Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
tennesseewhiskey1 · 15/05/2023 09:19

But she can’t sing….. this is a choir, where they need to be able to … sing.

Tellmeimcrazy · 15/05/2023 09:06

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 08:50

Usually they've got family and friends with them who've been telling them they're brilliant singers because they didn't want to damage their self-esteem so it is related.

Exactly what TrollyHolly is saying

Plumbear2 · 15/05/2023 08:55

I'm so sad this has happened. At my child's secondary anyone can join the choir, band etc. One of my kids is talented in an instrument, he agrees music is for everyone regardless. He enjoys that it is mixed ability and goes all out to help and encourage the other kids.

TimesRwo · 15/05/2023 08:51

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 15/05/2023 05:16

It was wrong for only the choir to get trips like that when the five girls who didn't sing could easily have been included on the trips too. I doubt they were singing at the ice rink.

It really was. It really forced the message in that we were crap singers! The days out were rewards for the hard work the singers put in with their weekly practices, but as you say, five extra students on the trips wouldn’t have made a difference. It was a private school so I doubt cost was a concern.

Funny thing is I’ve since learnt I’m not a crap singer, I just needed practice (my husband used to be a solo in his school choir so has taught me a little on how to sing).

TrollyHolly · 15/05/2023 08:50

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 07:06

The producers should never allow that to happen. They cruelly exploit people, many of whom seem to have mental health issues. Nothing to do with OPs situation.

Usually they've got family and friends with them who've been telling them they're brilliant singers because they didn't want to damage their self-esteem so it is related.

Tellmeimcrazy · 15/05/2023 08:50

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 08:40

@Tellmeimcrazy
What a horrible world it would be if young people weren’t allowed to even just have a go.

I have my dream job and I remember when I was young being told I couldn’t do it because it would never work out as I wasn’t up to it. However one adult told me to give it a go. I had many trials and tribulations over the years …many steep learning curves, some insults along the way until I rose to the top of my profession.

I always say that young people should never be written off. You never know where their passion and desire will get them. They pick up the skills of hard work and determination along the way. I have noticed that the very talented do not always rise to the top. They are often overtaken by those with great passion, drive and who are willing to work hard.

Darius (RIP) was mocked for his audition and went on to become a big West End star and producer.

I hate the culture of public shaming. It is as though bullying is a new sport that has been condoned by the general public.

I am not going to tell you what I do but most wouldn’t call me a “joker”. What do you do by the way?

Exactly - trials and tribulations. The point is for something you have to audition for - you may not make it. Whether it is school choir or Britain's got talent. OPs daughter had a go. She didn't make the cut. That's it. She can practice and try again next time. Nobody said she couldn't try again. She may have e to work twice or three times harder than someone who can naturally sing very well. She still may not make it.

My niece has always been a brilliant swimmer. She tried out for a local team, she didn't make it. They do bronze, silver and gold tiers for the team. We carried on practising, she tried again - she got in the next time straight to silver.

Nobody is saying OPs daughter is a write off, but she simply didn't make the cut this time and that's that. She is obviously welcome to keep trying, but she may need to accept she may not make the grade for whatever reason - that's life. If she decides not to try again well then one could argue she didn't want it enough.

Either way she didn't make it this time and it's a valuable life lesson that we do not always get what we want no matter how much we want it.

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 08:48

We don’t even know whether or not OPs daughter can sing because she hasn’t said. She may well be a talented singer who “choked” during the audition. This can happen to even the best singers. Many well known “stars” get stage fright.

OwlsRock · 15/05/2023 08:46

This is one of those occasions you need to absorb and validate her emotions of being disappointed not become vengeful and on a mission to fix it.

She's sad- she's told you. You need to manage that

Secondary school choirs are often amazing in their power sound. Due to having the kids that sing well involved and not the others.

I was like your daughter and its tough but think about your role in this upset.

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 08:40

@Tellmeimcrazy
What a horrible world it would be if young people weren’t allowed to even just have a go.

