Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there is still such a stigma on only children?

193 replies

BettyBoopBetty · 15/05/2023 15:47

DC is 3 and will most likely stay an only. For a mix of reasons really but mainly we both don’t particularly desire another one and the financial burden for full time childcare x2 (London) is something we are not willing to compromise on again. We’d have much more time, energy and resources to dedicate to our DC this way and we are very loving and involved parents. Still, when I tell people about our choice, they often judge and can’t wait to start telling us stories of how unhappy X’s childhood was as an only, how nice it is to have siblings etc etc.
I know some people who didn’t particularly want a second but did it anyway to give number 1 a sibling - I think it’s nuts!
If you have an only, have you found that people in general tend to judge you for it?

OP posts:
Shadyladyo · 21/05/2023 11:58

No, never felt judged but then I’m in London and about 40% of my daughter’s class are onlies.

Dontcallmescarface · 21/05/2023 11:55

What else could possibly replace the joy of those deep family bonds?

The only thing me and my siblings have in common were our parents. We all had different interests and hobbies. I have a much closer bond with my friend of 50 years than I will ever have with my siblings.

littleburn · 21/05/2023 11:52

Also I think the trope of a 'lonely childhood' doesn't hold true today, with the amount of after-school activities kids typically do. My 'only' DS does breakfast/after-school club twice a week, sport two nights a week and swimming, cubs and more sports at the weekend. He's always surrounded by other kids, they're just not related to him!

Thinking about it, parents I know with more than one kid spend most of their free time ferrying the children to their separate activities. I don't see much evidence of siblings spending huge amounts of time playing together. It's mostly just sitting down to eat dinner!

littleburn · 21/05/2023 11:44

I have only one and never received a negative comment on it. Some people do know I went through two miscarriages trying to conceive #2 so would know better than to say anything, but fortunately I've never encountered anyone who's felt the need to quiz me about it.

mumonherphone · 21/05/2023 11:40

I have an 'only' child, although I never describe him as this I just say I have one child/a son. In his case I'm hoping he won't feel resentful or lonely as he has three cousins close in age who are always at family gatherings, two on dh's side and one on mine. We see at least one cousin most weekends.

I feel there is a stigma as on TV programmes only children are referenced to as weird or being unable to share etc.. and I'm particularly sensitive to picking up on these references as the mother of an only child. So this line of thinking definitely exists. In real life nobody has said anything like that to my face though. (And my child is very happy to share his toys!)

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/05/2023 11:26

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/05/2023 11:10

The logic in this post is absurd. You seem to take as read a) that families with multiple children will automatically be closer to their cousins and extended families and b) that families are the only opportunities for big gatherings and get togethers. There’s no evidence whatsoever for either of these claims. They are just your prejudice.

I am not an only child, I have three siblings and am not close to any of them but I am a very social animal and have a number of close friends and a huge extended network, none of which is connected to my family at all.

I don’t understand the mindset that only families can provide these networks. A lot of people have built networks and friendships explicitly to get away from over reliance on their families.

I agree. I assume that the people who believe this must have struggled to make close friends. It makes no sense otherwise.

funinthesun19 · 21/05/2023 11:23

Alright as a child, shit as an adult.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/05/2023 11:10

Kpo58 · 20/05/2023 12:18

Why do so many people think that only children will have close relationships with cousins? It's more and more likely that they either won't have cousins or an extended family or know them as they live too far away.

Being an only myself, I always wished that I could have had a close relationship with my extended family, but I only ever got to see them at Christmas. So whilst they have lots of fun family gatherings with each other, I'm never invited. It is very lonely knowing that others get to go exciting things and you are always excluded from those events.

The logic in this post is absurd. You seem to take as read a) that families with multiple children will automatically be closer to their cousins and extended families and b) that families are the only opportunities for big gatherings and get togethers. There’s no evidence whatsoever for either of these claims. They are just your prejudice.

