Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
Lamaitresse · 15/05/2023 18:13

Oh come on. We should be preparing our children for adulthood, and yes they should know that rejection is a part of life.
If you’re too precious OP you’re not going to prepare your dd well enough, and she will not be in a strong position to thrive when she’s older.
If you already know that singing is not one of her skills, then you could have managed this before the audition by making it clear that it’s great to try out, but that not everyone will get picked. You could have let her know kindly in advance that her skills lie elsewhere, and if she’d been prepared for a possible rejection then it would not have been such a big deal.
You can also remind her that for many big stars, they too faced rejection, but stood up and carried on. You could also find the clip of Ed Sheeran being interviewed where he plays himself singing in his early teens - it was horrible 😂 Maybe get her singing lessons if she really wants to sing?
Whatever you do, it’s now up to you to show her the way forward and through this, and she’ll hopefully come out stronger for it 💪🏻

worriedmum46 · 15/05/2023 18:12

My daughter went to compulsory choir on Tuesday lunchtime in year 7. After 3 weeks the choir master called her in for a chat! Got her to sing the songs they had started learning and my Jean been happily sang them all as she had spent hours learning them all. He looked at her and said ‘you are not messing around are you’. Seeing as she wasn’t he excused her from choir practice meaning once a week she sat alone. Every time the choir went out she was stuck in school despite lessons being cancelled. I was gutted for her tbh and it knocked her confidence so much to be the only one out of 100+ girls excluded. Never felt it was a kind thing to do.

Lochjeda · 15/05/2023 17:59

Sorry yabu, kids can go to the sports club for practice because that won't impair on any one else playing and they likely don't get picked for the team.A bad singer affects the whole choir trying to learn and sing nicely in unison and at my child's school they are always practicing for the next thing they are signing at which I imagine hers will be too.

My son tried out for violin and guitar and never got picked it is what it is.

angela99999 · 15/05/2023 17:56

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

If she can't sing she'll spoil the sound of the rest of the choir.
The idea is that you choose people with good voices, ideally perhaps also with a knowledge of music.
I had a good voice but couldn't sight read so I wasn't chosen either.
You're encouraging her to be entitled, better to encourage her to get involved in something she can actually do well.

RemoteDesktop · 15/05/2023 17:47

We had the same in primary school. Sports were always the same too, only the most able kids would make the cut. I don’t really have an issue with that.

Nannygoat151 · 15/05/2023 17:42

That’s life sadly . Everyone can’t be good at everything . Find something they are good at

Skybluepinky · 15/05/2023 16:18

Of course they want the best singers, most school choirs enter competitions.
it’s a life lesson, yr child wasn’t up to the standard so didn’t get in. They could choose to have lessons to improve or just accept their voice isn’t choir standard.

mycoffeecup · 15/05/2023 16:14

Are you sure there isn't an open one too? In Y 7 there is usually a choir that anyone can join, and an audition based one.

ASGIRC · 15/05/2023 15:39

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:32

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing. I don't think she is even bad, she sounds like an 11 year old singing. Don't get me wrong, she doesn't have an amazing natural talent but nor is she someone who is completely out of time.

The way you phrased it, it seems you think all 11 year olds cant sing.
Thats not true. Ive seen 11 year olds who can absolutely sing, and would give any pop singer a run for their money.

If the choir has auditions, they wont accept just anyone. You need to be able to sing. Which clearly isnt the case with your daughter.

If they accepted anyone, there would be no auditions. Youd just apply to be a part of it.

And yes, people should definitely be told if they cant do something. Otherwise you get the Pop Idol contestants who cannot hold a tune whatsoever, but who say that everyone always told them they could sing! Its just embarrassing.

Eleganz · 15/05/2023 15:18

Catspyjamas17 · 15/05/2023 15:13

I think you are confusing football teams with school football teams.

No I'm not, the school football teams at our local schools all run try outs every year. You don't just get to play.

LolaSmiles · 15/05/2023 15:18

Eleganz
I agree. Different groups have different purposes and it's difficult to be all things to all people.

If the purpose of Choir A is a community choir/open access choir/singing club then it will have a different set of requirements (probably turn up and want to sing) than Choir B that focuses on large scale classica performances/competitions/ developing musical talent/providing a breadth of repertoire so choristers are versatile (probably expecting confident music reading and good vocal tone). Choir C might be a glee club/rock and pop choir so they might audition for vocal style and tone, but due to learning by ear/rote and group members working together to arrange parts they might not require confident score reading. Choir D is a chamber choir and requires 8-16 people who are not only good choristers, but have the ability to hold parts in smaller numbers and be confident enough not to rely on the person next to them.

Not everyone will be right for Choirs A, B, C, and D.

Sererus · 15/05/2023 15:14

I think YABU. I was in my school choir and if someone was off key, the teacher would go over that section to try to figure out who it was to help get them in key again. It wasn't done nastily and more to help that person reach the correct note, but if your DD isn't a good singer, surely it'll be worse being in the choir and constantly being the one singing out of key and not being able to fix it?
I think it would be cruel to pretend she can sing well and having her ending up embarrassed after performances.

Catspyjamas17 · 15/05/2023 15:13

Eleganz · 15/05/2023 15:09

They run trials. It happens all over the country every year. Seems to not be controversial.

I think you are confusing football teams with school football teams.

Eleganz · 15/05/2023 15:11

I think the big problem here is there has been a lot of popular exposure on community choirs and people like Gareth Malone getting random groups of people to sing together and so many people think that is what a choir is. That is just one type of choir and it is no more important that other types of choir that aim for different things, such as musical excellence. It would be great if a school had the resources to run both types of group but many won't and if there is a good, well-established auditioned choir at a particular school why scrap it?

Eleganz · 15/05/2023 15:09

Catspyjamas17 · 15/05/2023 11:23

Should school football teams just rotate all the kids that want to be in them because it's fairer, or only have the best players?

How do you know who the best players are without having a club they can go to which teaches them the sport more in depth than in PE lessons?

They run trials. It happens all over the country every year. Seems to not be controversial.

Eleganz · 15/05/2023 15:07

celticprincess · 15/05/2023 10:58

I’m a music teacher and this is shocking. School choirs should be inclusive or at least there should be a separate auditioned choir. I was told as a child never to sing and here I am teaching music and leading singing with kids. Choir was compulsory at uni for music students and there are many instrumental players who really can’t sing that well but through years of rehearsals we were taught how to improve. Our uni also had a separate auditioned choir but the main choir was for all music students and additional students who wanted to sing.

I hear what people say about sports teams being selective but they still encourage all the kids to go along and play non competitively.

I wouldn’t go quoting Gareth malone though - he’s often runs auditioned choirs. But there are many many inclusive choirs about. Professionally paid choirs should be able to be selective. But singing is for everyone.

Was the orchestra unauditioned at your university? Was there a training orchestra? Are choirs only for teaching people the basics of music making?

Youcunnyfunt · 15/05/2023 14:51

I was in the choir in year 7 and then was asked to switch to narration, poetry recital and stand up comedy segments for the shows in later years. I was the light relief for the parents Grin
I would encourage her to find something she else she enjoys. Bad singing is hell for other people in the choir (and the parents suffering the shows!). I'm sure she could try something else.

IndysMamaRex · 15/05/2023 14:02

Sorry but rejection is part of life & builds resilience. Maybe the teacher could have been a bit softer but at the end of the day just because she auditioned never meant she was ever going to be chosen.

LolaSmiles · 15/05/2023 13:50

Schroedingersimmigrant
I think some seems to mean anyone who wants to go should be able to, regardless of skill, vocal tone or ability to hold a tune. Anything else is mean and going to cause lasting damage for life.

The problem is that in many areas there's not the staff, resources or funding to run extensive ensemble provision so there's got to be a trade off.

Some people think that talented musicians and those with musical potential should fewer opportunities to develop in order to prioritise a "singing/music for all" approach. Others acknowledge that to improve representation in the arts and culture areas there needs to be opportunities for talented musicians who aren't loaded to develop, so think that having an audition process from secondary school is a logical thing to do.

In an ideal world everywhere would have both and parents would be a bit more realistic with their DC about their skills, but it's far from ideal in school music at the moment.

Schroedingersimmigrant · 15/05/2023 13:28

When people say "choir that anyone can join" they mean "anyone who can sing can join", don't they? But not based on perfect matching voice?

Tellmeimcrazy · 15/05/2023 13:26

CabbagePatchDole · 15/05/2023 08:48

We don’t even know whether or not OPs daughter can sing because she hasn’t said. She may well be a talented singer who “choked” during the audition. This can happen to even the best singers. Many well known “stars” get stage fright.

She said she sounds like an 11 year old singing. IMO that's not choir material

Fifthtimelucky · 15/05/2023 13:10

I agree with the OP. I think all secondary schools (and primary schools for that matter) should have a non-auditioned choir that anyone can join.

I also think secondary schools should also have a smaller auditioned choir for better singers.

Aprilx · 15/05/2023 12:40

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

It was always very clear to me what I was good and not so good at whilst I was at school. Everybody is surely?

Fourpeasinapodcast · 15/05/2023 12:07

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing. I don't think she is even bad, she sounds like an 11 year old singing. Don't get me wrong, she doesn't have an amazing natural talent but nor is she someone who is completely out of time

Little Tiger..... just so you are aware you might not get in to the choir. You have to be a really good singer to be accepted. By all means give it a go and try out but there may be some other girls there who are better at singing than you like you are better at some things sport/writing/painting than they are. You cannot be good at everything and we all have different talents. Maybe we can see if there are local singing lessons we could send you to since you enjoy singing so much. You can try again then next year.

FFS OP, a bad singer can throw the whole choir off, they don't accept kids who cannot sing, what is the point of that?: That's like me as a PE teacher picking someone for the gymnastics team who cannot do a tumble...just to be inclusive. It makes no sense. Your daughter needs to learn resilience, acceptance and understanding that she cannot be good at everything. They gave her a go and she didn't cut it, she will excel elsewhere.

gogohmm · 15/05/2023 11:37

Depends if there are limited spaces. If they can only take 35 kids and 35 audition 10 get rejected.