Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Huge argument with DH. AIBU?

189 replies

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 07:11

DH and I have been married for over 10 years, together for around 15. We have two children.

Ons issue that we have had, over these years, is the way DH talks to me when he is upset. He goes into fight mode and will speak in a way that I find aggressive. And I absolutely won’t accept that, although maybe the fact we are still married says different.

DH is usually a really lovely guy. Life and soul of the party, charismatic, friendly, confident. However, if I ever take issue with anything he does or has done, he blows ups

DH also does loads of work around the house whilst also working full time. I work part time whilst studying. I also have a medical condition that is causing extreme fatigue and I am receiving treatment soon that should treat this issue, however I have been pretty useless these last months because I have 0 energy. The qualification I’m studying for is demanding and I’m trying to do this to better our future.

The reason DH and I have fallen out is once again, because of how he speaks to me. However, he has said that he is fed up of feeling like he isn’t valued in our family. He does work hard to provide for us, and he does lots of housework, more than me. What has annoyed him is that yesterday, he did a lot of work round the house and left a pile of things on our bed that he asked if I could sort. I was studying at the time, but said okay. However, my sister called who I have not spoken to in months and I answered the call. DH then got annoyed that I hadn’t cleared the bed. Okay, maybe I was in the wrong here, but he now says that the majority of the time he asks me to do something, I don’t do it. I can’t explain how hectic my life has been lately. The job I do, although part time, is really demanding. The qualification requires around 20 hours of study a week. The kids are still at an age where they need lots of support. I organise all of their clubs and activities and then write a schedule for DH and I for pick ups/drop offs. I buy their clothes and any other things they need. When they go to parties, I sort the presents, I organise their birthday parties. I organise our holidays, and book any weekend activities. I organise play dates etc. All of these things mount up and on top of everything else I have to do for work and Uni, I have very little time left. For example, I can’t remember the last time I watched TV.

DH is saying all of these things about me not pulling my weight, as if it excuses the way he speaks to me. A few weeks ago, he slept in the spare room. I can’t even remember what the disagreement was that caused this, but when our 8 year old daughter woke up, she was concerned by this and asked her dad why he was there. He told her “don’t worry about it, it’s not for you to worry about”. DD was clearly more worried after this reply. I took her to one side and said that mummy had been snoring and that’s why daddy went through there. I don’t feel it’s right to put adult issues onto the children.

I just don’t know what to do. I have suggested counselling and he says it’s not for him. I’ve suggested he tries mindfulness but he won’t. I know I’m not perfect but I do want to bring our children up in a happy home, and I don’t feel we are able to do that. Maybe it’s me that’s causing all this? I just can’t see the wood for the trees at the moment.

OP posts:
QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 11:33

Kiwimommyinlondon · 14/05/2023 11:18

Perhaps your expectations are simply lower. I wouldn’t put up with this bullshit and nor should the OP. But if you think a night out will resolve things that’s your prerogative.

My expectations are not lower by any means but I wouldn't blow up my marriage on the say so of an internet forum.

TheShellBeach · 14/05/2023 11:33

Why are you doing all this to yourself?
You say you're exhausted but you're studying for another qualification?
Is this reasonable?
And FWIW I would also be less than impressed if you didn't tidy up a few things.

JoyceMeadowcroft1 · 14/05/2023 11:29

Some of your responses, OP, suggest that your understandable desire to put your children at the centre of your decision making, is limiting what you are open to considering.
Whilst reducing their clubs/activities might not be the best thing for them, what would be the benefits for you and/or your DH? Would this also bring about some benefits for them?
Whilst separating from your DH, whilst that would cause them distress, what would be the benefits for you? In turn, what would be the benefits for them?

I think it would be helpful to you if you thought about the above in some detail. You may still come to the same conclusion, but this might pave the way to identifying a tipping point. You can consider what is your tolerance point whereby you would decide to reduce activities/ commitments or leave your husband? At what point would you think that it is in your children's' best interest, even if you felt able to tolerate the upset for yourself.

OwlsRock · 14/05/2023 11:28

thoughtsofmoog3 · 14/05/2023 11:23

Before any talks or thoughts of divorce, have an honest, grown up conversation.
Marriage is hard, divorce is hard - choose your poison!

Relationships can be saved by a couple actually properly communicating - agree to be kind and talk with respect, and realise that each of you may have to face up to uncomfortable truths. Stop point scoring (both of you)

Easier said than done- few things worth working for are.

Yes. The issue of his angry response to her feedback needs fixing as a key part.
If he is not willing then it's a different discussion.

Chances are he won't be willing. Ime.

