Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
notacooldad · 14/05/2023 07:14

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...
Why lie though?
They learn they can’t be good at everything. You have to support them with what they are good at.

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing
no, that would be unkind to say you are shit at singing but you could be more tactful and kindly discourage her. You then encourage with the things she is good at whether it’s arts, sport or something else.

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 14/05/2023 07:14

A lot of PPs have repeated the myth that anyone can be taught to sing. This is nof the case because some people are afflicted with amusia and cannot discern different pitches. Some people are also deaf or hearing-impaired.

Amusia - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusia

WilkinsonM · 14/05/2023 07:13

YABU!!
at least she chose to audition - at my school choir tryouts were mandatory (one on one to the choir master) and you either got general choir, chapel choir (for the best) or no choir. Terrifying!
in any case it's a choir and the kids need some raw material to work with. Surely she had a realistic idea of her singing talent by age 11?

Neopolitan · 14/05/2023 07:12

You can really see the posters that are 'everyone wins a prize' type friends rather than parents on this thread. They can't see they are not preparing their child for life, they are creating anxiety. I feel sorry for their kids not being prepared for the world.

Blondewithredlips · 14/05/2023 07:12

Surely you have to be able to sing well to be in a choir?

autienotnaughtym · 14/05/2023 07:11

It sounds like being picked for the football team as opposed to going to the football after school club. A level of skill is required which your dd did not meet. She can either practice and aim to improve for next year or try her hand at something else. The best you can do is support her and help her understand it's impossible to be good at everything and that's ok.

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 07:10

And as for posters calling a disappointed child a spoilt madam and similar names, you should be ashamed of yourselves. The guff about an entirely misconceived ide a of 'resilience ' is just that, guff. Resilience is not .magically switching off disappointment, or having armour-pla ted confidence.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:10

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 07:04

Fantastic post.

I'm a decent (amateur) singer and sing in a couple of weak/struggling parish choirs as well as other, more challenging stuff. They're never going to be brilliant, but with work and patience they can sound pretty good and enrich services. A school that only has an audition-entry choir and not also a non-auditioning one is frankly taking itself far too seriously and its educational purpose far too lightly.

Agreed @Flibbyjibby @ShoesoftheWorld

No wonder kids have anxiety these days. The school could be offering an inclusive activity that lifts the soul, promotes community and inclusiveness, costs peanuts and helps children learn life isn't all about exams and grades.

Instead they're saying nope, you're shit at this at 11, don't bother, we don't want you.

Fcuk38 · 14/05/2023 07:09

Yes my kid didn’t get into the netball team and not allowed to go to the club. But she knows and respects because others were better. You really can’t have a choir with someone’s whose voice sounds like a cheese grater.

LolaSmiles · 14/05/2023 07:08

The larger schools I've worked at have had two tiers of ensembles: the main school ensembles and then a couple of training groups. That only works because the department is big enough to have enough staff to run them all.

In a smaller department I can see why there might be one ensemble and why they might make it audition entry. It's very difficult to be all things to all people and running a choir for people who can read music, sing well, and are looking to develop their technique is a very different focus to trying to get non-music readers who are tone deaf to sing a melody in tune.

MamaMilanoMouse · 14/05/2023 07:07

You need relative pitch to sing in a choir to know when you're out of tune. Maybe your dd doesn't have relative pitch?

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 07:07

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 14/05/2023 05:44

Anyone? My husband is completely tone deaf. Can tone deaf people be taught to sing if they just don't have that instinct for pitch? Doesn't matter though, he's got his own strengths.

Congenital amusia, hmm I'd hazard a no actually.

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/05/2023 07:07

tigerdrew · Today 01:26
Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad”

Yes, you don’t put it that bluntly though. Rather, play up their strengths and tell them that everyone is good at different things.

If you just tell them they’re marvellous at everything, they’re in for a big shock when they go to school.

PinkButtercups · 14/05/2023 07:07

No, that's the whole point.

Yes she is young and has high emotions but can't be upset that her voice was not good enough for the choir then you ask if YABU..

Of course YABU one bad singer in the choir would really stand out.

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 14/05/2023 07:07

I learnt to sing as an adult with vocal lessons. 97% of people can learn to sing. But the voice is a musical instrument that must be trained and learnt how to play.

Since singing in competitive choirs I've learnt that a huge amount of singers take lessons. It's not the innate talent we are led to believe.

It's the same as track sports. Everyone has arms and legs, but without dedication and training not everyone can run competitively.

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 07:04

Flibbyjibby · 14/05/2023 06:51

As a music teacher, I strongly believe that anybody can and should be allowed to sing! Being part of a musical ensemble like a choir is great for feeling a sense of belonging and community (especially important in y7) and fosters a love for music.

Yes I have pupils who struggle with pitch, intonation etc. But funnily enough, everything can be improved through practice and familiarity.

I wouldn’t dream of rejecting any child from our choirs, and I despise the elitist mentality some schools have regarding music. Private tuition is expensive and not every parent has the means or sees the value in investing in this for their child.

The bottom line is this: Music is for everyone. The school is wrong. If this is their outlook then they can’t have a particularly thriving music department.

Fantastic post.

I'm a decent (amateur) singer and sing in a couple of weak/struggling parish choirs as well as other, more challenging stuff. They're never going to be brilliant, but with work and patience they can sound pretty good and enrich services. A school that only has an audition-entry choir and not also a non-auditioning one is frankly taking itself far too seriously and its educational purpose far too lightly.

Neopolitan · 14/05/2023 07:03

Yes. And I think OP's daughter is the type who grows up, tries out for Idol, is turned down and makes a fool of themselves on tv by carrying on and not respecting the judges wishes, throws a tantrum and embarrasses themself. I think we can now understand why those types of contestants can't accept the judges' decisions. Their parents obviously never parented them and told them they can do whatever they want. So when they're told no, they just can't comprehend it. And so go into meltdown. As entertaining as those Idol contestants are, it's sad they were raised that way and it's sad they meltdown on tv from the rejection, because they were raised to have such rose-coloured unrealistic expectations of life. We now know how contestants like that come to be like that.

Summerfun54321 · 14/05/2023 07:03

You have 2 choices. Encourage her to think "poor me, it's someone else's fault if I'm not good enough" or, get her some singing lessons and encourage her to try again next year.

I had joint singing lessons with someone who was absolutely tone deaf in secondary school. I really wish the singing teacher told her not to bother sooner, it was painful.

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 14/05/2023 07:02

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

In grammar school areas, your DD would have been already told that she's good enough for grammar school or not, based on her 11+ results. If she'd tried out for inter-school sports teams at primary, she would have been accepted or rejected for the team already. She must have taken SATs and been told her results from those, right?

It's not too young to learn that you don't always get what you want, at all. It's not too young to learn that sometimes you lose.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:02

PurpleFlower1983 · 14/05/2023 06:51

I feel sad for your DD but unfortunately singing is one of those things that you can do or you can’t. I think you have to know your skill so you don’t embarrass yourself to be honest! Those who can’t sing do stick out like a sore thumb in a choir. It was the same when I went to school. I’m sure your DD has other talents. Could she take up an instrument if she likes music?

This is bullshit. Everyone can sing

Flibbyjibby · 14/05/2023 07:01

Tellmeimcrazy · 14/05/2023 06:52

Rubbish. The better the choir and musicians are the more the department will thrive especially if they compete. As PPs have stated a "?choir club" would be different

And how do the musicians get better? Not all musicians just have innate musical talent despite what most people seem to think!!

you want a thriving music department? You run ensembles that are open and inclusive!

I work in a state school in an area which is not particularly affluent. Our extra-curricular is open and all pupils are encouraged to come along no matter what their musical experience or ability.

We have huge uptake for GCSE and A-Level because we have broken through the mentality of “I can’t do music because I’m not ‘musical’”.

Yes we have more advanced ensembles open to only our exam group students, but we have open ensembles for all instruments and voices.

The problem here for me would be if this is the only choir in the school, and it is auditioned, it is killing the love of music for a lot of pupils.

CJsGoldfish · 14/05/2023 07:01

I honestly think that this post is exactly what is wrong with parenting today. Overprotective parents who think their child should be picked regardless of how rubbish they are because they don't want their children's feelings hurt

Definitely.
Children are 'protected' from rejection, conflict and any kind of negativity and can't learn how to manage these feelings and situations. It's a life skill and CAN be used positively in age appropriate ways.

AgentJohnson · 14/05/2023 07:01

If she wants to sing, pay for lessons.

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 07:01

Itsallok · 14/05/2023 03:44

Hardly the same thing. Required academic learning compared to a voluntary choir - which clearly stated auditions. No wonder schools are sick of parents

  1. All my academic learning amounted to nothing, as it wasn't relavent in the real work place.
  2. No wonder schools are sick of parents - What do you mean?
AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:00

I think that's awful. And the replies on here are also awful! I'm in a community choir run on natural voice principles, the idea is that singing is everyone's birthright. No one is 'bad'. You learn by rote rather than sheet music.

I get there some choirs want to run on different lines, but what do they expect of an 11yo?

I'd look up natural voice practitioners near you, there might be a youth choir or you could get one set up, at school or out of it? Start with a workshop.

It's so sad people think it's ok to exclude people from singing like this without a chance to learn and improve.