I have my dream job and I remember when I was young being told I couldn’t do it because it would never work out as I wasn’t up to it. However one adult told me to give it a go. I had many trials and tribulations over the years …many steep learning curves, some insults along the way until I rose to the top of my profession.

I always say that young people should never be written off. You never know where their passion and desire will get them. They pick up the skills of hard work and determination along the way. I have noticed that the very talented do not always rise to the top. They are often overtaken by those with great passion, drive and who are willing to work hard.

Darius (RIP) was mocked for his audition and went on to become a big West End star and producer.

I hate the culture of public shaming. It is as though bullying is a new sport that has been condoned by the general public.

I am not going to tell you what I do but most wouldn’t call me a “joker”. What do you do by the way?

Tellmeimcrazy · 15/05/2023 07:33

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 07:06

The producers should never allow that to happen. They cruelly exploit people, many of whom seem to have mental health issues. Nothing to do with OPs situation.

What a joker. I've seen the parents of kids backstage egging them on. It's a joke.

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 07:06

Tellmeimcrazy · 15/05/2023 04:27

This is why people end up singing on Britain's got talent and get laughed at and publicly shamed.

The producers should never allow that to happen. They cruelly exploit people, many of whom seem to have mental health issues. Nothing to do with OPs situation.

Forfrigz · 15/05/2023 06:55

TheFireflies · 14/05/2023 13:33

People keep saying this but it simply isn’t true. Nobody can learn to be “just as good”. Most people can improve, but lessons wont magically make them good singers. There was a programme on Sky Arts a few years back called Anyone Can Sing where poor singers were intensively mentored by world class vocal coaches with the premise as the title.

At the end, the majority were still poor singers, painfully so in a couple of cases.

That said, it’s a shame that creative pursuits aren’t treated the same as sports in schools, where competitive teams are provided separately to open lessons.

It is in fact true, but it can admittedly take a long time. I never saw that programme but i'm sure it didn't run over the course of years. In reality, mastering an art is many thousand of hours of practice, you can have all the intense mentoring you like but the sheer number of hours is what makes the difference to the vast majority of people. If someone isn't a good ai ger a few weeks after trying it doesn't mean they never will be. Indeed, when learning an art, periods of rest between practice can make just as much difference as the practice itself.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 15/05/2023 05:33

CrapBucket · 14/05/2023 01:27

A school choir should accept everyone! Gareth Malone wouldn’t tell an 11 year old they aren’t good enough. He’d teach them ways to improve.

Gareth Malone did tell some of the kids they weren't good enough for the trip to China.

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 15/05/2023 05:16

TimesRwo · 14/05/2023 09:37

I’m in my mid-30s, and I’m still hurt by this…

At my school, everyone had to audition for the choir when they started school at 11. So all 40 girls auditioned, and only 5 of us didn’t get in.

The choir would then have various trips throughout the year - ice skating in winter, chessington in summer, etc. So the 5 of us would have an ordinary school day whilst everyone else would go off on a jolly.

I’m clearly still bitter about it. There are kinder ways to treat 11 year olds rather than telling them they clearly have a crap voice and exclude them from all sorts of activities.

It was wrong for only the choir to get trips like that when the five girls who didn't sing could easily have been included on the trips too. I doubt they were singing at the ice rink.

Offensiveapprently · 15/05/2023 04:57

We can't all be good everything OP. You would expect a football team to take on someone who was no good at football, equally someone who is no good at singing doesn't need to be in a choir. Your daughter is and will be good at something. People need to deal with disappointments sometimes. Our children get told throughout their lives that they are amazing at everything and go throughout it thinking that should be able to join every club going.
My son is a good football player, his friend is not. Friend discovers a talent for skating and is now on a roller hockey team, my son didn't get selected because its not something he is good at. My son was disappointed but that's just life. Bolster your daughter up and encourage the many other things she's good at.

