Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what highly processed food you eat?

544 replies

Lifeswhatyoumakeit73 · 14/05/2023 17:35

I haven’t read the Dr Chris book yet about highly processed food but I have read other stuff & it’s made me super conscious of how much HPF we eat. I cook mainly from scratch but as a family of 3 pescatarians & me who is mainly plant based but eats eggs, I realise I need to look at what we eat & make some changes. I cook from scratch as much as I can but I am a busy mum who works full time so we do reply on some HPF. Looking in my cupboards:

We have:

  • baked beans
  • veggie sausages
  • veggie mince
  • oat milk
  • vegan cheese
  • vegan butter
  • Tacos
  • crackers, crisps, bread sticks
  • shop bought houmous
  • shreddies, weetabix
  • caramel wafers
  • yoyos
  • couple tins veggie chilli
  • peanut butter (whole earth so just peanuts but still bad apparently)
  • jam
  • seeded bread sliced
  • bagels

How bad is that? How does it compare to others? I use veggie mince to make a spag Bol from scratch but will, for example, use lentils instead.

i feel like most of our food is cooked fresh but judging by this list, we have a lot of processed crap that I hadn’t registered.

Aibu to ask you to share so I can compare?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
ostentatiousocelot · 23/05/2023 14:33

What I find a bit weird is that often you can get basically the same product, taste and price wise - but one will be UPF/have various additives and the other won't be. So for e.g. Philadelphia (UPF) vs Waitrose Essentials cream cheese (non UPF, and often much cheaper). Lindt/Green and Blacks/most other brands of milk chocolate (contain emulsifiers and sometimes other things) vs Waitrose No. 1 milk chocolate (no emulsifiers, similar price point). Sainsbury's organic tinned tomatoes (contain tomatoes + citric acid) vs Suma organic (5p more per tin, contain only tomatoes). So in many cases it can't be THAT difficult to manufacture without all the additives.

maybein2022 · 23/05/2023 13:54

@MMMarmite sorry those weren’t great examples, I totally agree- it’s very easy to think you’re eating ‘healthily’ but actually eating mostly UPF, in the examples you’ve given but also in things that on first glance look like a better option, than a chocolate bar, for example, but are actually worse.

Even Philadelphia cream cheese is UPF I think- it certainly had an ingredient in I wasn’t sure about!

freespirit333 · 23/05/2023 13:36

Probably nearly everything we eat. I only buy things at the supermarket due to convenience/cost, never at a local butchers etc.

Cereals (weetabix, shreddies etc), overnight oats made with yoghurts like Skyr, frozen fruit. Oat and soya milks.

All types of bread (sliced, pitta breads, bagels)

Condiments, spreads (Lurpak), jam, sandwich fillings like ham, Philadelphia.

Never buy things like pasta sauces but use chopped tomatoes for those. Sometimes use normal rice but often the pouches of rice/grains for convenience. Pasta, noodles. Oven food like fish fingers, fish cakes, sausages, chips or wedges. Baked beans.

Yoghurts, biscuits, chocolate bars, crisps, sweet and salty popcorn, cereal bars, kiddie fruit bars/snacks. Rice cakes, crackers. Ice cream, ice lollies. Sugar free fizzy drinks, juice, squash.

We eat fairly healthily as a family, I think, lots of fruit and veg, lean meat proteins/fish, always wholegrain bread, pasta (not rice, can’t stand brown so always basmati or long grain white), very rare takeaways, don’t drink much alcohol. But loads of UP. I really can’t lose sleep over it I have to say.

MMMarmite · 23/05/2023 13:32

maybein2022 · 23/05/2023 13:24

@RedRosette2023 I think that’s why some kind of scale is needed, I think it’s crazy that, for example, a seeded, wholemeal bread is UPF but so is a doughnut or a crunchie or a dairylea lunchable- and this is what I mean about a scale of risk and what PP have mentioned. I’m much less concerned about using some supermarket seeded bread with a shorter ingredients list- I’ll link the one I use when not using bakery- than I am about any of the examples of junk UPF food I’ve given! So I think like I said before I’m not going to be obsessive about it.

Re kids snacks out and about- I guess if you have time to bake some cake or biscuits in the evening and then freeze and just take out what you need. Yo yo fruit bears are not UPF although obviously a lot of fruit (and therefore sugar) packed into a condensed form. I also cut of chunks of cheese from a block for snacks, also the usual fruit and veg sticks, plain crisps with just potatoes and oil, some popcorn maybe is ok.

I agree with not being obsessive about it.

I disagree with only worrying about doughnuts and crunchies. It's obvious that those should only be eaten in moderation.

But you could have a breakfast and lunch of eating cereal, supermarket bread, margarine, cheap peanut butter or low fat cream cheese or cheap ham, and it would seem fairly healthy and yet be 80% upf. I think the jury's still out on how harmful those products are, but if they are worse than their natural alternatives, the insiduous way upf can take over the "healthy" parts of our diets worries me.

maybein2022 · 23/05/2023 13:24

@RedRosette2023 I think that’s why some kind of scale is needed, I think it’s crazy that, for example, a seeded, wholemeal bread is UPF but so is a doughnut or a crunchie or a dairylea lunchable- and this is what I mean about a scale of risk and what PP have mentioned. I’m much less concerned about using some supermarket seeded bread with a shorter ingredients list- I’ll link the one I use when not using bakery- than I am about any of the examples of junk UPF food I’ve given! So I think like I said before I’m not going to be obsessive about it.

Re kids snacks out and about- I guess if you have time to bake some cake or biscuits in the evening and then freeze and just take out what you need. Yo yo fruit bears are not UPF although obviously a lot of fruit (and therefore sugar) packed into a condensed form. I also cut of chunks of cheese from a block for snacks, also the usual fruit and veg sticks, plain crisps with just potatoes and oil, some popcorn maybe is ok.

RedRosette2023 · 23/05/2023 12:41

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/05/2023 20:21

I think some things on that list are worse than others. For example bread, some bread can have only flour and salt and yeast as ingredients. Some have loads of other shit. I generally think things I couldn't make myself are the worst eg cereals are worse than bread. But not sure if that's just in my head. What's wrong with peanut butter where the ingredient is just peanuts and nothing else?

I've started making baked beans, they freeze and reheat well and are a million times nicer than the canned type.

Agree somethings are worse than others and I’m struggling to wrap my head around how things can still have a decent nutrional value but be UPF. 🤯

Any ideas of non-UPF snacks for kids?

We do carrot sticks, fruit etc. But like to keep some snacks in my changing bag and also to throw at whinging kids when it gets too much in the afternoon!

Atm it’s usually a biscuit! I’ve realised that most of the UPF in my cupboard is supplied by MIL..! She just stuffs the kids full of absolute junk. It’s frustrating as it’s not just the odd biscuit she chases them around with bags of food praising them for stuffing their faces 😂 it was such a point of contention with my ex SIL that my MIL accused her of malnourishing her kids…

Qazwsxefv · 23/05/2023 11:01

Also big plea to those going to home made oat milk and also giving this to children under 5 as one of their main calorie sources, please check with a dietician first. I’m out of date but it was alpro growing up or oatly barista were the only nondairy milks that had enough calories for littles, you can’t match that with home made oat milks.

Also remember all white flour/bread by law in the uk has added calcium, iron, niacin, and thiamin so you’re going to find that on the ingredients list of flour/bread whatever you do. Not sure if that makes all white bread/baking UPF containing by default - guess it depends on how the vitamins are made!

