Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I actually have ADHD after all?

396 replies

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 10:37

I was diagnosed with ADHD last year at a private clinic after getting nowhere with the NHS. I did a fair bit of research and went to a named psychiatrist who specialises in treating ADHD and went in with an open mind not necessarily expecting a diagnosis.

Somewhat to my surprise I was diagnosed very quickly (I'd filled in lots of very lengthy forms before my assessment and off the back of that was told I was a clear cut case), and strongly encouraged to try medication (I haven't yet).

It's taken a bit of courage to tell family and friends - some have been supportive, some a bit sceptical ("but you seem completely normal?" "yeah I've seen all those TikTok videos too").

I still struggle a bit accepting the diagnosis and am prone to beating myself up about it (it's not ADHD, I'm just lazy, don't try hard enough, etc...).

Then I've seen this BBC news report today about the "ADHD private diagnosis scandal" suggesting people are being diagnosed by private clinics who don't actually have ADHD.

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation - BBC News

Have I just been taken in by all the TikTok nonsense (even though I don't use TikTok) and exploited by an industry trying to sell me expensive drugs?

Or do I have a genuine neurological condition that's being called into question by journalists looking to turn everything into a some kind of scandal?

I don't honestly know what to think any more.

Hand holding a bottle of pills

ADHD: Private clinics exposed by BBC undercover investigation

An undercover journalist for Panorama is diagnosed and given drugs without proper checks.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534448

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
InattentiveADHD · 15/05/2023 16:05

NotAnotherBathBomb · 15/05/2023 12:20

The real scandal here is the lack of access to NHS mental health services.

BINGO

And the poor knowledge of ADHD by some of the MH professionals as evidenced by some of the ridiculous comments some people have noted on this thread.

I tried to get a referral for an ADHD assessment about 15 years ago on the NHS. I spoke to a psychiatrist for 5 minutes who asked me one question. I started to answer it with "I'm not sure but..." and he shouted at me that I didn't have ADHD and that was the end of that.

I also spoke to a psychiatrist at a med review for another condition day within 5 minutes of talking to me having just detailed my diagnoses including ADHD. Said "no I don't think you have ADHD". By this time I was much better at advocating for myself so I just replied "yes, I do" and continued with what we were there to discuss. I don't take this BS any more!

Obviously others on this thread reporting things said like "well if you have done a degree you can't have ADHD" or "if you had ADHD you would have had severe behavioural problems at school/been in trouble with the police" etc etc etc demonstrates a complete lack of understanding of how ADHD can present.

So the PPs saying NHS response to ADHD/assessments etc is always high quality don't know what they are talking about quite frankly.

Nn9011 · 15/05/2023 15:57

It is really common to feel like a fraud after receiving an ADHD diagnosis so this is totally normal.
Everything you have described to me absolutely sounds like you do have ADHD. Going private for a diagnosis has been really stigmatized however most clinics follow exactly the same as NHS if not better and those identified in the documentary will be very few and rare.

I would really recommend doing more research on how ADHD impacts women, you are not alone and many women who have been diagnosed get the same reaction. The problem is that it's very much viewed as a young male issue and so we can reach adulthood just scraping through but at some point reach a burnout.

If you don't want to take medication there are also other things that can help, perhaps seek a counsellor who specialises in ADHD as well. Feel free to reply if you'd like me to recommend some accounts on TIKTOK that I have found personally helpful x

slamfightbrightlight · 15/05/2023 15:53

InattentiveADHD · 15/05/2023 15:49

How do you know what clinics are being featured? Where can you find this information?

They’re named in the bbc article
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534449

Rory Carson

I don't have ADHD, but three private clinics say I do

A BBC journalist was told "You do not have ADHD" by an NHS doctor - but private clinics said otherwise.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534449

Madeintowerhamlets · 15/05/2023 15:52

Robinni · 15/05/2023 14:47

@RagingWoke Could hug you for this. Great, accurate post, very well articulated. Thank you for sticking up for ND people so well!

