Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there is still such a stigma on only children?

193 replies

BettyBoopBetty · 15/05/2023 15:47

DC is 3 and will most likely stay an only. For a mix of reasons really but mainly we both don’t particularly desire another one and the financial burden for full time childcare x2 (London) is something we are not willing to compromise on again. We’d have much more time, energy and resources to dedicate to our DC this way and we are very loving and involved parents. Still, when I tell people about our choice, they often judge and can’t wait to start telling us stories of how unhappy X’s childhood was as an only, how nice it is to have siblings etc etc.
I know some people who didn’t particularly want a second but did it anyway to give number 1 a sibling - I think it’s nuts!
If you have an only, have you found that people in general tend to judge you for it?

OP posts:
user1471556818 · 19/05/2023 15:44

My ds aged 28 is an only child as is his wife
They look likely to only be having 1 child
Interestingly both mothers have told them our regret in them being only the child
They both feel never missed out as had close friends and cousins and have reaped the benefits of being only children with financial support and inheritances coming to them
So do what feels right for youb

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/05/2023 15:28

gannett · 19/05/2023 15:20

There isn't a stigma against only children. MN is literally the first and only place I have ever encountered strong opinions about only children being destined for miserable, lonely lives and that parents should "give" them siblings. None of the only children I know IRL have particularly strong feelings about it!

But MN is to some extent a proxy for normal life, it’s not a parallel universe. There are four or five posters on this thread alone who have expressed the view that it’s cruel not to provide children with siblings.

So there must be people hiding in plain sight who privately think having an only child is “sad” but have the sense to know what bigoted idiots they look like.

NewNovember · 19/05/2023 15:22

mrlistersgelfbride · 15/05/2023 16:05

I'm very grateful for this thread today. I have an only child of 5 and a half. She's sweet, sociable, confident and bright with lots of friends. We have money to spend on her hobbies and have nice holidays. I'm also able to keep my job and do my hobby and get some sleep, without feeling totally frazzled. My partner is a bit selfish, we definitely aren't equals in raising her and my parents aren't interested in helping either.

After years of struggling I think I have the balance right now. The only thing I have a problem with is people's unwanted opinions, which I've had a range of responses for over the years! Now, I just don't care! 💚

I'm happy, DD is happy, we have a good life. Her friends are welcome, I'm a bit like a big kid myself and happy to do playdates and be sociable with other mums when I can.

I'm not willing to roll the dice for no good reason just to give her a sibling. I do feel twinges of sadness when I hear about people's 2nd pregnancies, but I know it's not the right life for us.
We are getting on with our precious lives 😊

You are not like a kid though you are a parent It's no substitute for a sibling, very odd thing to say.

gannett · 19/05/2023 15:20

There isn't a stigma against only children. MN is literally the first and only place I have ever encountered strong opinions about only children being destined for miserable, lonely lives and that parents should "give" them siblings. None of the only children I know IRL have particularly strong feelings about it!

Whichnumbers · 19/05/2023 15:17

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 15:14

I've heard this too. Weirdly, it was said to me by a woman who had very sadly lost her only child, with the clear implication that I needed to produce a "spare" just in case. As if a parent with other children wouldn't be every bit as devastated by the loss of a child.

Sadly, tragedy hits in various ways and I know a few people who have lost multiple children. Nothing comes with any guarantees.

Should we do the same with spouses just incase? 🙄 you can’t replace a child with a spare
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-south-scotland-65424579

how many D.C. should you have “ just in case” 🤦‍♀️

Mavis Paterson

Grandmother cycling 1,000 miles in memory of her three children

The challenge will help Mavis Paterson cope with losing all three of her children in four years.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-south-scotland-65424579

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 15:14

IAmTheWalrus85 · 19/05/2023 15:09

The worst I have had was someone at the school gates ask, ‘what would you do if your only died?’ To this, I was flabbergasted for a moment but then said, ‘I think I would respond in the same way as you would if one of your DC died, heaven forbid!’

I’ve heard this said before and of all the comments about having an only child that people make, I find this one the most bizarre.

It’s not as if a parent of three children would shrug and say ‘not to worry, we’ve got two others’ if one died is it?!

I've heard this too. Weirdly, it was said to me by a woman who had very sadly lost her only child, with the clear implication that I needed to produce a "spare" just in case. As if a parent with other children wouldn't be every bit as devastated by the loss of a child.

Sadly, tragedy hits in various ways and I know a few people who have lost multiple children. Nothing comes with any guarantees.

Whichnumbers · 19/05/2023 15:14

bookworm14 · 19/05/2023 10:52

But that is bloody stigma!

It’s ignorant regardless

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/05/2023 15:13

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves

And I think people who make stupid comments like yours are insensitive twats who have no care for how much pain they might be causing for others who might not actually have any control over the size of their families. We are all entitled to our opinions, I suppose.

