Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 15/05/2023 22:29

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

Would you rather they lied to your dd and told her she has a lovely voice and ruined the sound of the choir? If you are not good at something you need to practice more to improve. No one has told your dd she can never get better at singing, just at the moment her voice is not up to scratch. I was not in the choir. I didn't even audition because I knew my voice was not good enough. Get her some singing lessons if it bothers you so much.

Ilkleymoor · 15/05/2023 22:26

@ScotsBluebell excellent post

Ilkleymoor · 15/05/2023 22:23

I was in a natural Voice choir for a few years. I'm not a confident singer but the approach - anyone can sing, learn by ear and not songsheets - did wonders for my confidence and my ability to sing. I agree, schools should have a community choir approach and then a smaller audition group if relevant or good for those singers to get more tutoring. Community music is an amazing experience. We do young people a terrible disservice to block them from creative opportunities such as group singing so easily.

I had one try out to play guitar at primary school, was told I was not capable and that was that, no other music opportunity for me ever and I assumed I was just shit at music. In my 20s I joined a drumming group and gigged all over the place. I just needed a way in that suited me - surely this part of education and access to art?

Izzy24 · 15/05/2023 22:21

ScotsBluebell · 15/05/2023 18:59

A school choir holds auditions, then tells eleven year olds they're not good enough to participate - and people on here are agreeing with that? The plain truth is that EVERYONE can sing, provided they have working vocal cords. They just need to be taught properly. Back when I was at a bog standard state comprehensive, our brilliant music teacher never held auditions for the choir, although he did for the solo roles, later on. But that was fine, because by then, we were all involved. Everyone who wanted to work at it was welcome and we even won prizes, although that was never his main aim. He just wanted to show us the ability we all had. It's like youth theatre - some kids are natural stars, but the really good directors are the ones who choose the right material, exclude nobody, instil confidence and achieve amazing results. Especially at eleven or twelve. Why must everything be so competitive, so young? I agree with you OP. It's pernicious nonsense. And when you look back over this thread, there are so many people who clearly fell victim to the same nonsense when they were young and have gone through life believing it. Nobody should have to pay for singing lessons for their child to join a school choir. Have we all taken leave of our senses?

Thank goodness for a post like this.

xmaswiththeinlaws · 15/05/2023 22:18

I didn't get into the school choir in Year 4, I was very nervous at the audition but tried again the following year and got in. I also sang in the church Junior choir. Some choirs have very high standards and consequently are more popular than others. We were sent to a school choir competition in London when I was in year 6, it was all very exciting. I didn't sing in any choirs in secondary school, our music teacher had very high expectations and I had enough other clubs to keep me busy.

Timesawastin · 15/05/2023 21:57

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 07:07

Congenital amusia, hmm I'd hazard a no actually.

Our experience says no, as per previous posts. Might as well try and get me a maths degree. My everyday arithmetic is fine, fortunately.

Copasetic · 15/05/2023 21:45

How about private singing lessons?

Copasetic · 15/05/2023 21:44

I do actually agree with you. My son’s school has 3 choirs - one for everybody, one auditioned for yrs 7-9 and another auditioned yr 10+. That seems much fairer to me.

celticprincess · 15/05/2023 21:41

The orchestra wasn’t auditioned either. But music students did have to audition to get into the uni and it was compulsory for them to play in the orchestra. But, other non music students who played instruments could also join. I guess you wouldn’t join an orchestra if you don’t play an instrument though. And o guess you’d only ask to join a choir of you thought you were able to keep up with the standard.

I’ve had zero singing lessons. I can now sing quite confidently in a choir and sing some quite difficult pieces. I sing in several choirs that are non auditioned. Singing on a choir is very different to playing on an orchestra. Orchestras are naturally slightly elitist as you have to be able to afford an instrument to learn and then a decent instrument to get a sound out of. Most people have a voice which is free to use - I say most as I work with non verbal students are able to join in with my singing sessions through sign language and movement but it’s j likely they’d request to join a purely singing choir. But the voice is an instrument that can be practised and improved with the help of just singing in a group. I went to train in Hungary where all children are expected to sing at this particular school. They sing from reception up to the age of 18. They generally don’t have children who ‘can’t’ sing as being immersed in regular group singing around children who can sing and staff who encourage singing, the very few children who seem to be ‘tone deaf’ eventually become able to sing by secondary. They are all given the opportunity to sing as their first instrument and then once they have mastered musicianship skills they then choose if they want to take up an instrument.

WillowtreeHouse · 15/05/2023 21:35

This makes me think of that X factor audition years ago when the mum had been telling her daughter she had a beautiful voice and completely lost it when Simon Cowell disagreed. I think she might have gone in and whacked him one. 🤣

AtlasSeven · 15/05/2023 21:34

It is a shame that they don’t have a “just for fun” choir as well as the auditioned one.

The choir at my secondary school was open to any child who wanted in and was willing to go to all the practices. It may not have been the best choir in the world, but it was still a good confidence building activity for the kids who joined.

Outofthepark · 15/05/2023 21:26

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP not sure if it helps but I was desperate to be in the choir. Between ages of 8-12 it was very prestigious so I got rejected every year because to be honest I couldn't really sing. I had to wait until it became uncool and the choir was more desperate then I got in. And ended up signing at the Albert Hall actually (with around 1000 other kids). That Albert Hall thing is one of my favourite memories of school! And I always laugh and feel impressed at myself at how I just stick with it every year until I could get in.

If you want to sing in the choir at the end of the day, it's only fair that either you can sing, or that the choir is desperate for people - I wasn't fussed which one I got into as long as I got in! Just tell your daughter to keep trying. It'll happen one day.

Schroedingersimmigrant · 15/05/2023 21:17

But at school let every child who loves music join in and be a part of it.

Sorry to pick on this point (not the poster in particular, few are making the same point about enjoyment)
My mum loves music, loved it since she was tiny.
Her singing makes dogs run away🙈 Loving music doesn't mean you should do music. She still "sings" at home a lot and loves it, but god, no way should she be anywhere near choir🙈

BubsysMum123 · 15/05/2023 21:15

Totally reasonable to be rejected on bad voice at 11! She can have singing lessons and try again if she’s desperate to join!
People should be aware of what they are good at and not good at in life! My voice is bad and I think I realised when auditioned for Joseph at primary school age 9!

Kaz40s · 15/05/2023 21:14

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

Yes though not in those words obviously. They need to know they have strengths which they should absolutely be encouraged in & then things that they are less good at & thats ok. A life lesson they definately need to be taught at that age imo. Its all how you say it though & also a time & a place 🤷‍♀️

toobusymummy · 15/05/2023 21:07

big hugs to you and DD - yes it IS an important lesson to master BUT 11 is still very young to get your hopes smashed! If she's showing an interest in singing there are loads of am-dram choirs around (outside of school) who'd be delighted for her to join up - she may never make a professional singing but with the right coaching you can definitely improve the voice! Maybe remind her that pretty much EVERY famous person, whether actor or singer, was rejected multiple times after auditioning and went on to have amazing careers anyway - the key is persistence and being confident in what she enjoys and what she likes to do, and when she DOES improve then she can take pleasure in knowing that the school choir missed out ;-) (and to be fair whilst I think its not unreasonable for 'auditions' to be exactly that, I don't see why ANY school would discourage this kind of enthusiasm and not have a 'just for fun' choir too, my DD has a lovely signing voice but got terrible stage fright and because the choir HAD to participate in the various concerts and shows she decided not to join - might be worth mentioning to her music teacher at the next parents evening? just a though!)

ironblancmange · 15/05/2023 21:04

I think she should be allowed to join the choir if she loves singing. What is the point of the choir? Auditioning for good voices means the choir is intended to sound really good above everything. But in a choir you learn a lot about music, about harmonising, that you don't learn in music lessons. I speak as someone who has regretted for 60 years that our school choir went by audition.

Lovetoplan · 15/05/2023 21:02

That was me! Only girl rejected from the choir. Didn't realise my voice wasn't good. I was disappointed but I got over it. Best to just move on and focus on something she is good at.

