Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I actually have ADHD after all?

396 replies

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 10:37

I was diagnosed with ADHD last year at a private clinic after getting nowhere with the NHS. I did a fair bit of research and went to a named psychiatrist who specialises in treating ADHD and went in with an open mind not necessarily expecting a diagnosis.

Somewhat to my surprise I was diagnosed very quickly (I'd filled in lots of very lengthy forms before my assessment and off the back of that was told I was a clear cut case), and strongly encouraged to try medication (I haven't yet).

It's taken a bit of courage to tell family and friends - some have been supportive, some a bit sceptical ("but you seem completely normal?" "yeah I've seen all those TikTok videos too").

I still struggle a bit accepting the diagnosis and am prone to beating myself up about it (it's not ADHD, I'm just lazy, don't try hard enough, etc...).

Then I've seen this BBC news report today about the "ADHD private diagnosis scandal" suggesting people are being diagnosed by private clinics who don't actually have ADHD.

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation - BBC News

Have I just been taken in by all the TikTok nonsense (even though I don't use TikTok) and exploited by an industry trying to sell me expensive drugs?

Or do I have a genuine neurological condition that's being called into question by journalists looking to turn everything into a some kind of scandal?

I don't honestly know what to think any more.

Hand holding a bottle of pills

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation

An undercover journalist for Panorama is diagnosed and given drugs without proper checks.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534448

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
IHadADreamBut · 16/05/2023 20:52

Daftasabroom · 16/05/2023 20:18

There seems to be a general misunderstanding of what a spectrum is in a STEM context - including a medical context. Hopefully this explanation might help a bit.

I work in STEM research and spectra are used in many different disciplines to identify or classify complex systems with multiple factors into sets that can be understood, and studied, and to clarify both challenges and opportunities.

I've been trying to think of a not to sciencey analogy and this might be a bit daft but the clue is the name. I have no idea whether the following is a thing but hopefully you get the drift.

Happy frogs, sad frogs, and environmental spectra.

A suitable environmental habitat for froggy can be measured by a number of environmental factors. Max and min temperature, humidity, food type, food availability, pond availability, water temperature, prevalence of predators.

We compare three habitats. The first is high humidity, constant warm temps day and night year round, lots of yummy bugs and creepy crawlies to eat, not just ponds but a full on jungle, very few predators.

The second has scorching day times and freezing nights, bone dry, few bugs, no ponds or water, and everything wants to eat eat froggy.

The third has rather cool but relatively constant temps, muggy sometimes but not too often, puddles more than ponds, cold enough in winter to make froggy sleep for a couple of months, and if only the two legged beasts didn't poison the slugs, his tummy would be a lot happier too.

Each of these habitats are clearly identifiable by the their common qualities. Rain forest - very happy froggy. Desert - very dead froggy. Oceanic - froggy has twenty different terms for rain and is weather obsessed.

Each of these habitats have the same parameters that can be used to identify how happy froggy will be. So I'm sure the spectra for the Atacama and the Sahara will both shout, desert, don't go there. The Amazon and the Congo rain forests will be froggy's top holiday spot to get away from very average Northern European or Colorado winters.

The point of this is that all these places have the same traits, just in a different abundance or quantity. It is the abundance of each trait that results in a pattern, called a spectra or spectrum, that identifies a place as rain forest, desert etc.

The is no mild end or severe end, just different patterns.

When applied to neurological disorders or conditions the pattern can be used to describe a particular diagnosis, what it can't necessarily do is identify the specific needs of an individual. Some froggies will be very happy in the jungle, some more so at the bottom of my garden.

Also check mass spectrometry.

I liked the frogggy that's a bit weather-obsessed and has different names for rain. 🤣

Anyway, so the spectrum is that autistic people or people with adhd have most or all of the traits but in varying degrees/intensity. The intensity is where the spectrum lies, not in the traits.

