically asked me, and then emoted about it!

I was told my parents were selfish not making me an only child and that they had ruined my life. The judgmental old bag* who told me went very quiet when I told her my Dad was told he may have to decide between his wife or child when I was born.

*I'm not apologising for being ageist, I knew the woman and it's quite a polite description!

PleaseJustText · 16/05/2023 14:29

I've never seen having an only child treated like a stigma. Plenty of people make small talk about children but very few actually care about the answer. It's just another thing to say and part of getting to know someone and their life.

There are very few times I judge people who tell me about their children. It's usually when they brag about having them but don't actually support them financially or see them.

BotterMon · 16/05/2023 14:02

There isn't a stigma. If people want to judge, that's on them.

BettyBoopBetty · 16/05/2023 13:59

@cobbledstone but I don’t quite fully get this. Surely once you are an adult, your partner, potential DC and chosen group of friendships will also play a massive role in this, not just the siblings? Infact I dare saying that most adult people I know find their comfort in the families they have chosen, not their siblings - many of which don’t even get along that much.

OP posts:
Muddygreenfingers · 15/05/2023 23:40

People will have different opinions on this because they mostly base them on their own experiences of childhood, or of those around them. Everyone's experiences of childhood is massively different, so many factors involved.

if people choose to ask questions or openly 'judge' you for having one child, they are either:

A) making conversation (like using weather to start small talk, like so many do)

Or

B) are aresholes and can't seem to understand that others might have different opinions/experiences to them.

Therefore, you really don't need to worry about it. Nobody really cares that much, and if they do, that speaks more about them than you.

Do what makes you happy.

StarDolphins · 15/05/2023 22:37

Where I live, I’m not children are common. Nearly half the kids in ur 3 are only children. No one even ever asks me about only having 1 & in my group of 6 friends (I’m the oldest) only 2 have more than 1 child.

Colourmylifewith · 15/05/2023 22:37

My DC is an only, he is sociable and has this amazing ability to make friends wherever he goes, he just has a way of contacting with others which seems way beyond his years. Conversely he appreciates his ‘down time’ and loves being able to come home to his peaceful home, where he adores being centre of attention. I feel he has the best of both worlds and it has only ever been a positive in his life x