I am not an only child, I have three siblings and am not close to any of them but I am a very social animal and have a number of close friends and a huge extended network, none of which is connected to my family at all.

I don’t understand the mindset that only families can provide these networks. A lot of people have built networks and friendships explicitly to get away from over reliance on their families.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/05/2023 10:59

ChocChipHandbag · 21/05/2023 10:22

"What else could possibly replace the joy of those deep family bonds?"

If I had to choose between never seeing my brother again and never seeing my husband again, it would be "see ya Bro".

And I get on really well with my brother, see him regularly and love him to bits. But he's absolutely not the most important "bond" in my life.

My relationship with my son is the most I important bond in my life. Husband next. Two lifelong best friends whom I see most weeks.

Then my brother after all of them.

I agree. I get on well with my dsis. We played together as children and have quite a lot in common with her as an adult. I love her, but it certainly isn't the most important bond in my life by any measure.

It's lovely when siblings are close but there are no guarantees of that. Some siblings bring joy to each other's lives, others bring pain and others make little difference in either direction. You can't predict how things are going to pan out.

My dd always says that she doesn't miss having siblings because you don't miss what you've never had. She has plenty of very close bonds in her life, including people who she has known for as long as she can remember. Honestly, her quality of life is way better than mine was at her age because of the quality and range of her close relationships...she simply has better social skills than I had and more confidence in building and developing those bonds.

ChocChipHandbag · 21/05/2023 10:22

"What else could possibly replace the joy of those deep family bonds?"

If I had to choose between never seeing my brother again and never seeing my husband again, it would be "see ya Bro".

And I get on really well with my brother, see him regularly and love him to bits. But he's absolutely not the most important "bond" in my life.

My relationship with my son is the most I important bond in my life. Husband next. Two lifelong best friends whom I see most weeks.

Then my brother after all of them.

CountMushroom · 21/05/2023 10:02

UWhatNow · 20/05/2023 23:54

“I had three, the third very much a surprise. I wouldn’t change that but I can see how having one might have given him a better quality of life, particularly in the longer term.”

I had 3 but oddly the thought of any one of them being an only makes me so sad. It most definitely wouldn’t be a ‘better quality of life’ because their sibling relationships are so valuable and will only improve in the longer term imo. Especially when they start having families. They’re already planning Christmases and holidays together with their respective partners and children! What else could possibly replace the joy of those deep family bonds?

Well, that’s a good example of the kind of thing people say, actually. I personally think it verges on the delusional. No one can predict the strength of their children’s sibling bonds in adulthood. My siblings and I are civil, but not at all close.

UWhatNow · 20/05/2023 23:54

“I had three, the third very much a surprise. I wouldn’t change that but I can see how having one might have given him a better quality of life, particularly in the longer term.”

I had 3 but oddly the thought of any one of them being an only makes me so sad. It most definitely wouldn’t be a ‘better quality of life’ because their sibling relationships are so valuable and will only improve in the longer term imo. Especially when they start having families. They’re already planning Christmases and holidays together with their respective partners and children! What else could possibly replace the joy of those deep family bonds?

Changechangechanging · 20/05/2023 13:38

I was an only child and never had an issue with it growing up. I think all of the only children amongst my peers in school are all people who are very much comfortable with being alone and doing things alone, including travel. I recognise I had financial advantages, particularly as my parents were very much working class and managed to fund me through uni and then a masters and they left me everything they had which has been helpful.

The only time I had an issue with it was when illness set in - dementia in my mum’s case (my dad had been dead 10 years at that point) and the putting her in a home and having no one to help with it, the guilt, the justifications. Of course, having a sibling might have made no difference anyway. No way of knowing.

I teach in an independent. Of a class of 24 I have in year 7, I would say at least half are only children. It certainly makes you think. I had three, the third very much a surprise. I wouldn’t change that but I can see how having one might have given him a better quality of life, particularly in the longer term.

Dontcallmescarface · 20/05/2023 13:12

Kpo58 · 20/05/2023 12:18

Why do so many people think that only children will have close relationships with cousins? It's more and more likely that they either won't have cousins or an extended family or know them as they live too far away.

Being an only myself, I always wished that I could have had a close relationship with my extended family, but I only ever got to see them at Christmas. So whilst they have lots of fun family gatherings with each other, I'm never invited. It is very lonely knowing that others get to go exciting things and you are always excluded from those events.

DD grew up living literally a 2 minute walk away from her cousins. Now adults, DD and 1 of her cousins who were particularly close growing up, now visit each other regularly. I have, to the best of my recollection, 26 cousins (both of my parents were from larger families), and I honestly couldn't pick any of them out in a line-up of 1.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 20/05/2023 12:40

Kpo58 · 20/05/2023 12:18

Why do so many people think that only children will have close relationships with cousins? It's more and more likely that they either won't have cousins or an extended family or know them as they live too far away.

Being an only myself, I always wished that I could have had a close relationship with my extended family, but I only ever got to see them at Christmas. So whilst they have lots of fun family gatherings with each other, I'm never invited. It is very lonely knowing that others get to go exciting things and you are always excluded from those events.

Maybe because some only children do have close relationships with their cousins?

My dd is extremely close to one cousin, who is the same age as her and also an only child. I have no doubt that their relationship will endure throughout their lives, and that they will have many shared memories from their childhood.

She is also quite close to her other cousins (she has many!) though she sees them less due to distance.

ChocChipHandbag · 20/05/2023 12:40

Kpo58 · 20/05/2023 12:18

Why do so many people think that only children will have close relationships with cousins? It's more and more likely that they either won't have cousins or an extended family or know them as they live too far away.

Being an only myself, I always wished that I could have had a close relationship with my extended family, but I only ever got to see them at Christmas. So whilst they have lots of fun family gatherings with each other, I'm never invited. It is very lonely knowing that others get to go exciting things and you are always excluded from those events.

Also @Kpo58 do you mean you are not invited to family things because you never gut to know the cousins well enough as a child, or that they don't invite you because you live far away?

I wasn't close to my cousins as a child (I only have two as my Dad was an only), they are older and lived hundreds of miles away.

However I made an effort to get to know them as an adult and they now welcome me, DH and DS into family occasions. Communication, sharing pics etc is easier these days, as is travel when you are an adult.

ChocChipHandbag · 20/05/2023 12:35

Kpo58 · 20/05/2023 12:18

Why do so many people think that only children will have close relationships with cousins? It's more and more likely that they either won't have cousins or an extended family or know them as they live too far away.

Being an only myself, I always wished that I could have had a close relationship with my extended family, but I only ever got to see them at Christmas. So whilst they have lots of fun family gatherings with each other, I'm never invited. It is very lonely knowing that others get to go exciting things and you are always excluded from those events.

Sorry, I don't follow why it's more likely that an only child will have fewer cousins, or live far away from extended family. What's the causal link there?

Is it that you think that only children are more likely to have parents who were themselves only children?

Or that people who move far from where they grew up are more likely to have only children?

On the other hand, if an only child happens to live near similar- aged cousins, and the parents get on, it's quite likely that the cousins will play together and do things together a lot as the only child won't have a ready-made playmate at home.

We're off on holiday next week with DH's sister and her kids. The cousins are a few years older than DS, and both girls, but they (and we) all enjoy spending time together.

Kpo58 · 20/05/2023 12:18

Why do so many people think that only children will have close relationships with cousins? It's more and more likely that they either won't have cousins or an extended family or know them as they live too far away.

Being an only myself, I always wished that I could have had a close relationship with my extended family, but I only ever got to see them at Christmas. So whilst they have lots of fun family gatherings with each other, I'm never invited. It is very lonely knowing that others get to go exciting things and you are always excluded from those events.

