Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No party invite and DD upset shall I text mum?

361 replies

helpMeWritethis · 14/05/2023 08:45

I’m a little upset and wondering if I should say something to this mum or just leave it as I usually do. I have never had any confrontations with any of the mums ever so it’s a new territory for me to even think about texting this mum!

my daughter is friends with another little girl they both in year 4. My daughter came home upset Friday saying all the girls in class have been invited to a party on Saturday and “Emma’s” mum will call me later to give details as Emma will ask mum if my daughter can come. She kept asking me every few minutes on Friday evening and Saturday morning if she’s called. It must so heartbreaking. I’m socially awkward but my daughter is complete opposite and loves going to parties but never gets invited. She really thought “Emma” would invite her.

I’m thinking of texting the mum with a heads up that my DD might ask her tomorrow and maybe we can arrange a playdate something along those lines.

just for context my DD having birthday next month and I’m inviting the entire class.

OP posts:
Mala1992 · 16/05/2023 18:59

Blossombathing · 16/05/2023 18:50

What on earth does ‘stay in your lane’ even mean when we are talking about an eight year olds party??!!

Stay in your lane

It means nothing much when your child is ‘winning’ like my DC2 did on popularity stakes from the outset.

It means something a whole lot more painful in a school year like I had with DC1 when they were being bullied (bad enough), but class teacher was endorsing it and a fair few parents got on board.

Dibbydoos · 16/05/2023 18:58

Yes I'd text her.

Tandora · 16/05/2023 18:58

Blossombathing · 16/05/2023 14:20

Call me whimsical but surely if we have young children it’s far healthier that they grow up in am inclusive, caring environment and learn to feel secure and safe in their communities including school. Surely that is the most healthy outcome for a child - especially when they are young.

So I don’t really understand why any parent would want their child to learn the cynical, manipulative, game playing behaviour that can happen later in life anyway. It sounds like the old fashioned school of hard knocks, you had better get used to exclusion and rejection now kiddo, there is more where that is coming from. It’s quite sad and detrimental.

The aim shouldn’t be what my kid wants for s party, my kid gets. Surely we should be teaching our children kindness, inclusiveness and values. We raise every kid out for himself at our peril. Good team players, a moral compass, understanding difference are key planks of development, how will that be achieved for the child that is told it’s okay to not care about others?

Absolutely this

ootb · 16/05/2023 18:58

Above not with reference to OP's post though which seems more of a mix up.

ootb · 16/05/2023 18:57

The responses are interesting, and I think show the "inner child" in a lot of people.

I grew up in a competitive, very well to do and bitchy (both students and parents) area... But as an adult, I've grown out of this insecure "scarcity mindset" myth, where there has to be an out-group for there to be an in-group. I now know inclusion actually feels pretty nice.

Yes logistics exist, but if you HAVE to exclude just ONE child for Precious Little Timmy to have his Sherpa Guided Volcanic Everest adventure... Is it more about proving something? Some inner insecurity or wound that was never fixed in childhood?

Parents who exclude just 1 or 2 children may not necessarily take pleasure in it, but they definitely still have this scarcity mindset, whether in terms of belonging or £ ("it's my money I'm spending, therefore it's my tool of exclusion").

Blossombathing · 16/05/2023 18:50

Lefteyetwitch · 16/05/2023 16:05

I disagree. We don't need to burden ourselves or our children with the feelings of every Tom, Dick and Harry around them.

Our choices shouldn't affect others. So my child's choice of birthday party is nothing to do with some other child who has decided to have feelings about it.
I think a more important lesson is stay in your lane

What on earth does ‘stay in your lane’ even mean when we are talking about an eight year olds party??!!

Mala1992 · 16/05/2023 18:47

Notanothermoan · 16/05/2023 17:21

So sad for your DD ☹️ unfortunately the same happened with my little girl (7) twice and I was heartbroken too. She was at a school with 8 girls in the class, DD included and was excluded from a sleepover party, I’m good friends with the mom and when she found out DD was upset from her own daughter she messaged me saying how sorry she was and how she knew what this was like as her own son was often excluded due to his sensory issues, later found out that all the girls apart from mine had been invited, some to just spend the day there and go home and some to stay over, I was a little miffed and couldn’t understand why my girl had been excluded but left it at that, I personally would invite all or none at all, couldn’t bare to think of any other children feeling how mine did, especially as she’d always been invited to every birthday party to every child in the past. Another occasion was a little girl with not the nicest mom, often falling out with moms on the playground if their children had had a disagreement, unfortunately it was my turn this time and her daughter handed out the invites infront of mine and then turned to her and said ‘you’re not invited’ this broke her heart, I spoke to her teacher about this as I felt it was bullying. She is in a new school now and the girls seem much nicer.

That’s the thing. Sometimes it is just parents point scoring/settling old scores/trying to keep their child as a ‘popular one’.