Bookworm79 · 15/05/2023 20:42

Oh I really feel for you and your daughter. Mine went through exactly the same thing. She auditioned and was the only one out of her group of friends who didn’t get in. She was absolutely distraught. It’s so sad as in year 7 they are still keen to participate in all these activities whether they are great or not. As they get older they will naturally do less and less so I think it’s important that they have opportunities to participate in something that they enjoy, whether super talented or not. Luckily for my daughter there was also a non selective singing group which she joined and they even ended up doing a music tour in Paris. They were all abilities and they sound great when they perform. I would contact school and suggest an open access non audition singing club. I am sure there are other children who love to join. And please tell her that even though she didn’t get this chance, there will be something else waiting for her.

SpringIntoChaos · 15/05/2023 20:42

MamaMilanoMouse · 15/05/2023 20:24

That's simply the loveliest post on this thread @SpringIntoChaos .

What a lovely professional journey you have had and who knows, you might return to sining and music making in due time or combine teaching with your passion for music. 🎵

Very uplifting to read.

Awww thank you...I do love to sing with my class (year 2s 😍) and my favourite singers are the ones who belt it out 'like nobody is listening' - sounding like a rumbling train on a rickety track. I just love their enthusiasm and joy 😍

(That said - obviously there is a place for audition only choirs/orchestras and bands of course...if it's competitive or professional, then clearly only the most talented will be accepted...but there are plenty of community ventures for those with more 'spirit' than 'skill' 😉)

LolaSmiles · 15/05/2023 20:41

She’s not being unreasonable.
Music (except by professionals) should be a joyous, collaborative experience that promotes community and teamwork
You seem to really underestimate how few people make it professionally as musicians and that actually there's a lot of very talented amateur musicians.

Many of my friends from school were grade 8 musicians from their mid teens. Only a handful went to study music to a higher level beyond college and only a handful of them do it professionally. At school I was a reasonably good chorister, good enough for an auditioned choir, but not good enough for chamber choir. There's nothing wrong with that.

I'd like to join an orchestra again but I'm not good enough. The local amateur ones play to a high standard and I don't currently meet that standard. As an audience member of I go to see them play, or local chamber choirs perform, I go to listen to well-performed concerts, not a mediocre rendition of anyone who wants to have a go.

Famzonhol · 15/05/2023 20:34

strawberryFforever · 15/05/2023 20:25

You're being unreasonable. Sorry

The kid auditioned and didn't get in.

Encourage her to find something else

She’s not being unreasonable.
Music (except by professionals) should be a joyous, collaborative experience that promotes community and teamwork.
Not an attempt by the school to exclude all but a few so they can win a, let’s face it, meaningless piece of tin.
If you’re a gifted singer and want to sing with the best, by all means seek out and audition for a professionally trained choir outside of school. But at school let every child who loves music join in and be a part of it.

strawberryFforever · 15/05/2023 20:25

You're being unreasonable. Sorry

The kid auditioned and didn't get in.

Encourage her to find something else

MamaMilanoMouse · 15/05/2023 20:24

That's simply the loveliest post on this thread @SpringIntoChaos .

What a lovely professional journey you have had and who knows, you might return to sining and music making in due time or combine teaching with your passion for music. 🎵

Very uplifting to read.

SpringIntoChaos · 15/05/2023 20:11

True story: when I was 10, I went along with my friend Maria to audition for a new selective children's choir in our town. It was a HUGE deal at the time and made the local papers (this choir went on to win lots of competitions subsequently!).

Anyway, we all turned up on our allocated day, and had to stand in rows,singing scales to the piano, whilst stern-looking women walked up and down the rows listening. If they tapped you on the head you had to sit down.

After about 15 minutes of this, around half the room were sat down...me included. My friend was still standing. The 'sitters' were sent home, unsuccessful, and the standers had passed and were in the choir. It was quite a brutal audition and very public. I actually still feel the humiliation of that rejection...not 'because' I was rejected, but because of how it was done. We were so very young and it was quite a harsh way to do it.

I was devastated because I'd always been told I had a great singing voice, and was a Musician in other areas too (piano/saxophone and flute). It really knocked my confidence.

Anyway...several years later, after working my socks off, I attended The Northern College of Music, did my degree, and sang for many years on the professional circuit (before giving it all up after having my kids and becoming a primary school teacher 🤷‍♀️🤣)

OP...the moral here is, never give up on your dreams! If you work hard and train hard, it can pay off. Hope your DC is ok ♥️