Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone from a different GP's access my medical records?

107 replies

Lelala · 14/05/2023 21:37

just as the title says really

I am registered with a gp surgery

someone known to me works for a completely different gp surgery but seems to have knowledge of my medical information

are they able to access my medical records even though they work at a separate surgery?

OP posts:
DistrictCommissioner · 15/05/2023 10:35

What a confusing thread!

DH is a GP working at one surgery but he can access the records across all surgeries in the PCN (primary care network - roughly our local council area)

Houseupdate · 15/05/2023 10:33

BeverlyHa · 14/05/2023 21:41

Yup, i heard that anyone who knows your name and surname, and work in the NHS, can just click your name into the NSH database and see all your records, including even cleaners. Not sure is it true but I heard it in a discussion with actual professionals

Of course cleaner’s can’t access medication records!

Tortiemiaw · 15/05/2023 10:27

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 09:23

I think we are banging heads against the proverbial brick wall here.

Yes. Apologies for being a bit thick. My understanding is that if you are based in one surgery, you will be given only access to those patients, be it on systm 1 or emis. Clearly , nhs staff who work in more than one will have more access. I took the OP to mean that the person they are worried about was based in one.
As has been said other trists may act in different ways

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 09:23

FarmGirl78 · 15/05/2023 08:46

People saying "I work in a GP surgery and I can only access our own patients" should actually be saying "I work in a GP surgery and the level of access my person profile is programmed into our system with means I can only access our own Patients".

With the right level of access it is possible to see other Patients' summaries. Eg, diagnosed conditions, medications, etc.

I think we are banging heads against the proverbial brick wall here.

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 09:21

TroysMammy · 15/05/2023 09:16

We can't access patients details who are based at a different surgery only patients who are registered with us. Surgery staff can only access blood, urine and radiology results requested by the hospital and vice versa but the surgery can only see their patient's information.

if that was the case then we wouldn't have requests from other surgeries for information about patients who have newly registered with them and information is only sent if already showing transferred out or if we have the patient's permission if not showing transferred out yet.

Unless of course this person in the other surgery has falsely contacted the patient's current surgery pretending they are transferring out to obtain basic information.

It depends what permissions are on your smart card.

TroysMammy · 15/05/2023 09:16

We can't access patients details who are based at a different surgery only patients who are registered with us. Surgery staff can only access blood, urine and radiology results requested by the hospital and vice versa but the surgery can only see their patient's information.

if that was the case then we wouldn't have requests from other surgeries for information about patients who have newly registered with them and information is only sent if already showing transferred out or if we have the patient's permission if not showing transferred out yet.

Unless of course this person in the other surgery has falsely contacted the patient's current surgery pretending they are transferring out to obtain basic information.

ChocHotolate · 15/05/2023 08:58

I work in urgent care / walk in centre and we use System one. I can see the whole GP record for my patients plus any notes added by community teams who use the same system.
I guess I could search for anyone I wanted too but I don't because it is morally wrong and I value my job and registration.

FarmGirl78 · 15/05/2023 08:46

People saying "I work in a GP surgery and I can only access our own patients" should actually be saying "I work in a GP surgery and the level of access my person profile is programmed into our system with means I can only access our own Patients".

With the right level of access it is possible to see other Patients' summaries. Eg, diagnosed conditions, medications, etc.

FarmGirl78 · 15/05/2023 08:39

endofthelinefinally · 14/05/2023 22:04

This not correct. When I worked in GP I did clinics in 5 different surgeries. I could access the system from one surgery to the others. Systm 1 at 3 surgeries and EMIS at 2. Different staff members have various levels of access.
OP you need to contact the practice manager at your own surgery and ask for an audit by the Caldicott Guardian.

@Lelala This answer by @endofthelinefinally is the most comprehensive correct answer you've had so far. Make it clear that you want the know about access by all individuals, not just ones in your own practice.

Looking at records without reason is a very serious breach of both professional guidelines AND contract of employment. We aren't even allowed to look up our own records.

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 08:25

I don't know if anyone has explained that the smart card is a plastic card with a microchip that is physically slotted into a port on the computer. Then you have to input your unique password in order to access the system. It seems obvious, but maybe some people don't know exactly how it works.

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 08:19

CantBeArsedOrAsked · 15/05/2023 08:17

Yes. I worked in a surgery where the receptionists would stay logged on to System 1 in busy times because it took too long to get onto the system if they logged out each time.
Other staff, practice nurses, GPs etc would also use the reception computers to quickly look patients details up without logging in under their own name.
If this is widespread then it would be very easy for someone working in one surgery to get information about an NHS patient in another area and impossible to know who had accessed this information.

That is really bad practice.

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 08:18

Tortiemiaw · 15/05/2023 08:02

I work in a gp surgery and can assure you that on our systems - the two main ones used - I can only see those patients that are registered with my surgery.

Yes, because those are the permissions installed on your smart card. Everyone who is providing patient care has a smart card that is programmed specifically for their role.
That is why it is a very serious matter to share your smart card or password with anyone else.
Obviously a cleaner wouldn't have a smart card or a password.

CantBeArsedOrAsked · 15/05/2023 08:17

Yes. I worked in a surgery where the receptionists would stay logged on to System 1 in busy times because it took too long to get onto the system if they logged out each time.
Other staff, practice nurses, GPs etc would also use the reception computers to quickly look patients details up without logging in under their own name.
If this is widespread then it would be very easy for someone working in one surgery to get information about an NHS patient in another area and impossible to know who had accessed this information.

Livebythecoast · 15/05/2023 08:13

I worked in GP surgeries for 14 years until last year. I've only ever used the EMIS system and you can't access other patients records from another practice. If they're not registered, their name wouldn't come up. However, I can only speak from my experience and not sure about other systems.