That’s where I think some schools have made rules - they’ve seen enough of this behaviour and the effect it has on dynamics. It runs counter to the vibe the school is trying to promote

Radishy · 16/05/2023 18:29

This happened to me and my friend when we were in a small class, we just weren’t popular enough. My mum decided to invite the whole of my year and my brother’s year minus the two horrid girls who left me and my friend out to the most awesome Halloween party. We were legends. The girls came to apologise as their mums hadn’t realised they’d left us out - never any harm in a little taste of one’s own medicine!

Tiredalwaystired · 16/05/2023 17:36

QueefQueen80s · 16/05/2023 11:55

Not if it's 10 out of 11/12 boys/girls.

What is this obsession with single gender parties on this thread? Dont kids mix any more? The broad message here seems to be if they had six girls and four boys from their class because they were their friends it is ok, but ten girls is not? What on earth does genitalia have to do with any of this?

Notanothermoan · 16/05/2023 17:21

So sad for your DD ☹️ unfortunately the same happened with my little girl (7) twice and I was heartbroken too. She was at a school with 8 girls in the class, DD included and was excluded from a sleepover party, I’m good friends with the mom and when she found out DD was upset from her own daughter she messaged me saying how sorry she was and how she knew what this was like as her own son was often excluded due to his sensory issues, later found out that all the girls apart from mine had been invited, some to just spend the day there and go home and some to stay over, I was a little miffed and couldn’t understand why my girl had been excluded but left it at that, I personally would invite all or none at all, couldn’t bare to think of any other children feeling how mine did, especially as she’d always been invited to every birthday party to every child in the past. Another occasion was a little girl with not the nicest mom, often falling out with moms on the playground if their children had had a disagreement, unfortunately it was my turn this time and her daughter handed out the invites infront of mine and then turned to her and said ‘you’re not invited’ this broke her heart, I spoke to her teacher about this as I felt it was bullying. She is in a new school now and the girls seem much nicer.

Lefteyetwitch · 16/05/2023 17:13

I am. Because you can have empathy for people without burdening yourself with their problems.

So being sad their not invited to a party is a them problem. You can understand why they are sad. Empathise with them, yea that does suck.

And still not change the behaviour. Because there is nothing wrong with it.

HarrietJet · 16/05/2023 17:06

Lefteyetwitch · 16/05/2023 16:05

I disagree. We don't need to burden ourselves or our children with the feelings of every Tom, Dick and Harry around them.

Our choices shouldn't affect others. So my child's choice of birthday party is nothing to do with some other child who has decided to have feelings about it.
I think a more important lesson is stay in your lane

Stay in your lane?? 😵‍💫
You must be raising fabulous, empathic people. Bet they make you so proud.

mummysherlock · 16/05/2023 16:33

OP unless your DD is a prolific bully it is extremely unlikely that she has been the only girl excluded on purpose.
’All the girls have been invited to Emma’s party except me’ most likely means 3, 4, or 5 girls have truly had an invite due to the activity having a restriction on numbers, but ‘Emma’ is trying to push her luck a bit and have more friends there so she has said to DD (and the other uninvited girls) ‘I will ask my mum if you can come and get her to text your parents the details.’ Cue lots of excited girls and DD getting the impression everyone is going.

You mention that your DD doesn’t get invited to parties: By year 4, it is mostly have a few friends over for a sleepover or a trip to the cinema territory, they don’t tend to have ‘parties’ as such. As only a few people can be invited to these sort of things, it generally tends to be the birthday child’s closest friends that make the cut. If your DD is the type of child that talks to and gets on well with everyone, but doesn’t really have ‘close’ friends this may explain why invite’s don’t happen. Maybe ask her who she would like to be closer friends with and invite those kids for some play dates (could be from school or from out of school activities) and see if those friendships develop.

If you are happy to have a whole class party for your DD next month and that is what she wants, then go ahead, but be aware that it is unlikely to lead to lots of reciprocal party invites for your DD from her classmates as most whole class parties die off after year 1 and most kids her age will have preferences for the activities above. Also if it is not really what your DD wants, and you are doing it because you think it is kinder or more inclusive, that’s not great either if she would rather do something different. It is indeed very unkind to have a large party and exclude just 1 or 2 children in the class, but fine to have a much smaller event with just a handful of kids where those not invited are in the majority.

And don’t text Emma’s mum. The party has now been and gone and nothing good will come of it. Also don’t tell DD ‘Emma’s mum forgot’ she is nearly 9 years old and needs to know the truth and that she can’t get invited to everything, or she will ultimately struggle more as she gets older.

saraclara · 16/05/2023 16:33

I didn't ask the mum, as at the end of the day it's up to her who she has at her daughters party - although I am a little standoffish with her now. But said child will not be coming to my daughters birthday.

So @JustWingingIt8 you acknowledge that it was up to the mum who she had at the party, but you're going to punish her child for it?
That's not just spiteful, it's totally illogical.

familyissues12345 · 16/05/2023 16:30

Relieved my children are over the age of having class birthday parties!

The worst incidence during primary school was one mum who thought her son was going to be invited to a party, even bought a present and told him all about the impending party. He didn't get an invite (was mainly family with a few school friends) and she caused a real stink over it, about how disappointed her son was etc - why tell him before the invites came out?! It was embarrassing and the party mum felt awful even though she had nothing to feel ashamed of.