In other words, even if you/"everyone has some adhd/autistic traits", if you don't have most or all - regardless of the intensity - it doesn't count as autism/adhd and you won't meet the threshold for diagnosis.

Is that right?

Righthandman · 16/05/2023 20:46

RagingWoke · 16/05/2023 19:29

Apologies @Righthandman poor phrasing. Maybe better to say people are likely agree someone severely affected, eg non verbal, needs support and it's unlikely to be disputed- fully appreciate its very complex in practice.

Whereas there are PPs in this thread who refuse to acknowledge someone who can mask might need any kind of support (or compassion, empathy or just not flat out hate directed at them).

Thanks for your reply @RagingWoke I appreciate it. Yes, In some basic respects agreement that support is required is easier to come by.

Support, compassion and empathy are in woefully short supply generally, it seems. I agree a lot of people who are skilled at masking and coping could do with a lot more of all three.

wnaderingmind · 16/05/2023 20:32

YourTruthorMine · 16/05/2023 19:20

Personally, I believe and have always believed that ADHD is a form of autism. I and almost all of my ADHD friends have sensory issues, extreme hyperfocus when interested in a subject and difficulty socialising with neurotypical indviduals. (alongside the usual ADHD symptoms)

Yes, me too.

Daftasabroom · 16/05/2023 20:18

There seems to be a general misunderstanding of what a spectrum is in a STEM context - including a medical context. Hopefully this explanation might help a bit.

I work in STEM research and spectra are used in many different disciplines to identify or classify complex systems with multiple factors into sets that can be understood, and studied, and to clarify both challenges and opportunities.

I've been trying to think of a not to sciencey analogy and this might be a bit daft but the clue is the name. I have no idea whether the following is a thing but hopefully you get the drift.

Happy frogs, sad frogs, and environmental spectra.

A suitable environmental habitat for froggy can be measured by a number of environmental factors. Max and min temperature, humidity, food type, food availability, pond availability, water temperature, prevalence of predators.

We compare three habitats. The first is high humidity, constant warm temps day and night year round, lots of yummy bugs and creepy crawlies to eat, not just ponds but a full on jungle, very few predators.

The second has scorching day times and freezing nights, bone dry, few bugs, no ponds or water, and everything wants to eat eat froggy.

The third has rather cool but relatively constant temps, muggy sometimes but not too often, puddles more than ponds, cold enough in winter to make froggy sleep for a couple of months, and if only the two legged beasts didn't poison the slugs, his tummy would be a lot happier too.

Each of these habitats are clearly identifiable by the their common qualities. Rain forest - very happy froggy. Desert - very dead froggy. Oceanic - froggy has twenty different terms for rain and is weather obsessed.

Each of these habitats have the same parameters that can be used to identify how happy froggy will be. So I'm sure the spectra for the Atacama and the Sahara will both shout, desert, don't go there. The Amazon and the Congo rain forests will be froggy's top holiday spot to get away from very average Northern European or Colorado winters.

The point of this is that all these places have the same traits, just in a different abundance or quantity. It is the abundance of each trait that results in a pattern, called a spectra or spectrum, that identifies a place as rain forest, desert etc.

The is no mild end or severe end, just different patterns.

When applied to neurological disorders or conditions the pattern can be used to describe a particular diagnosis, what it can't necessarily do is identify the specific needs of an individual. Some froggies will be very happy in the jungle, some more so at the bottom of my garden.

Also check mass spectrometry.

Faffertea · 16/05/2023 20:17

No I meant neurodiverse in the sense most people understand it vs neurotypical though I take your point that neurodevelopmental may be more accurate or specific.

I think we could argue about whether some of your list can be considered neurodiverse but that’s not the point of the thread!

plasticpens · 16/05/2023 20:15

@Garethkeenansstapler

And as part of a general discussion it's reasonable to ask if people are qualified or 'laymen' for want of a better term. That way you know how to formulate your response. Not sure why you felt the need to jump in there really?

