Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No party invite and DD upset shall I text mum?

361 replies

helpMeWritethis · 14/05/2023 08:45

I’m a little upset and wondering if I should say something to this mum or just leave it as I usually do. I have never had any confrontations with any of the mums ever so it’s a new territory for me to even think about texting this mum!

my daughter is friends with another little girl they both in year 4. My daughter came home upset Friday saying all the girls in class have been invited to a party on Saturday and “Emma’s” mum will call me later to give details as Emma will ask mum if my daughter can come. She kept asking me every few minutes on Friday evening and Saturday morning if she’s called. It must so heartbreaking. I’m socially awkward but my daughter is complete opposite and loves going to parties but never gets invited. She really thought “Emma” would invite her.

I’m thinking of texting the mum with a heads up that my DD might ask her tomorrow and maybe we can arrange a playdate something along those lines.

just for context my DD having birthday next month and I’m inviting the entire class.

OP posts:
Blossombathing · 14/05/2023 11:22

I am struggling to understand why your solution to this is a play date with Emma?! They didn’t invite dd to the party, so wouldn’t be getting further invites from me.

In your place I would be boosting dd’s confidence with lots of play dates with other children that value her and the friendship.

Teaching dd to run after those that are clearly not as invested will give her low self esteem and lead to people pleasing behaviour.

I would not be contacting the mother, and would find out if it was a whole class party or not ( bullying issues need to be thoroughly checked out)

funtycucker · 14/05/2023 11:12

BungleandGeorge · 14/05/2023 10:49

A whole class party isn’t necessarily expensive if you hire a bouncy castle or similar, the kids are very unlikely to all turn up. Our rule was either all the same sex children or half or less. Inviting almost all is quite unpleasant. But you can’t control other people and she will have to get used to it as it’s unlikely to be the last time something similar happens. I wouldn’t text

You must have a huge garden/ house if you can accommodate 30 children, 30 parents and a bouncy castle in it

SeasonFinale · 14/05/2023 11:11

SoupedUpSue · 14/05/2023 09:01

”all the girls in the class” bar one isn’t a cap on numbers it’s bullying. This is actually not allowed at my kids’ school - it’s in the school rules.

yes text the mum a very bland message specifically asking. “Hi, hope you’re well. My daughter mentioned that XX told her she is having a party next weekend for all the girls in the class and that you’d be able to provide details. Just wanted to check date and time to make sure [my daughter] is free.”

if she says you’re daughter is not invited I would query with the teacher whether it actually was all the girls in the class and potentially escalate it. Utterly shitty behaviour.

Bit we don't knkw this is the case. To an 8 year old it might seem "everyone " else is invited when they mean 6 people are.

Not everyone gets invited to everything. She's done quite well that she has gotten to y4 and nearly end lf school year for this to be the time this realisation kicks in.

It doesn't matter what you plan to do OP for your DD's party. This was obviously a limited numbers one.

Shhhquirrel · 14/05/2023 11:08

SoupedUpSue · 14/05/2023 09:01

”all the girls in the class” bar one isn’t a cap on numbers it’s bullying. This is actually not allowed at my kids’ school - it’s in the school rules.

yes text the mum a very bland message specifically asking. “Hi, hope you’re well. My daughter mentioned that XX told her she is having a party next weekend for all the girls in the class and that you’d be able to provide details. Just wanted to check date and time to make sure [my daughter] is free.”

if she says you’re daughter is not invited I would query with the teacher whether it actually was all the girls in the class and potentially escalate it. Utterly shitty behaviour.

and potentially escalate it

Don’t be ridiculous it’s a kids party, not the Geneva Convention!

Fe1986 · 14/05/2023 11:02

I’d be really surprised if just your daughter wasn’t invited so I’d want to be 100% certain that was actually the case first. Only then I’d have to say something to the mother, from a position of “Is there anything I should know about that’s happened between them, as my DD is also oblivious if there is and was really heartbroken to have been the only one not invited?” I’d also speak to school so they can keep an eye out on anything.

But I really don’t think this will be the case. I’m sure there was a numbers/logistics/cost obstacle. Kids that age are fickle sometimes with their friendship groups and they change them often. They are too young to have a sense of reciprocating invitations too. All too often, they also think someone is their best friend and it’s not mutual. Indeed, they change their best friend frequently too. Although I’m not saying it’s not still hurtful when it’s a smaller group invited and your DD is excluded for whatever reason, whether logistical or not.

You have the right approach: all the class is invited to your DD’s party. I’m sure some will rightly say about keeping costs down with a smaller group but having seen how hurtful it can be for some little ones who never get invited to a party (I’m a teacher), I just wouldn’t do this kind of party personally. But that’s just me. We have however gone really small with a tea party for just a handful of my little one’s cousins - they only have those few so nobody’s left out.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/05/2023 11:01

I wouldn't text. Not getting invited to a party is something that happens.

Help your dd to find a narrative to understand it e.g. Emma would probably have liked you there, but some parties can only have a certain number of people. But we can have a nice time doing X instead.

Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 10:55

SoupedUpSue · 14/05/2023 09:01

”all the girls in the class” bar one isn’t a cap on numbers it’s bullying. This is actually not allowed at my kids’ school - it’s in the school rules.

yes text the mum a very bland message specifically asking. “Hi, hope you’re well. My daughter mentioned that XX told her she is having a party next weekend for all the girls in the class and that you’d be able to provide details. Just wanted to check date and time to make sure [my daughter] is free.”

if she says you’re daughter is not invited I would query with the teacher whether it actually was all the girls in the class and potentially escalate it. Utterly shitty behaviour.

Yep bullying. So glad it’s against your school rules @SoupedUpSue

The invitations handed out at school, the party talked about at school before and after ….. how could this ever be anything but bullying? Weaponising a birthday? Shame on any parents and schools that enable this

Sammyandtheboocas · 14/05/2023 10:53

I think there's some things you need to consider here.

  1. Is your daughter OK socially at school? It seems there's an issue somewhere if she is getting left out of parties regularly.
  1. You CAN control an 8 year old approaching parents in a school yard and making them uncomfortable. I find it a bit 'red flag' that you feel aspect of your daughters behaviour is uncontrollable.
  1. If you are inviting the whole class to your daughters party , the number of eventual attendees will tell you how 'popular' your daughter is with her peers. You may have some work to do if half decline, for example.
  1. Under no circumstances do you pursue an party invite. It's awkward and embarrassing. If your daughter hasn't received an invite it's because she didn't make the original guest list. There wont be a mistake, and the party girl in question here will be just trying to be kind.
BungleandGeorge · 14/05/2023 10:49

A whole class party isn’t necessarily expensive if you hire a bouncy castle or similar, the kids are very unlikely to all turn up. Our rule was either all the same sex children or half or less. Inviting almost all is quite unpleasant. But you can’t control other people and she will have to get used to it as it’s unlikely to be the last time something similar happens. I wouldn’t text

Anotherusernameagainitseems · 14/05/2023 10:47

If she is rarely getting asked to parties and especially for girls she thinks are close friends, I would have a quiet word with the teacher to see if she needs help with social skills. Or if there is some low level bullying going on that the teacher can help sort.

SchoolShenanigans · 14/05/2023 10:46

You sound like a lovely, caring mum.

I probably wouldn't approach the mum, it could be extremely awkward and I think it will come across a bit pushy, especially if Emma doesn't actually want your daughter there but is saying she does to appease your daughter.

Instead, I would focus on your child. Explain to her that lots of parties have limited numbers, especially as they're so expensive. Isn't your daughter lucky to be able to have everyone at hers. Isn't your daughter very mature for understanding. Because she's being so mature about it, you're going to treat her to a lovely trip to XYZ.

If you can come out of this, having taught your daughter to be kind and open, and not judge herself by her friendships, then I think that's better than any party invite.

And things may change, perhaps she's having a tricky time socially now, but she may find the best of friends at secondary.

watcherintherye · 14/05/2023 10:39

I remember being the kid that was left out and it’s fine

I remember being the kid that was invited, but got told by the child in question that she didn’t want to invite me, but her mum said she had to! Still stings!

Motherhubbardscupboard · 14/05/2023 10:37

If it really was all the girls except your daughter, that is very thoughtless but there isn't anything you can do about it. It happened to my DD (almost 20 years ago, but it still makes me cross!). It was only a small class, and this was an at home party so no reason for a limit on numbers that excluded one person. I know for sure she was the only one not invited because it was such a small class and one of the other mums noticed she wasn't there and we talked about it afterwards. What I never worked out was whether she genuinely wasn't invited, was forgotten, or the invitation was lost. How we dealt with it was by holding out own mini party at home - party food, balloons, games and fun. We still talk about it after all this time.

Theydontknowthatweknowthattheyknow · 14/05/2023 10:37

Great if you want to do it but I think that expecting a whole class party in Y4 is being a bit precious tbh. We did a whole class party for my YR dd this year and I'm already done with it. About a 3rd of the class didn't make a response either way so that's 10 kids I'm having to factor into numbers and buy food/party bags for wtc because I don't know if they're coming or not. Then I've found out that quite a few of the kids I invited had large parties but didn't invite my dd. Next year I won't be inviting anyone that didn't even have the curtesy to respond to my invite or who had parties and didn't invite my child. I refuse to waste the money. I'm planning 1 or 2 larger parties but by junior school age I'm fully anticipating that my dd will be able to tell me herself 5-10 kids she really wants at the party. Junior school is the age at which friendships really start to cement and where kids might want to do something a bit more pricey as a party eg sleepover/laser quest/bowling.

