Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:40

The same goes for sport.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:39

Well you get to choose between the few who are in it for competition vs the many who are in it for pleasure.

In a SCHOOL I vote the latter.
And with a good enough teacher who can sub-divide the singers it need not exclude talent at all.

Eleganz · 17/05/2023 08:37

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:13

So you’re saying all those people in community choirs who clearly love participating should be given the boot so that you personally can sing with only the best?

Isn't there room for all levels of choir? Why don’t you start an auditioned one? It’s fine for adults to do this. We’re talking about children in a school though, where there may be only one choir. And as you’ve observed yourself, so many people do love singing.

There should be room for all levels of choirs. The problem is that there are lots of people who think that auditioned groups for children should not exist, not that community choirs should not exist.

Pursuit of musical excellence is just as important as inclusion in the musical life of our country. Unfortunately not every school or community can offer everything to everyone and we need to take a wider view of things before condemning a particular school for having an auditioned, rather than unauditioned group.

My secondary school had no musical groups in it at all. We had one music teacher who was, as far as I could tell, a miserable drunk stuck teaching kids with largely no interest in his subject. It was only because of a local music centre that my parents took me to, run by volunteers, that I was exposed to music and then only because the lady that took the young children's choir at that centre told my mum I had a good voice and pointed me to a very good girl's choir in the next town over and that my parents prioritised spending their time and limited money on supporting me to sing. It would have been far more inclusive for my school to have run an auditioned group for free in my school than relying on parents having the resources to fund participation outside school.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:36

LolaSmiles · 17/05/2023 08:28

But also, how do we get the next generation of professionals? The BBC Singers don't just pop into existence because a few people had a go at singing in an unauditioned group
I agree.
There's a range of ensembles out there and if we are serious about getting better representation of state school children into the arts then we need to invest in having opportunities for talented musicians and artists, as well as those who have demonstrated potential.

Taking the view that if there's only one choir (remembering that these are enrichment activities done by staff who volunteer) it should be for anyone who wants a go, regardless of aptitude, ensures that any students who are musically talented or have an aptitude (and could come on well in a choir without their parents forking out for private vocal tuition) don't get the chance.

Whats wrong with a jolly sing along for all children?

See the quote above.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:36

Yerroblemom1923 · 17/05/2023 08:32

This is how those on X Factor get on it. They've been lied to for years by well- meaning people that they're amazing at singing when they're really not. Then they're genuinely hurt and surprised when Simon tells them the truth.

You don’t have to lie to anyone that they can sing. You let them sing in the all-comers choir regardless of whether they can sing. Believe me, if the teacher is good enough the choir will sound amazing. We have an all-comers choir at my DC school and they sound fantastic. The only exclusionary criteria is if a child doesn’t engage or attend regularly.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:34

Hmm sometimes I think the parents take these sorts of “disappointments” more to heart than the children.

I think we’ve all seen the parents that argue with the umpire at sports day about who won a race while the child is stood looking mortified muttering It’s fine mum leave it.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:34

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:25

Well no @Famzonhol I think that poster was pointing out that an auditioned school choir shouldn’t be the same as a community choir?
She was giving her own experience of community choirs and pointing out the disadvantages of using that model in secondary school.

Its a choir to nurture the skills and give valuable experience to more accomplished talented pupils who may go on to pursue music in further education, join orchestras or a career on the musical stage, rather than a jolly sing along.

But that’s exactly my point. What’s wrong with a jolly singalong for children at school level? Why exclude the many children who would like to do precisely that very thing?

Dulra · 17/05/2023 08:32

I was and still am a terrible singer, I absolutely loved to perform and sing as a young child, still dream about being the lead in a westend musical. I remember the class choirs (where everyone is included) I was politely asked if I could mime because I was putting everyone else off 😂I was devastated but they were dead right I was woeful

Yerroblemom1923 · 17/05/2023 08:32

This is how those on X Factor get on it. They've been lied to for years by well- meaning people that they're amazing at singing when they're really not. Then they're genuinely hurt and surprised when Simon tells them the truth.

WildFlowerBees · 17/05/2023 08:31

If she really can't sing and lots of people can't instead of focusing on the 'can't' find the other things she is brilliant at. Help her find her strengths and manage her disappointment. Also just because one person says something doesn't make it true. She might not be the 'voice of an angel' but she may be perfectly good enough for a different choir. Try and change your perspective, your responses will help your dd a great deal.

LolaSmiles · 17/05/2023 08:28

But also, how do we get the next generation of professionals? The BBC Singers don't just pop into existence because a few people had a go at singing in an unauditioned group
I agree.
There's a range of ensembles out there and if we are serious about getting better representation of state school children into the arts then we need to invest in having opportunities for talented musicians and artists, as well as those who have demonstrated potential.

Taking the view that if there's only one choir (remembering that these are enrichment activities done by staff who volunteer) it should be for anyone who wants a go, regardless of aptitude, ensures that any students who are musically talented or have an aptitude (and could come on well in a choir without their parents forking out for private vocal tuition) don't get the chance.

Lovemylaminator · 17/05/2023 08:26

I wouldn't have thought the music teacher said 'you can't sing', maybe that was the implied message the daughter is now quoting.

A choir is at year 7 level is the same as a sports team or a drama production. It's based on talent not enthusiasm.

I think the OP needs to stop wrapping her daughter in cotton wool, and use this as s life lesson. There will be something that the daughter is good at that others won't be.

There will also be 'singing for fun' opportunities and singing lessons if she really enjoys it that much.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:25

Well no @Famzonhol I think that poster was pointing out that an auditioned school choir shouldn’t be the same as a community choir?
She was giving her own experience of community choirs and pointing out the disadvantages of using that model in secondary school.

Its a choir to nurture the skills and give valuable experience to more accomplished talented pupils who may go on to pursue music in further education, join orchestras or a career on the musical stage, rather than a jolly sing along.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:13

JediIsMyMaster · 16/05/2023 22:26

The problem with accepting everyone, is it means that the best students have no space to expand their abilities. I think a medium has to be struck.

This. As someone who used to sing to a high standard, I’ve pretty much had to give up as it’s all community choirs round my area - not auditioned and no sheet music given (plus everything is too low for me, even though I’m a mezzo not a soprano). It’s great for people with limited musical background, but I don’t find it enjoyable. A bit like most sports are more fun when you’re playing with / competing with players of similar ability.

So you’re saying all those people in community choirs who clearly love participating should be given the boot so that you personally can sing with only the best?

Isn't there room for all levels of choir? Why don’t you start an auditioned one? It’s fine for adults to do this. We’re talking about children in a school though, where there may be only one choir. And as you’ve observed yourself, so many people do love singing.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:02

Yeah I agree @Schroedingersimmigrant

I didn’t get into choir but I wasn’t told I was bad- my name just wasn’t on the Notice board for choir. I’m not scarred.

I doubt the teacher was pulling faces and shaking their head like Simon Cowell and declaring Urgh You can’t sing.

Schroedingersimmigrant · 17/05/2023 07:31

I’ve sung with many adults who have perfectly fine voices but still have a fear of singing because of bad treatment as a child

I am going to be brutal, but one teacher with some remark about singing really shouldn't carry that much weight to cause fear in adulthood. I have both hands left and still love doing trying unsuccessfully things even though my teacher called my knitted sock a horror movie material. To be fair to her, it was. My art teacher often stood over my "art" silently trying to figure out what to say😂 I am still creating art abominations happily.
As I said. I also failed a very good choir audition due to not good enough voice, which I physically can't do anything about. It happens. But carry it into adulthood as fear is different issue though and I don't think it's fair to place all that as some teacher's fault.

jc12689 · 17/05/2023 07:28

You know on the early stages of Britain's Got Talent where you have people coming who are absolutely awful and humiliate themselves. That's because noone told them they were awful, or worse still, told them they were good.

Why spoil it for others who have some talent (for singing in this case) by letting People join group activities when they have no talent.

