Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 14/05/2023 06:01

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing

Exactly that.

If it bother you or her so much then do something about it but don’t lie to your child. It will save a lot of heartache

Yeahno · 14/05/2023 06:00

I would have taken a hint from 'audition' and 'choir'. If you want singing lessons, find one and pay for it.

Totalwasteofpaper · 14/05/2023 06:00

Yabu.
I tried out and didnt get in. It hurt my feelings and in the end joined an everyone can join choir and learned to sing less loudly. I quit by year 9.

I think try and position it as a life lesson for her. Not everything will go your way. Its an opportunity to teach resilience

Also my DH positively loves my dodgy singing and he is an amazing and talented musician - go figure?!

CosmosQueen · 14/05/2023 05:56

RampantIvy · 14/05/2023 01:32

There wouldn't be any point in having auditions if they didn't want to only select the best singers.

YABU.

Precisely!
Why on earth would a choir include those who cannot sing?
It’s no wonder that many young people feel that they’re entitled to do whatever they like if they never get told no.

Sunnycornwallanddevon · 14/05/2023 05:54

I honestly think that this post is exactly what is wrong with parenting today. Overprotective parents who think their child should be picked regardless of how rubbish they are because they don't want their children's feelings hurt

Totally agree

RedHelenB · 14/05/2023 05:54

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

You do for school football/netball teams. And girls school plays. When she goes for a job, she might well get rejected, not even get an interview. School helps you build resilience fir things like this. There will be something else at school that will be a good fit for her, maybe try drama if she likes performing

SavvyWavvy · 14/05/2023 05:49

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

And this is exactly why kids aren’t learning resilience. This is one of many times your daughter will be told they’re bad at something. Help her to come to terms with it but don’t tell her the school were wrong or unkind because that’s simply not true.

GuevarasBeret · 14/05/2023 05:49

Norma27 · 14/05/2023 01:19

i have an awful voice and no way should I be allowed to ruin a choir however much I want to join. I was pretty much told at primary school I was too bad- which I was.

Me too, and my daughter.
but we can accept it with good grace, we have other talents.

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 14/05/2023 05:44

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 03:41

I'm actually on your side. My gran had the worst singing voice ever, and a professional voice coach once said "I could make you sing - anyone has the ability to sing if they're taught correctly."

School's for learning and encouraging, if her singing isn't good enough for the choir, she needs extra support, not told she's not good enough.

To put it into perspective, if you do a maths or georgraphy test in year nine and get a grade D, the teacher doesn't say "Not good enough, give up."

Anyone? My husband is completely tone deaf. Can tone deaf people be taught to sing if they just don't have that instinct for pitch? Doesn't matter though, he's got his own strengths.

soupmaker · 14/05/2023 05:44

It's rubbish for your DD but this is a life lesson. We need to prepare our kids for disappointment and rejection. Resilience in the face of disappointment is a key life skill.

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 14/05/2023 05:41

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

No but it's a good lesson for them to know that we all have our strengths and talents and some people are better at some things than others. They have their things they are best at. I don't think it's good for kids to be told they are amazing at everything, when they're not.

Also, that sometimes they have to try more than once to get what they want. A friend's daughter applied to medical school four times before being accepted on the fifth time. She learned from the rejection that she had things to work on to be more competitive next time.

It doesn't sound like this is an all comers choir so she must have known she might not have got in?

Hal9001 · 14/05/2023 05:29

Jinglesplodge · 14/05/2023 01:42

The thing about singing is that people presume it's all about some kind of innate natural talent: sometimes it is. Often it's not.

If she's discouraged by not doing well in the audition the best thing she can do is have singing lessons.

If a child didn't make the swimming squad but was desperate to do so you'd put them in swimming lessons. If a child needed to pass the 11 plus but was behind the curve you'd get a tutor. But with music there is a perception that you turn up, have a go, and that's all there is. If she didn't get into the choir and would like to, she has the option of lessons to get her up to the standard, otherwise it's pretty fair for them to select based on audition.

This is correct.

One can learn to sing, I learnt to sing through lessons. I'm never going to be brilliant, but I'm better than I was!

Someone also taught me to talk, drive, ride, cook, draw, write and make a martini!

These are all skills, they're not innate, one can have a natural acuity but just because I can shake my booty, it doesn't mean I can dance like a prima ballerina, just because I can draw a passable likeness of a human I'm not going to be accepted to art school.

It's ok to be ok at things, and it's also a good lesson in resilience to realise that you're not going to be great at everything and you can't always just join in because 'you want to'.

It's also OK to take singing lessons and become good enough to join a choir. I did, because I really like singing and I knew I needed to sharpen up my voice a bit in order to do so.

steff13 · 14/05/2023 05:09

TheShellBeach · 14/05/2023 04:10

Nobody can be taught to sing in tune.

Of course you can.

If she's serious about singing, get her voice lessons. Or, maybe she could join a church choir? They generally let anyone join.

sunnydayhereandnow · 14/05/2023 05:01

As a music teacher I’m 99% sure that this is not to do with her actual voice but rather that she was finding it very hard to sing in tune, and the choir director probably just doesn’t have enough time on their hands to work from the beginning with weaker kids on ear training as well as teaching the stronger kids to sing harmonies and so on (which is really hard to do if some of the group is not singing in tune).

The good thing is that it’s not about talent, it’s just about training the ear to hear musically. Nearly everyone can learn to sing in tune. Any kind of music lessons will help and the teacher will be able to work on this with her.

Garethkeenansstapler · 14/05/2023 05:00

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

What’s the alternative? False hope? Letting her hold the choir back so they can’t enter competitions or be taken seriously at events? This ‘everyone is a winner’ stuff is ridiculous, must we cosset children at every turn until they’re 18 only to discover the world is actually competitive and ruthless?

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/05/2023 04:42

Why is being told 'you don't have the requisite skills for this activity' in any way 'shaming' now?

It's simply a statement of fact!

I don't feel shamed if told I don't have the skill of ooh, walking, horse riding, flying a plane, playing bass guitar etc etc - even though some of those things I did used to be very skilled at, the fact is, right now, I do not have those skills!

Was the OP's child held up in front of the whole school and everyone booed her after it was publically announced shes not a good enough singer to join the choir? That would be shaming. Simply being told 'nope you didn't pass the audition' is absolutely not though!

I disagree that people who can't sing cannot be taught though. Some people are out of tune because they lack the confidence, the voice control, the breathing, to hit the notes required. They can hear that they're out of tune or not hitting notes, but they just don't know how to do it.

That can be taught in most cases.

People who cannot hear that they are off key however, thats harder and I do agree, most people who are tone deaf can't learn that.

echt · 14/05/2023 04:31

TheShellBeach · 14/05/2023 04:10

Nobody can be taught to sing in tune.

The ShellBeach, barring a signifiant physical or mental impediment, what you say sounds colossal bollocks.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 14/05/2023 04:29

I think this is harsh. Singing is often something we naturally, as children and babies, love to do. It is only when we are shamed that we lose that joy. I think it is wrong to shame a child for something as naturally joyful as singing. A PP incorrectly stated that you cannot be taught to sing in tune. Untrue. OP, your daughter may need some professional lessons to learn to hear her voice aligning with the notes. If you are able, I'd encourage lessons. Please reassure her that although she might not have the right voice for this choir, she should continue to enjoy singing.

JudgeRudy · 14/05/2023 04:29

YABU to think that rejecting someone from a choir based on their voice is anything other than expected. I bet she wouldn't be chosen for the football team either.

Buttonsandlace · 14/05/2023 04:23

Resilience is serious lacking in youngsters today. She can't sing. Find her something she can shine at doing.

Brenda79 · 14/05/2023 04:22

Aw I’m sorry for your daughter. It must be so tough to see her be into something good for her, when she has the confidence to do it, but not be accepted to do it.
i take my toddler to a music class where the teacher says anyone can sing, and often voices her upset at people being told they can’t sing well enough etc. The one day, at school or somewhere else, that changes and they are taught otherwise. So it must be so confusing for children to be taught they can do anything then overnight it seems to all change.

is there a another group in school she can join? Or a group outside of school that is less selective?

Lemonademoney · 14/05/2023 04:19

I’m afraid I see it just as I’d see trying out for a sports team. Not everyone will get in. But I am sorry she’s been so hurt by it. Is there anything else she could try out for instead?

theGooHasGone · 14/05/2023 04:14

To answer your question - no, it's not horrible, it's real life.

theGooHasGone · 14/05/2023 04:13

Sorry, your kid's not good enough to sing in the choir. Get her some lessons and she can audition again in a year.

TheShellBeach · 14/05/2023 04:10

WandaWonder · 14/05/2023 03:51

Yea people can learn to swim, play the violin, sing with lessons

Nobody can be taught to sing in tune.