Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I actually have ADHD after all?

396 replies

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 10:37

I was diagnosed with ADHD last year at a private clinic after getting nowhere with the NHS. I did a fair bit of research and went to a named psychiatrist who specialises in treating ADHD and went in with an open mind not necessarily expecting a diagnosis.

Somewhat to my surprise I was diagnosed very quickly (I'd filled in lots of very lengthy forms before my assessment and off the back of that was told I was a clear cut case), and strongly encouraged to try medication (I haven't yet).

It's taken a bit of courage to tell family and friends - some have been supportive, some a bit sceptical ("but you seem completely normal?" "yeah I've seen all those TikTok videos too").

I still struggle a bit accepting the diagnosis and am prone to beating myself up about it (it's not ADHD, I'm just lazy, don't try hard enough, etc...).

Then I've seen this BBC news report today about the "ADHD private diagnosis scandal" suggesting people are being diagnosed by private clinics who don't actually have ADHD.

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation - BBC News

Have I just been taken in by all the TikTok nonsense (even though I don't use TikTok) and exploited by an industry trying to sell me expensive drugs?

Or do I have a genuine neurological condition that's being called into question by journalists looking to turn everything into a some kind of scandal?

I don't honestly know what to think any more.

Hand holding a bottle of pills

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation

An undercover journalist for Panorama is diagnosed and given drugs without proper checks.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534448

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Neededanewuserhandle · 15/05/2023 19:29

DeadSea95 · 15/05/2023 16:22

Despite having no formal financial education (haven't studied maths since I was 15) I got into banking.

Started in a call centre / admin role at the end of 2017 and worked my way up into pure theory / decision making roles. I worked really long hours, did a lot of overtime and changed projects frequently.

I was fortunate that since I was so obsessive I performed and interviewed well the majority of the time.

Thank you - I appreciate the answer.

LimitIsUp · 15/05/2023 19:25

@manontroppo Care to dismiss this too:
Ritalin Poses Cognitive Risks to Those Without ADHD (pharmacytimes.com)

From that article:
"Findings from a new study published by the Journal of Neural Transmission suggest that the use of Ritalin without a prescription can alter brain chemistry. These changes can affect risk-taking behavior, sleep disruption, and elicit other side effects.
"Although Ritalin's effectiveness in treating ADHD is well-documented, few studies have looked at the drug's effect on non-prescribed illicit use," said researcher Panayotis Thanos, PhD. "We wanted to explore the effects of this stimulant drug on the brain, behavior and development on non-ADHD subjects."

So both the pharmacy times link and the previous link from the blog that I cited come from a scholarly article published in the Journal of Neural Transmission

Ritalin Poses Cognitive Risks to Those Without ADHD

Female rats observed to be especially susceptible to methylphenidate-related behavioral changes.

https://www.pharmacytimes.com/view/ritalin-poses-cognitive-risks-to-those-without-adhd

manontroppo · 15/05/2023 19:14

LimitIsUp · 15/05/2023 17:44

Yes taking Ritalin without ADHD might temporarily increase focus and some students pay for it to pull all nighters BUT if you didn't have ADHD and took Ritalin on an ongoing basis the side effects described in this article would soon make themselves felt www.seasidepalmbeach.com/addiction-blog/what-does-ritalin-do-to-a-person-without-adhd/

That blog is nonsense. Not only does it talk about the effects of Ritalin in rats, it makes no basis for the supposed effects of Ritalin in NT people nor does it say that those effects are not present in ND rats taking Ritalin.

Honestly, this kind of psedo bullshit is half the problem!

Pinkprescription · 15/05/2023 18:43

@Tuatara22 unlike you I may not have been sacked from jobs but I’ve been on many a performance plan as I can’t do admin at all. I forget half the things I am supposed to do even with lists. I can’t get going on things unless I’m under extreme time pressure. I’m some respects it’s good I have a high pressure job.
periodically I break down as I can’t live under such enormous pressure all the time.
As for emotional regulation and behaviour, mine was extreme at school. I would easily have been picked out by a SENCO etc.
Getting to the point I’m at now where I’m medicated and some of my struggle is understood and I can access help /assistance has been a painful and difficult time. Let alone realising that my life would have been very different had s received a diagnosis 10,20,30 or even 40 years ago.
we really don’t need more stigma and skepticism.