Hear hear, except I would disagree with you about these people being entitled to their opinions. The right to an opinion requires at baseline the capacity for a bit of critical thinking and common decency. These posters have neither and therefore they would do everyone a favour by keeping their opinions to themselves.

I find the people pretending to pity (but actually judging) others for what is quite often an accident of biology breathtakingly ignorant and offensive.

You are quite correct that there is no credible evidence whatsoever of a link between being an only child and feeling lonely or sad. There are posts from only children who were lonely or sad and posts from lonelies who loved it. To my knowledge no one has ever done a long-term study on the connection between being an only child and therefore its pure prejudice that only children are sad.

It's just simple-minded people lashing out at anyone and anything they consider not to be normative and pathetic one-upmanship dressed up as concern.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 19/05/2023 15:09

Amore2023 · 15/05/2023 16:26

I don’t think there is such a stigma attached to it so much anymore. But we have encountered a few. My DM was a bit worried that we would regret our decision to stop at one and did put some of our DD’s behavioural traits down to being an only child but this was genuine concern.

The worst I have had was someone at the school gates ask, ‘what would you do if your only died?’ To this, I was flabbergasted for a moment but then said, ‘I think I would respond in the same way as you would if one of your DC died, heaven forbid!’

This comment was pretty bad but I think these are individual extremes. It really depends if you are ‘one and done’ by choice, circumstances not to do with infertility or due to infertility problems and how you feel as a couple and family that counts. Also, I have learnt not to let other people’s received ideas affect me too much. There was one woman who was kind of implying I wasn’t as much of a mother as her as she had three, I just kind of ignore it and say ‘it works for us!’ It’s hard to deal with these kinds of judgemental comments but it says more about the other person than you in a way. Smile, hold your head up and be proud…and get on with your life.

The worst I have had was someone at the school gates ask, ‘what would you do if your only died?’ To this, I was flabbergasted for a moment but then said, ‘I think I would respond in the same way as you would if one of your DC died, heaven forbid!’

I’ve heard this said before and of all the comments about having an only child that people make, I find this one the most bizarre.

It’s not as if a parent of three children would shrug and say ‘not to worry, we’ve got two others’ if one died is it?!

momtoboys · 19/05/2023 14:43

I do not think that there is anything wrong with a single. I have a niece who was my brothers only child. I will admit to being one of those crazy people that had a second primarily because I didn't want my son to grow up without a sibling. I ended up having four more! Now you can call me crazy!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 14:42

DameKatyDenisesClagnuts · 19/05/2023 14:40

My 10.5 yo DD is an only. Never felt that there's any stigma. Kindly, it sounds like you might be feeling rather defensive

Do you not think that some of the comments on this thread are reflective of a stigma?

E.g. only children are sad, only children are to be pitied, you shouldn't be prepared to have children at all if you aren't prepared to "give" them a sibling.

DameKatyDenisesClagnuts · 19/05/2023 14:40

My 10.5 yo DD is an only. Never felt that there's any stigma. Kindly, it sounds like you might be feeling rather defensive

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 14:34

Dixiechickonhols · 19/05/2023 14:32

She may very well not be alone she may have a husband or wife or long term partner.
My husband is one of 3 siblings but only he will sort MIL’s estate in all likelihood aided by me who has known MIL over 30 years (one sibling disabled, one lives long way away and keeps self to self)
Friend (one of 3 siblings) has just dealt with full burden of her parent’s death, I don’t think it’s unusual that it often falls to one.
Mines an only and I honestly don’t give it thought.

Yes, that's very true. My DH does much more for my ageing parents than my sister does!

Dixiechickonhols · 19/05/2023 14:32

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 14:25

Yes, exactly.

I don't really worry that my dd will feel the lack of a sibling when it comes to sorting stuff out for me and DH when we're older, precisely because she has seen first hand that having a sibling - in my case, an older sister - is absolutely zero guarantee that you'll get help with it in any case. The care for my elderly parents (and indeed another elderly relative) falls exclusively to me.

DH and I will do as much preparation as we can to ease the burden on her, but I don't worry about her having to deal with it alone. She might have had to do that anyway.

She may very well not be alone she may have a husband or wife or long term partner.
My husband is one of 3 siblings but only he will sort MIL’s estate in all likelihood aided by me who has known MIL over 30 years (one sibling disabled, one lives long way away and keeps self to self)
Friend (one of 3 siblings) has just dealt with full burden of her parent’s death, I don’t think it’s unusual that it often falls to one.
Mines an only and I honestly don’t give it thought.

Cherrypossum · 19/05/2023 14:29

There are estimated to be around 3.45 million two-children families in the United Kingdom as of 2021, with a further 3.46 million one child families, and 1.24 million families that have three or more children.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 14:25

NeedToChangeName · 19/05/2023 14:16

@BashfulClam I think that can go either way

I've known only children who were grateful they could bash on with what they thought was best for their parents, without siblings having to be involved

And I've known people with siblings who had to do it on their own, and resented their siblings for not stepping up and helping

Yes, exactly.