Shelefttheweb · 16/05/2023 20:02

Faffertea · 16/05/2023 19:37

Undoubtedly it falls into ‘neurodiversity’ as an umbrella term and well established that neurodiversity conditions often co-occur.

Neurodiversity also includes; dyslexia, dyspraxia, epilepsy, acquired brain injury, dementia, stroke, very high IQ, learning disability, cerebral palsy, sensory processing disorder, left handedness, Tourette’s syndrome, auditory processing disorder, sensory impairments, foetal alcohol syndrome, other teratogenic conditions, Rett’s syndrome, other genetic conditions, Parkinson’s disease, other degenerative conditions, attachment disorders, BPD, schizophrenia, mental health conditions, PANDAS, other brain infections….

I think you mean neurodevelopmental conditions.

ScrollingLeaves · 16/05/2023 19:42

Mabelface · Yesterday 10:51
I don't like the spin that's been put on this, as the reality is that adhd is under diagnosed and waiting lists, including now for private assessments, are getting longer. You have symptoms indicative of adhd therefore you have a diagnosis. You're not just lazy. I was diagnosed last year (on top of an asd diagnosis) and the validation is huge. The meds have transformed my life.

The thing is that someone could have all the symptoms but those may not be as a result of ADHD. People need a diagnosis based on having taken account all the differentials first.

Therefore it would be incorrect to say,” You have symptoms indicative of ADHD therefore you have a diagnosis.”

Garethkeenansstapler · 16/05/2023 19:38

plasticpens · 16/05/2023 19:35

Qualifications? Profession?

Or just random 'this is what I think'?

It is an Internet forum to be fair, it’s mainly ‘this is what I think’

Faffertea · 16/05/2023 19:37

Undoubtedly it falls into ‘neurodiversity’ as an umbrella term and well established that neurodiversity conditions often co-occur.

plasticpens · 16/05/2023 19:35

YourTruthorMine · 16/05/2023 19:20

Personally, I believe and have always believed that ADHD is a form of autism. I and almost all of my ADHD friends have sensory issues, extreme hyperfocus when interested in a subject and difficulty socialising with neurotypical indviduals. (alongside the usual ADHD symptoms)

Qualifications? Profession?

Or just random 'this is what I think'?

Faffertea · 16/05/2023 19:34

Sorry that was supposed to a reply to @NotAnotherBathBomb post at 12.44 yesterday but reply function didn’t work 🙄

Faffertea · 16/05/2023 19:32

I’m an NHS GP.
On the shared care prescribing there is no obligation for shared care between private providers and NHS for anything not just ADHD meds. This is for a variety of reasons but it might be because of concerns about what the private provider is suggesting (I have had a private clinic ask me to prescribe medicinal cannabis for a patient with no reason to have it that would be covered by NHS guidance or even UK law). It can also be due to concerns about what care private clinics will provide for follow up or what will happen if the patient becomes unwell due to medication prescribed. The legal responsibility is with the person prescribing so if I am going to prescribe some medication with serious side effects or risks associated with it then I need to ensure that either I know what to look out for and how to deal with it or that there is a specialist regularly seeing the patient who does. That is the purpose of a shared care agreement signed by specialist, patient and GP. It clearly sets out everyone’s roles and responsibilities.

I have undertaken shared care with private consultants in the past but only when I am confident in the skills of the specialist and that they will fulfil their obligations on reviewing and actioning any problems; that I have spoken to the patient and they have agreed to fulfil their part e.g attending reviews, having blood tests if needed and that if they don’t or can’t then I can no longer prescribe. I don’t like that it means they have to continue to pay to see a specialist and usually they are waiting for the NHS to see them anyway but sometimes it’s the least worst option if it means they have medication they need for now.

As others have said, the scandal is how this government has undermined and underfunded the NHS forcing people to wait years for treatment or go private.

RagingWoke · 16/05/2023 19:29

Apologies @Righthandman poor phrasing. Maybe better to say people are likely agree someone severely affected, eg non verbal, needs support and it's unlikely to be disputed- fully appreciate its very complex in practice.

