Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not allow DD to go on school trip for breaking phones?

245 replies

Feefoog · 14/05/2023 18:51

My DD 10 yo DD has broken her phone. I thought fine I have a spare one. DDs put a pin on the spare factory reset model. I have reset the phone but it says put in previous users emails. I've tried both mine and DDs emails, I think she's created an email to get round family link and screen time she said she might have done this. I'm really mad she's effectively broken 2 phones and broken my trust . She has a phone to walk to and from school so needs one, she has a school residential that's £310 which is already expensive. It's not so much about the money its that she shows no regard for rules, money or possessions.

AIBU to refuse to pay for this school trip as she needs a new phone well 2 phones really hers and the spare. She has already been snowboarding this year and will be having 2 weeks in Greece in August so its not like she won't be having trips away.

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 15/05/2023 09:19

I’d do the trip but not a new phone

MarsDestroyerOfWorlds · 15/05/2023 09:17

Please let her go on the residential. I k ow what it feels like to be left out from things like that.

JazbayGrapes · 15/05/2023 09:15

Your own fault for giving an expensive smart phone to a 10yo. Why?

towriteyoumustlive · 15/05/2023 09:12

Why does she NEED a phone to walk to school? What for?

She is clearly very smart being able to bypass security systems, but she has also shown she cannot be trusted with a phone.

When my DS attempted something similar earlier this year (he is 12) then he got a 1 month screen ban. He did it again and queue another 1 month screen ban. Needless to say it has now learned his lesson and all devices are handed over at 8pm!

If she NEEDS a phone for school then just get her a basic one that makes phone calls, or a tracking watch that you can call specific numbers from.

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 08:54

I wouldn't pay for the trip. She needs to be more responsible.

SparklyBlackKitten · 15/05/2023 08:41

As she proved herself untrustworthy. Give her a phone that only allows texts and calls .

user1477391263 · 15/05/2023 08:38

I’d be much more worried that she’s actively bypassing the security measures on your devices and her phone - a good indication she’s not mature enough for unsupervised access and for that reason I’d be removing her phone and access to any devices, not finding a replacement unless is was a brick or one of the cheap watches you can phone her on.

This. I'm eye rolling the idea that she needs a phone at all for a short walk, but if she really must have one, get her a brick.

And do send her on the residential - without a bloody phone. As another poster said, a school trip which presumably would be without screens would actually be good for her. The residential also has nothing to do with the phones so as a punishment it makes no sense.

LIZS · 15/05/2023 08:38

I suspect you would have to pay for the trip now anyway. Agree get her a brick phone for emergencies, confiscate iPad/tablet and delete any unauthorised accounts. When she needs a smartphone again, once she has earned your trust, limit and cap data usage and part of the deal is that it has to be linked to a family account and you have right of access a d monitor her activities.

WildFlowerBees · 15/05/2023 08:31

We bought a cheap PAYG phone that made calls and texts and that was it. Whenever she had her phone confiscated she got that one instead. She could call if needed and that was enough. Could you do that?

WarmButteryCrumpets · 15/05/2023 08:30

So pretty much everyone agrees:

  1. Get her a cheap brick phone for now
  2. Let her go on the trip because it's important and nothing to do with the phone issues
  3. The real issue is her desperation to bypass your limits (and unless she's a code-cracking genius, it's on you to use better passwords etc
purpleboy · 14/05/2023 22:44

doodleygirl · 14/05/2023 19:28

I think you have a much bigger problem than broken phones. Your 10 yr old is already outsmarting you regarding screen boundaries and your response is to ban a trip which I assume would be screen free. Maybe stop allowing smart phones/tablets and work on boundaries. She is 10, it will be so much harder when she is older.

Agree with this.
She is showing you she isn't mature enough to own a phone, time to be the parent.

GOW56 · 14/05/2023 22:39

I don't think a ten year old.needs a phone but she does need to go on the school residential trip which presumably isn't a holiday.
Tennis still very young It sounds as though she has become very obsessed with technology does she have any other hobbies or interests?

AccountantMum · 14/05/2023 22:25

If the school trip is one that the whole year group goes to it seems harsh to not let her go because she broke a phone and forgot a password to another.

I think it makes more sense to just not replace the phone as I can't imagine a 10 year old really needs a phone - if you are close enough for her to walk to school does she really need one for that? And I imagine not having a phone for a year or 2 would encourage someone to look after a phone/other things more than missing a school trip.

IfIGoThereWillBeTrouble · 14/05/2023 21:57

Personally I wouldn’t even let her have a brick phone, but if you do, make it really uncool - get one of the phones with giant buttons that are marketed towards the elderly!