I don't really worry that my dd will feel the lack of a sibling when it comes to sorting stuff out for me and DH when we're older, precisely because she has seen first hand that having a sibling - in my case, an older sister - is absolutely zero guarantee that you'll get help with it in any case. The care for my elderly parents (and indeed another elderly relative) falls exclusively to me.

DH and I will do as much preparation as we can to ease the burden on her, but I don't worry about her having to deal with it alone. She might have had to do that anyway.

bookworm14 · 19/05/2023 14:23

Hear hear, MrsBennetspoornerves. Of course it’s going to touch a nerve when someone claims your perfectly normal family set-up is ‘sad’. They can never give any valid reason why it’s ‘sad’, of course.

NeedToChangeName · 19/05/2023 14:16

BashfulClam · 15/05/2023 15:55

My husband is an only child, he has social phobia and is really shy. I have a sibling and I’m better at being outgoing, I’ve even been on tv lol.

the main thing is now everything widowed MIL need falls on DH and it’s really stressful. She doesn’t drive and has slight reading and writing difficulties and is a natural worrier. As I have a sibling we can share any issues with my mother and have two heads to put together. If I can’t get to her or my brother can’t, hopefully the other will be free. DH was I’ll from stress during lockdown because of mil but she is a manipulative old bag too.

@BashfulClam I think that can go either way

I've known only children who were grateful they could bash on with what they thought was best for their parents, without siblings having to be involved

And I've known people with siblings who had to do it on their own, and resented their siblings for not stepping up and helping

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 14:13

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/05/2023 12:40

@usererror99

It's not a choice i would have made for my child personally - I think if you are prepared to bring one child into the world then you should be prepared to have a sibling

Can you explain the rationale for this statement please?

I genuinely can't understand this argument that there is an obligation to either have multiple children or not bother.

You can't understand it because it's just illogical fuckwittery that has no basis in anything.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 14:12

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 19/05/2023 12:45

I only think it bothers you if it hits a nerve.
I think being an only is sad, I think having 3 kids is insanity. If someone with 3 children looks at me and thinks 2 isn’t enough, it doesn’t bother me in the slightest.

And I think people who make stupid comments like yours are insensitive twats who have no care for how much pain they might be causing for others who might not actually have any control over the size of their families. We are all entitled to our opinions, I suppose.

And yes, it does hit a nerve for me because I wasted years worrying about this issue for absolutely no reason because of crass, ignorant people like you telling me that my child is "sad" because I miscarried her only sibling. I now understand that there was no need for me to worry in the slightest because the stereotypes are all nonsense and my dd is happy and thriving without siblings. I am totally at peace with the fact that I wasn't able to have a second child because it has worked out brilliantly for us and I would plan it that way now if I had my time over. However, I didn't always feel like that, and I'm acutely aware that parents who are still in that very painful phase of coming to terms with the fact that they might not be able to have any more children - for whatever reason - will not necessarily recognise this bullshit for what it is, and they will suffer more because of it.

So much of the sadness that I felt during those early days was the direct result of stupid comments from random strangers and not because of any actual negative impact on my child from being an only child....because there hasn't actually been any negative impact. And no thanks, I have no need to find fault with your perfect two-child family but I do absolutely take issue with your thoughtless and insensitive comments. And all of the others on this thread. Do you really want to make people who may have already struggled with multiple miscarriages and/or with health issues that mean they can't have another child feel even worse about this than they already do?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 19/05/2023 12:45

I only think it bothers you if it hits a nerve.
I think being an only is sad, I think having 3 kids is insanity. If someone with 3 children looks at me and thinks 2 isn’t enough, it doesn’t bother me in the slightest.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/05/2023 12:40

@usererror99

It's not a choice i would have made for my child personally - I think if you are prepared to bring one child into the world then you should be prepared to have a sibling

Can you explain the rationale for this statement please?

I genuinely can't understand this argument that there is an obligation to either have multiple children or not bother.

cpphelp · 19/05/2023 12:26

@Wenfy, did you see in my post that my children are 11 MONTHS apart? My 4yr old is definitely not supervising my twin 3yr olds.

Not sure how your experience is similar to mine to be honest

Peppadog · 19/05/2023 12:18

Wenfy · 19/05/2023 11:23

My mum had lots of kids too. It was usually me (from about age 7) who was responsible for all the kids when we were in the pool. Including my 1 year old brother. One thing parents with lots of children don’t realise is that if you’re not also wealthy it’s your eldest child who ends up doing the parenting with none of the recognition.

Well I have multiple DC and my eldest never parents the younger ones, but that's the stigma always thrown at larger families.
And even if I we offer to do things apart they usually prefer to do things together.

CountMushroom · 19/05/2023 12:16

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/05/2023 10:49

I don't think there is a stigma as such but I do think some people perceive it as a bit selfish and perhaps feel pity for the only. Rightly or wrongly.

I think you might want to look up the definition of ‘stigma’.