Yes, thank you for this 🙏

InattentiveADHD · 15/05/2023 15:49

Creamcrackersandricecakes · 15/05/2023 11:18

My DD was diagnosed by ADHD360, who are one of the clinics featured. I'm now terrified that we've been fleeced of nearly £1000 and that my DD is on unnecessary medication.
I tried to get her assessed through the NHS and they wouldn't even put her on the waiting list due to her masking and being a high achiever at school...it didn't matter that she was an anxious mess at home as there was no 'independent proof' of that.
I've already had my dad, (who 'doesn't believe' in adhd or anything like it), phone me AND send me an email this morning, insisting I watch the panorama programme tonight as it 'proves' that private clinics are just 'money grubbing shysters' apparently. FML <screams into a pillow>

How do you know what clinics are being featured? Where can you find this information?

LostMyUserName · 15/05/2023 15:47

Creamcrackersandricecakes · 15/05/2023 12:34

@LostMyUserName - she's still at the stage where they're adjusting the dose / type etc, as she only started taking them a couple of weeks ago. Not a huge difference as yet, but she does say she feels more focused in the afternoons, (previously, as she became tired throughout the day, her focus would really wander in the afternoons, particularly if it was a subject she wasn't that interested in). We haven't had any negative side effects at all, which is a relief. She's on Concerta 27mg.

I hope she can find a dosage that helps her @Creamcrackersandricecakes.

Kyiv · 15/05/2023 15:44

My husband has ADHD, diagnosed by the NHS, and there is no financial incentive at all for them to diagnose. We had the option to choose a private clinic through the NHS but ultimately chose to wait for the NHS psychiatrist at the NHS hospital because they weren't billing anyone for their time and weren't charging for prescriptions. There was literally nothing in it for them and that's what my husband felt would get him a more honest assessment

Neededanewuserhandle · 15/05/2023 15:40

and by the way - for the things that take 300% extra effort - I can then just about manage to do them to a standard where most people would (and do) think I am a lazy feckless cunt. Try living your life like that a bit and then ask why it matters.

Neededanewuserhandle · 15/05/2023 15:38

So, if you are capable of doing well at school, and holding down a decent job, and getting the bills paid (even if a bit late or it stresses you) then even if you DO have ADHD, why does it matter so much?

I can't answer for anyone else but for me it's been a lifelong continual feeling (often invoked by the behaviour of others) that I am a worthless piece of shit because I can't remember to do things or concentrate on them. I can do some things at work well, and some really badly - and by trying about 300% harder than "normal" people to do the difficult ones I can get them to a level where I mostly don't get fired.

I know this will sound like a cop out, but you really can't understand this if you don't experience it.

Neededanewuserhandle · 15/05/2023 15:30

DeadSea95 · 15/05/2023 12:56

You can funnel the traits into something decent, even unmedicated.

I'm still terrible at admin but in a high paid job because I generally function better with stress.

I dropped out of school at 16 and dropped out of a postgrad later. Couldn't handle coursework or low contact hours.

I need things to be fast paced and change jobs every year - self-employed.

Do you mind me asking what you do? I have had a series of unsatisfactory (but reasonably paid) jobs. I crashed out of Uni due to the low contact hours and always struggle where this occurs.
I was diagnosed with ADHD 3 years ago at age 58 by paying for a private consultation but never completed the drug titration.

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 15:23

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 15:15

Which may apply to some but certainly not all in my experience.

Some of the people deciding they have ADHD may well not have it, of course that's the case. If you float a list of symptoms in social media, people will diagnose themselves; cognitive biases work that way. If I start posting at length about nits, your head may begin to itch.