Whereas there are PPs in this thread who refuse to acknowledge someone who can mask might need any kind of support (or compassion, empathy or just not flat out hate directed at them).

YourTruthorMine · 16/05/2023 19:20

Personally, I believe and have always believed that ADHD is a form of autism. I and almost all of my ADHD friends have sensory issues, extreme hyperfocus when interested in a subject and difficulty socialising with neurotypical indviduals. (alongside the usual ADHD symptoms)

Daftasabroom · 16/05/2023 19:08

DeadSea95 · 16/05/2023 13:09

She means most mental health issues are on a spectrum - ASD, ADHD, bipolar etc

So she's saying if people at the milder end are diagnosed, what impact does it have on people at the more severe end.

I don't see an issue with milder cases being diagnosed, unless it comes to campaigning where there's a big privilege difference.

People who can mask any condition definitely get treated better in some ways. I know I do.

ASD, ADHD are not mental health issues they neurological differences. In many instances they can lead to mental health issues but they are different things.

Spectra, and spectrum disorders, do not have a mild end and a severe end. That is a very dangerous misconception.

Nestpasenville · 16/05/2023 18:01

It’s definitely a spectrum. I have an ADHD diagnosis, NHS funded referral to private provider. Not one featured on the programme.

I’ve also said on here (diff user name) that I think the threshold is higher in NHS services. Not a popular opinion on here.

Lots of people can have these behaviours to more or less a degree. Sometimes people are able to manage them better as an adult even if they did have them in childhood. Sometimes not.

The key is how much it impacts on your life to the point that you’re actually having major problems. Particularly noted difficulties with work, social interactions, relationships, life admin. Serious executive function issues. Trauma response and anxiety can also have similar symptoms. The meds can have serious side effects so there needs to be a really good cost/ benefit ratio. It requires thorough psychiatric assessment.

Shelefttheweb · 16/05/2023 17:46

Private health care is not like NHS health care. Waiting lists, costs and workload mean the NHS is much more conservative. By contrast private providers have a very direct conflict of interest. They make more money off patients who have treatment than those who don’t, and also means they have an incentive to keep people happy (not healthy) by meeting their diagnostic expectations. It would be more surprising if Panorama did not find evidence of overdiagnosing, than that they did.

Shelefttheweb · 16/05/2023 17:34

There are a lot of leaps of logic on this thread:

there is an industry making money privately diagnosing adhd in those without it; “how dare you say my adhd isn’t real!”

the top NHS psychiatrist knew he was being filmed so was bound to have done a slapdash assessment and put his professional reputation on the line by telling someone with adhd they didn’t really have it - in a widely broadcast documentary

this particular private service wasn’t featured; that must be because they diagnose correctly and that proves that there aren’t some services over diagnosing even if some clinics featured do

they must have adhd because their lives are hard therefore it can’t possibly be another condition which might also make their lives hard

being incorrectly diagnosed with adhd and therefore not being treated correctly for their true condition is ok because NHS waiting lists are too long

Righthandman · 16/05/2023 17:34

RagingWoke · 16/05/2023 15:16

People who can mask any condition definitely get treated better in some ways. I know I do.

And worse, people who can mask are often overlooked and not given support they desperately need. It's easy to see, for example, what the needs are for someone nonverbal who needs 24 hour care and can't do anything independently and put that support in place (in theory, I appreciate in practise it's not black and white).

Now compare that to someone able to mask and when they ask for help it's met with the judgment and hatred some of the PPs here have shown because they present as ok. There is almost no support so when the mask slips you end up with severe outcomes, something like 1 in 4 women with adhd report they have attempted suicide.

I would strongly dispute that it’s easy to see or meet the needs of someone nonverbal, even in theory, unless you deny them any sort of autonomy and assume needs are limited to ‘offered food and the chance to wash.’ Honestly, it’s much more complicated than this when you’re taking about an adult, but just look at all the threads here with despairing parents of nonverbal NT toddlers to see how ‘easy’ it is.

