Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
TheShellBeach · 14/05/2023 04:08

Nobody would listen to a choir which contained bad singers, though.
If people cannot sing, they cannot be taught to do so. You either can or you can't sing. People singing out of tune are really obvious in part singing.
I've sung in various choirs throughout my life (well-known ones).
People wouldn't pay to listen to bad ones. Why should your daughter ruin things for listeners?
I've also run a couple of choirs. I wouldn't accept someone whose voice ruined the overall effect.
YABU. When I was at school I was terrible at games. Should I have been allowed to join the hockey team, just because I wanted to?

JMSA · 14/05/2023 04:06

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

But sometimes that's just life.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/05/2023 03:53

If you're there to be taught something, it's fine for all-comers (assuming you fulfil any other basic requirements - are old enough etc.); but if you're there to develop, share, enjoy and hopefully demonstrate your skills to (maybe paying) audiences, you do need to have some skills to demonstrate in the first place.

WandaWonder · 14/05/2023 03:51

WandaWonder · 14/05/2023 03:48

To me a child wanting to join (examples only) art club who has no talent is different to joining a violin orchestra who has never played a note or a competition swim club for a child who can't swim

If you can't sing you can't sing

Yea people can learn to swim, play the violin, sing with lessons

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/05/2023 03:50

If numbers are limited - which in a choir they often are, should a person who can't sing take the place of one that can?

But they often aren't limited in numbers - so the children with good voices will get in, but their efforts will be wrecked as they are drowned out by the bad one(s)!

The very nature of out-of-tune voices is that, even in amongst 30 tuneful voices, they are the one that you will instantly hear most clearly of all!

WandaWonder · 14/05/2023 03:48

To me a child wanting to join (examples only) art club who has no talent is different to joining a violin orchestra who has never played a note or a competition swim club for a child who can't swim

If you can't sing you can't sing

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/05/2023 03:46

Nah, 20 odd years ago our choir and orchestra was audition/skills based not 'anyone can join in'. I got into choir first time, I had to wait til 2nd year to get into orchestra as I was bottom of the heap at Flute AND there were already loads of flutes so no room for a 'just about good enough' player.

Choir/Orchestra are equivalent to 'sports team' here, they're not a club, they're not an 'improving at this skill' session.

They learn pieces and perform at events and competitions (or certainly did way back when I was involved in both).

Having someone next to you who is off key, out of time or playing bum notes is off putting and yes, you CAN hear it in the audience.

Sorry, I think you have failed here in not preparing her to have realistic expectations of the process, or her ability. If she wants to improve at singing, get her singing lessons.

Itsallok · 14/05/2023 03:44

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 03:41

I'm actually on your side. My gran had the worst singing voice ever, and a professional voice coach once said "I could make you sing - anyone has the ability to sing if they're taught correctly."

School's for learning and encouraging, if her singing isn't good enough for the choir, she needs extra support, not told she's not good enough.

To put it into perspective, if you do a maths or georgraphy test in year nine and get a grade D, the teacher doesn't say "Not good enough, give up."

Hardly the same thing. Required academic learning compared to a voluntary choir - which clearly stated auditions. No wonder schools are sick of parents

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 03:41

I'm actually on your side. My gran had the worst singing voice ever, and a professional voice coach once said "I could make you sing - anyone has the ability to sing if they're taught correctly."

School's for learning and encouraging, if her singing isn't good enough for the choir, she needs extra support, not told she's not good enough.

To put it into perspective, if you do a maths or georgraphy test in year nine and get a grade D, the teacher doesn't say "Not good enough, give up."

GADDay · 14/05/2023 03:41

This will stand her in good stead.

All things are not equal. Not everybody gets a prize (nor should they). Some people are better at some things than others.

If numbers are limited - which in a choir they often are, should a person who can't sing take the place of one that can?

Oh and fyi - all 11 year olds definitely don't sound the same.

Makingamess4212 · 14/05/2023 03:36

My primary choir just let anyone in, we must of sounded awful haha! I cannot sing at all, but I LOVE it ! In this house we listen to music and sing, the TV is hardly on, just music .. But I still didn't make it into the comprehensive choir. I'm not a good singer, and I needed the truth. Or I would of tried X factor and made an absolute fool of myself 🤣 I thought I was the next Cher haha!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/05/2023 03:32

I'll always remember the school play where I was given the 'role' of 'Villager'. This meant that I, and the other two dozen or so villagers, had to sit quietly and motionless at the back of the stage and.... watch the talented kids act in the roles that had speaking parts and/or actually did something that the parents would want to watch them doing.

I wouldn't have minded quite so much, except we were made to turn up for every single rehearsal - even though I was already very accomplished indeed (if I do say so myself) at sitting quietly on the floor!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/05/2023 03:27

I can see both sides of this.

I've been in community choirs (for adults) where everybody is welcome - auditions for solos, as you'd expect - although I always remember one where there was a woman with the double whammy of being a terrible singer but convinced that she was amazing and insisting that she stand right under one of the microphones, so the tech guy just switched that one off!

Yes, a good choir leader can teach people to improve, within reason, but there are people - often those who insist on singing at top volume - who are just tone deaf and cannot/will not be helped, and who will single-handedly wreck the choir.

I don't know if anybody on here has seen the guilty pleasure programme 'I Can See Your Voice'. The basic premise is that contestants have to pick up on cues and clues when people mime (good ones mime to a recording of their own voice and bad ones mime to somebody else's, who IS good!) and guess whether they are good singers or bad singers - and they win money if they identify the good singers and the bad singers win the money if they can fool the contestants into thinking that they are good singers!

They usually avoid those who are mediocre and only have wonderful or horrendous singers - and the horrendous ones know that they are awful and think it might be a laugh and a good earner if they can wing it - but I always thought how extremely awkward it must be if the programme makers approached (or were approached by) terrible singers who genuinely believe they sound like Adele or Lewis Capaldi, when they actually sound like a cat with its tail trapped in a door!

Obviously, there are ways of telling people who sound terrible sensitively, but it's difficult when faced with those who refuse to listen and gainsay you when you tactfully try to tell them that they are good at a lot of things, but maybe singing isn't one of their fortes.

As has been said already, it's accepted that people are chosen/accepted on merit when it's a sports team, but it's often considered really cruel when it's a choir - even if somebody has such a frightful voice that drowns out the others and makes the choir into such a laughing stock that there's no point anybody else trying or even turning up.

It seems very unfair on people like me, who were the last to be picked for PE every single time (oh, the grimaces of sheer disappointment on the pickers' faces, who would rather their team have been one player down than have me), but who have quite good voices and have even on occasion been picked for solos.

It's a difficult one - especially when you often hear proclamations that 'absolutely anybody can learn to sing well', when the truth is more like 'most people can learn how to sing better, but some are thoroughly beyond all hope, however hard they may try'. Maybe it's also a significant factor that sports teams usually have a set number of people, so people can understand that they weren't one of the best seven (or whatever) players this time - but they were almost certainly the eighth best by the narrowest of margins(!), and can still make it on to the subs bench (which they never leave). In sharp contrast, choirs don't usually have a set number of people, so you can't use the excuse that "You're really great, but we already have X number of people who are just a tiny bit even more polished than you at this stage".

Itsallok · 14/05/2023 03:20

The key is the word - audition! Same as the school musicals - auditions are held, some get in, some don't. Same as sporting teams. Schools are actually good for this. And why should yeachers give up even more time for yet another choir. Cough up for singing lessons if its that important.

Your kid will have no resilience in life if you become that parent.

Tellmeimcrazy · 14/05/2023 03:20

Is this post for real? If you audition or try out for anything you don't get picked if you aren't good enough. Your child may be a good singer, but there were probably far better and both you and your child need to accept that.

I honestly think that this post is exactly what is wrong with parenting today. Overprotective parents who think their child should be picked regardless of how rubbish they are because they don't want their children's feelings hurt.

Would you hire someone for a wjob that was sub-par?

Gwdihooooo · 14/05/2023 03:16

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

You risk becoming one of those parents who encourages their child to sing on x factor even though they’re rubbish… and they just get ridiculed for laughs

EpicChaos · 14/05/2023 03:15

If everyone should just be able to join the choir if they want, regardless of being tone deaf, or whatever, how about other tone deaf kids playing all the violins? Is that what you'd like to listen to?
And what about poor parents having to cope with bleeding ears from having to listen to the screech, screech, screech of badly played violins. Schools would have to start therapy sessions for parents who've suffered the trauma and literal violence of hearing the noise.

jazzybelle · 14/05/2023 03:10

I tried out for the school choir in the juniors and was accepted. Two others weren't. That's life. We can't be good at everything.

Redglitter · 14/05/2023 03:09

My brother got into the school choir. He got kicked out a few months later. That was sorer than if he hadn't got in initially

Izzy24 · 14/05/2023 03:07

CrapBucket · 14/05/2023 01:27

A school choir should accept everyone! Gareth Malone wouldn’t tell an 11 year old they aren’t good enough. He’d teach them ways to improve.

Yes this, absolutely.

Ladybug14 · 14/05/2023 03:05

But that's what an audition is for. To weed out those who are not good enough

And yes, you DO say to your child

'that's a shame that your voice isn't what they're looking for. If you'd like to sing in a choir, let's get you some singing lessons to help you improve'

I'd also check with the choir master at school to clarify what area in particular he'd suggest she improves

Stop being one of those mothers fgs

SparklyBlackKitten · 14/05/2023 03:04

Yabu. And rediculous really
They have auditions for a reason. To pick the good singers

"Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad..."

Of course you say to kids (especially your own!!!) They they are not good at something. But that isn't sad . Just reality. My kids are HORRIBLE at drawing and I tell them that. They are amazing at math. And I tell them that too.

Imagine if I'd send my kids to a drawing audition and then be all sad and annoyed that they didn't get in?! I know they suck. And even if they were just mediocre . If they dont qualify. They dont qualify. And I would encourage them to try out for something else.

ElizabethBest · 14/05/2023 03:00

Replace singing with swimming. Now think about how silly you sound.

LBHSisgreat · 14/05/2023 03:00

Get her a year of singing lessons and if she works hard she can reaudition. It's a great learning experience!

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/05/2023 02:57

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:29

Most clubs at school are about improving, anyone can sign up for the netball or football clubs, not sure how the team things work but even if they are selected from the clubs, anyone can still do the clubs. So even if they wanted a choir to perform and be the best, they should surely have an option for the kids wanting to participate and improve, like they do for everything else. DD was just told no and that's that, no way for her to get to sing at all at school even though that's what she enjoys and is interested in. Does just seem unfair

Dd had never played netball before secondary and she really enjoys it now and says she’s pretty good (she gets picked for the team) so it would be pointless to get Year 7s to try out. The peer pressure with football is such that by secondary boys know whether or not the can play football and have pretty much already self selected. Besides, only the ones, who can play will be picked to go to matches. Effectively this is just another form of audition and the kids not picked tend to drop out of the practice sessions.