mathanxiety · 15/05/2023 04:54

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:29

Most clubs at school are about improving, anyone can sign up for the netball or football clubs, not sure how the team things work but even if they are selected from the clubs, anyone can still do the clubs. So even if they wanted a choir to perform and be the best, they should surely have an option for the kids wanting to participate and improve, like they do for everything else. DD was just told no and that's that, no way for her to get to sing at all at school even though that's what she enjoys and is interested in. Does just seem unfair

Performing as a vocal ensemble requires everyone to be able to hit the notes. You wouldn't expect a kid who got a trumpet for Christmas and can't actually play it to be allowed to join a brass ensemble alongside players who have been playing for four or five years.

Get your child private voice lessons if you want someone to put in the time and effort it would take to help him or her improve. However, there's not much you can do about a wooden ear, sadly.

Tellmeimcrazy · 15/05/2023 04:27

SnackSizeRaisin · 14/05/2023 18:32

No of course you don't tell her she's bad. The op doesn't even think that if you read her posts.

Definitely encourage her to go for it, perhaps prepare her for the idea that not everyone is successful. As a parent your job is to encourage her not to crush her completely at the tender age of 11.

This is why people end up singing on Britain's got talent and get laughed at and publicly shamed.

Wenfy · 15/05/2023 01:39

A lot of private schools insist on all kids learning how to sing and joining the school choir (there were seperate choirs for advanced competitions depending on requirements that students were pooled into). The understanding was that everyone and anyone can learn how to sing in a basic way barring disability & I think that reasoning is sound. I have yet to hear a bad singer at DD’s school.

Murdoch1949 · 15/05/2023 01:31

There are many opportunities at school to enjoy a skill or hobby, but some involve a level that not everyone can achieve. Sports teams will select the best 11, choirs want the singers who have the best voices, the debating team is for the best speakers. Yes, it is hard for those who enjoy singing or football or speaking to not get selected, but this is life. Children understand their place in the pecking order, they know if they're good at sports or chess etc. A good school will provide opportunities for as many as possible, but not everyone can be in the team.

oneleggedspider · 14/05/2023 19:25

See if there's a youth community choir outside of school that she could join? They usually don't audition.

Violinist64 · 14/05/2023 18:39

Before my very first sports day at primary school, my mother gently made me aware of the fact that I was and am totally non-sporty and that I was not going to do very well in the races. She told me that I was very lucky because I found reading, spelling and maths easy and other children did not so that this was their chance to shine. This seemed eminently fair and sensible to me at five or six and I certainly was not upset. I find it a little disturbing that eleven year olds have not accepted this fact yet (whatever the weakness may be). Even in the weakest areas we can still practise in order to improve but the fact is that someone who is talented in a particular area and also works at it will always be better than others. I have a teenage piano pupil who has just been accepted as a junior scholar at one of the most prestigious music colleges in the country. Each year, l put on a concert in which all my pupils participate in front of an audience of family and friends. It is fully inclusive so that the even the youngest beginner plays a little piece. As they become more advanced, the pieces become longer and more difficult and everyone plays to the best of their ability. Everyone is pleased for everyone else and extremely encouraging. They are also vocal about how much improvement there has been in the past year. However, everyone also knows that the pupil on his way to music college is outstanding and he plays a bit more than everyone else. I have also provided extra opportunities for him to perform. Having been at a music college myself, though, I know that the training will take no prisoners and I have already warned him that he will be a little fish in a big pool, rather than a big fish in a little pool as he is at the moment. It is a very good lesson to learn.

SnackSizeRaisin · 14/05/2023 18:32

FarmGirl78 · 14/05/2023 14:52

What? Of course you tell her if she's not up to it! If she chooses to go on and audition anyway that's up to her but she needs to know if she's BAD. You can flower it up to break the news gently, but she needs to know. This is how you get AWFUL singers on XFactor and BGT, who are oblivious to the fact, who then get told so publicly. That famous one where the parents stomped onstage and told Simon Cowell off. Its THEIR fault their Daughter ended up humiliating herself on National TV, because they were either so deluded they couldn't see their little darling was bad, or knew full well like you do but shyed away from being the one to break the news.

If she's actually BAD who would you rather tell her? You, or a teacher who'll tell her without sympathy, a hug, and possibly in front of others?

No of course you don't tell her she's bad. The op doesn't even think that if you read her posts.

Definitely encourage her to go for it, perhaps prepare her for the idea that not everyone is successful. As a parent your job is to encourage her not to crush her completely at the tender age of 11.

Eleganz · 14/05/2023 17:55

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 13:28

Well apparently there are plenty of parents who fork out for singing lessons for their kids. Why couldn't there be plenty of parents who pay a bit for a non-selective choir?

Agreed it's about kids having an opportunity to do something beneficial even if they don't have star quality. Like kids should learn to cook even if they're not cut out to run a restaurant or be a celeb chef or whatever. Because it's good for you and brings joy. It's sad when everything is made into a competition.

I don't see anything wrong with kids competing in some areas, but don't think singing should be one that's solely competitive.

Because parents don't pay for things like this I'm afraid.

The reality is that a school running and auditioned choir is not "making everything a competition" it is about running a music group that is attempting to achieve something different and equally valid to a non-auditioned ensemble. To make music more inclusive at the highest levels we actually need more state schools focussing on supporting musical excellence, not less. This idea that music in schools is just a general enrichment activity rather than something that someone can genuinely have talent in and seek a career in is a major problem for representation in the arts.

BogRollBOGOF · 14/05/2023 17:45

DS is 10 and loves his sports, but it's pretty brutal out there. He trains with a football team and is rarely selected for matches which increases the cycle of falling behind because he has less experience. He keeps training because he loves it and there will be other opportunities.
He also does parkrun, and that comes with its own life lessons. Focus on your time and your pbs; that's objective. Don't focus on your position, that's relative to who else turned up that day. Do it because you love it, and the pbs and placings are a lovely bonus when they fall into place.

11 is not too young to accept that you're not the right fit for anything you want to do. If you love it, there are other opportunities to get involved.

Most hurtful is struggling on the periphery, more than an outright initial rejection. Sometimes rejection is because of objectively not reaching a standard. Sometimes it's bad luck that there's just more people willing to go for it than the capacity to accommodate it, and the margins are far tighter.

A school has limited resources to support choirs and it's not unreasonable for them to audition and select the pupils that meet a standard that they can manage.
At school, some years I got into school plays, some years I didn't. The years I didn't, I worked backstage because I enjoyed the involvement. Sometimes being rejected can make you look sideways for related opportunities.

Kazzyhoward · 14/05/2023 17:43

Fundamentally, life is a competition. That means there'll be "winners" and "losers". The sooner children realise that, the less they're set up for disappointment. Primary schools are terrible with their mantra of "you can be want you want to be", and the transition to secondary is usually where the child realises that they've been led up the garden path.

When it comes to boyfriends, the OP's DD will almost certainly end up being dumped for someone else with longer hair, bigger boobs, or whatever, or the lad they fancy won't ask them out. Boys and girls are competing for eachother.

When it comes to GCSEs and A levels, the marking/grade boundaries is set up deliberately make x% of people get 9s/A*s and y% of people "failing" by getting the lower grades. So kids are competing against eachother to get the best grades they can.

When it comes to Uni, it's a competition for a fixed number of places - based on A level grades (GCSEs to an extent), partly hobbies & interests, partly the quality of their personal statement.

Same with jobs, some will get the top jobs, others won't, all based on competition. Same with promotions. Same if your job involves selling things, applying for grants, etc - you're competing against other firms.

Looking further, buying or renting a house is also a competition, people are competing with eachother to get the house they want in terms of how much they offer, their credit rating, etc etc.

The sooner that children realise life is a competition, the better.