Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I actually have ADHD after all?

396 replies

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 10:37

I was diagnosed with ADHD last year at a private clinic after getting nowhere with the NHS. I did a fair bit of research and went to a named psychiatrist who specialises in treating ADHD and went in with an open mind not necessarily expecting a diagnosis.

Somewhat to my surprise I was diagnosed very quickly (I'd filled in lots of very lengthy forms before my assessment and off the back of that was told I was a clear cut case), and strongly encouraged to try medication (I haven't yet).

It's taken a bit of courage to tell family and friends - some have been supportive, some a bit sceptical ("but you seem completely normal?" "yeah I've seen all those TikTok videos too").

I still struggle a bit accepting the diagnosis and am prone to beating myself up about it (it's not ADHD, I'm just lazy, don't try hard enough, etc...).

Then I've seen this BBC news report today about the "ADHD private diagnosis scandal" suggesting people are being diagnosed by private clinics who don't actually have ADHD.

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation - BBC News

Have I just been taken in by all the TikTok nonsense (even though I don't use TikTok) and exploited by an industry trying to sell me expensive drugs?

Or do I have a genuine neurological condition that's being called into question by journalists looking to turn everything into a some kind of scandal?

I don't honestly know what to think any more.

Hand holding a bottle of pills

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation

An undercover journalist for Panorama is diagnosed and given drugs without proper checks.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534448

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
manontroppo · 15/05/2023 16:51

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 16:47

This is interesting as it seems to be received wisdom amongst the online ADHD support groups I watch that the stimulant medication won't help you unless you actually have ADHD. Almost that this provides proof your ADHD is genuine.

The ADHD groups are wrong - Ritalin/Concerta are stimulants that work on anyone (and there is plenty of evidence to show that).

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 16:47

ChevreChase · 15/05/2023 11:31

On Today, towards the end, they spoke with someone whose name I forget, but that he is the longest serving NHS psychiatrist working in ADHD. He said that the medicines used will cognitively enhance performance in anyone taking them, regardless of the diagnosis not being correct.

This is interesting as it seems to be received wisdom amongst the online ADHD support groups I watch that the stimulant medication won't help you unless you actually have ADHD. Almost that this provides proof your ADHD is genuine.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 16:38

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 16:20

But in the current situation that could leave children struggling without effective support for years with waiting lists what they are.

What would make more sense is some agreement of what a private provider needs to have done in diagnosing. Some Local Authorities for example will accept a private ASD diagnosis if a proper ADOS assessment has been done. It could be that an ADHD assessment MUST have been done by a psychiatrist and MUST include elements that the NHS requires.

SOME local authorities won't refer any children through schools now. (Friend is a teacher in a neighbouring council area). But SOME will. SOME won't refer kids performing at expected standards even if they are clearly under achieving.

DS is being treated differently to a child who could live 2 miles down the road. Its been made very clear to me and looking through the difference system in each council area from MN posters this is really obvious.

How the fuck is that right?

And that's NOW. Nevermind 30 years ago.

It's already a postcode lottery just with schools.

GPs are no different.

We know that there are massive inconsistency over other types of referral in the NHS already too.

DoIReallyNeedToNC · 15/05/2023 16:33

I recommend reading any book by Russel Barkley..if what he says applies to you then you probably do have ADHD.

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 16:32

plasticpens · 15/05/2023 16:22

What would make more sense is some agreement of what a private provider needs to have done in diagnosing. Some Local Authorities for example will accept a private ASD diagnosis if a proper ADOS assessment has been done. It could be that an ADHD assessment MUST have been done by a psychiatrist and MUST include elements that the NHS requires.

I thought that's what DSM V or ICD 11 did?

The reports seem to be suggesting that some of the private diagnoses are being made by under-qualified medical professionals and with a less thorough assessment. I presume this can still lead to a statement that the DSM criteria have been met, but with less confidence in that judgement. It doesn’t necessarily mean they are wrong either, but there becomes room for doubt on the basis of process.

I feel awful for those who are now doubting their diagnosis. But seriously, pharmacists doing ADHD assessments?

Robinni · 15/05/2023 16:32

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:08

Outwardly you wouldn't think I had any issues, decent career, dh and dc, nice home etc but privately I am a mess. Depressed, shockingly bad executive functioning, almost no emotional regulation, anxiety, panic attacks... the list goes on.

I do object to this ‘NT people can’t possibly know what it’s like to be depressed/antisocial/to struggle’.

There is a real undercurrent on threads like this that NT people breeze through everything, are social butterflies, and have a much higher tolerance for life’s difficulties. It’s not true at all and is quite unkind.