I hope I'm wrong.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 14/05/2023 11:28

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 11:07

These sound like fraught conversations had in the midst of rows. I'm just suggesting a different way. But hey, what do I know. LTB, take him for all he's got, get your ducks in a row, etc etc.

Yeah, it sometimes seems as if posters are relieving their own tensions and grievances by pushing the nuclear button on other peoples behalf.

They certainly don’t seem to follow the advice not to let the sun go down on your anger.

thoughtsofmoog3 · 14/05/2023 11:23

Before any talks or thoughts of divorce, have an honest, grown up conversation.
Marriage is hard, divorce is hard - choose your poison!

Relationships can be saved by a couple actually properly communicating - agree to be kind and talk with respect, and realise that each of you may have to face up to uncomfortable truths. Stop point scoring (both of you)

Easier said than done- few things worth working for are.

footpedal · 14/05/2023 11:20

Why are people suggesting things to minimise his rage. Surely the foundation of this needs fixing not the things that "upset" him

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 11:19

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 11:07

These sound like fraught conversations had in the midst of rows. I'm just suggesting a different way. But hey, what do I know. LTB, take him for all he's got, get your ducks in a row, etc etc.

They “sound like”? Do they??? OP said absolutely nothing of the sort, you have invented something that simply isn’t in the text,

I never understood how anyone could fail English GCSE before MN.

I’m also agog to hear how to fix a personality and 15 years of behaviour issues in one calm conversation.

silverfullmoon · 14/05/2023 11:19

Jewel1968 · 14/05/2023 10:17

I think you have too much on your plate. You work in a demanding job, studying, have a health condition, mum to young kids and are in a relationship with someone who doesn't seem to appreciate that. To me your health condition alone should be enough for you H to be kind let alone the other stuff.

Options:

  • get a cleaner anyway and ignore his objections
  • reduce your working hours
  • take career break from work until your health has stabilised or you finish your study or both
  • reduce the activities your kids do

Overall I think you need a conversation with H and try and get him to understand that you really do have a lot on your plate and that you both need to think about solutions or accept that the house will be a bit messy.

I agree with this and I dont think this situation is tenable going forward. Its not realistic to have the kids doing multiple activities, working, studying, health conditions to take into account, the house being absolutely spotless at all times with no outside help etc. Thats a ridiculous amount of pressure to put on any family. Its not necessary to aim for this level of perfection and the cost of all this is your mental health and exhaustion (for both of you).

Kids dont need to be doing activities all the time, reduce some of these pressures as I think all this would lead any family to boiling point, health condition or not.

Its clearly too much for both of you, I dont know why you dont examine this and cut some of this stuff back.

Kiwimommyinlondon · 14/05/2023 11:18

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 11:07

These sound like fraught conversations had in the midst of rows. I'm just suggesting a different way. But hey, what do I know. LTB, take him for all he's got, get your ducks in a row, etc etc.

Perhaps your expectations are simply lower. I wouldn’t put up with this bullshit and nor should the OP. But if you think a night out will resolve things that’s your prerogative.

MyAnacondaMight · 14/05/2023 11:15

Is this about allocation of domestic tasks? Or about his anger problem and how he speaks to you?

The first is resolvable - the second will never change, as he has no interest in counselling or reflection. And resolving the first won’t make the second go away.

DustyLee123 · 14/05/2023 11:12

willWillSmithsmith · 14/05/2023 11:06

I don’t understand why posters are putting more value on doing chores around the house than the fact the OP’s dh has anger problems and brings unnecessary and nasty aggressiveness into the family home. Is not folding some clothes really a bigger issue than a dad making his daughter upset because he got angry she kissed a pebble? It seems to some on here that getting a cleaner will transform your husband in to a nice husband and good dad.🤨

She’s said twice that he won’t have a cleaner.

willWillSmithsmith · 14/05/2023 11:08

OwlsRock · 14/05/2023 11:00

DH is usually a really lovely guy. Life and soul of the party, charismatic, friendly, confident.
*
"*However if I ever take issue with anything he does or has done he blows up"

He's not burnt out. He's an arsehole who can't take criticism.

The bed clearing is a red herring.

A lot of charismatic, life of the party people are actually nasty arseholes behind closed doors.

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 11:08

DMLady · 14/05/2023 10:57

Does your DH know the impact the way he talks to you has on you, OP? I guess what I’m wondering is if there’s a way you could both sit down and talk through this together — not in the heat of the moment, or in a tit for tat way, but calmly, gently. It might not affect how he behaves but if he understands how it makes you feel, he might be more inclined to change. And perhaps he can explain to you a bit more about how he feels (I think you mentioned somewhere that he feels he does a lot and isn’t always appreciated). If you can talk about it from both your points of view, and both really listen to and try to understand the other, you might be able to move forward?

I agree, and have suggested similar, but apparently a calm conversation is not the MN way. Prepared to be flamed for daring to suggest it!

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 11:07

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 10:53

I find it baffling that you’re apparently unable to read the OP’s posts which detail that his anger and aggression has been going on for 15 years. That she has repeatedly talked to him about counselling and a cleaner and he shut both down?

How do you think a “calm conversation” will fix that??

These sound like fraught conversations had in the midst of rows. I'm just suggesting a different way. But hey, what do I know. LTB, take him for all he's got, get your ducks in a row, etc etc.

willWillSmithsmith · 14/05/2023 11:06

I don’t understand why posters are putting more value on doing chores around the house than the fact the OP’s dh has anger problems and brings unnecessary and nasty aggressiveness into the family home. Is not folding some clothes really a bigger issue than a dad making his daughter upset because he got angry she kissed a pebble? It seems to some on here that getting a cleaner will transform your husband in to a nice husband and good dad.🤨

Freddiefox · 14/05/2023 11:05

SquashAndSqueeeze · 14/05/2023 08:10

So what do I do? How do I move forward? I feel so confused and alone. I just want a happy family, something I wasn’t fortunate enough to have myself growing up. Our kids deserve it.

You both have to cut some things out. You both work, and clean, and cook.

maybe you have too much going on. Something will give, either your marriage, or then both of you.

OwlsRock · 14/05/2023 11:00

DH is usually a really lovely guy. Life and soul of the party, charismatic, friendly, confident.
*
"*However if I ever take issue with anything he does or has done he blows up"

He's not burnt out. He's an arsehole who can't take criticism.

The bed clearing is a red herring.

tara66 · 14/05/2023 10:58

Not read PPs but just wanted to say - you can buy children's clothes online and have them delivered - are you doing that to save time and energy?

Deadringer · 14/05/2023 10:58

My dh is very similar op, great as long as everything is going his way, and hostile and shouty when they aren't. He won't change because this is who he is and he doesn't think he is doing anything wrong. You can have a heart to heart talk with him or give him an ultimatum, but the reality ime is that you put up with it or leave.

DMLady · 14/05/2023 10:57

Does your DH know the impact the way he talks to you has on you, OP? I guess what I’m wondering is if there’s a way you could both sit down and talk through this together — not in the heat of the moment, or in a tit for tat way, but calmly, gently. It might not affect how he behaves but if he understands how it makes you feel, he might be more inclined to change. And perhaps he can explain to you a bit more about how he feels (I think you mentioned somewhere that he feels he does a lot and isn’t always appreciated). If you can talk about it from both your points of view, and both really listen to and try to understand the other, you might be able to move forward?

bobbysock · 14/05/2023 10:55

Banditdog · 14/05/2023 09:56

I really think you are making out you do a lot more than you really do. I deal with our finances, I wouldn’t even register it as a task, it is what fifteen minutes online once a week? I have also undertaken study recently, a masters and there is no way I would use that as an excuse to not do housework either.

It sounds like he is fed up of doing everything and asking you to do very simple tasks like moving stuff off the bed and you won’t even do that.

This!

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 10:53

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 10:48

Because right now neither of them can see the wood for the trees and having a conversation out of the home environment, a night off from chores/kids/work/studying, could facilitate a calmer conversation where they can talk about what's been going on and see if there's a way through it.

Seriously, am I the only person who goes out with their DH to talk about things?! It's good to check in and have a relationship MOT once in a while. I find it baffling that the idea is being rubbished.😳

I find it baffling that you’re apparently unable to read the OP’s posts which detail that his anger and aggression has been going on for 15 years. That she has repeatedly talked to him about counselling and a cleaner and he shut both down?

How do you think a “calm conversation” will fix that??

QueenieMe · 14/05/2023 10:48

Mirabai · 14/05/2023 10:41

He’s always been angry, aggressive and belittling according to the OP: how do you propose date night to fix that?

Because right now neither of them can see the wood for the trees and having a conversation out of the home environment, a night off from chores/kids/work/studying, could facilitate a calmer conversation where they can talk about what's been going on and see if there's a way through it.

Seriously, am I the only person who goes out with their DH to talk about things?! It's good to check in and have a relationship MOT once in a while. I find it baffling that the idea is being rubbished.😳

DeedlessIndeed · 14/05/2023 10:46

I totally agree, the way he is treating you is not appropriate and bordering on abusive.

Why don't you swap roles for a bit? If you are working PT and studying PT, that roughly equals 1 FT role. He also works FT. Swap everything else. Have a sit down chat and outline everything you do, and make these his responsibility. He can outline everything he does and make these your responsibility. At least then you can both get a feel for how much each other does - it might create a bit of empathy for the other person.