Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Huge argument with DH. AIBU?

189 replies

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 07:11

DH and I have been married for over 10 years, together for around 15. We have two children.

Ons issue that we have had, over these years, is the way DH talks to me when he is upset. He goes into fight mode and will speak in a way that I find aggressive. And I absolutely won’t accept that, although maybe the fact we are still married says different.

DH is usually a really lovely guy. Life and soul of the party, charismatic, friendly, confident. However, if I ever take issue with anything he does or has done, he blows ups

DH also does loads of work around the house whilst also working full time. I work part time whilst studying. I also have a medical condition that is causing extreme fatigue and I am receiving treatment soon that should treat this issue, however I have been pretty useless these last months because I have 0 energy. The qualification I’m studying for is demanding and I’m trying to do this to better our future.

The reason DH and I have fallen out is once again, because of how he speaks to me. However, he has said that he is fed up of feeling like he isn’t valued in our family. He does work hard to provide for us, and he does lots of housework, more than me. What has annoyed him is that yesterday, he did a lot of work round the house and left a pile of things on our bed that he asked if I could sort. I was studying at the time, but said okay. However, my sister called who I have not spoken to in months and I answered the call. DH then got annoyed that I hadn’t cleared the bed. Okay, maybe I was in the wrong here, but he now says that the majority of the time he asks me to do something, I don’t do it. I can’t explain how hectic my life has been lately. The job I do, although part time, is really demanding. The qualification requires around 20 hours of study a week. The kids are still at an age where they need lots of support. I organise all of their clubs and activities and then write a schedule for DH and I for pick ups/drop offs. I buy their clothes and any other things they need. When they go to parties, I sort the presents, I organise their birthday parties. I organise our holidays, and book any weekend activities. I organise play dates etc. All of these things mount up and on top of everything else I have to do for work and Uni, I have very little time left. For example, I can’t remember the last time I watched TV.

DH is saying all of these things about me not pulling my weight, as if it excuses the way he speaks to me. A few weeks ago, he slept in the spare room. I can’t even remember what the disagreement was that caused this, but when our 8 year old daughter woke up, she was concerned by this and asked her dad why he was there. He told her “don’t worry about it, it’s not for you to worry about”. DD was clearly more worried after this reply. I took her to one side and said that mummy had been snoring and that’s why daddy went through there. I don’t feel it’s right to put adult issues onto the children.

I just don’t know what to do. I have suggested counselling and he says it’s not for him. I’ve suggested he tries mindfulness but he won’t. I know I’m not perfect but I do want to bring our children up in a happy home, and I don’t feel we are able to do that. Maybe it’s me that’s causing all this? I just can’t see the wood for the trees at the moment.

OP posts:
Vikingthings · 14/05/2023 09:55

DH won’t agree to this. And also, in your post you imply that his agression is because he is burnt out. He has always spoken to me like that.

Has your situation changed with life pressures over the years? Has he, or you, had other stuff going on before that might have filled your cups up a bit too much? Or even when things were as relaxed as they can be, did he still speak like that?

Ultimately OP if he has always spoken to you like it and you/him don't want to unpick what is going on or why that might be, then maybe you need to think about separating. You can't live on egg shells forever.

How do his family, or did his family, speak to him? I find so much of this stuff comes from how adults were spoken to as children and maybe he has his own issues to work through there. You don't have to be there for that if you don't want to, it depends if you want to stay with him or not. I guess that is the question. Where do you want to be?

Codlingmoths · 14/05/2023 09:54

MiIIiex · 14/05/2023 07:56

You are both on different pages with your illness. You are not doing things around the house because of it, and he is using that against you. So the first thing is to be on the same page. You both have different views of it at the moment.

And secondly, yeah he could fuck off speaking to you like that. If he refuses to change I don't think I could stay with him.

Is she not doing jobs around the house? Or equivalent anyway? She cleans, she cooks, she organises everything for the dc. All the finances. It’s not at all clear that she doesn’t do half. She would have put away the things.
What if you said next time you talk to me like that I am hiring a cleaner. If you really don’t want one you will just have to not be nasty to your wife, let’s see if that’s possible for you.

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 09:51

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 09:48

Temporary help to reduce the load on both (cleaner),

DH won’t agree to this. And also, in your post you imply that his agression is because he is burnt out. He has always spoken to me like that.

It’s all in your posts OP. He has always been rude and aggressive and unfortunately you have always accepted it.

I’m unsure why his word on the cleaner is final - other than he’s controlling and you both seem to agree he has the upper hand.

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 09:50

Backstory: my DH has a chronic illness and is also studying, amongst other things, so I generally do most of the housework whilst also working a full time job. DH does take the children to their weekly activities too.

OP is working PT, studying 20 hours pw, carries the mental load of the kids and their activities. She and DH share housework, although she reckons he does slightly more housework. On top of that OP is currently unwell.

PT job + 20 hours of study = equivalent to working FT, depending on the hours of the job.

CaffeinateMeNow · 14/05/2023 09:49

Whilst I’m sure the root of this argument may have ‘blame’ on both sides, a life lived on eggshells is no life at all. I remember an ex being so similar you your DH and I have never felt as lonely as I did in that relationship. How people manifest anger is so important, and gritted teeth and explosive anger are horrible.

I think you need to emotionally start leaving. Be honest with DH and say you cannot live this way, or allow your children to live this way, and if he decides to accept some responsibility to improve things: great. If not, I honestly think you and your children could be happier without him. Good luck.

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 09:48

Temporary help to reduce the load on both (cleaner),

DH won’t agree to this. And also, in your post you imply that his agression is because he is burnt out. He has always spoken to me like that.

OP posts:
DustyLee123 · 14/05/2023 09:48

The children will fear you splitting up, but they will get over that when they see two parents happily comparenting.
Constantly living in fear or you arguing/tense atmosphere is not good for them, it may well produce anxiety, along with seeing your relationship as normal

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 09:45

Why shouldn't Op take a call & sort the stuff out afterwards?

I’m wondering this. Does no one ever take a phone call if they have any outstanding jobs in their house? Also, is it essential to go on hands free and complete the job? Would no one have their conversation and then do the job later? Like literally never?? I chatted for 20 mins whilst still working on my laptop. I then took the kids to an activity, then came back and sorted the stuff on the bed. Some people believe this makes me an awful wife!

OP posts:
Vikingthings · 14/05/2023 09:43

With the aggression? The pointing gritting of the teeth? Going off at the kids? Naa bullshit would they

"I need some advice handling some things at home.
Backstory: my DH has a chronic illness and is also studying, amongst other things, so I generally do most of the housework whilst also working a full time job. DH does take the children to their weekly activities too.

I do find keeping on top of all of the housework whilst working challenging. I'm usually tired and a bit overwhelmed myself, so I might ask DH to do small jobs such as put a pile of clothes away that are on the bed.

Yesterday I asked him to do this but I later found that he had taken a call from his DB instead and when I looked, the clothes were still where I left them. I'll admit I might not have spoken to him nicely about this but I'm just exhausted from all of the juggling.

I'm finding that I'm becoming less tolerant of the behaviour of my family, even when they do minor things I'm getting angry straight away. I'm probably burning out.

How do I speak to DH about how all of this is affecting me? I have my own communicational issues to work on but I don't know if I can do that if I'm tired all of the time and I'm becoming resentful"

...so, how would that thread go as a woman? This won't have been the only time OP didn't put something away, no offence OP.

There's two sides to every story, the DH (real DH) shouldn't be speaking to OP or the kids like he is but something needs to give so that he can work on his communication. If he didn't sound on the verge of burning out and was feeling hunky dory but still spoke to everyone like that, then it's an issue.

Temporary help to reduce the load on both (cleaner), possibly reducing the activities the kids do, whilst things balance back out. Then when everyone's buckets are less full, they can discuss the way they communicate and potentially seek help with this.

LakieLady · 14/05/2023 09:42

Your description of the way he speaks to you sounds very much like my ex, OP.

That's why he's my ex, and why I ended the marriage.

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 09:38

GabriellaMontez · 14/05/2023 09:32

Your OP is about putting clothes away. But I'm not sure this is the real problem.

Your subsequent posts refer to aggression, finger pointing, shouting. Never backing down. Him justifying his unpleasantness by comparing it to a messy house.

You also have loads going on, so everyone is struggling.

It's a confusing picture tbh. Sounds like you need to have a chat at a calm moment. Not dwell on specific events, but plan a way forward. Do you want to be with him?

Exactly. The real problem is DH’s personality. While OP says she will not accept being spoken to aggressively - the reality is that she does and has done for 15 years.

diddl · 14/05/2023 09:37

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/05/2023 09:35

So he asked you to do one thing and you didn't do it whilst he is doing jobs around the house and you took a call Instead? If this is the kind of thing you do, it would be very annoying. But that also doesn't mean he can talk to you like shit.
Tbh you actually sound incompatible.

Why shouldn't Op take a call & sort the stuff out afterwards?

GabriellaMontez · 14/05/2023 09:36

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 07:36

Surely there's not that much to do making a schedule of pick ups? Once a term and check on a Sunday for the incoming week? Same with presents - just Amazon them or pick a few up at a time and have a presents box, or stick a fiver or a tenner in a card?

The activity schedule changes weekly here and is a logistical nightmare, so a lot more involved in that than you would expect. These are just some of the things I do that he doesn’t consider. I also deal with all our finances etc. I could go on listing things but I don’t want to make this tit for tat, I just want to illustrate that I do a lot for the kids, on top of work and study commitments.

Sounds hectic.
Can you cut stuff until you've finished your course and are feeling better?

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/05/2023 09:35

So he asked you to do one thing and you didn't do it whilst he is doing jobs around the house and you took a call Instead? If this is the kind of thing you do, it would be very annoying. But that also doesn't mean he can talk to you like shit.
Tbh you actually sound incompatible.

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 09:35

@Gardendad He sounds extremely frustrated and although you are sick and do other things he does the majority of it.

It doesn’t sound to me like he does the majority of it. It sounds equal.

Indeed it sounds less like an inequality/injustice pattern problem and more like an aggressive bellowing man problem. He’s also very controlling.

Most men with a sick wife who is also working, studying and carrying much of the mental load of the kids, including some domestic work, would agree to a cleaner at least in the short term to lighten the load for both.

GabriellaMontez · 14/05/2023 09:32

Your OP is about putting clothes away. But I'm not sure this is the real problem.

Your subsequent posts refer to aggression, finger pointing, shouting. Never backing down. Him justifying his unpleasantness by comparing it to a messy house.

You also have loads going on, so everyone is struggling.

It's a confusing picture tbh. Sounds like you need to have a chat at a calm moment. Not dwell on specific events, but plan a way forward. Do you want to be with him?

loislovesstewie · 14/05/2023 09:30

Pointing a finger at the OP isn't what a good man should do.

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 09:29

Cloud9Super · 14/05/2023 08:24

Your DH sounds annoyed that his ingrained idea of a wife has not been fulfilled, ie you do not cook/clean/do all the menial household work. Well. Tough shit to him. He sounds to do about the same as I do, work full time and do loads around the house, the same as many working parents. Can’t quite see his issue to be honest. Get rid, he’s a bully and an aggressive one at that.

OP does cook and clean as per her posts.

LadyJ2023 · 14/05/2023 09:26

You can tell the women that don't have a good guy like yours lol. My hubby exactly same absaloutely wonderful around the house helping with our 4 kids etc etc etc it was hardly unreasonable to be asked to put a small pile of washing away considering your saying yourself how much he does. Cmon I also have a medical condition on treatment for life since I had thyroid removed and some days its like hitting a brick wall of tired that never goes and I cant praise hubby enough for what he does to help. Funnily enough when we first got together I used to say why did he raise his voice if we disagreed on something. Now I know he actually doesn't even know he is doing it and actually it doesn't matter at all because he isnt nasty or swearing or anything at me when we disagree his voice just changes and that's him. Be grateful for what you have seriously you also have a very good man there. I'm always doing little things to show how much I appreciate hubby working and still doing a ton at home especially the days I'm struggling badly. We make a very good team and rarely disagree anyhow so it's all good.

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 09:23

I thought a cleaner would change my life, and it really hasn’t.

I do have a much younger child than the OP, but the cleaner comes Friday morning. By Saturday things are ‘busy’ again and by Monday it’s reverted back to norm.

What does make a difference is time, but if you don’t have it, you don’t. I ended up with an unexpected afternoon off this week due to a last minute cancelled medical appointment. I pulled out all the furniture downstairs, swept, mopped and hoovered, really cleaned thoroughly. Looked amazing. If I had that time every week all would be well.

It could be the OP is just fundamentally lazy, but I have to say I don’t like other people deciding what I do. Either the stuff being out away is of crucial, paramount importance, so the person it is important to can do it themselves, or it is not, in which case it can wait until a good moment. The only exception to this is when it’s something someone genuinely can’t do and it really is urgent (the memory of half begging DH to do a food shop days after my EMCS are still fresh in my mind!) but while I did find that really infuriating it isn’t a reason for aggression.

Theunamedcat · 14/05/2023 09:23

Vikingthings · 14/05/2023 08:36

I also think if this was written from a man's perspective (woman doing the cleaning etc, man not putting things away) nobody would side with the OP...just saying.

With the aggression? The pointing gritting of the teeth? Going off at the kids? Naa bullshit would they

Julti · 14/05/2023 09:22

You both sound unhappy. If you left him, would you manage on your own with all the housework by yourself and the studying and work with your health issues? There doesn't seem to be an easy solution.

BananaCocktails · 14/05/2023 09:18

Gardendad · 14/05/2023 08:53

A really useful thing I learned is that a lot of couples arguments hinge on justice/ injustice themes. So you think its unjust because.., he counters and says its more unjust for him etc.
He sounds extremely frustrated and although you are sick and do other things he does the majority of it.
Therefore when he asks you to do something, you agree and then dont do it thats probably quite maddening because it probably feels like you do not appreciate his effort. There is no excuse for his communication style but you would be better discussing why he is so frustrated and adressing that. A cleaner will rebalance some of your contribution and help you both. Communication is your problem though not cleaning.

This

BananaCocktails · 14/05/2023 09:16

Organising activities and holidays for your family isn’t you pulling your weight
it sounds like you barely do anything around the house and because he works so hard in a full-time job and has almost everything in the house. He is starting to feel quite resentful which I don’t blame him. To be honest. He probably forgets that you have a medical condition, but we are all human and nobody can be perfect all the time and it can be hard living with someone who doesn’t lift their fingers much Yes he blew up at you but really you should understand that cleaning and sorting out a whole house after working all day can be really stressful and I guess he’s just tired. No he shouldn’t have shouted at you for not clearing the bed. You are not his child however maybe try to find ways where you can pull your way a bit more
agree with him that you should do some tasks around the house, which you find easier to do such as putting clothes away doing the laundry or the washing up et cetera. That way he doesn’t have to feel so pressured to do everything.
get the kids to help as well .

Setyoufree · 14/05/2023 09:10

It's hard to say without being there but hitting the roof about seemingly small things like DD kissing a stone can be a sign of someone who's just utterly burned out.

Why didn't you put your phone on speakerphone and put the washing away at the same time? I have to say I'd be pretty pissed off if I'd spent a day tidying the house and DH spent hours talking on the phone and didn't do the 1 thing I'd asked for