@Garethkeenansstapler

You’re sort of missing the point.

For NT people who get depressed, therapy, medication, intervention etc very often improves circumstances. Because they are designed for NT people. The foundation of these people if you can imagine is made of bricks; they have a lot to build upon in that their basic functionality is recoverable, because it was there in the first place.

For ND they attend the appointments, take the drugs, do it all…. And largely it doesn’t work because we are fundamentally wired differently. The foundation is sand.

I’m talking like people who have a top programmer job, but have difficulty with organising how they brush their teeth.

Manage to paint beautiful pictures, but cannot cook a meal.

Have postgraduate degrees, but cannot drive a car or manage to dress themselves half the week.

Elaborate mirages are created to cover all of these deficits up, so they can fit into society and not endure social exclusion or ridicule. But it is hugely exhausting.

A NT person who is depressed will not largely hide it from the world, a ND person could be on the verge of suicide but have just aced an exam or done an excellent presentation, run a marathon. In fact this is the time they will be at their most vulnerable.

The fact is NT people are substantially more likely to have good mental and physical health and they are less likely to suffer physical and sexual assault and premature death. Statistically NT do have it better and that inequality needs to be addressed.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 15/05/2023 16:30

RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 16:19

One of my friends has a history of mental health problems. She has been hospitalised at one point.

She's waiting for an asd assessment on the NHS.

But talking to her, it doesn't sound like ASD. I suggested she look at the symptoms for ADHD in women.

She said she's ticking ALL the boxes for adhd but not ASD. So she's going to talk about it with her GP. It's never been suggested before.

She looked up the medications she's had previously. She's tried loads with no joy. The only one that's had any positive effect was one she's since found is sometimes used for ADHD. She had no idea about this previous to my suggestion. It's an unusual medication for depression.

We also know that there has been a high level of misdiagnosis of ASD for ADHD particularly in women!

I just can't help but think that the BBC are coming at this subject from the wrong angle.

There is a clear problem which is hitting women particularly badly. And it's women who are most likely to be negatively impacted by private misdiagnosis. And the stigma from now having an 'unreliable' private diagnosis. And be put off trying to get a private or NHS diagnosis.

I'm really quite upset and don't think it's responsible journalism on the basis of what the BBC news article has put out. There's too many ommisions which are crucial here to understanding whats going on in full.

Maybe the programme will cover these but I'm not hopeful.

Great post.

It's also available to watch on iplayer now, but I'm currently (being unproductive) at work so will watch later

DoIReallyNeedToNC · 15/05/2023 16:28

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 11:06

It should all be the same threshold. DSM-V diagnostic criteria for ADHD in adults is very clear.

They aren't clear at all. This is why it takes any psychiatrist (NHS or private) a couple of hours at least of talking about your symptoms and history in detail. Most people fit the symptoms in the list sometimes. The point is to figure out how often is outside the normal range and how much the impact of the symptoms is outside the normal range. You need to look at the big picture.

Of course this means there is also a lot of subjectivity. The first NHS psychiatrist I saw said that because I had a degree, was (still just about) employed, had a roof over my head and was (still just about) in a long term relationship it couldn't be ADHD. I was then diagnosed privately. Like the op I didn't trust my diagnosis but then the second NHS psychiatrist I saw said it was very clearly ADHD. All subsequent NHS psychiatrists have confirmed this (in my trust the consultant seems to change every six months so I have seen a lot of different ones) but their knowledge and interest in this subject definitely varies.

Op, what are your options. I assume you have tried the usual advice: working harder, trying to be more disciplined and having more will power. Has it worked? If not is there anything else you can try that you haven't already?

(Also, things that might genuinely help: eating and sleeping well, exercise, ruling out other disorders, nutrient deficiencies, etx)

I still doubt my diagnosis every day but without meds I am wasting my life. I have tried for decades to "try harder" and I just couldn't. I can neither work nor do anything meaningful in my leisure time so I've decided that even if I am just lazy, crazy and stupid if the meds are the only things that help me not to be lazy, crazy and stupid then I will take them.

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 16:28

DizzyRascal · 15/05/2023 16:18

Right. So, if ADHD is affecting your life to the extent that you can't actually cope, a diagnosis and meds/life coach would probably be helpful. But I come accross people in increasing numbers who are not experiencing those difficulties in any meaningful way but still want the label.
I was diagnosed (ADD) many years ago, but never medicated, and not 100% convinced my issues were not actually trauma related, so I do completely understand the obstacles of the symptoms. I also understand that, as someone who has an OK career (yes after many detours..) and can behave professionally at work, sort my direct debits out (after much procrastination) It would be dishonest to call myself disabled.
I knew what I said would be met with howls of "ableist!" but that is so far from the truth. In fact it's the opposite; rather than being discriminatory toward people with disabilities I am trying to protect them by pointing out that ADHD and Autism are conditions that can make some people's lives really difficult. Every third person claiming a label diminishes those struggles, and makes it less likely that they will get the help and support they deserve.

