Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
EasterBreak · 15/05/2023 20:07

yabu op I enjoy playing the keyboard but I'd never pass any auditions for it because I'm not good.

ItsCalledAConversation · 15/05/2023 19:48

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:29

Most clubs at school are about improving, anyone can sign up for the netball or football clubs, not sure how the team things work but even if they are selected from the clubs, anyone can still do the clubs. So even if they wanted a choir to perform and be the best, they should surely have an option for the kids wanting to participate and improve, like they do for everything else. DD was just told no and that's that, no way for her to get to sing at all at school even though that's what she enjoys and is interested in. Does just seem unfair

But it’s not “singing club”, it’s the choir. By your logic, it’s like saying anyone should be able to get onto the football or netball team regardless of how shit they are at sport. You’re being deeply unreasonable.

SpringTime2020 · 15/05/2023 19:45

Deathbyfluffy · 14/05/2023 01:25

Of course you can’t be in a choir if you can’t sing. YABU

Plenty used to sing in the community choir I used to be part of that couldn't really sing. Being in a group helps them. And we sounded great and we're very popular.

ZiriForEver · 15/05/2023 19:40

First thing - it is ok and normal, that DD feels sad about it. Yes, she will have to get over it, but there is nothing wrong about the emotion and it is great she told you.

Yes, if the school has open clubs for sports and than selective school teams, it would be fairer to do the same about music, they can do easier songs with the "for fun one".

It was the same when I was 11 yo, the school choir was just a group of children who went through some music education outside of school. And a bit later a selective one was practically a small vocal group, entirely consisting from people who had solo singing lessons (outside of school, not with the same teacher).
The strange thing, it sounded normal, no-one questioned it, but maybe it shouldn't be.

MrsKeats · 15/05/2023 19:32

I'm not very good at tennis.
How very dare Wimbledon say I can't play?!
Get a grip.

Pootle23 · 15/05/2023 19:26

YABU. They audition for a reason, they want good singers. It is not always the taking part that matters but the winning. Maybe the school choir is exceptionally good and wins lots of competitions, they don’t want people who can’t keep in tune. My school choir did and wouldn’t accept people who couldn’t sing.

As someone who can and does sing, not everyone can actually sing.

Singing at a karaoke evening is not the same as singing The Messiah.

sadsack78 · 15/05/2023 19:18

I have listed some suggestions above so your dd has some options going forward if she really wants to sing.

I have sympathy though. My DH has a beautiful voice and has sung professionally in bands. His music teacher in primary school told him he 'couldn't sing' and it hurt him very much. It took him years and years to get over that and find the confidence to develop his voice.

Teachers have the power to scar people's confidence for life if they're tactless or not careful. The amount of adults I meet who say they were told they were crap at sports, couldn't draw etc is so sad. The truth is, if you practice ANYTHING you WILL get better at it, no matter your talent or ability when you start.

newnamethanks · 15/05/2023 19:16

YABU. Not everyone can sing in tune and if you are one of them, you don't belong in a choir. Thats why they have auditions. It's very off-putting standing next to someone singing off-key, it can throw the whole thing off.

Stompythedinosaur · 15/05/2023 19:11

I think there's a value in non-competitive and inclusive activities, but also a value in talented dc having a space to excel.

Stompythedinosaur · 15/05/2023 19:10

ScotsBluebell · 15/05/2023 18:59

A school choir holds auditions, then tells eleven year olds they're not good enough to participate - and people on here are agreeing with that? The plain truth is that EVERYONE can sing, provided they have working vocal cords. They just need to be taught properly. Back when I was at a bog standard state comprehensive, our brilliant music teacher never held auditions for the choir, although he did for the solo roles, later on. But that was fine, because by then, we were all involved. Everyone who wanted to work at it was welcome and we even won prizes, although that was never his main aim. He just wanted to show us the ability we all had. It's like youth theatre - some kids are natural stars, but the really good directors are the ones who choose the right material, exclude nobody, instil confidence and achieve amazing results. Especially at eleven or twelve. Why must everything be so competitive, so young? I agree with you OP. It's pernicious nonsense. And when you look back over this thread, there are so many people who clearly fell victim to the same nonsense when they were young and have gone through life believing it. Nobody should have to pay for singing lessons for their child to join a school choir. Have we all taken leave of our senses?

I can't see how it's any different than having try outs for sports teams.

sadsack78 · 15/05/2023 19:07

If your dd really wants to sing and you can afford it, get her some lessons.
Most people can improve their singing, whether they naturally have a lovely voice or not. It's a skill that needs to be practiced regularly, like piano or ballet.

If you have the money, learning to play piano is great for singing. It really helps train the ear and builds knowledge about keys, vocal ranges etc.

And maybe there is some kind of community or church choir outside of school she could join? Things like that might be more relaxed and help her gain confidence.

Lightsbonaza · 15/05/2023 19:07

I agree with you OP. It’s not proper choir. It’s a school one. It should be open to those who enjoy music.

secondary school/adolescence is hard and music can have a wonderful impact on those involved. It also gives children a chance to mix with people outside their circle etc. I would rather go and see my kid singing in an ‘awful’ choir full of kids who were just passionate than one which was exclusive. I wouldn’t be impressed if I paid for a ticket at a professional venue and got a bunch of out of tune kids but it’s just a school thing.

MargaretThursday · 15/05/2023 19:00

I auditioned for my school choir in year 4 and 5 before finally getting in in year 6. I don't think year 7 is too early to learn how to pick yourself up and try again.

A few things. Firstly one child off key can effect the others. I remember one of my dc's year in juniors sounded terrible. Absolutely a hoard of droners. I was a bit puzzled by this as I knew three or four who had lovely voices, but singing together they reverted to this drone. None of my other dc's year groups had this issue.
One performance they sang beautifully with most of the year except a few who had speaking parts, then for the last song they all sang together, including the narrators who had not joined in until that point-and the last song was back to the drone. It was unfortunately immediately obvious that the culprit was one absolutely lovely confident little girl who belted out the songs at the top of her voice-and totally off key, taking the rest of the year with her.

Secondly the choir may be doing competitions or shows, in which case they are looking for the best. Would it be worse for her to practice the songs with the choir, and then be told not to come to the competitions? I think so.
I know the school choir I eventually made would be invited to a number of events over the year, and they also entered competitions-and won more often than not.

And also, singing is something you can do on your own, or in a group. It costs nothing. So if your dc wants to join a choir they can try practicing on their own. It's not like football or something like that which is hard to do alone.
So encourage her to sing to herself, to practice, see how she can get the notes and maybe she can get better to try again another time.

ScotsBluebell · 15/05/2023 18:59

A school choir holds auditions, then tells eleven year olds they're not good enough to participate - and people on here are agreeing with that? The plain truth is that EVERYONE can sing, provided they have working vocal cords. They just need to be taught properly. Back when I was at a bog standard state comprehensive, our brilliant music teacher never held auditions for the choir, although he did for the solo roles, later on. But that was fine, because by then, we were all involved. Everyone who wanted to work at it was welcome and we even won prizes, although that was never his main aim. He just wanted to show us the ability we all had. It's like youth theatre - some kids are natural stars, but the really good directors are the ones who choose the right material, exclude nobody, instil confidence and achieve amazing results. Especially at eleven or twelve. Why must everything be so competitive, so young? I agree with you OP. It's pernicious nonsense. And when you look back over this thread, there are so many people who clearly fell victim to the same nonsense when they were young and have gone through life believing it. Nobody should have to pay for singing lessons for their child to join a school choir. Have we all taken leave of our senses?

Toomuchtrouble4me · 15/05/2023 18:54

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

Erm…yes! Do you really tell kids they are good at something they’re not? They have a long way to fall. Best know your weaknesses… and your strengths.
you could get her singing lessons and try to improve it if she’s really bothered.

lieselotte · 15/05/2023 18:52

Haven't read the full thread but my school had two choirs - one for all comers and one that was audition only. I would have thought that most secondary schools were big enough to support both.

Whatkindofuckeryisthis · 15/05/2023 18:50

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

Well yes! Something like singing is hard to learn I think… I would assume if you’re bad, you’re bad and no amount of lessons would change that? I don’t know! But I think your daughter needs to accept this isn’t for her and try something else!

7eleven · 15/05/2023 18:47

Crap voices can be hidden in a choir. Singing is joyous and should be open to everyone. Absolute rubbish that a school choir would audition. I feel really strongly about this. I sing and am not too bad. Out of principle I would never sing for a choir that holds auditions.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 15/05/2023 18:35

KrisAkabusi · 14/05/2023 01:22

In our year 5 class one poor boy was told to just mime in the choir, he sounded so bad! In this case you are being unreasonable though. If you have to audition, a certain level is obviously required.

Headmistress in primary school told me to mime. Primary school fgs, at that age just let the children sing, especially as it was just singing in class in the music lesson. Mortifying, even at 9 or 10, to be singled out in front of the whole class and told that you're so shit at something that you shouldn't participate.

SmileyClare · 15/05/2023 18:34

It’s not the holy grail to be in a school choir anyway.

From what I remember at school there was a bit of buzz about choir auditions after the posters went up around our secondary school.

Then lots of kids found it really boring and decided they didn’t want to stay late after school ( putting out and clearing away all the chairs in the hall and practising the same songs over and over) and left. Then others left because their mates weren’t doing it.

Your dd may still get in if that happens!

Sennelier1 · 15/05/2023 18:32

@tigerdrew , the improving and learning is done in the music lessons, and your child is still welcome to take these I suppose. The choir is for those with a good voice and able to keep the tone 🤷🏼‍♀️ It's like playing netball in the PE lessons but not being picked for the competition. I thinknyou gave your daughter false hope encouraging her to take the audition.

Cazareeto1 · 15/05/2023 18:31

LightDrizzle · 14/05/2023 01:29

Very apposite name choice there!

😂 I just noticed that ha ha

CantFindMyMarbles · 15/05/2023 18:26

YABU
It’s a choir. If she’s not good then she’s not good. End of. Kids can’t be great at everything.

neslop · 15/05/2023 18:19

worriedmum46 · 15/05/2023 18:12

My daughter went to compulsory choir on Tuesday lunchtime in year 7. After 3 weeks the choir master called her in for a chat! Got her to sing the songs they had started learning and my Jean been happily sang them all as she had spent hours learning them all. He looked at her and said ‘you are not messing around are you’. Seeing as she wasn’t he excused her from choir practice meaning once a week she sat alone. Every time the choir went out she was stuck in school despite lessons being cancelled. I was gutted for her tbh and it knocked her confidence so much to be the only one out of 100+ girls excluded. Never felt it was a kind thing to do.

This post doesn't make any sense to me?

Hadroncollideer · 15/05/2023 18:16

I had the same, in junior school.

I Don't think I was terribly upset, but on the other hand I do remember it. I am a very bad singer so it may have been the case of being beyond a bit of subtle help from the choir leader.