Better still, “threaten” her with one of these Doro phones that don’t even have a keypad! https://www.doro.com/en-gb/shop/mobile-devices/easy-phones/doro-780x-iup/?variationCode=7978&gclid=CjwKCAjwjYKjBhB5EiwAiFdSfnIozygLWbrwgr2hbCJrPcJC7KfZAKms3onCMEj8afbkBJYDtmSE-xoCiw4QAvD_BwE

Doro 780X IUP - - Doro

https://www.doro.com/en-gb/shop/mobile-devices/easy-phones/doro-780x-iup/?variationCode=7978&gclid=CjwKCAjwjYKjBhB5EiwAiFdSfnIozygLWbrwgr2hbCJrPcJC7KfZAKms3onCMEj8afbkBJYDtmSE-xoCiw4QAvD_BwE

Cc1998 · 14/05/2023 20:50

I dont understand how she's "broken" the second phone.

LimeCheesecake · 14/05/2023 20:49

Another saying the punishment doesn’t fit, so the punishment should be no internet access without adult supervision. At all, until year 7/she’s proved herself to be capable.

remove the phone, she gets an old dumb phone with no internet access if you want her to have a phone for the school walk ( something like this )

your tablet is removed to a locked drawer (with key). She is not allowed access without you there, 1 hour a day max, you set a timer, she doesn’t touch it apart from that.

at 10 if she’s trying to find ways round parental controls, she’s already got a problem with screen usage.

Nokia 110 4G Deals, Contracts & Pay Monthly | Tesco Mobile

Explore the Nokia 110 4G contract deals available at Tesco Mobile. A reliable phone that has been designed with simplicity in mind. Free UK delivery.

https://www.tescomobile.com/110-4g?color=charcoal&tariff=500mb&s_kwcid=AL!12341!3!610177121176!!!u!346445316184!&&&&&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=CjwKCAjwjYKjBhB5EiwAiFdSfmao6weafxSokJGu6EdgpVPcu0xaORs0P6GvzrcPT2vfqlGs9kaQoRoCGeAQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

Shadowworry · 14/05/2023 20:48

WheelsUp · 14/05/2023 19:05

Get her an embarrassing phone- the £18 Nokia sounds perfect. Hopefully peer pressure will mean that she will cave in and give you the passwords and email address that she used.

This and factory reset the other one or take it to a place that can. Change the WiFi, iplayer, and Netflix password and tell her she can earn them back when she earns your respect agsin.

TheIsleOfTheLost · 14/05/2023 20:46

The breaking of the phone is an accident. I have smashed more phones than most as I am accident prone, so wouldn't see thst as an issue. The security controls part is though. Get the device reset and only accessible with your fingerprint so there is no code to guess. Then she can have some screen time when you are there to supervise, but not alone looking at unsuitable content.

Snugglemonkey · 14/05/2023 20:45

To me, the consequence should be related to the behaviour, so I would not cancel the trip. I would just not replace the phone.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/05/2023 20:40

I’d be much more worried that she’s actively bypassing the security measures on your devices and her phone - a good indication she’s not mature enough for unsupervised access and for that reason I’d be removing her phone and access to any devices, not finding a replacement unless is was a brick or one of the cheap watches you can phone her on.

My two know I’ll look at their phones at any time for any reason, look at their messages and browsing history etc etc. If for any reason they’re reluctant to show me or change the passcode they lose the phone/device. By passing screen limits, creating new emails or profiles is an absolute no for me, I wouldn’t be replacing the phone, and certainly wouldn’t be taking them off a school trip to pay for it. They’d be going without a phone.

Cloud9Super · 14/05/2023 20:40

The punishment doesn’t really fit the crime. Also - your ten year old is more tech savvy than you?! Says more about your ineptitude than her I think, and I imagine that’s what you’re secretly pissed off about.

TallerThanAverage · 14/05/2023 20:39

Your DDs school will allow phones on the residential.

that should be Your DDs school will allow phones on the residential?

Pammela · 14/05/2023 20:39

I actually would be less worried about the breaking of phones (she is 10, but I agree it’s annoying) and more worried about how she knows about bypassing screen time and then why she wants/feels she needs more access to screen time.
Ask her what she wants more time for- have a calm and open discussion about it all. Hopefully you can come to some agreement which avoids the lying etc.

ForestDad · 14/05/2023 20:39

I think that as well as having no/brick phone you need to address the lack of trust that her bypassing your controls has created.

DD needs to show she is trustworthy by changing her actions and attitude.

AtlasSeven · 14/05/2023 20:37

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/05/2023 20:23

I've never understood why kids need phones either. They whole "it keeps them safe" notion baffles me - how does that work? Do they say to abductors "Can you hang on while I phone my Mum?" or some such.

Someone on here said to me that in my day, there were phone boxes from which we could phone home in an emergency and there aren't any now, why is why kids need phones. I couldn't be arsed to reply that hardly any of us had phones at home when I was a kid. I was 21 before my parents had one installed!
.

My 11yr old has a phone because he goes to school on a school bus. The school’s too far away for him to walk.
So the phone gives him a way to contact us if something goes wrong with the bus.
He’s got a basic brick phone that just does phone calls and texts though.

FWIW my parents have had a phone for as long as I can remember.