Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop flogging a dead horse - family

41 replies

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 10:15

I would love some opinions on this - to figre out whether I am rightfully upset or whether AIBU on this.

There is so much nuance and details to this, but I am going to try keep it very high level. My family: dad and step mum (and my brother and two half siblings, all 18+) in one coutry, my two step sisters in two other countries (both with 2 kids, both separated from their partners). All in closish European countries. Me, DH and kids in the UK.

We don't see each other that often due to distance. And this is where my issue lies. We don't see them often, but they all see each other loads. My SSs casually mentioned this week that they are both going to see our parents this week, with thier kids, going to a summer house. So turns out it's going to be a fully family holiday - other than with my family. Loads of rubbish excuses about it being spotaneous (and conflicting stories about how it came to be, so they are clearly lying), but the fact of the matter is my whole family is holiday together this week and it wasn't even mentioned to me. Yep, it's tricker for us to go because it's further, but on two days notice it's of course impossible.

And the thing is that this isn't a one off. I think it's the 5th time it's happened in the last 2 years. On top of that my dad and step mum have visisted my SSs loads in the last year, and not been here once. My DD is starting to ask why her cousins are always getting toether and we are never there.

Similar story when we do plan holidays. It's all on my SSs availabity and terms. When they want and what they want to do. If it's inconvenient for me, I get told I am being difficult and "I can find a cheap flight from the UK, I don't know why you are saying it's expensive that day" (queue link to flight from Glasgow a 4am). If I try to put in place boundaries they just say ok, we will go ahead with out plans.

I've frankly had enough, and feel really hurt. Mainly because it happens over and over. I don't think they think "let's not tell Nordicrain", I just think they don't even think about it. And i feel left out, and sad for my kids who are getting left out as a result. The only way I think of taking control of the situation is just to distance myself from them completely, but I can't figure out if I am cutting off my nose to spite my face, and depriving my kids of their (disinterested) expended family. WIBU to just take a massive step back, give up on trying to be involved and, effectively, grey rock the lot of them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
aSofaNearYou · 15/05/2023 13:29

My instinct was the same as many others - it's your SM that drives these things actually happening and she's prioritising her own kids. It's your dad that is letting you down.

I can understand why you're upset but I would also say, it's not unreasonable for your SS's to want to see their mum without you sometimes. I'm a step mum and I wouldn't want to always have to invite my DSS if I was spending time with my adult DD's. It sounds like the balance isn't right though, because your dad isn't equally bothered about making sure he sees you.

YWNBU to pull back but you would then obviously have to come to terms with having very little family.

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 13:14

In which case I think that you need to speak to whichever sister you are closer to.

Say really calmly that it feels like they are excluding you. That it may not be intentional but that's how it feels.

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 13:10

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 12:55

If you are step sisters then are the children actually cousins?

Just thinking about it objectively, they are no relation to each other.

Is it worth trying to talk to whichever sister is the main organiser and explaining how you feel?

Yes, no blood relation. But my kids call my SM grandma, and my SS aunty and they have always been referred to as each other's cousins. This is what I mean, it's not like I've made up this close relationship in my head. It's definitely been a thing - we are all a family - especially when we started having children.

OP posts:
Booklover40 · 15/05/2023 12:57

I just wouldn't bother with them any more tbh. Typical case of a man putting his second family first and not bothering with his kids from his first marriage.

Sorry, it sucks.

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 12:55

If you are step sisters then are the children actually cousins?

Just thinking about it objectively, they are no relation to each other.

Is it worth trying to talk to whichever sister is the main organiser and explaining how you feel?

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 12:53

Landndialamrhf · 15/05/2023 12:07

I’m in a similar position, and I don’t think YABU to be hurt, but I think realistically your step sisters are just closer to each other, maybe just because they live nearer each other, or for some other reason than not being full siblings with you, but right now they’re closer to each other, and they decided to go together and visit their family. - likely they’re visiting their mum not your dad really.

you could try make more of a connection with them all on an individual basis?
i always think, even if I feel like they’re being unfair, is there a possibility I’ll regret not giving this more effort? If the answers yes then reach out even if they’re not reciprocating
if the answers no, let it go

Maybe I'll regret it. But maybe I will also regret spending my life accepting being a second class family member, and the same for my children. This is the exact question I am torn on.