Lollzi86 · 20/05/2023 12:11

Imagine what you get when you say you don’t want any 😂. I’ve always said I didn’t want children, got the ‘oh your young you’ll change your mind etc’ I’m now late 30s still haven’t changed my darn mind! Also it’s soooo rude to ask why you only have one/don’t have any, people can have fertility issues on a second baby/health problems etc. Nosey Parker’s x

RedRosette2023 · 20/05/2023 08:12

Only children or big gaps between children (4-5 years) are common in my friendship group. It’s usually finances and then I think they get past the baby stage and don’t want to go back to the baby stage. I have two
in nursery and the fees are eye watering. I took the view of getting it out the way - I didn’t want to go back to the baby stage and wanted them to be close enough to have similar interests. But I am fortunate in that our financial circumstances allowed us to write off my earnings to childcare for the 2-3 years.

I think most people understand the desire only to have one.

kikisparks · 20/05/2023 08:08

I haven’t faced any stigma for having an only child yet (but DD is only 18 months) but DH got told at work he “has to have two” so they can play together, and that two is less work. I can say for sure that more laundry, bedding to wash, bedrooms to clean, dishes to wash, food to prepare, when older clubs to ferry to, mental load etc etc would be more work for me, I’d rather play with DD, even though DH can be relatively good I do more of the domestic load.

I often think the attitude of “you must have two” is not a feminist one. Why should a woman go through pregnancy and childbirth, loss of earnings and pension contributions on mat leave, a possible negative affect on her career, and in most cases take on more domestic responsibility, if she doesn’t want to? Surely in this day and age women can choose the family size they want (subject to fertility) whether that’s zero children, one child or four children.

I am actually infertile and needed IVF and now I have been so lucky to have DD I will not go through it again. I also have endometriosis and taking hormonal contraception that stops my period keeps me from enduring agonising pain so there will be no accidents even in the highly unlikely scenario that I could conceive naturally.

I absolutely adore DD, she is the best thing ever and I will do everything in my power to give her a happy, fulfilled childhood without a sibling, but I finally feel I have my body and life back after years of TTC (and endo pain), then injections and TV scans and surgery and early pregnancy loss and endless heartache, then pregnancy and sickness and breathlessness and heart palpitations and dizziness and debilitating anxiety, then traumatic and agonising birth, then months of post natal physical and mental healing. I feel I have my life back and now I get to live it and enjoy finally being a mum.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/05/2023 16:26

user1471556818 · 19/05/2023 15:44

My ds aged 28 is an only child as is his wife
They look likely to only be having 1 child
Interestingly both mothers have told them our regret in them being only the child
They both feel never missed out as had close friends and cousins and have reaped the benefits of being only children with financial support and inheritances coming to them
So do what feels right for youb

Interesting. Nice that they feel that way.

Does this make you and your son's MIL feel better, or do you still feel guilty?

Or is your regret less about the effect on your son and more that you would have enjoyed being Mum to another child?

thecatsthecats · 19/05/2023 16:14

Try being a youngest child! So much BS sprouted about spoiled behaviour.

In my case, I was a well behaved child, who got zero attention because the older ones all had problems, and in spite of being a good kid, I had to live with the strict rules invented due to the behaviour of my hooligan siblings.

Anon6842 · 19/05/2023 16:12

I have an only child, and yes I have definitely felt a stigma attached. I work hard at my child not falling into the only child stereotype.

In an ideal world I would’ve liked another but for many reasons we decided against it.

So much emphasis is put on the importance of sibling relationships, and how they will support one another once parents have passed. But this is not a guarantee. My sibling ruined my life in the most unimaginable way. Then they died.
admittedly my circumstances were extreme, but my experience definitely shaped my view on having more than one child.

Now I’m generally pretty happy with our decision to stick with one, not least because they’re an expensive little bugger!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/05/2023 15:51

NewNovember · 19/05/2023 15:22

You are not like a kid though you are a parent It's no substitute for a sibling, very odd thing to say.

It isn't necessary to substitute for a sibling though. No substitutes required!