Just find something she's good at and do that.

Eleganz · 17/05/2023 07:28

LolaSmiles · 17/05/2023 06:50

I sometimes thing people thing music is a less legitimate subject of study, which I don't think it is. The problem with accepting everyone, is it means that the best students have no space to expand their abilities. I think a medium has to be struck
This. All this "inclusive unless it's a professional ensemble" misses the point that most musicians are not professional and there are a LOT of talented amateur musicians. Many high quality amateur ensembles are good and can play the repertoire they do because the musicians are a certain standard. Same for auditioned school choirs, school orchestras, regional youth ensembles, etc.

It's ok to not be good enough for an auditioned ensemble. That's why there's a range of activities and ensembles, just not all of them will be offered at school by staff volunteering.

But also, how do we get the next generation of professionals? The BBC Singers don't just pop into existence because a few people had a go at singing in an unauditioned group.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 07:23

bad treatment as a child..a music teacher told them they couldn’t sing.

I see your point and posters are giving anecdotes about teachers, but nowadays with school emphasis on personal development and positive reinforcement, it’s unlikely a teacher would tell a pupil “you can’t sing”.

A mate or your brother remarking “it sounds like a cat’s being strangled!” or a comment on your TikTok but a music teacher? No.

LolaSmiles · 17/05/2023 06:50

I sometimes thing people thing music is a less legitimate subject of study, which I don't think it is. The problem with accepting everyone, is it means that the best students have no space to expand their abilities. I think a medium has to be struck
This. All this "inclusive unless it's a professional ensemble" misses the point that most musicians are not professional and there are a LOT of talented amateur musicians. Many high quality amateur ensembles are good and can play the repertoire they do because the musicians are a certain standard. Same for auditioned school choirs, school orchestras, regional youth ensembles, etc.

It's ok to not be good enough for an auditioned ensemble. That's why there's a range of activities and ensembles, just not all of them will be offered at school by staff volunteering.

Anele22 · 16/05/2023 23:22

Oops just seen Year 7, not 7 year old.

Anele22 · 16/05/2023 23:20

So many people grow up thinking they can’t sing because a music teacher told them they couldn’t or rejected them from the choir or told them to mime. I’ve sung with many adults who have perfectly fine voices but still have a fear of singing because of bad treatment as a child. At 7 little girls voices are still developing and with practice most people learn to sing tunefully. If the school wants a specialist singing group they should run two choirs -rather like first and second teams. It’s so sad when schools can’t find away to be inclusive and let all the children have a go at whatever they want. God knows there’ll be years when they can’t.

JediIsMyMaster · 16/05/2023 22:26

The problem with accepting everyone, is it means that the best students have no space to expand their abilities. I think a medium has to be struck.

This. As someone who used to sing to a high standard, I’ve pretty much had to give up as it’s all community choirs round my area - not auditioned and no sheet music given (plus everything is too low for me, even though I’m a mezzo not a soprano). It’s great for people with limited musical background, but I don’t find it enjoyable. A bit like most sports are more fun when you’re playing with / competing with players of similar ability.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/05/2023 22:22

I'm interested in whether the pps who see music as an activity that should be fully inclusive regardless of ability, whether they feel the same about sports, drama and other areas? So names out of a hat for who plays in a football game, or gets the lead in the school play?

I sometimes thing people thing music is a less legitimate subject of study, which I don't think it is. The problem with accepting everyone, is it means that the best students have no space to expand their abilities. I think a medium has to be struck.

SmileyClare · 16/05/2023 22:08

School choirs are for children to enjoy and remember all their lives

In secondary school a choir is often about more than fun enjoyment for kids.

Some will be following a path into further training and musical qualifications, progressing to singing in orchestras or studying music at college.

So no, a school choir for older pupils isn’t just about jolly fun and fond memories. It can be a real chance for pupils to have their talent nurtured and gain valuable experience required to access college courses or musical training.

If numbers are limited, what’s the alternative to auditions? Names out of a hat?