But it's a dangerous assumption to make that people do NOT have ADHD because they appear to have had no problems beforehand. I could easily have been described like that but when I did get diagnosed, lots of people who knew me when I was younger said that suddenly things I'd done back then made sense - it's common for the bigger picture of difficulties not to be apparent at the time because you have problems with what feels like disparate things, but people who know you in different contexts will say 'ah, I see, that explains it'. And because each of those difficulties may seem relatively minor in isolation, if you are surface-functioning, no one is worried about you, but when you are experiencing yourself all those minor things at once, it's totally overwhelming. The effect though is to think that you're just a failure because you seem to get so many things wrong.

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 15:20

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 14:56

I agree to an extent. I don't think it's a result of a secular society but I do think it's a society that is now very based on 'labels' and pathologising any kind of difficult or uncomfortable behaviour.

MN is a good barometer as you see not only armchair-diagnoses of every kind of behaviour being likely indicative of some kind of pathology but also becoming part of identity and how people present themselves.

A lot of threads start with "me, possible ASD, DH possible ADHD, DS1 waiting for ADHD assessment, DD 1 diagnosed ASD". Or end with " be kind, I have anxiety".

It's designed to make people not just be supportive or sympathetic but to also back off and never say anything critical ever because "ND or mental health"

It's not helpful, minimises diagnoses and really does result in people getting pissed off and then thinking its all rubbish when it really isn't

But to challenge that, what is the problem with "labelling" or "pathologising" these things?

I was depressed a couple of years ago and it took me a while to acknowledge that I was actually capital-D Depressed and not just a bit down and finding everything a struggle. Accepting the label of "depression" and seeking help made a huge difference to my life. Anti-depressants worked wonders.

What proportion of people take ADs? It's certainly over 1 in 10. And I know there's talk of ADs being over-prescribed etc but recognising how widespread depression is, being prepared to identify it in yourself and others is I think hugely beneficially.

I don't know how much that reads-across to ADHD but when I doubt my own diagnosis I do remind myself that I doubted my depression too, but with hindsight it was clearly 'real' and benefited from treatment.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 15:15

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 15:13

Very good explanations of this have been provided.

Which may apply to some but certainly not all in my experience.

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 15:13

plasticpens · 15/05/2023 13:15

@Willyoujustbequiet

A couple don't bother with the meds. They have used the diagnosis to apply for PIP and were open about it.

How do they evidence their difficulties?

GP discussions on their record (although were declined for referrals), counselling and private psychologist (not ADHD specialist).

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 15:13

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 15:04

Yes. Its this that I take issue with.

Very good explanations of this have been provided.

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 15:07

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 14:51

You say the diagnostic criteria are clear but they're inherently subjective.

"Often has trouble..." How often is often? What does "has trouble" actually mean? That it's not absolutely effortless, or that it's practically impossible, or somewhere inbetween - if so where inbetween?

"Clear evidence that the symptoms interfere with or reduce he quality of social, school or work functioning" - how much do they need to interfere? how much do they reduce quality of life?

Given most symptoms of ADHD somewhat apply to most people some of the time (are occaionally distracted, make careless mistakes etc) it can't be absolutely black and white

All mental health or neurodevelopmental diagnoses are essentially subjective because there isn't a blood test, X-ray to confirm it. They're not an exact science.

So diagnostic criteria is based on a number of the population exhibiting a number of certain characteristics outside of the 'norm' which in isolation may be very common in the general population but when part of a group of many characteristics are not that common in the general population so seen to be potentially indicative of a disorder or illness.

A skilled and experienced assessor will know the difference. You don’t need to.

RedToothBrush · 15/05/2023 15:06

So, if you are capable of doing well at school, and holding down a decent job, and getting the bills paid (even if a bit late or it stresses you) then even if you DO have ADHD, why does it matter so much?

I did well at school but I COULDN'T hold down a decent job and I struggle with the life admin of remembering passwords. I have had multiple mental health breakdowns. With no satifactory explanation or reason. And THAT is the point.

On the surface, people will say I'm capable. In practice I'm not.

The stigma and all the people saying its not really an issue ARE part of the problem imho.