Falt · 15/05/2023 18:42

Also worth noting about the "must be present in childhood" part of the diagnosis that up until very recently (and even still nowadays) we socialise girls to do what they're told, not make a fuss, care about what others think of us etc. So it can already be more difficult for a girl / woman to evidence it (or even recognise it) in their own childhood when their reports say they were bright, or relatives say they were "a little ditzy". I definitely fall into that category but I was practically managed by my grandmother who did most of the caring (highly suspect it's because my mum had undiagnosed adhd btw). I sort of coasted along and always labelled very smart purely because I love learned new things and have a shit hot memory for facts and information. But I could never have remembered I had PE and needed my kit despite it happening the same time every week without help. As a teen my impulsively was more about fixating on a new boy every week, changing my hair colour monthly, rearranging my bedroom, going on day trips in random boys cars to the other end of the country "for a laugh". Nothing that was seriously affecting my life.

For loads of girls / women it's only when they grow up, move out, have their own children etc that "the Virgin bill needs paying on the 5th and the youngests school lunches need to be selected by Tuesday night" becomes too much. Impulsivity is maxing out your credit cards because you were watching a show on Netflix and liked the look of their living room. Ending perfectly good relationships for no logical reason etc. That's when it comes debilitating.

Fwiw I've been on and off medication for years and I wouldn't put my child on them either, despite hers being every bit as bad as mine was growing up. But that's just me. They can be a lifeline for adults who need to hold down a job or face homelessness, who're in debt, whose house is falling apart etc but I just don't see the same risk/ benefit analysis in children.

Tuatara22 · 15/05/2023 18:24

*personal beliefs.

Also wanted to add that without my meds, I cannot function properly. I really need them, because without them 'm spacy and fatigued and make constant mistakes. I've been sacked from 5 jobs over the years, when I was unmedicated. Medicated, I'm excellent at my job. I really worry that this investigation is going to create more of a stigma and skepticism around ADHD diagnoses when women with ADHD already struggle so much to have the condition recognised and treated.

Tuatara22 · 15/05/2023 18:16

Hmm. Just keep in mind that ADHD diagnoses aren't foolproof no matter where they come from. It's not like the NHS is doing brain scans or blood tests to spot it and the private clinics aren't. A diagnosis based on one person's opinion and assessment and that obviously is subjective. To be honest, the whole DSM that the diagnosis is based on is not fit for purpose and is decided by a committee of doctors influenced by lobbyists, personality beliefs and fads but that's what we have to work with. Not to mention it's woefully outdated and years behind the latest research. ADHD diagnostic criteria is still based on the behavioral problems of little boys.

I have ADHD, diagnosed in my home country twice and again in privately in the UK. I went through Psychiatry UK and the assessment process was more thorough than the assessments in the BBC investigation.

User98866 · 15/05/2023 18:06

ImPrawnCrackers · 15/05/2023 17:54

Well it's basically speed! A friend of mine at uni took speed to get her through her law degree. She was able to focus, got a lot of our housework done too! I wouldn't give it to a kid though (unless absolutely 100% his/her only option, which it rarely is...) Sorry sounding judgy, I just think this stuff is given out way too much, especially in the US

It’s bloody scary that it’s being normalised. Ritalin can be very addictive too.

LimitIsUp · 15/05/2023 17:59

Yes I know @ImPrawnCrackers, I was just pointing out that for those diagnosed privately who it is suggested may have been misdiagnosed, their reaction to their medication would soon expose that their diagnosis was unsound

ImPrawnCrackers · 15/05/2023 17:56

Nn9011 · 15/05/2023 17:09

This isn't true at all. In order to get an ADHD diagnosis, the symptoms have to be present in childhood. Therefore you do have to ask family to get involved and they are asked their perception of how you were as a child and that is strongly taken into consideration. If there was no impact in childhood then it is not ADHD it's like trauma or something causing similar symptoms. It's not just a self report.

But it's still just the report of the other people too. There's nothing objective in an ADHD diagnosis, just one or two people giving their opinion. And most mental health diagnoses don't even have to rely on anyone's report except the patients..

ImPrawnCrackers · 15/05/2023 17:54

LimitIsUp · 15/05/2023 17:44

Yes taking Ritalin without ADHD might temporarily increase focus and some students pay for it to pull all nighters BUT if you didn't have ADHD and took Ritalin on an ongoing basis the side effects described in this article would soon make themselves felt www.seasidepalmbeach.com/addiction-blog/what-does-ritalin-do-to-a-person-without-adhd/

Well it's basically speed! A friend of mine at uni took speed to get her through her law degree. She was able to focus, got a lot of our housework done too! I wouldn't give it to a kid though (unless absolutely 100% his/her only option, which it rarely is...) Sorry sounding judgy, I just think this stuff is given out way too much, especially in the US

arethereanyleftatall · 15/05/2023 17:51

Yes but @Falt, my point about businesses saying what you want to hear, isn't the money they've got for your session, you're right they'd get that regardless, it's the fact that the diagnosed person then goes on to tell everyone 'dr Smith was brilliant, he understood us perfectly.'

I remember a (very rich) mum at the school gates got through about 10 private doctors trying to get her son diagnosed with adhd, and the first 9 who didn't diagnose it were 'useless' and the last one, who did, was 'fabulous'. So it's the advertising, as anyone else who wanted their dc diagnosed, went straight to no 10.

LimitIsUp · 15/05/2023 17:44

Yes taking Ritalin without ADHD might temporarily increase focus and some students pay for it to pull all nighters BUT if you didn't have ADHD and took Ritalin on an ongoing basis the side effects described in this article would soon make themselves felt www.seasidepalmbeach.com/addiction-blog/what-does-ritalin-do-to-a-person-without-adhd/

Righthandman · 15/05/2023 17:42

Robinni · 15/05/2023 16:32

@Garethkeenansstapler

You’re sort of missing the point.

For NT people who get depressed, therapy, medication, intervention etc very often improves circumstances. Because they are designed for NT people. The foundation of these people if you can imagine is made of bricks; they have a lot to build upon in that their basic functionality is recoverable, because it was there in the first place.

For ND they attend the appointments, take the drugs, do it all…. And largely it doesn’t work because we are fundamentally wired differently. The foundation is sand.

I’m talking like people who have a top programmer job, but have difficulty with organising how they brush their teeth.

Manage to paint beautiful pictures, but cannot cook a meal.

Have postgraduate degrees, but cannot drive a car or manage to dress themselves half the week.

Elaborate mirages are created to cover all of these deficits up, so they can fit into society and not endure social exclusion or ridicule. But it is hugely exhausting.

A NT person who is depressed will not largely hide it from the world, a ND person could be on the verge of suicide but have just aced an exam or done an excellent presentation, run a marathon. In fact this is the time they will be at their most vulnerable.

The fact is NT people are substantially more likely to have good mental and physical health and they are less likely to suffer physical and sexual assault and premature death. Statistically NT do have it better and that inequality needs to be addressed.

@Robinni I would broadly agree with this summary - therapies are designed and work for NT people and ND people are sometimes so good at masking that even the psychiatrist they are asking for help will miss how serious their problems are.

But then I hesitate a little bit thinking about how many ‘hidden’ ND people there are- all the undiagnosed women for example. And all the highly academic doctors and psychiatrists who devised these therapies who may well have been ND and, especially historically, may well have been unaware of it in themselves. And I wonder how in that climate we societally came up with therapies that are so good for NT people and so largely unhelpful for ND people.

I’m not disputing your point, I think it is largely borne out in real life. But I’m interested in your thoughts on how on earth it happened that way!

DeadSea95 · 15/05/2023 17:34

Mangogogogo · 15/05/2023 17:20

I had a diagnosis of bipolar which went into remission and I’m now completely medication free (and actually feeling way better from it) that was an nhs diagnosis. I then had private therapy who went on to say it was probably ADHD and the bipolar was misdiagnosed. Then I began private assessment for adhd but sacked the whole lot off. It felt like they were messing with my head a lot tbh. It was awful. I see the symptoms and me and family laugh like ‘probs the adhd lol’ but I don’t ‘identify’ as having either now tbh. I can also see a scandal coming based on my experience, but I don’t know if that’s just me rejecting more diagnoses. It’s a very stressful process and I do not wish to be medicated even though I still sometimes struggle with things

I'm the exact same as you. I've been off medication for the most part since mid-2017.

I still get bipolar symptoms (depressed in winter) but it was listed as in remission fir years.

I think it's just that now milder forms are diagnosed, people can learn to live with it. Not the extreme psychosis types where people have worse outcomes.

Anevilintervention · 15/05/2023 17:22

I'll be watching with interest as one of the clinics is the same one I was planning to use for DS due to the lengthy wait for NHS input. I think I will still go down the private route as its been evident since he was a pre-schooler that something's been going on with him.

Mangogogogo · 15/05/2023 17:20

I had a diagnosis of bipolar which went into remission and I’m now completely medication free (and actually feeling way better from it) that was an nhs diagnosis. I then had private therapy who went on to say it was probably ADHD and the bipolar was misdiagnosed. Then I began private assessment for adhd but sacked the whole lot off. It felt like they were messing with my head a lot tbh. It was awful. I see the symptoms and me and family laugh like ‘probs the adhd lol’ but I don’t ‘identify’ as having either now tbh. I can also see a scandal coming based on my experience, but I don’t know if that’s just me rejecting more diagnoses. It’s a very stressful process and I do not wish to be medicated even though I still sometimes struggle with things

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 17:18

FlyingUnicornWings · 15/05/2023 17:09

And the DIVA Interview which is the standard diagnostic assessment interview for ADHD - used by all.

The DIVA people themselves though advise that it should be combined with a wider psychiatric assessment to rule out differential diagnoses.

plasticpens · 15/05/2023 17:15

Nn9011 · 15/05/2023 17:09

This isn't true at all. In order to get an ADHD diagnosis, the symptoms have to be present in childhood. Therefore you do have to ask family to get involved and they are asked their perception of how you were as a child and that is strongly taken into consideration. If there was no impact in childhood then it is not ADHD it's like trauma or something causing similar symptoms. It's not just a self report.

I didn't have anyone involved in mine regarding childhood. I'm satisfied with my diagnosis though as I know the problems were present even if I don't have anyone to say so.

Nn9011 · 15/05/2023 17:09

This isn't true at all. In order to get an ADHD diagnosis, the symptoms have to be present in childhood. Therefore you do have to ask family to get involved and they are asked their perception of how you were as a child and that is strongly taken into consideration. If there was no impact in childhood then it is not ADHD it's like trauma or something causing similar symptoms. It's not just a self report.

FlyingUnicornWings · 15/05/2023 17:09

plasticpens · 15/05/2023 16:22

What would make more sense is some agreement of what a private provider needs to have done in diagnosing. Some Local Authorities for example will accept a private ASD diagnosis if a proper ADOS assessment has been done. It could be that an ADHD assessment MUST have been done by a psychiatrist and MUST include elements that the NHS requires.

I thought that's what DSM V or ICD 11 did?

And the DIVA Interview which is the standard diagnostic assessment interview for ADHD - used by all.

ImPrawnCrackers · 15/05/2023 17:05

Then problem with mental health diagnoses (and I'll lump ADHD in with that for present purposes, even though it's a bit different!) is the reliance on self report! People can read up about all the symptoms, convince themselves they have X or Y diagnosis, go to the psychiatrist and report all the symptoms they've read about. The psychiatrist ticks off the checklist and diagnoses you. It actually is pretty much that simple! A better psychiatrist diagnosing ADHD should ask for corroborating evidence from family and school if kids, or family/others known since childhood and maybe school reports for adults. But even with corroborating evidence, it's still just self report. Schizophrenia and Eating disorders being the exceptions (and these are not over diagnosed or in fashion labels at the moment and never will be, due to the need for more than self report!)

If we all self diagnosed medical problems and reported the symptoms to a gp and they didn't have to take bloods etc .. just diagnosed based on the symptoms, then we'd all be walking round with cancer diagnoses, heart problems etc .. ! Most people worried about X or Y go to the GP and the blood tests rules out what they think they have in many cases!

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 17:03

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 17:01

I understand but I'm not assuming they never had any issues before hand. I'm talking about those people whom by their own admission didn't.

Adhd is a very real disability and affects all aspects of lives. If people acknowledge they have never been impacted by it growing up then its reasonable to be sceptical.

Well, I would totally agree with that. And they shouldn't be diagnosed if that's the case as one of the diagnostic requirements is that you are able to demonstrate (in whatever way practical for your circumstances) that you have been affected throughout your life. If people are being diagnosed without that happening, then those diagnoses are highly questionable.

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 17:01

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 15:23

Some of the people deciding they have ADHD may well not have it, of course that's the case. If you float a list of symptoms in social media, people will diagnose themselves; cognitive biases work that way. If I start posting at length about nits, your head may begin to itch.

But it's a dangerous assumption to make that people do NOT have ADHD because they appear to have had no problems beforehand. I could easily have been described like that but when I did get diagnosed, lots of people who knew me when I was younger said that suddenly things I'd done back then made sense - it's common for the bigger picture of difficulties not to be apparent at the time because you have problems with what feels like disparate things, but people who know you in different contexts will say 'ah, I see, that explains it'. And because each of those difficulties may seem relatively minor in isolation, if you are surface-functioning, no one is worried about you, but when you are experiencing yourself all those minor things at once, it's totally overwhelming. The effect though is to think that you're just a failure because you seem to get so many things wrong.

I understand but I'm not assuming they never had any issues before hand. I'm talking about those people whom by their own admission didn't.

Adhd is a very real disability and affects all aspects of lives. If people acknowledge they have never been impacted by it growing up then its reasonable to be sceptical.

Falt · 15/05/2023 16:53

arethereanyleftatall · 15/05/2023 11:16

I'm sorry op, but I do imagine there are some unscrupulous private doctors who will tell you exactly what you want to hear in return for money. They are a business after all.
The great thing about the NHS is that there is absolutely nothing in it for them to say what you want to hear, so their diagnosis will always be a correct one.
I don't know if yours was a correct diagnosis or not.

But most of the Drs also work for the NHS (they do private work on the side) and it's the same money they're making wether they decide you do or don't have it? You pay for the assessment - they don't give you the money back if you don't have it!

I mean all the article proves is that anyone can go to a doctor, lie about their symptoms, get a diagnosis and receive treatment for it. I could go to my GP tomorrow and tell them I think I'm depressed, having suicidal thoughts, sleeping all day and neglecting my house and I'm pretty confident they'd suggest we treat my depression.

BUT if I went to the same GP and said "I'm a journalist doing an undercover report on how easy it is to be a diagnosed with depression" any decent doctor think twice before diagnosing me and giving me medication. As I'm sure those private doctors would have if they'd been told up front he was a journalist like the NHS was.

The other question you have to ask yourself is... why bother if you don't genuinely think you have it? To get a hold of medication? You can find them a whole lot cheaper than the £500-£1000 it costs to get a diagnosis and the £150-£200 a month it costs you to fulfil the prescription, and all that for what is essentially a microdose of speed that you can get from any local dealer or the dark web Confused? Why would anyone actually bother? £10 and a snapchat account will get you what need ffs.

And if they DID go to all of that bother despite not actually having ADHD, the chances of them actually getting on with the medication enough to take it long term are negligible imho. Christ I know loads of folk with a diagnosis who are terrible at taking their medication because of side effects, or because they don't really like the actual "normal" effects of them anyway. And even if this non-ADHD person got on with them and found they made their life better then, what? What's actually the problem? They study a little harder or get a little better at doing their laundry? Whelp! We can't be having that, can we? Scandalous!

The real scandal here is that people are having to fork out hundreds of pounds for private diagnosis because the NHS waiting lists are years long and access to medication they need to function normally is so restricted. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Cannabis is another one... pretty sure you can go to a private doctor and get it on prescription from a company that is owned by an MPs husband, or you can get it from the dealer round the corner, but not the NHS. So is it allowable or not? Is it bad or not? Why do people care so much about what other people choose to do with their health / bodies / lives?