I don’t consider myself disabled by my ADHD either, and have been criticised because of that. It doesn’t mean I don’t think others are. I have family members whose ADHD causes them to function extremely poorly.

I am also not medicated although I hope to see whether I can find something that helps. But in general I get on by. I certainly have never for one moment considered applying for any benefit on the back of this.

My diagnosis has led to self-acceptance and a far better understanding of my strengths and weaknesses. It’s so valuable to me. I can say without doubt that had I been diagnosed earlier, I would have had a happier and better life. I have come off a treadmill of mental health treatment because I now understand that my symptoms have been those of cyclical burn out and RSD. So although I am not disabled by ADHD, I cope with life an awful lot better now than I used to.

RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 16:27

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:13

It is very typical for women to have a diagnosis of social anxiety or bipolar for it later to become apparent that its ADHD.

I’m not saying this in a goady way at all, but I wonder if it’s actually the other way round - literally every diagnosis now is ASD/ADHD. In fact I can’t remember the last time I saw somebody diagnosed with anything else, in terms of behavioural difficulties or problems coping with day to day life.

I worry the spectrum of symptoms is now so wide virtually anybody who isn’t very NT appearing can fit a diagnosis, and therefore it’s becoming a bit meaningless. Perhaps breaking them down into several conditions would be better and more specific.

This is what the specialists leading explorations into the gap between male / female diagnostic patterns are saying.

These are some of the most respected individuals in the NHS - not private practice.

I suspect there is over diagnosis privately. But I think this points to abject failings within the NHS rather than pure failure privately.

As I say upthread, there are clear issues with female diagnosis because all the criteria is based on male presentation. There's reams and teams written on this.

Why? Ask the question. Why?

Don't say that can't be right without having a clue. Ask why it could be.

plasticpens · 15/05/2023 16:22

What would make more sense is some agreement of what a private provider needs to have done in diagnosing. Some Local Authorities for example will accept a private ASD diagnosis if a proper ADOS assessment has been done. It could be that an ADHD assessment MUST have been done by a psychiatrist and MUST include elements that the NHS requires.

I thought that's what DSM V or ICD 11 did?

DeadSea95 · 15/05/2023 16:22

Neededanewuserhandle · 15/05/2023 15:30

Do you mind me asking what you do? I have had a series of unsatisfactory (but reasonably paid) jobs. I crashed out of Uni due to the low contact hours and always struggle where this occurs.
I was diagnosed with ADHD 3 years ago at age 58 by paying for a private consultation but never completed the drug titration.

Despite having no formal financial education (haven't studied maths since I was 15) I got into banking.

Started in a call centre / admin role at the end of 2017 and worked my way up into pure theory / decision making roles. I worked really long hours, did a lot of overtime and changed projects frequently.

I was fortunate that since I was so obsessive I performed and interviewed well the majority of the time.

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 16:20

Somanycats · 15/05/2023 16:16

And this quite frankly is why nhs trusts and education often refuse to accept a private diagnosis for ADHD and autism spectrum. It has long been known that many private clinics will over diagnose. A private diagnosis just cannot be allowed to trigger an NHS or educational provision.

But in the current situation that could leave children struggling without effective support for years with waiting lists what they are.

What would make more sense is some agreement of what a private provider needs to have done in diagnosing. Some Local Authorities for example will accept a private ASD diagnosis if a proper ADOS assessment has been done. It could be that an ADHD assessment MUST have been done by a psychiatrist and MUST include elements that the NHS requires.

User98866 · 15/05/2023 16:20

This panorama doesn’t surprise me at all. A whole lot of money to be made, people will act unscrupulously. I have a friend who works for a new company who’s purpose is to edit and check reports for private clinics. They are churned out by the bucket load and often don’t even have the correct named on them. They are certainly not detailed assessments.

As for the drugs, I fear they’ve become the new ‘mothers little helper’. There will eventually be a big blow up of this scandal. We are a drug dependent nation who want a pill to fix literally every ill, inconvenient emotion and behaviour.

RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 16:19

One of my friends has a history of mental health problems. She has been hospitalised at one point.

She's waiting for an asd assessment on the NHS.

But talking to her, it doesn't sound like ASD. I suggested she look at the symptoms for ADHD in women.

She said she's ticking ALL the boxes for adhd but not ASD. So she's going to talk about it with her GP. It's never been suggested before.