OP posts:
Allthings · 15/05/2023 12:39

It’s your father who is the issue. I had much the same, but within different areas of the UK. As the first family we eventually ended up being airbrushed out and were an afterthought when he died being informed almost 4 days later. I suspect that your current situation will be ongoing and will potentially get worse the older your father gets despite whatever efforts you make.

Tanktanktank · 15/05/2023 12:37

I’m a stepmother. My DH is dire at contacting his DC. I often remind him to do so. I’m lucky my DD’s (I call them all that regardless of our true relationship) get on well, message each other frequently and am blessed with an extremely well blended family.

I’ll also say DH’s biological DC are dire at contacting him. I get miffed occasionally that I’m the pivotal point of a lot of family get togethers and general chit chat and news. We are also spread across UK and EU.

if you want things to happen my personal view is you have to make the effort but I also agree if it’s not reciprocated it’s upsetting.

can’t say I’ve read everything on this post in huge detail but maybe you have to really start communicating with your dad, then when your step mum says she’s organising something you’ll be more in his mind and hopefully he’ll speak up for you.

a friend of mine got her mum a photo frame where all the her siblings can send photos to their mum (friend does all tech stuff) photos are loaded automatically for the technophobic mother. I think they’ve now got four frames synchronised and it adds another dimension to the family keeping in touch. The situation here was slightly different as all siblings felt mother was too involved with her hobbies and paid them no attention. The frame sparks off, what have they been doing messages and more contact has been achieved.

Landndialamrhf · 15/05/2023 12:07

I’m in a similar position, and I don’t think YABU to be hurt, but I think realistically your step sisters are just closer to each other, maybe just because they live nearer each other, or for some other reason than not being full siblings with you, but right now they’re closer to each other, and they decided to go together and visit their family. - likely they’re visiting their mum not your dad really.

you could try make more of a connection with them all on an individual basis?
i always think, even if I feel like they’re being unfair, is there a possibility I’ll regret not giving this more effort? If the answers yes then reach out even if they’re not reciprocating
if the answers no, let it go

SquirrelsStars · 15/05/2023 12:02

It's true that there is no automatic bond with a step-parent in the way there usually is with your own parent - but there is such a thing as common decency and fairness which seems to be somewhat lacking here. Excluding you from 'family' holidays and get-togethers is just not nice and probably comes from a place of deep insecurity or selfishness in the relationship if there's no particular falling-out with you as such. But you are still on the receiving end of it and the failure of your father to step in and say no that's not right is weak and unfair.

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 11:59

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 11:54

Also, if you want big group holidays them could you organise holidays with friends?

A step relationship is a tricky one to navigate because there is no automatic relationship and shared kinship.

It's not I want big holidays, I would like to spend time with my family and be include when they organise big family trips. So my children can spend time with their cousins, and so we can all see each other.

Yes, I agree. But we've always been close. It was always a "one family" vibe. But, as I said above, i acknowledge that perhaps I have read more into that than they have.

OP posts:
Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 11:54

Also, if you want big group holidays them could you organise holidays with friends?

A step relationship is a tricky one to navigate because there is no automatic relationship and shared kinship.

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 11:51

SquirrelsStars · 15/05/2023 11:48

This isn't nice and they know it isn't nice which is why they aren't being fully open about it and coming up with conflicting stories. It's also exhausting and painful for you. I hate to say it but from my own experience it won't get any better. If someone doesn't voluntarily and automatically want to treat you fairly and equally to other family members, then pointing it out or falling out over it won't make any meaningful difference. Don't waste your time chasing after someone who isn't very invested in you.

This is how I feel. It's got gradually worse over the years, and I can't see it improving. It's not like I've not asked them to let me know "next time" so I can see if I can make it.

OP posts:
Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 15/05/2023 11:51

Don't cut off your nose to spite your face. It seems to be down to your dad who lets his wife sort it all out and she prioritises her own DC. He should be doing the same for you. It's horrible to be left out.
I've have a friendly chat with SS and ask to be included in future holidays and mention your DD's feelings.

SquirrelsStars · 15/05/2023 11:48

This isn't nice and they know it isn't nice which is why they aren't being fully open about it and coming up with conflicting stories. It's also exhausting and painful for you. I hate to say it but from my own experience it won't get any better. If someone doesn't voluntarily and automatically want to treat you fairly and equally to other family members, then pointing it out or falling out over it won't make any meaningful difference. Don't waste your time chasing after someone who isn't very invested in you.