Parties bring out the funny side of people

Bib1234 · 16/05/2023 16:25

helpMeWritethis · 14/05/2023 09:04

Thank you all. I think I’m definitely not going to text the mum! It will just escalate. I’ll text her for a playdate instead.

im going ahead with my daughters party next month and will be inviting the whole class. It’s really cruel to leave kids out.

It’s not really cruel to leave kids out - some people literally can’t afford to invite the whole class or even more than one or two

TallerThanAverage · 16/05/2023 16:17

JustWingingIt8 · 16/05/2023 14:30

Lovely human being, my daughters a bullet to be dodged - typical nasty mumsnetter.
It's called ratios, it's up to my daughter who she chooses to attend for the number of children allowed.

Nasty? I’m not the one excluding the 8 year old child from a party with friends out of spite. Missing the party and you chaperoning was the dodged bullet not your child. Just to remind you of your comment::

A similar thing happened to my daughter.
She's in YR3 and her whole friendship group got invited to a party apart from her. I felt so heartbroken for her, I think we all just want to shield and protect our children from any heartbreak.
I didn't ask the mum, as at the end of the day it's up to her who she has at her daughters party - although I am a little standoffish with her now.
But said child will not be coming to my daughters birthday.

no mention of ratios, funny that.

Lefteyetwitch · 16/05/2023 16:05

Blossombathing · 16/05/2023 14:20

Call me whimsical but surely if we have young children it’s far healthier that they grow up in am inclusive, caring environment and learn to feel secure and safe in their communities including school. Surely that is the most healthy outcome for a child - especially when they are young.

So I don’t really understand why any parent would want their child to learn the cynical, manipulative, game playing behaviour that can happen later in life anyway. It sounds like the old fashioned school of hard knocks, you had better get used to exclusion and rejection now kiddo, there is more where that is coming from. It’s quite sad and detrimental.

The aim shouldn’t be what my kid wants for s party, my kid gets. Surely we should be teaching our children kindness, inclusiveness and values. We raise every kid out for himself at our peril. Good team players, a moral compass, understanding difference are key planks of development, how will that be achieved for the child that is told it’s okay to not care about others?

I disagree. We don't need to burden ourselves or our children with the feelings of every Tom, Dick and Harry around them.

Our choices shouldn't affect others. So my child's choice of birthday party is nothing to do with some other child who has decided to have feelings about it.
I think a more important lesson is stay in your lane

Greensleeves · 16/05/2023 15:55

JacquiPan · 16/05/2023 14:37

Sounds like she really doesn't have those assumed social skills given she is always left out and certainly don't e courage her to confront the mother of the other child. No-one likes a precocious narcissist! I doubt she was excluded due to numbers as the rest of the girls in the class went. She was excluded because of her. May be a little harsh but you should be aware that there are issues here that need addressing if you do not want your daughter to be a social outcast all her life...

Have you got something prickly in your knickers? What a foul, pointless comment Confused

HeartStarRose · 16/05/2023 15:38

Hard though it is, in this sort of situation, it's least said, soonest mended.

It will blow over long before any awkwardness that results from texting the mum would.

JacquiPan · 16/05/2023 14:39

She may have lied to you out of awkwardness. If the child did not want your son there, I doubt the mum will tell you that!

JacquiPan · 16/05/2023 14:37

Sounds like she really doesn't have those assumed social skills given she is always left out and certainly don't e courage her to confront the mother of the other child. No-one likes a precocious narcissist! I doubt she was excluded due to numbers as the rest of the girls in the class went. She was excluded because of her. May be a little harsh but you should be aware that there are issues here that need addressing if you do not want your daughter to be a social outcast all her life...

JustWingingIt8 · 16/05/2023 14:30

Lovely human being, my daughters a bullet to be dodged - typical nasty mumsnetter.
It's called ratios, it's up to my daughter who she chooses to attend for the number of children allowed.

larlypops · 16/05/2023 14:29

My daughters in a year 4 and only joined half way through last year, the amount of times she comes home mentioning play dates and parties yet out of all she mentions it’s the odd one here and there.
I don’t know the boy/girl ratio in either of my kids class but pretty rubbish if she was the only one

Blossombathing · 16/05/2023 14:20

Call me whimsical but surely if we have young children it’s far healthier that they grow up in am inclusive, caring environment and learn to feel secure and safe in their communities including school. Surely that is the most healthy outcome for a child - especially when they are young.

So I don’t really understand why any parent would want their child to learn the cynical, manipulative, game playing behaviour that can happen later in life anyway. It sounds like the old fashioned school of hard knocks, you had better get used to exclusion and rejection now kiddo, there is more where that is coming from. It’s quite sad and detrimental.

The aim shouldn’t be what my kid wants for s party, my kid gets. Surely we should be teaching our children kindness, inclusiveness and values. We raise every kid out for himself at our peril. Good team players, a moral compass, understanding difference are key planks of development, how will that be achieved for the child that is told it’s okay to not care about others?