And I am willing to bet that those who have an actual diagnosis on this thread will understand that sentiment...

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 15:04

YukoandHiro · 15/05/2023 13:03

Child diagnosis is very different.

A lot of adults seem to be diagnosed recently despite reporting zero issues in childhood and during their school/college/uni learning journeys.

Yes. Its this that I take issue with.

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 14:56

totallyteutonic · 15/05/2023 14:28

I think we are over-medicalising and pathologising ourselves because we seek higher meaning and happiness that is very difficult to find. We used to find our hope in religion and its code of virtues and ethics, but now society is very secular we put the emphasis on science and medicine to explain and remediate our "bad" emotions and behaviours.

From my own experience and those I have loved and taught, I can see that ADHD symptoms can result from trauma like Gabor Maté says. But I think on some deeper level the current trend is about people looking for some explanation for their perceived "difference" from others. This is based on the illusion that others appear to be able to function better in society than them. But in reality, most people (especially those with caring responsibilities and in poverty etc.) find life very difficult. Perhaps the structures and institutions around people (work, family, money etc.) are what need to change.

I agree to an extent. I don't think it's a result of a secular society but I do think it's a society that is now very based on 'labels' and pathologising any kind of difficult or uncomfortable behaviour.

MN is a good barometer as you see not only armchair-diagnoses of every kind of behaviour being likely indicative of some kind of pathology but also becoming part of identity and how people present themselves.

A lot of threads start with "me, possible ASD, DH possible ADHD, DS1 waiting for ADHD assessment, DD 1 diagnosed ASD". Or end with " be kind, I have anxiety".

It's designed to make people not just be supportive or sympathetic but to also back off and never say anything critical ever because "ND or mental health"

It's not helpful, minimises diagnoses and really does result in people getting pissed off and then thinking its all rubbish when it really isn't

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2023 14:56

NotAnotherBathBomb · 15/05/2023 12:49

Then they’re just overall liars and scammers who would find any way if they could to get money from the government (and I’m surprised you know so many).

In order to get enough points to be approved for PIP, you have to say on your form and discuss with an assessor that you need help getting dressed and preparing the simplest of meals.

Rethink your friendship circle.

I understand pip and dla, dc are in receipt of both high rate care and mobility.

That's the thing though they genuinely believe they have it and are therefore entitled. Not as a scam but a deep rooted conviction. Its almost a form of brainwashing by social media.

FlipsFlops · 15/05/2023 14:51

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 13:45

Absolutely. The people here saying NHS thresholds are higher than private are affirming the view that private diagnoses aren't as legitimate.

The DSM-V criteria for Adult ADHD is clear and should be the diagnostic threshold for every assessment.

But that doesn't seem to be happening, hence why after years of whistle-blowing and complaints, Panorama have investigated and confirmed that sometimes, corrupt Psychiatrists are enabling 'bought' diagnoses.

You say the diagnostic criteria are clear but they're inherently subjective.

"Often has trouble..." How often is often? What does "has trouble" actually mean? That it's not absolutely effortless, or that it's practically impossible, or somewhere inbetween - if so where inbetween?

"Clear evidence that the symptoms interfere with or reduce he quality of social, school or work functioning" - how much do they need to interfere? how much do they reduce quality of life?

Given most symptoms of ADHD somewhat apply to most people some of the time (are occaionally distracted, make careless mistakes etc) it can't be absolutely black and white

OP posts:
Robinni · 15/05/2023 14:47

RagingWoke · 15/05/2023 14:44

It's a spectrum, just because someone doesn't meet your expectation of an autistic person doesn't mean their diagnosis is any less.

What a disgusting, ableist attitude.

We have much better understanding of neurodiversity that has allowed more people to be diagnosed and treated. Girls in particular are much better at masking, they may appear to be coping fine but inside it's a constant, exhausting struggle that too often ends with depression, burnout and even suicide because they 'look normal'.