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 11:47

And invite your dad to visit you.

Suggest a specific date etc

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 11:46

I think if you do all the organising for a holiday. Then their response will tell you the truth.

Either they will be enthusiastic, and once you've been together once or twice then it becomes more normal and routine.

Or they won't want to. In which case you know that a big family holiday is off the cards.

And instead you will just focus on visiting your dad etc

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 11:46

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/05/2023 11:42

Can’t you organise something in The Uk for them to come to?

I've asked. It's too expensive/ no convenient etc etc etc. last time my SSs came to the UK was 6 years ago. Actually one of them has been to visit friends here since.

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 11:45

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 11:41

Do you ever do the instigating?

Do you suggest a big family holiday with everyone, find a location and organise dates?

Yes, I do. Often. It always ends up being on my SS's terms though.

OP posts:
Ktime · 15/05/2023 11:45

I guess my main query is what is the solution? And WIBU to just take a huge distance from them all, to avoid my own upset (and potentially the kids picking up on it)?

YANBU. It takes 10 secs to message and say we are going to visit parents on this date, would love to see you there.

They are either (i) wrapped up in their lives and don't think to ask you (ii) don't want to work around your availability (iii) prefer your parents' attention to be on them and their dc {iv) see you as different because you are married (v) prefer to have more room to themselves as you, DH and dc would take a room/s.

Nordicrain · 15/05/2023 11:44

Darkchocolatekitkat · 15/05/2023 11:24

If they invited you to all these things, would you go?

I’m a “local” sibling in a semi similar situation. We don’t tell distant sibling about many of our family meet ups because realistically they can’t/won’t come and it felt hurtful constantly saying “we’re all meeting for a bbq at x’s this weekend do you want to come?” to someone who lived hours away, was permanently skint, didn’t drive and realistically couldn’t say yes. The alternative was for none of us to meet up, which seemed ridiculous. So it might be that they’re being thoughtless or excluding you, or it might be they’re actually trying not to be hurtful.

I couldn't come to all of them, but with notice I could make some of them. The point is it would be nice to be asked, even if I couldn't. Everyone has to travel, it's cheaper and there are more options for them, but we all have to fly to get there.

I do go see them (my dad/ SM). But it's always on my initiative and me (and the kids) travelling. My dad obviously feels that it's not his responsibility to make sure I'm included. I would like to think my SSs thought of me, but obviously they don't. I guess I would handle it differently, but as I said above maybe this thread has jstu made me realise that I feel more that we are a family than they do.

@TheYearOfSmallThings Maybe, but I am not really willing to let my kids feel like spare parts or not quite like "real" family in all these contexts. It's a horrible feeling.

@moose62 my borther still lives with them as his MH issues are so serious he cannot live alone. They are well managed, but he needs support. I couldn't ring him up and arrange something. We aren't very close either (due in part to his MH, he just simply is difficutl to be "close" to).

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/05/2023 11:42

Can’t you organise something in The Uk for them to come to?

Dishwashersaurous · 15/05/2023 11:41

Do you ever do the instigating?

Do you suggest a big family holiday with everyone, find a location and organise dates?

35965a · 15/05/2023 11:38

This is definitely crappy of them. I think pulling back is probably what I would do too. However, if you think it’s more thoughtlessness than outright nastiness then it may be worth speaking to your SM and dad about it honestly. Be totally honest about how you feel left out and your dc notice it. If after this it’s still the same then I definitely would just think ‘well fuck you’ then and not bother with them.

MenopauseSucks · 15/05/2023 11:36

@Nordicrain

As @Darkchocolatekitkat has said

'My hunch is that it’s your SM organising this stuff/carrying the emotional load of family life, and she’s prioritising her own kids. Is your Dad organising and arranging get togethers? Are you suggesting things and making the effort to arrange them? It’s difficult and I sympathise but to an extent I think it’s an inevitable consequence of living further away that family life will carry on without you'

I think this sums it up really. Women tend to do all the organising so your SM's first thought is towards her daughters.
Can you arrange to go visit your Dad without seeing your SS? You would see him, your brother & half-siblings.
Don't even talk to your SM about it - talk to your Dad. Arrange it with him directly. It doesn't matter if the SS aren't there - you're not visiting to see them.