Qazwsxefv · 23/05/2023 10:48

Undisclosedlocation · 22/05/2023 15:04

Well maybe( I genuinely don’t know, not trying to be snippy) but sugar is not a UPF. Is malted barley? I know it’s at the very least a processed product and ideally wouldnt contain anything beyond flour/yeast/salt but that’s not my first concern. Making my own bread isn’t an option right now and probably isn’t for many here. I’m just looking for less bad options

I’d say you’re fine with malted barley. It is a fermented grain. it os essentially barley left to soak and start to ferment, making sugar yes but also yeast to make the bread rise and give it flavour like a soughdough dough. Barley flour is a traditional bread ingredient and definitely not an UPF. Using malted grains is a traditional way of getting additional yeast and is something you could do at home if you so wished, sort of like making a sourdough starter yourself but with grains not flour.

After all yeast only works with sugar - if you don’t add sugar to bread (and you don’t need to) it uses the sugar in the wheat flour (flour is a carb, so it’s lots of glucose bits joined together on a chemical level). Bread therefore contains sugar, agree no added sugar is needed but claiming bread has no sugar is like saying fruit has no sugar.

RedRosette2023 · 23/05/2023 10:08

@Evenstar I agree re being angrier and think we’ve all sleep walked into this too led by big corps.

But re gluten free - my guess is it needs more processing to be made into something it’s not? I’ve been coeliac for 20+ years now and the alternatives when I was first diagnosed were truly disgusting. I think it’s probably the processing that’s allowed them to produce what they do and then taste pretty good.

QueenLagertha · 23/05/2023 09:01

@lljkk it's all connected. Very interesting. Give it a google

lljkk · 23/05/2023 08:40

QueenLagertha · 22/05/2023 19:52

@lljkk your brother has severe mental illness. Huge link between the gut microbiome and mental illness. Gut dysbiosis manifests differently in different people. This is likely how his is presenting.

mmmm... I tend to agree with the docs that years of tweaking (crystal meth) fried his brain. Tweakers tend not to eat at all.

Evenstar · 22/05/2023 21:48

I have been gluten free for 10 years, I haven’t got a diagnosis of coeliac, but after severe reactions in terms of joint pain and exhaustion after having gluten, my doctor felt there was no merit in going back on gluten to be tested.

I have started reading Dr Chris’ book and have been horrified how much gluten free food is ultra processed. I was already careful about checking labels but feel I now need to steer clear of bread, cakes and pastries unless I bake them myself. We should all be angrier than we are about our food being adulterated, I think it is especially upsetting that “free from” food which is catering for those who may already have severe medical issues is full of these additives.

maybein2022 · 22/05/2023 21:12

That’s interesting re Nova- I have noticed some very odd anomalies so it’s definitely a case of using judgement, looking carefully at ingredients and not obsessing about it I think.

Whichnumbers · 22/05/2023 20:49

Undisclosedlocation · 22/05/2023 19:02

Biscoff are rated as Nova 3 on the app. Likewise several shortbreads, doves farm fruity oat, duchy organic stem ginger. Bizarrely a Sains TTD choc chunk cookie is a 3 as well!

All of which make me deeply suspicious of the app’s reliability in all honesty.

https://www.verywellhealth.com/defining-ultra-processed-foods-is-debated-5509462

To ask what highly processed food you eat?
QueenLagertha · 22/05/2023 19:52

@lljkk your brother has severe mental illness. Huge link between the gut microbiome and mental illness. Gut dysbiosis manifests differently in different people. This is likely how his is presenting.

Mumsday · 22/05/2023 19:11

ostentatiousocelot · 22/05/2023 09:25

Re school lunches, it annoys me that nurseries and primary schools clearly have to follow really strict guidelines about fat, salt and sugar - but not UPFs. So they are serving up UPF cereal for snacks, cheap bread etc, and now there's a big push in our local authority area towards veganism too (sorry - "plant based diets") which would be fine if it actually was proper plants (vegetables and pulses) rather than fake meats, fake milks, cheap spreads instead of butter, etc. Given that everywhere is nut-free and they can't live on beans as the sole source of protein, I think it's really inappropriate for small children given all the research on UPFs that's been coming out for years.

100% agree with all of this!

Undisclosedlocation · 22/05/2023 19:02

Biscoff are rated as Nova 3 on the app. Likewise several shortbreads, doves farm fruity oat, duchy organic stem ginger. Bizarrely a Sains TTD choc chunk cookie is a 3 as well!

