Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have 11 year old get himself ready and go to school alone?

109 replies

NoahandIsaac · 14/05/2023 16:44

Hi, I've had to get a new job (I start at 6am) there's no flexibility with this, but it pays well and I need this salary to cover our living expenses (single mum).

My son is 11 and in year 6, but will obviously be starting secondary school this year. His primary school is in our village and he honestly usually meets up with friends and walks by himself. When he starts secondary school, I'm sure he will walk himself to the school bus stop and meet his friends there as well. Thing is, I won't be there when he wakes up, so he needs to get himself up (we have already been working on that this past year anyway, with him setting his own alarm, obviously I'm up already and would be there to ensure he did actually get up, but it's been going fine and he will usually get up to his own alarm).

He's capable of making some toast or cereal for breakfast and obviously gets himself ready. I finish before school ends, but he always walks himself home anyway, but I'll be there every day when he returns. Obviously still available for all after school activities and things. It seems like it will work really well, apart from him obviously being on his own in the mornings. Would this bother you and would it be unreasonable to expect him to be okay on his own every morning?

OP posts:
Voerendaal · 14/05/2023 22:47

Fair enough Rampantivy. Apologies. I was just getting frustrated with some of the comments about how inappropriate it was for an 11 year old to get themselves to school. Of course some kids will be more mature than others at this age and more able but I honestly believe that most kids blossom when given some independence and responsibility. Mollycoddling our children because of what if and just in case is not helpful. So sorry - I got it wrong - I thought you were celebrating an independent 22year old 🤣🤣🤣🤣

maryberryslayers · 14/05/2023 20:31

If he's happy it seems ok. No different from waiting around for you to get home if you worked later and will set him good habits for the future. I'd definitely give him a call each morning just to check he's ok.

My only thoughts would be that you do have the ability to answer your phone a any time if he really needed you and that there is a trusted adult near by if he needed help.

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 20:27

I would advise caution about advertising the fact there is a child alone in the house at that time actually.

CeliaNorth · 14/05/2023 20:23

If he doesn't show up at school in the morning (imagine he gets hit by a car crossing a road or similar) and it's harder for you/school to figure out where he might be

He'll be in school uniform. If he's involved in an accident on the way to school, it will take police attending about two seconds to work out where he's supposed to be, if he's unable to tell them. If his uniform/school bag is marked with his name, they'll also know who he is. School won't have to figure it out; they'll be informed.

TheRevolutionmaywellbetelevised · 14/05/2023 20:01

Do people imagine this mother has lots of choices????

OP my DS of the same age is fiercely independent and would cope no problem. All of us understand that it’s not the happiest solution, but we’re far too tactful to point that out.

Do what you have to do. You’re doing it for the right reasons. As others have said, when he gets home you’re there to ask him about his day and give him an ear and some encouragement.

I wish you both well. Hope the job goes well and that your son manages perfectly well.

CrumpetsandJammmm · 14/05/2023 20:01

I think it sounds fine. I’d put plenty of contingency plans in place in case - a neighbour he can knock at if he’s feeling worried about something in the house, a friend’s parent he can knock at or call if he needs to. And phone him as he should be getting ready to leave the first week or so. Maybe sets lots of timers on his phone and have a good timetable on the wall to help him out.

fishonabicycle · 14/05/2023 19:57

My son did that at 11 - I went to work very early, and husband (who had got up with him til then) had to start earlier too, so we had no choice. He was very good about it, and only overslept once I think!

TheRevolutionmaywellbetelevised · 14/05/2023 19:56

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 14/05/2023 17:29

I agree with the poster who said that primary schools wouldn't be keen if they knew. Equally, I think many secondaries would be a bit uneasy if they knew about this. But there's not anything they can actually do about it. Not the walking to school alone, but the getting up alone and having to lock the house up every day.

For me, there are two big risks:

He forgets to lock the house up properly.

If he doesn't show up at school in the morning (imagine he gets hit by a car crossing a road or similar) and it's harder for you/school to figure out where he might be, as you don't really know when he left. And actually, you don't know if he's at home and just hasn't woken up.

I think in the unlikely chance something did happen, it would be viewed as a bit neglectful.

But as I say, in most circumstances, there's nothing that could be done, even if a school was unhappy with the set up, unless they felt he was being neglected on a wider level.

Jesus Christ. Fancy asking a single mother who is trying to put food on the table to IMAGINE HER CHILD GETTING HIT BY A CAR.

Is that your idea of supportive?

You astound me. Truly.

Ali2710 · 14/05/2023 19:55

How would you manage if he woke up and was unwell and not able to go to school? I think it should be fine for an 11 year old to do this and you clearly have little choice but perhaps you can think of back up plans for uneventualities?

RampantIvy · 14/05/2023 19:40

@Voerendaal what I mean to say was that although DD was independent way before 22, she is now completely independent living and working away from home since she graduated. Just that some DC take longer than others.