KingsHeath53 · 16/05/2023 16:45

@NotAnotherBathBomb i don’t know you so I couldn’t say :-)

But I do know that according to the diagnostic criteria, for someone to meet a threshold of clinical adhd they need to have suffered serious setbacks as a result of their symptoms. I gave examples of the types of setbacks I have seen amongst my family members, and they are serious ones. What I have observed recently is many adults I know with very smooth functioning happy lives, determining that they suffer this debilitating neurological condition but somehow have just masked it their whole lives. Which is pretty wild.

I couldn’t possibly say if this would be you or not. I would never wish (real) adhd on anyone. Far from being a ‘superpower’, it’s a debilitating lifelong condition with statistically poor outcomes for mental health, life expectancy and a raft of other indicators.

Circethemagician · 16/05/2023 16:29

I haven’t watched the programme yet but read the summary and will watch it soon.

It’s very concerning to me that there is such wide variety in diagnosis.

DS has had 2 ADHD assessments and an ASD assessment with NHS doctors (referred via primary school and paediatrician) at a clinic that specialises in children’s health including SEN.
The assessments were conducted with input from the school and myself. So I have no reason to doubt they were valid.

All assessments came back that although he had a number of issues, he did not meet the threshold for diagnosis because his behaviour was not severe enough.

However due to my field of work I have seen ADHD reports from private clinics and I am certain that if I was to get DS assessed by them now he would be diagnosed with ADHD.

DS does struggle a lot with certain things, and we have had to give him a lot more support and guidance than my DD. But is it significant enough that I would be willing to give him medication with so many side-effects? (I have seen them first-hand).

Yes he probably could get higher exam grades if I got him medication - he’s another one of those ‘bright and has all the information in his head but struggles to get it down on paper’. He would probably seem more ‘normal’. But he does ok and is happy, and weighing it up, I just don’t know if the risks are worth it.

Career-wise we will guide him towards something that will suit him, knowing his strengths and weaknesses.

Maybe our expectations of what our lives should be like are too high. A lot of people on here have talked about feeling like a failure, or they feel other people manage their lives better, or wonder ‘what could have been’ and that their ADHD has caused this. I think it’s quite sad. There should be room in society for all different sorts of people.

KingsHeath53 · 16/05/2023 16:27

@FlipsFlops no i wouldn’t because depression is an illness not a neurodevelopmental disorder.

It’s like saying i’m dyslexic but i’ve masked it my whole life by being really good at reading. If you were dyslexic you wouldn’t be able to be really good at reading, that’s the definition of the thing.

My son has full on, medicated ADHD and I can tell you he cannot cope in everyday life without meds. He can barely hold a conversation, can’t attend regular school, needs to be constantly supervised like a toddler etc. The idea he could ‘mask’ this any more than he could mask his skin colour or other fundamental aspect of his character is absurd.

I have many of the same traits but according to the diagnostic criteria a psychiatrist should look at whether symptoms are a barrier to normal functioning before giving a diagnosis, and I have functioned mostly fine my whole life so i shouldn’t get a diagnosis, even though i am sure i’d get one if i went to a private clinic.

Sakigake · 16/05/2023 16:16

I seem to need to experience some sort of stimulation 100% of the time. If I’m trying to concentrate, watch TV or read I’m constantly rubbing my skin or my scalp to the point it’s sore. I don’t even realise I’m doing it until my arm starts to ache. I’m also horribly addicted to nicotine and have been since I was 13. I used to chain smoke, 45-60 fags a day at one point. Then I vaped constantly but now it’s snus. It’s like ‘I’m bored! I know, I’ll have some nicotine to entertain myself for 10 minutes!’

Even watching TV alone isn’t stimulating enough, I have to also be doodling or reading. During a lecture I fill an A4 sheet doodling and then I can’t remember anything that was said.

I’m so embarrassed writing this but it also feels good to just get it out.