It's not that everyone with an ASD or adhd diagnosis needs medication or a lot of support, it may be a small adjustment and some understanding makes a huge difference but while people still have this awful attitude those people will continue to be marginalised and suffer.

Outwardly you wouldn't think I had any issues, decent career, dh and dc, nice home etc but privately I am a mess. Depressed, shockingly bad executive functioning, almost no emotional regulation, anxiety, panic attacks... the list goes on. That outward presentation comes at a huge emotional and physical cost, we are taught how to act to 'fit in' and keeping that mask up is so damaging.

Educate yourself rather than relying on half arsed, sensationalist headlines.

@RagingWoke Could hug you for this. Great, accurate post, very well articulated. Thank you for sticking up for ND people so well!

Leftoverssandwich · 15/05/2023 14:45

The internet is full of memes about how no two people with a disability are alike, but in my experience that just isn't true.

Do you have wide experience? Because you mention just two people you know with autism (who are different, but because they are different, you think one of them must not have autism). Autism is known as a spectrum condition because different people have different challenges in different areas (across a spectrum) and present differently.

So, if you are capable of doing well at school, and holding down a decent job, and getting the bills paid (even if a bit late or it stresses you) then even if you DO have ADHD, why does it matter so much?

Because doing those things when you have ADHD can be extremely difficult. Not just 'stressing you'. The cost of them to you can be enormous. I have a 30+ year history of mental health issues, including treatment in specialist centres, which were caused by trying to cope with life with undiagnosed ADHD. I am not unusual.

RagingWoke · 15/05/2023 14:44

DizzyRascal · 15/05/2023 14:29

Its definitely become fashionable to seek diagnosis for things that, to be quite honest, are sometimes personality traits. I would include adult asd diagnosis in that too (sorry, I know half of MN is apparently on the autistic spectrum but it has to be said).
I am NOT saying ADHD doesn't exist. I am saying that fairly average people who are a bit scatty, or suffer from anxiety, or have trouble being tidy, being labelled as ADHD really diminishes the actual, serious difficulties proper ADHD sufferers have. Same with autism. I always understood autism to be an inability to connect with other humans, affecting cognitive processing, and leading to a fairly limited type of life. I have an autistic family member, and he fits the bill for this. You couldn't meet him and not know instantly. He cant make eye contact, he does a job way, way below what he technically could do because he cant really cope with working with people, he has never been in a relationship and never will be.
I met a friend the other day who informed me that her (brilliant, confident, student with a sociable part time job) daughter had been diagnosed as autistic. I have know this girl since she was two. She is really good at maths and very slightly gawky...not even on the same planet as my relative. She can function very well in life and is on track to get a first class degree.
The internet is full of memes about how no two people with a disability are alike, but in my experience that just isn't true.
So, if you are capable of doing well at school, and holding down a decent job, and getting the bills paid (even if a bit late or it stresses you) then even if you DO have ADHD, why does it matter so much?

It's a spectrum, just because someone doesn't meet your expectation of an autistic person doesn't mean their diagnosis is any less.

What a disgusting, ableist attitude.

We have much better understanding of neurodiversity that has allowed more people to be diagnosed and treated. Girls in particular are much better at masking, they may appear to be coping fine but inside it's a constant, exhausting struggle that too often ends with depression, burnout and even suicide because they 'look normal'.

It's not that everyone with an ASD or adhd diagnosis needs medication or a lot of support, it may be a small adjustment and some understanding makes a huge difference but while people still have this awful attitude those people will continue to be marginalised and suffer.

Outwardly you wouldn't think I had any issues, decent career, dh and dc, nice home etc but privately I am a mess. Depressed, shockingly bad executive functioning, almost no emotional regulation, anxiety, panic attacks... the list goes on. That outward presentation comes at a huge emotional and physical cost, we are taught how to act to 'fit in' and keeping that mask up is so damaging.

Educate yourself rather than relying on half arsed, sensationalist headlines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread