Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Huge argument with DH. AIBU?

189 replies

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 07:11

DH and I have been married for over 10 years, together for around 15. We have two children.

Ons issue that we have had, over these years, is the way DH talks to me when he is upset. He goes into fight mode and will speak in a way that I find aggressive. And I absolutely won’t accept that, although maybe the fact we are still married says different.

DH is usually a really lovely guy. Life and soul of the party, charismatic, friendly, confident. However, if I ever take issue with anything he does or has done, he blows ups

DH also does loads of work around the house whilst also working full time. I work part time whilst studying. I also have a medical condition that is causing extreme fatigue and I am receiving treatment soon that should treat this issue, however I have been pretty useless these last months because I have 0 energy. The qualification I’m studying for is demanding and I’m trying to do this to better our future.

The reason DH and I have fallen out is once again, because of how he speaks to me. However, he has said that he is fed up of feeling like he isn’t valued in our family. He does work hard to provide for us, and he does lots of housework, more than me. What has annoyed him is that yesterday, he did a lot of work round the house and left a pile of things on our bed that he asked if I could sort. I was studying at the time, but said okay. However, my sister called who I have not spoken to in months and I answered the call. DH then got annoyed that I hadn’t cleared the bed. Okay, maybe I was in the wrong here, but he now says that the majority of the time he asks me to do something, I don’t do it. I can’t explain how hectic my life has been lately. The job I do, although part time, is really demanding. The qualification requires around 20 hours of study a week. The kids are still at an age where they need lots of support. I organise all of their clubs and activities and then write a schedule for DH and I for pick ups/drop offs. I buy their clothes and any other things they need. When they go to parties, I sort the presents, I organise their birthday parties. I organise our holidays, and book any weekend activities. I organise play dates etc. All of these things mount up and on top of everything else I have to do for work and Uni, I have very little time left. For example, I can’t remember the last time I watched TV.

DH is saying all of these things about me not pulling my weight, as if it excuses the way he speaks to me. A few weeks ago, he slept in the spare room. I can’t even remember what the disagreement was that caused this, but when our 8 year old daughter woke up, she was concerned by this and asked her dad why he was there. He told her “don’t worry about it, it’s not for you to worry about”. DD was clearly more worried after this reply. I took her to one side and said that mummy had been snoring and that’s why daddy went through there. I don’t feel it’s right to put adult issues onto the children.

I just don’t know what to do. I have suggested counselling and he says it’s not for him. I’ve suggested he tries mindfulness but he won’t. I know I’m not perfect but I do want to bring our children up in a happy home, and I don’t feel we are able to do that. Maybe it’s me that’s causing all this? I just can’t see the wood for the trees at the moment.

OP posts:
QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 10:45

Vikingthings · 14/05/2023 10:40

Because yet again a MN thread has gone straight for the nuclear button 'LTB, call Women's Aid' option and marriages aren't as simple as that. Nowhere has OP said she wants to end the relationship and given how snappy and defensive she's being in her posts, I wonder if time outside the house doing something not work/kids/chores related might help the both of them to relax enough to have a calm, considered conversation about their issues. If her OH still reacts like an arse, she has her answer. But there's definitely two sides to this one.

^ this. I remember when I said something in a post once and everyone started screaming LTB at me. My DH is an absolute star and I was horrified at the responses because we had a minor blip that I dared to express online - and god forbid he had depression, which was causing the issue!

It's why I'd never share any of the rows or disagreements I have with my DP on here! I do wonder how many women have blown up their marriages after posting on MN and whether they ever come to regret it. Obviously in some cases the woman absolutely should get the hell out without a backward glance – DV, financial abuse, aggression towards DC etc – but sometimes the situation is more opaque and I think this is one of them. It's clear OP and her OH are both exhausted and struggling and while he definitely needs to be kinder in how he talks to her is divorce really the best and only option as others are suggesting?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/05/2023 10:45

I might be going against the grain here but I dont think he has any reason to have a go at you.

You did clear the stuff from the bed, just not immediately. Some jobs have to be done straight away (eg clear the table so you can eat off it, wash something before using it) but clearing something from a bed only needs to be done before you sleep surely. Me and my husband often ask each other to put the kids clothes away etc and dump them somewhere...we leave the other person to schedule it in when its convenient for them.

Why does he get to make all the decisions? He decides you wont get a cleaner. He decides which jobs need doing and when, he decides that the jobs he allocates you aren't good enough, he decides that the way he speaks to you is acceptable even though you've said it upsets you. It sounds like there is a big power imbalance here.

What does he actually want from you? You work part time, it sounds like you do all the mental load, and your share of childcare and study the rest of the time. It would be different if you were sitting on the sofa watching TV while he was running around cleaning but you're not, it sounds like you dont get much of a break either. He won't listen or action any of your suggestions like cleaners or counselling either.

So I'd ask him to sit down and list specifically what he actually wants you to do, and why, and what he thinks you can drop

I dont know if this will help though as it sounds he has an 'I'm the boss' attitude that I can't see improving. If he won't go to counselling then maybe get some yourself to see how you feel about leaving. If you are already going down the path of leaving you could say you will leave if he speaks to you like that again or if he doesn't try counselling with you...but I think youd need to be prepared to follow through

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 10:44

MN overreacts in some cases, but it also under-reacts in others. There are staggeringly low expectations of men in some quarters and a tolerance and expectation of male aggression.

In my house, this guy wouldn’t have made 6 months of dating, if he’d never even made a month.

NeedToChangeName · 14/05/2023 10:44

Vikingthings · 14/05/2023 08:36

It’s stuff on the bed. Why is it worth getting so het up about (him, not you!)

I actually totally understand why he got annoyed about this. I do about 85% of the housework and after spending ages doing it all, might leave a small pile of clothes for DH on the bed to put away (his own things). Very frequently it just gets put on the floor, picked up by me, put on the floor...it's infuriating because it's not a big job.

Everyone is busy but it really doesn't take much to do small jobs around the house especially when one person is doing most of the housework.

OP, you and your DH both sound burnt out. What the children is over hearing isn't ok but I wouldn't blame DH entirely for this (although he DOES need to learn to regulate). If you can afford a cleaner, I think it would solve a few arguments. If not, I think you should put small piles of things away if he asks you.
I don't think studying is an ok reason to opt out of this stuff IMO.

@Vikingthings if I have a pile of stuff for someone to put away, I put it in a box. And add to it. And then move it to the spare bedroom. And then tidy it away in the garage. So, if it's not emptied, it's not my problem

BonnieBobbin · 14/05/2023 10:43

He shouldn't be aggressive. If that's a deal breaker for you then you need to take steps to leave. You say you've been unhappy about it for ages but you're not doing anything to change that pattern except asking him to change. That hasn't worked for the last ten years. It isn't going to work now. You can go to relationship counselling on your own.

On the tidying the bed / phone call issue. I'd be annoyed if I asked DH to do something. He said he would do it. Then spent ages on the phone to a sibling or friend instead. You can sort stuff whilst on the phone. It would also annoy me if he then complained he was always too busy/tired to do anything - when he'd just spent ages on a phone call (proving he obviously wasn't too busy/tired to take the call and that the fatigue was only relevant as an excuse to do something I'd asked him to do).

Smallyellowbird · 14/05/2023 10:42

He sounds very unsupportive and very unpleasant to live with. He's not doing anything to help improve your home life - not agreeing to a cleaner, or your relationship, by not agreeing to counselling. He sounds like he's not focusing on your children's sense of security or happiness, and that he's getting increasingly selfish.

In an ideal world people step up when their partners are unwell - he's not doing this, he's trying to manage you to maximise your productivity.

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 10:41

It’s true that MN often overreact, I’m not denying that for an instant. But I really do struggle to justify jabbing a finger in a face. That’s not acceptable at all IMO.

It may not have to mean end of the line, but it does have to change - surely we all agree on that!?

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 10:41

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 10:37

Because yet again a MN thread has gone straight for the nuclear button 'LTB, call Women's Aid' option and marriages aren't as simple as that. Nowhere has OP said she wants to end the relationship and given how snappy and defensive she's being in her posts, I wonder if time outside the house doing something not work/kids/chores related might help the both of them to relax enough to have a calm, considered conversation about their issues. If her OH still reacts like an arse, she has her answer. But there's definitely two sides to this one.

He’s always been angry, aggressive and belittling according to the OP: how do you propose date night to fix that?

Vikingthings · 14/05/2023 10:40

Because yet again a MN thread has gone straight for the nuclear button 'LTB, call Women's Aid' option and marriages aren't as simple as that. Nowhere has OP said she wants to end the relationship and given how snappy and defensive she's being in her posts, I wonder if time outside the house doing something not work/kids/chores related might help the both of them to relax enough to have a calm, considered conversation about their issues. If her OH still reacts like an arse, she has her answer. But there's definitely two sides to this one.

^ this. I remember when I said something in a post once and everyone started screaming LTB at me. My DH is an absolute star and I was horrified at the responses because we had a minor blip that I dared to express online - and god forbid he had depression, which was causing the issue!

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 10:40

See I don’t think the OP is being snappy or defensive at all 🤷🏼‍♀️ I just don’t see it. She seems bewildered to me, if anything.

I do think housework can be a MN ‘trigger point’: there are a few. I remember posting annoyed because my husband followed me into the toilet to tell me I left my work lanyard out and the consensus was I was an unreasonable slob!

He could be a decent guy but decent men don’t jab their fingers in their wives’ faces.

Thelnebriati · 14/05/2023 10:37

Your DH is only lovely as long as things are going the way he wants them.

The sensible solution to the problem would be to have a cleaner, which he has refused. You could both learn to communicate more effectively by going for counselling but he won't.
These are indications he is controlling. They are red flags. Please consider going for counselling just for yourself, and look at The Freedom Program website.
https://www.freedomprogramme.co.uk/graphic.php

Dominator and Mr Right Graphic Freedom Programme

Freedom Programme Dominator and Mr Right Graphic in all languages

https://www.freedomprogramme.co.uk/graphic.php

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 10:37

Kiwimommyinlondon · 14/05/2023 10:20

Why on earth would the OP want to have a night out with this guy? It doesn’t sound like ‘fun’ in any shape or form. A dinner out isn’t going to resolve his aggressive manner and fundamental lack of respect.

Because yet again a MN thread has gone straight for the nuclear button 'LTB, call Women's Aid' option and marriages aren't as simple as that. Nowhere has OP said she wants to end the relationship and given how snappy and defensive she's being in her posts, I wonder if time outside the house doing something not work/kids/chores related might help the both of them to relax enough to have a calm, considered conversation about their issues. If her OH still reacts like an arse, she has her answer. But there's definitely two sides to this one.

Marchintospring · 14/05/2023 10:30

So split.
Whats stopping you? Children adapt, plenty of women have done it.

Its pointless expecting him to change. He’s always been like this. I suspect half of it is your reaction. On some level he wins by annoying you. It doesn’t sound like you are making him happy either.
Honest question, do you think he might be happier out of the relationship?

LightlySearedontheRealityGrill · 14/05/2023 10:30

I had a partner jab his finger in my face while aggressively berating me, it is abusive, demeaning and threatening. Your husband needs to work on himself, but if he's never wrong, thats not going to happen. I think all this usually stems from childhood issues, over critical parenting, which he is now enacting on your children. Id be throwing down some ultimatums, he needs to get help or the marriage is not going to last.

Fairislefandango · 14/05/2023 10:23

It's clear from your posts that you are not being lazy or messy, or failing to do a reasonable amount of housework, in spite of your health issues. It's also clear that your husband has pretty rigid 'my way or the highway' attitude towards household tasks (and is maybe a bit obsessive about cleanliness and hygiene, judging by his reaction to your dd and the rock).

Not only doesn't he seem to be able to consider the concept that his way isn't necessarily automatically the 'right' way, he is also very angry about it and has a long history of talking angrily and aggressively to you. This isn't ok at all, and I doubt he will change. This isn't something you should live with, or that your r dc should grow up seeing.

Kiwimommyinlondon · 14/05/2023 10:20

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 09:55

You both sound defensive in the way you communicate to be honest. You are snapping back at posters who are offering mitigation for why your DH might be reacting as he does, so it's easy to imagine that's how you are IRL too.

This is something I and my DP struggle with. When we're both exhausted and overwhelmed by all our responsibilities, it can quickly descend into a competition of who is most the most put upon and we do end up talking to each other unkindly.

When was the last time you went out as a couple and had some fun?

Why on earth would the OP want to have a night out with this guy? It doesn’t sound like ‘fun’ in any shape or form. A dinner out isn’t going to resolve his aggressive manner and fundamental lack of respect.

Jewel1968 · 14/05/2023 10:17

I think you have too much on your plate. You work in a demanding job, studying, have a health condition, mum to young kids and are in a relationship with someone who doesn't seem to appreciate that. To me your health condition alone should be enough for you H to be kind let alone the other stuff.

Options:

  • get a cleaner anyway and ignore his objections
  • reduce your working hours
  • take career break from work until your health has stabilised or you finish your study or both
  • reduce the activities your kids do

Overall I think you need a conversation with H and try and get him to understand that you really do have a lot on your plate and that you both need to think about solutions or accept that the house will be a bit messy.

billy1966 · 14/05/2023 10:13

OP,

You and your children are being abused by an angry, aggressive man.

I think your children are hugely aware of the toxicity of his behaviour and there will be long term consequences.

His anger and aggression towards you is a long term issue.

This is so bad for your children to be around.

Please call Womens aid for a chat.

You need to simplify the childrens activities to lighten your load.

You need to talk to your husband about time apart.

He can accuse you of what he likes.

Tell him his anger and aggression is scary for you and the children and you intend to seek support outside the family.

Talk to your GP.

He sounds like he is working hard and very resentful.

It can be hard when life is as busy as you describe BUT his anger has ALWAYS been an issue.

Far better that you live apart than your children grow up witnessing this atmosphere.

Reach out to family and friends for support.

Unfortunately the environment you describe can cause stress, anxiety, self harm and depression, substance abuse in teens.

This invariably becomes a life long burden.

Take this very seriously.

I'm so sorry that life is so hard for you.

Batalax · 14/05/2023 10:08

I get it. Quite often people like this might have a point, but they’d be far more effective if they speak with a normal tone rather than over reacting in the first instance.

diddl · 14/05/2023 10:05

PLus Op is studying to benefit the whole family-not just for shits & giggles!

Although of course that would be OK if it had been agreed!

Outofthepark · 14/05/2023 10:00

OP it's way worse for your kids living with this stress and tension in the house now, than it would be if you both spent some time apart.

Time apart can give relief, clarify things, make you both appreciate what each other does more, etc, or make clear you're happier apart. Co parenting can definitely work if the parents are openly civil, or even on good terms, and that will make the kids feel secure. It's just not a tenable situation at the moment and it needs a meaningful change. Stuff like a cleaner is just a temporary plaster, and the argument over the clothes on the bed was clearly over more than the clothes on the bed.

Alainlechat · 14/05/2023 09:57

I think your husband does not consider what you do as the equivalent to his input and effort, when really looking at your posts it seems roughly in line but your husband doesn't think this.

Therefore he thinks he is entitled to give you tasks and react aggressively when not completed within his timeframe.

Mindyourfingers · 14/05/2023 09:57

@SquashAndSqueeeze , I think that it is the insistence (that is shared by some posters) not so much that the jobs need to be done, or that you mind doing them, but that they are not done there and then it is worthy of aggression that worries me.

I get some things have to be done within a certain time frame but this isn’t one of them.

My DH wouldn’t dream of being aggressive but I’ve had to tell him to cut it out before, as I work term time only. He used to work predominantly from home and on school holidays - on the ONLY couple of days every couple of months I had peace and quiet - he’d be in and out with this needs doing and that needs doing. I know and I will do it but when it suits me!

Banditdog · 14/05/2023 09:56

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 07:36

Surely there's not that much to do making a schedule of pick ups? Once a term and check on a Sunday for the incoming week? Same with presents - just Amazon them or pick a few up at a time and have a presents box, or stick a fiver or a tenner in a card?

The activity schedule changes weekly here and is a logistical nightmare, so a lot more involved in that than you would expect. These are just some of the things I do that he doesn’t consider. I also deal with all our finances etc. I could go on listing things but I don’t want to make this tit for tat, I just want to illustrate that I do a lot for the kids, on top of work and study commitments.

I really think you are making out you do a lot more than you really do. I deal with our finances, I wouldn’t even register it as a task, it is what fifteen minutes online once a week? I have also undertaken study recently, a masters and there is no way I would use that as an excuse to not do housework either.

It sounds like he is fed up of doing everything and asking you to do very simple tasks like moving stuff off the bed and you won’t even do that.

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 09:55

You both sound defensive in the way you communicate to be honest. You are snapping back at posters who are offering mitigation for why your DH might be reacting as he does, so it's easy to imagine that's how you are IRL too.

This is something I and my DP struggle with. When we're both exhausted and overwhelmed by all our responsibilities, it can quickly descend into a competition of who is most the most put upon and we do end up talking to each other unkindly.

When was the last time you went out as a couple and had some fun?