In response to pp being responsive to a child's emotions absolutely isn't to mirror their emotions and over-reaction. This is exactly why so many kids are growing up mentally unwell and lacking basic resilience. The correct response IMO is to acknowledge their emotions but mirror an appropriate reaction to their situation. In this scenario staying calm is absolutely the appropriate reaction not going mental at the school or the other kid's mum. Maybe talk to your dd about what is good friendship and what is unkind and gently encourage her to seek out other kids to play with but otherwise let her make up her own mind. When it comes to kid's friendships I personally think that the best approach is to let kids be their own judge of character as this is half of what being a school child is all about. I definitely wouldn't be forcing my child to have an all-inclusive party with kids who don't include her to things. I'd let her decide

DeeCeeCherry · 14/05/2023 10:35

Just leave it OP. You won't say whether or not your DD was the ONLY child not invited, and you've been asked directly more than once - which makes me think, others in class also weren't invited. You should've been bright and breezy and taken her out somewhere really nice and special for the day.

I never did whole class parties when DC's were younger. I couldn't have afforded it. They have cousins of similar ages, were friends with my friends' DCs etc I'd have ended up doing a party for 50+ children. .
So they invited close school friends only. It was fine. They weren't invited to every single party either. I can't recall that any child in class was. You don't know Emma's circumstances ie her family members could have been making up the numbers.

The competitiveness and entitlement over class parties nowadays is ridiculous, parents need to stop fuelling it. I think it's bad form to contact Mum generally.

Canyousewcushions · 14/05/2023 10:32

Tandora · 14/05/2023 10:13

We just dealt with it at home in a bright and breezy way

Curious how this idea of just being upbeat and “not making an issue”/ big deal when your child is hurt at being left out tallies with the modern day advice of validating , not dismissing, small children’s emotions? Of course social rejection hurts - there are very basic evolutionary biological reasons for this. Just being “bright and breezy” in response might not be the simple plaster you think it is.. @Canyousewcushions

But there's also a real need for children to develop the resilience to deal with setbacks.

An element of this is acknowledging that you feel disappointed, but then learning how to pick yourself up and move on is just as important.

A more bright and breezy approach has always worked well in this house- acknowledging that it's disappointing but also out of our control. So let's cheer ourselves up and have fun doing something else rather than moping, dwelling, and feeling hard done by and struggling to move on.

Tiredalwaystired · 14/05/2023 10:32

Tandora · 14/05/2023 09:57

For all those saying it’s not “cruel” to leave kids out - the definition of cruel is “wilfully causing pain and suffering to others, or feeling no concern about it.” Being left out is deeply hurtful and painful to small kids- whether you chose to accept it or not- that’s the reality. You may say it’s justified for x, y, z practical reason, fair enough, but it certainly can be cruel. Own it.

As a PP said, some people are just kinder than others 💁🏼‍♀️.

The key word in this is “wilful”.

If it a finance issue or a capped numbers issue it’s not wilfully designed to upset this particular child.

Its just disappointing and unfortunately, part of life.

MathsNervous · 14/05/2023 10:31

Sound advice OP just to arrange a playdate and say no more about the party.

MathsNervous · 14/05/2023 10:30

None of my children have had whole class parties due to cost. They just pick who they want to be there.

Grimbelina · 14/05/2023 10:30

You need to help your daughter to process this and talk to her about how it wouldn't help/would be inappropriate to bring it up on Monday. She is 8 not 4. It's a good time to start talking about how some people don't consider us friends as much as we do etc. and that friendships change etc. Yes it is painful but by avoiding it and 'keeping her busy' you aren't actually helping her.

Daisypain · 14/05/2023 10:28

Sorry that reply was not to you @Clementinesucks !

Daisypain · 14/05/2023 10:28

Clementinesucks · 14/05/2023 10:21

I’m sure you were a real delight to go to school with.

We all know then men who were given the gift of superiority like your son is having modelled.

Im so glad I’ve shown my kids to be thoughtful of other’s feelings. I’ll never regret that.

RavenclawDiadem · 14/05/2023 10:24

SoupedUpSue · 14/05/2023 09:02

Right that would have been helpful in the opening OP. You need to check with the teacher if it was all the girls bar your daughter. This isn’t ok.

Back in the real world, or at least at the Primary School my kids went to, teachers and school staff did not get involved in party arrangements .

The policy was crystal clear- no class lists would be provided, no party invitations would be handed out by teachers. Parents had to make their own arrangements with other parents. Teachers have 101 other things to be doing rather than party planning for 8 year olds.

Clementinesucks · 14/05/2023 10:21

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 14/05/2023 10:04

I really can't feel bad about this at all.

I don't care if my DS isn't invited to every party. I help him deal with the disappointment and I spend less money on gifts for kids I couldn't give two shits about.

My DS gets to invite the amount of children I can afford to entertain. Who gets on that list is up to him. I only want him to have people there thay he likes and wants to spend time with.

Your all very precious about your little darlings missing out.

I’m sure you were a real delight to go to school with.

ellaballoo · 14/05/2023 10:20

It is very cruel to invite all the every girl and leave one out.
I don’t let my class hand out invitations in the classroom as it leads to a lot of upset.
I don’t think any of my Y4 have had a whole class party though, they seem to get smaller in KS2.