All of which make me deeply suspicious of the app’s reliability in all honesty.

AtomicBlondeRose · 22/05/2023 17:59

Shortbread tends to have the shortest ingredient list - all-butter of course.

ostentatiousocelot · 22/05/2023 16:04

Has anyone found non UPF biscuits of any kind? We don't buy biscuits much anyway, but it would be useful to know. I do sometimes bake using rich tea biscuits, so those would be a particular plus.

Stravaig · 22/05/2023 15:48

I find it easier to cut entire categories of food. I don't do well with milk, so I rarely drink it, but never go near highly processed substitutes. I don't eat much meat or fish, so I base my meals around vegetables, not plants tortured into fake meat dishes.

Even so, I think it's always worthwhile to look for the best possible version of whatever we do still want to eat. Sure, we may be kidding ourselves a bit (or a lot) but it all helps move us in a healthier direction.

Ice cream. If you're not using the delicious homemade ice-cream recipes posted earlier 😍 then look at Haagen Dazs Vanilla. Cream, condensed milk, sugar, egg yolk, vanilla extract. That's it. Easy to add berries or lemon zest or grated dark chocolate. It's about the only widely available brand that has recognisable ingredients, and even then only in a few traditional flavours. Small local indies are often good too. Anything else, absolutely not (for me).

Peanut butter. Can be just ground peanuts (eg. Meridien), or peanuts/good quality oil/salt (eg. Whole Earth). OR it can have cheaper oil plus added sugar, stabilisers, etc (eg. Sun Pat, supermarket own brands).

Bread. Baked at home or in an artisan bakery, better; mass produced for supermarket with lots of added gunk, not.

Yoghurt. Traditional plain cultured milk, fine. Anything added, whether sweeteners or flavours or protein powder, not so much.

Breakfast cereals. For me, processed carbs are essentially a bowl of sugar, so I don't. I have oat groat porridge in winter. But if I had to have a cereal, then I might mix up a muesli based on oats, or, if it had to be a supermarket box, I think Shredded Wheat are the only thing that is just 100% wholegrain wheat, nothing added. Everything else has added sugars and is fortified to make up for the nutrients stripped in processing.

(Mostly I have a vegetables and eggs based breakfast/lunch - though eggs are tricky and expensive to find just now.)

The other thing I remind myself is just how much taste buds adjust over time! To the point where previously delicious foods taste sickly sweet or 'claggy' or 'dead'.

The trouble with everything I just wrote is that the best quality items are also the most expensive. So we're forced into carefully planned, highly selective food choices, and fewer calories overall. In truth, great for the health of most of us - but hell if you're trying to feed a family, most of whom aren't even on board in the first place.

ostentatiousocelot · 22/05/2023 15:33

That Waitrose chocolate is good - I buy it quite often. There are other non UPF plain milk chocolate bars too - Divine and Montezuma's (also Montezuma's milk chocolate buttons). Only the plain ones by those brands are totally non UPF I think, but Seed and Bean also do a really lovely lime and chilli milk chocolate bar. I even found a non UPF white chocolate bar somewhere, but that was £££ unfortunately.

maybein2022 · 22/05/2023 15:11

Agree- it’s finding stuff that is a happy medium! I do a lot of cooking from scratch for meals but I’d like to find options that are ‘less bad’ (for want of a better word!) UPF wise. I found some chocolate from Waitrose which I don’t think is UPF, will add image. Also I discovered that Waitrose sell Gails sourdough, again I don’t think UPF although expensive 🙄. The main confusion for me is oils- so it seems to be that cold pressed rapeseed oil is ok, but rapeseed oil is in a LOT of stuff, and it’s not going to be the cold pressed type… but often in the ‘better’ foods that’s the only UPF so maybe that’s better than some other things.

Also, re chocolate, obviously it’s never going to be a great choice because of the sugar- but if the choice is between one with no emulsifiers and one with…