She looked up the medications she's had previously. She's tried loads with no joy. The only one that's had any positive effect was one she's since found is sometimes used for ADHD. She had no idea about this previous to my suggestion. It's an unusual medication for depression.

We also know that there has been a high level of misdiagnosis of ASD for ADHD particularly in women!

I just can't help but think that the BBC are coming at this subject from the wrong angle.

There is a clear problem which is hitting women particularly badly. And it's women who are most likely to be negatively impacted by private misdiagnosis. And the stigma from now having an 'unreliable' private diagnosis. And be put off trying to get a private or NHS diagnosis.

I'm really quite upset and don't think it's responsible journalism on the basis of what the BBC news article has put out. There's too many ommisions which are crucial here to understanding whats going on in full.

Maybe the programme will cover these but I'm not hopeful.

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:19

DizzyRascal · 15/05/2023 16:18

Right. So, if ADHD is affecting your life to the extent that you can't actually cope, a diagnosis and meds/life coach would probably be helpful. But I come accross people in increasing numbers who are not experiencing those difficulties in any meaningful way but still want the label.
I was diagnosed (ADD) many years ago, but never medicated, and not 100% convinced my issues were not actually trauma related, so I do completely understand the obstacles of the symptoms. I also understand that, as someone who has an OK career (yes after many detours..) and can behave professionally at work, sort my direct debits out (after much procrastination) It would be dishonest to call myself disabled.
I knew what I said would be met with howls of "ableist!" but that is so far from the truth. In fact it's the opposite; rather than being discriminatory toward people with disabilities I am trying to protect them by pointing out that ADHD and Autism are conditions that can make some people's lives really difficult. Every third person claiming a label diminishes those struggles, and makes it less likely that they will get the help and support they deserve.

I agree completely Toothbrush.

DizzyRascal · 15/05/2023 16:18

RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 15:06

So, if you are capable of doing well at school, and holding down a decent job, and getting the bills paid (even if a bit late or it stresses you) then even if you DO have ADHD, why does it matter so much?

I did well at school but I COULDN'T hold down a decent job and I struggle with the life admin of remembering passwords. I have had multiple mental health breakdowns. With no satifactory explanation or reason. And THAT is the point.

On the surface, people will say I'm capable. In practice I'm not.

The stigma and all the people saying its not really an issue ARE part of the problem imho.

And I am willing to bet that those who have an actual diagnosis on this thread will understand that sentiment...

Right. So, if ADHD is affecting your life to the extent that you can't actually cope, a diagnosis and meds/life coach would probably be helpful. But I come accross people in increasing numbers who are not experiencing those difficulties in any meaningful way but still want the label.
I was diagnosed (ADD) many years ago, but never medicated, and not 100% convinced my issues were not actually trauma related, so I do completely understand the obstacles of the symptoms. I also understand that, as someone who has an OK career (yes after many detours..) and can behave professionally at work, sort my direct debits out (after much procrastination) It would be dishonest to call myself disabled.
I knew what I said would be met with howls of "ableist!" but that is so far from the truth. In fact it's the opposite; rather than being discriminatory toward people with disabilities I am trying to protect them by pointing out that ADHD and Autism are conditions that can make some people's lives really difficult. Every third person claiming a label diminishes those struggles, and makes it less likely that they will get the help and support they deserve.

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 16:17

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:08

Outwardly you wouldn't think I had any issues, decent career, dh and dc, nice home etc but privately I am a mess. Depressed, shockingly bad executive functioning, almost no emotional regulation, anxiety, panic attacks... the list goes on.

I do object to this ‘NT people can’t possibly know what it’s like to be depressed/antisocial/to struggle’.

There is a real undercurrent on threads like this that NT people breeze through everything, are social butterflies, and have a much higher tolerance for life’s difficulties. It’s not true at all and is quite unkind.

I do agree, actually, that some posters can be very dismissive of people who are not neurodiverse. Life can be really challenging for anyone, and neurodiversity is one of those challenges but by no means the only one. There shouldn’t be a competition over who has the worst of it. We all need compassion for each other.

Having said that, there is context to the post you quote, and others on this thread, which is that they are written in response to the challenge that people with ADHD who have succeeded on some measures of what might be considered life achievements don’t have any problems. I read them (and wrote my own) as genuine attempts to explain what is going on under the surface.

Somanycats · 15/05/2023 16:16

And this quite frankly is why nhs trusts and education often refuse to accept a private diagnosis for ADHD and autism spectrum. It has long been known that many private clinics will over diagnose. A private diagnosis just cannot be allowed to trigger an NHS or educational provision.

plasticpens · 15/05/2023 16:14

I worry the spectrum of symptoms is now so wide

It's the diagnostic criteria that matter, not 'symptoms' -

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:13

It is very typical for women to have a diagnosis of social anxiety or bipolar for it later to become apparent that its ADHD.