BaggyTrousersBT · 14/05/2023 19:39

I know my kid and he’d be fine. Also it’s much nicer to have you home early … that’s way more use to him than morning which is essentially swallow breakfast and leave. Lots of first years come home to an empty house, you’re just doing it the other way round. Congrats on the job

Jonniecomelately · 14/05/2023 19:31

My main concern would be them not locking the door properly and leaving the house unlocked all day. Our front door is quite awkward to lock.

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 19:31

This is what I mean though @DivorcedAndDelighted . An eleven year old can be left overnight but that doesn’t mean you should.

It’s completely different to dressing a three year old who can do it themselves. There’s a massive difference between independence and unsupported. I don’t think some posters understand the difference. Nineteen year old chooses to move out to live with their mates at uni with their parents’ blessing - independence. Nineteen year old chucked out because parents have had enough of him - unsupported.

TumbleFloat · 14/05/2023 19:31

He will be fine. As you have the Ring doorbell you can see when he leaves and triggers the camera you can speak to him through that if needed and see him lock up. Let him practise now, just out the house and locking the door. Maybe put a checklist on the back of the front door so he can make sure he has done everything before he leaves ie got his bag, lunch whatever.

Mine had their front door key on one of those retractable key rings which was attached inside their school bag so the key was always with the bag. My friend's son turned 11 on the 31st August and started secondary a few days later so literally just 11.

Also get him to shout bye as he comes out of the house meaning anyone watching thinks someone is in there. I used to do this when I came into the house too.

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 19:28

Irrespective of the OP, who I appreciate is having to do this, there really is no mad rush towards independence.

It can become a bit daft on here sometimes with posters falling over themselves with tales of what they did and how young they were when they did it.

I do not for a moment think it’s wrong but I wouldn’t do it personally and I don’t think it’s an ideal setup.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 14/05/2023 19:25

A bit OT but re independence and being capable at this age - the Montessori principle of never doing anything for a child which she can do for herself is so true.
They will not learn if we do things for them. That’s not just lip service, they truly Will Not Learn. Without the opportunity to practice and make mistakes, their coordination cannot develop. Without fussing with that zipper or button or shoelace, they Will. Not. Learn.

Learning is a coordination of mistakes and practice and repetition, until the right skills in the right sequence come together and can be repeated.

When we prevent the practice, we prevent the learning, and then we really are an Obstacle to Development.

baandek.org/posts/never-help-child/

ohjeesus · 14/05/2023 19:25

My mum was a teacher she had to leave at 7am everyday, i went to school by myself when i was 9 and my sister was 8! Depends on the area and the child

Lemonademoney · 14/05/2023 19:25

Can you pack his bag the night before and leave it by the door? Set some alarms up to prompt him through his morning? Set his breakfast stuff up so it’s waiting for him as he gets up? I’d probably recommend getting a ring door bell so you can see him coming and going. I’d also chain clip got his front door key to his school bag so he can’t lose it.

Its not ideal but it’s definitely doable…

weareallout · 14/05/2023 19:20

@Postapocalypticcowgirl I think that's a very paranoid stance. I live in an urban area and it's perfectly normal for yr4/5 kids to walk to school solo. No yr6 has a parent walk with them unless they really want it. I work from home but start work before my Yr6 goes out so I largely leave them to it.
All Yr6 and a lot of Yr5 walk home alone.

DragonflyLady · 14/05/2023 19:18

My daughter was capable of getting herself ready and to school in Y6 - but secondary has hit hard and if I wasn’t chivvying her along and walking her to the bus stop, she wouldn’t get to school. So just consider how he might change.

weareallout · 14/05/2023 19:17

Defo invest in a key safe. Phone him at 8am to check he is on track

junebirthdaygirl · 14/05/2023 19:14

Be good for him to have his shower every night before bed as teen boys can sometimes try to dodge this if left alone. Uniform and lunch ready and off he goes. Think him waving to you at the door is a great idea and the Summer holidays are nearly here.

Wenfy · 14/05/2023 19:12

Can you ask any of your neighbours or his friends’ parents for help? My daughter’s friend’s mum is a nurse, has shift work, and I so I do let her sleep over during the week as needed. I then wake them all up. At 11 I think the biggest concern would be if they woke up ill - there have been days when my dd’s friend has woken up poorly & I’ve kept her with me.

ButterCrackers · 14/05/2023 19:11

Should be fine. Get him to message when he’s up and then when he arrives at school even if you can’t response immediately as you’re at work. It could be an idea to let the school know that he’s up and out on his own in case of any problems or he doesn’t arrive.

buellerbuellerbueller · 14/05/2023 19:06

Admittedly this was before mobiles and Ring doorbells, so may be overkill nowadays!

Swipe left for the next trending thread