Tortiemiaw · 15/05/2023 08:02

BeverlyHa · 14/05/2023 21:41

Yup, i heard that anyone who knows your name and surname, and work in the NHS, can just click your name into the NSH database and see all your records, including even cleaners. Not sure is it true but I heard it in a discussion with actual professionals

I work in a gp surgery and can assure you that on our systems - the two main ones used - I can only see those patients that are registered with my surgery.

Sidge · 15/05/2023 07:53

I can only access records of patients registered at my practice, and the other practices in my PCN (primary care network) that I have been authorised access to.

My practice manager would have the same authorities. We have no authorisation on out smart cards to access records outwith our practices. So we can’t see patients records if they’re registered in another town, or a neighbouring practice that isn’t part of our PCN.

We can’t see hospital records, and as far as I’m aware they can only see a patients summary care record and only then if a patient has given consent for their summary record to be shared. Staff can access patients records if authorised to do so in their role, eg community staff nurses, dietitians, OT, physio, midwives, and I can see their entries.

An audit trail is kept electronically. It is entirely possible to access records without reason, but only if you already have the authorisation to do so and run the risk of being questioned why if it is flagged up.

Lougle · 15/05/2023 07:52

It is a very serious issue. When I was a nurse I had access to all levels of information because my job required it. I was not allowed to access records unless I had a legitimate clinical reason. I was not allowed to access my own records to check the results of the flu swab I had been asked to take- I had to ask a doctor to do it.

When I came into contact with patients who I knew for other reasons, I always went to my line manager, disclosed the reason I knew them (former colleague, relative, etc.) and asked for specific permission to access their records.

Each time you log into the system, there is an audit trail. You can view the audit trail. It tells you who has accessed the records (each user has a unique code), what records they viewed, and the time and date of access. So if I looked at a blood result, it would log it. If I then looked at different records and returned to the first patient's blood results, it would record my access again.

Each record is its own entity. A user may have a legitimate reason to access blood results, but not swab results. Or they may have legitimate reason to access admissions data, but not blood results. If questioned, the user would have to justify accessing each piece of information.

It may be technically possible, but this person would know what a massive problem it would be if they were caught.

Butterfly44 · 15/05/2023 07:37

"Have you read the Guardian news item linked above? It explains how the woman stallked by a hospital doctor found out that they'd accessed her GP's records (from California, so not even from within her NHS trust!)
You can do exactly what the stalled woman did."

@saraclara that's not what it says at all. Zero mention of California Hmm In fact absolutely no details are given of the victim as identities are protected. They would have been linked to the Trust in order to have a record. And no one can see anything without the trail. It will always timestamp who accessed when.

saltandpepperspareribs · 15/05/2023 07:34

There's a lot of conflicting information on this thread.
If someone has a smart card and uses SystmOne in their role (including non clinical staff like admin), then they can see information relating to individuals from other gp's or other services. Eg physio who also use SystmOne.
Generally hospital information can't be seen because they usually use different electronic records. But if a hospital wrote a letter to the GP or health visitor for eg following an admission or out patient appointment then admin would scan that letter onto the record and it could be seen by whoever accesses the record. Some GP entries on SystmOne aren't able to be seen outside of that practice if the patient has requested limitations on their settings/consent to share.
Every time a record is opened on SystmOne it shows which smart card was used and for how long it was viewed even if no data is input. It's a very simple report to run. I occasionally click on the wrong record when there's a list but the digital footprint will show I'm in it for seconds and out as soon as I've realised my error. Someone looking at a record they shouldn't for any length of time will be caught if audited.
Your starting point is your own GP practice. You don't necessarily need a full copy of your record (unless you want it) via a subject access request just an audit and investigation by a nominated senior person whose role it is to undertake this.
I can only speak for SystmOne which is one of the biggest non hospital electronic record keeping systems but not every GP practice uses them.

TumbleFloat · 15/05/2023 07:29

@endofthelinefinally thank you for clarifying, I wasn't suggesting she names who she thinks did it. But knowing the right wording of the request helps so requesting an audit trail as suggested by you helps us non-medical people.

gettingolderbutcooler · 15/05/2023 07:25

Yes, they can. But there is an audit trail of who looks up your information.

endofthelinefinally · 15/05/2023 07:23

TumbleFloat · 15/05/2023 07:20

As endof said above "OP you need to contact the practice manager at your own surgery and ask for an audit by the Caldicott Guardian"

Raise your concerns and say it is possible that someone has accessed your records and you would like this investigated. See what comes of it from there. I am glad that we went over onto computerised systems as now there is a trail of who has accessed what information.

OP, you don't have to mention who you think has accessed your record.
You can ask for an audit trail check.

Menora · 15/05/2023 07:20

PollyPeptide · 15/05/2023 06:10

But does that mean that access to those 5 surgeries has been put on your smart card and you can't access any other gp surgeries besides those 5? Or can you access all GP surgeries in England?
If the ops surgery is not attached to the surgery of the person who op believes has checked their records, would the staff member have access?
I guess I'm asking if you're saying that every gp surgery can access the full notes of all other gp surgeries in the country?

They can’t you have to have the role assigned to you. You can however go onto the SCR on the portal but it isn’t a full record

Either way, this person has not legitimately accessed a record by the sounds of things and this is why I only ever assigned ‘book appt’ only access to people from other surgeries if this ever came up and they can’t retrieve a record (working from a shared system)

TumbleFloat · 15/05/2023 07:20

As endof said above "OP you need to contact the practice manager at your own surgery and ask for an audit by the Caldicott Guardian"

Raise your concerns and say it is possible that someone has accessed your records and you would like this investigated. See what comes of it from there. I am glad that we went over onto computerised systems as now there is a trail of who has accessed what information.