I’m not saying this in a goady way at all, but I wonder if it’s actually the other way round - literally every diagnosis now is ASD/ADHD. In fact I can’t remember the last time I saw somebody diagnosed with anything else, in terms of behavioural difficulties or problems coping with day to day life.

I worry the spectrum of symptoms is now so wide virtually anybody who isn’t very NT appearing can fit a diagnosis, and therefore it’s becoming a bit meaningless. Perhaps breaking them down into several conditions would be better and more specific.

LostMyUserName · 15/05/2023 16:13

NotAnotherBathBomb · 15/05/2023 12:40

My biggest regret is not seeking an assessment when I had my ‘lightbulb moment’ after stumbling across an article on MN 5 years ago. I would have been assessed through the NHS much quicker, and not have the whole ‘it’s just TikTok’ argument thrown at me as I’d have a more ‘believeable’ diagnosis.

Due to my procrastination in seeking it (ha!) waiting lists in my area had quadrupled by the time I reached my breaking point and got myself in gear to request it from the GP. I then gave in and sought a private diagnosis after 6 months because I was struggling so much in a new job.

I’m still in the titration process, it’s been nearly 6 months of trying different medication and weekly reports. I’m not made of money and it isn’t cheap, so the idea that ‘everyone thinks they have ADHD now’ is so insulting to me.

@NotAnotherBathBomb I can relate to beating myself up about not doing things straight away rather than put them off but I don’t seem to learn from this and do things differently. I frustrate myself. I know if I had someone to keep me on track or hold me accountable it would help.

My son is autistic and when we went through his diagnosis, I learned so much about neurodiversity to support him and found myself identifying with some aspects. It took me several years to pluck up the courage to speak to my GP and when he asked me to tell him why I thought that I clammed up and never went back. Own worst enemy springs to mind.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 15/05/2023 16:10

@Nn9011 pls can you recommend them to me? I'm interested (and addicted to TikTok, but mostly real estate that I can't afford 😂)

RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 16:09

Why should we pathologise???

Well if we were talking about something else, it would be a scandal if women were being misdiagnosed for decades.

The impact of late diagnosis IS increased problems with comorbid issues such as anxiety, depression and eating disorders. It can therefore potentially be fatal in rare cases.

It is very typical for women to have a diagnosis of social anxiety or bipolar for it later to become apparent that its ADHD. And they will ALREADY have had years of various medications which haven't worked and perhaps have had side effects as a result of misdiagnosis.

The article talks about people getting unnecessary medication - but doesn't talk about whether they were on other medication previously or getting medication for the first time. This is perhaps relevant for context purposes.

Being on the wrong medication because of misdiagnosis and inability to access an assessment through the NHS FOR YEARS, is no less of a scandal than overdiagnosis and medication of ADHD.

People don't fork out hundreds of pounds on a diagnosis on the basis that they saw something on social media. There has to be something fundamentally 'wrong' in their life thats having a significant impact to their daily lives, to go through the process.

This bloke rocking up with a few thousand pounds without thought, isn't reflective of the real world.

If you are going down the private route, chances are there is a sense of getting desparate for appropriate support for SOMETHING.

Also the BBC article is based on the example of one male getting misdiagnosed privately. It doesn't talk about who is seeking diagnosis by private assessment. If there is a heavy basis to a certain demographic - for example adult women are particularly over represented in seeking a private diagnosis there may be other issues at play. For example we know that the autism diagnositic tools favour diagnosis of boys because girls present differently and the science is only just begining to catch up on that. It could be that the NHS is behind the curve on diagnosis in girls / women and the criteria they are using is no longer fit for purpose and not matching what we know about ADHD in women.

I am curious as to whether the programme touches on this at all. In using a male for the programme, I also worry whether the effect of the programme will further disportionally affect women who were much more likely to be underdiagnosed in the first place.

Garethkeenansstapler · 15/05/2023 16:08

Outwardly you wouldn't think I had any issues, decent career, dh and dc, nice home etc but privately I am a mess. Depressed, shockingly bad executive functioning, almost no emotional regulation, anxiety, panic attacks... the list goes on.

I do object to this ‘NT people can’t possibly know what it’s like to be depressed/antisocial/to struggle’.

There is a real undercurrent on threads like this that NT people breeze through everything, are social butterflies, and have a much higher tolerance for life’s difficulties. It’s not true at all and is quite unkind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread