Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 12:48

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 12:27

I’m sure that some mixed ability choir might not stretch the very able.

Choices choices: should a school only cater for very able singers - and the majority of ordinary children seek out and pay for music classes elsewhere (or not sing at all, if they can’t afford it).

Or should the school cater for everyone - and the smaller number of able singers seek out extra singing opportunities in addition to what they do at school, this getting a double helping of what they are good at.

I know which I’d choose.

Not all schools have those choices do they?

Quite often there are limited spaces, limited staff available after school and the hall or wherever they practice has a maximum safe capacity or staff to pupil ratio.

So your preferred choice is often not possible, leaving auditioning or operating some sort of lottery for places (which would probably garner even more parental complaints).

KarmaStar · 17/05/2023 12:40

You are being precious and teaching her she can be entitled to anything as mummy says so.
get a grip and look at what you are teaching your child.

pollymere · 17/05/2023 12:35

I've had to audition for CHURCH choirs. An audition suggests a limited number of spaces and high standards. You can't have too many sopranos for example so the number of sopranos is restricted by the number of altos, tenors and basses. Not getting into the choir does not indicate your DD is a bad singer, especially in Y7. I've sung professionally yet failed to get into the School Production in Y7 as they gave priority to students higher up the school.

Get feedback from the Music Teacher perhaps? Mine had a similar problem with hockey tryouts. Excellent at hockey but they already had several excellent players on the wing.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 12:27

I’m sure that some mixed ability choir might not stretch the very able.

Choices choices: should a school only cater for very able singers - and the majority of ordinary children seek out and pay for music classes elsewhere (or not sing at all, if they can’t afford it).

Or should the school cater for everyone - and the smaller number of able singers seek out extra singing opportunities in addition to what they do at school, this getting a double helping of what they are good at.

I know which I’d choose.

JediIsMyMaster · 17/05/2023 12:10

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 12:08

Sorry but it is perfectly possible to develop a very decent mixed ability choir provided the participants are engaged and prepared to take direction. I’ve seen and heard it.

The school may not win the national gold medal for Best Choir Ever - but I suppose each school needs to decide what it thinks is important in the long run.

My experience has been very different, unfortunately. I’ve never known a mixed ability choir where the more able are sufficiently challenged.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 12:08

JediIsMyMaster · 17/05/2023 11:41

But can’t you see that there is no way of including everyone fairly?

If you include the bad singers, you’re excluding the decent ones as they won’t engage / won’t be developed to the best of their ability.

If you include the good singers, you exclude the bad ones.

Ideal is to have different groups that cater to all - but there are obvious resourcing issues.

Sorry but it is perfectly possible to develop a very decent mixed ability choir provided the participants are engaged and prepared to take direction. I’ve seen and heard it.

The school may not win the national gold medal for Best Choir Ever - but I suppose each school needs to decide what it thinks is important in the long run.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 11:58

No I’m not saying Music is a whim. Music is on the national curriculum and taught to all pupils from 5-14 years; whether they want to do it or not!

I do understand your view about the advantages of allowing all pupils to join a choir if they wanted, you have some valid points.

I think what’s up for debate is whether it’s damaging to children to be told, I’m sorry you haven’t won on a place on the school choir.
I don’t think it is and parents should help manage a child’s disappointment at not winning/ qualifying for something rather than being angry , saying the school are “horrible” (op’s words) and it’s so sad that this particular activity isn’t inclusive to everyone.

Lets give some credit to children who are 11 or older. They are capable of managing disappointment and accepting others may be better at something than they are.

JediIsMyMaster · 17/05/2023 11:41

But can’t you see that there is no way of including everyone fairly?

If you include the bad singers, you’re excluding the decent ones as they won’t engage / won’t be developed to the best of their ability.

If you include the good singers, you exclude the bad ones.

Ideal is to have different groups that cater to all - but there are obvious resourcing issues.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 11:38

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 11:21

We’re just talking about an after school choir that meet up and practice, not the school curriculum. In which music is offered to all pupils.

I don’t know why parents think schools should or are able to cater for every child’s whim under the guise of “inclusivity”

I suppose it depends on what you think of as a whim.

Many children love participating in music. It’s not a new thing or a whim. It’s been around for millennia so has stood the test of time.

Sport too, despite the fact that many schools push medal-winning for the few over participation for the many.

ILikeToSleepALot · 17/05/2023 11:22

YABU. I would say most artistic activities are for everyone to enjoy regardless of skill, but singing is not one of those things. It's very unpleasant to endure listening to someone who sings badly, much more so than it is to look at paintings made by someone who can't paint very well, or to read a poem written by someone who can't write very well. It's an assault on the senses! One terrible singer in a choir can ruin it for everyone. It's perfectly normal to lack aptitude for some things and it shouldn't be seen as an offense or a trauma to be told so.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 11:21

We’re just talking about an after school choir that meet up and practice, not the school curriculum. In which music is offered to all pupils.

I don’t know why parents think schools should or are able to cater for every child’s whim under the guise of “inclusivity”

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 10:46

Because it’s an inclusive school that values all the children - and it is a very happy school.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 10:45

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:56

A lot of parents can’t pay for private tuition, you’re right so where does that leave the gifted musicians at school that require nurturing or tuition or valuable experience to access a place at music college or a scholarship?

Their only choice would be a fun community school choir?

There are plenty of spaces for a child to sing for fun which isn’t choir.
Local groups/ clubs , teen friends getting together and putting their songs on TikTok, buy a second hand karaoke machine and invite their mates over?

Again, it seems to be a choice between nurturing the gifted vs allowing everyone to enjoy music.

In some schools at least.

Other schools (eg my DC state school) seem to manage this perfectly well.

cestlavielife · 17/05/2023 10:26

where does that leave the gifted musicians at school that require nurturing or tuition or valuable experience to access a place at music college or a scholarship?

There are schemes for those kids.
Op admits her dc is not in the gifted category

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 08:56

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:45

Yes because it’s that easy for many parents to pay for such a thing.

Also, most children want to sing in a choir with others rather than alone in a room.

Your response just illustrates your utter lack of ability to see other people’s point of view

A lot of parents can’t pay for private tuition, you’re right so where does that leave the gifted musicians at school that require nurturing or tuition or valuable experience to access a place at music college or a scholarship?

Their only choice would be a fun community school choir?

There are plenty of spaces for a child to sing for fun which isn’t choir.
Local groups/ clubs , teen friends getting together and putting their songs on TikTok, buy a second hand karaoke machine and invite their mates over?

NoraBattysCurlers · 17/05/2023 08:55

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

What is really sad are young adults who completely collapse at the first setback.

Your child is not a young kid. She is an 11 year-old. Infantilising her does her no favours.

JediIsMyMaster · 17/05/2023 08:51

To be clear, I have no issue with community choirs - I think they’re great! I just don’t enjoy participating in them.

But I’m an adult, and have had opportunities in the past. Most of those opportunities in respect of singing came from my (auditioned) school choir. A non-auditioned one would not have provided the same opportunities (and actually our school did have both some years, other years there wasn’t enough take-up to run the non-auditioned one).

I don’t see a problem with children with potential being supported to reach it. There was always opportunity to sing at school without being part of the formal choir - assemblies, music lessons etc. Is this no longer the case?

Eleganz · 17/05/2023 08:48

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:44

Yup. And in my view, the needs of the children who would like to sing are just as important. And with a good enough teacher, both can be accommodated.

I think that with limited resources one cannot do everything. Taking an auditioned group is very different to taking an unauditioned one. The idea that music teachers are only "good enough" if they can do both and have the time to do both is totally unrealistic and unfair on them.

Eleganz · 17/05/2023 08:46

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:39

Well you get to choose between the few who are in it for competition vs the many who are in it for pleasure.

In a SCHOOL I vote the latter.
And with a good enough teacher who can sub-divide the singers it need not exclude talent at all.

Well that is your opinion. Do you have any evidence that it is better for encouraging more diversity in the performing arts professionally?

I'm sorry, but how do you "subdivide" singers within a choir at different abilities? This isn't maths lessons... you need everyone sing the same piece at the same time or it isn't a choir. I suppose you might be able to get a few solos but if you start having semi-choruses doing hard stuff then lots of kids will be stood around doing nothing for a large parts of the rehearsal or you are going to need separate rehearsals and essentially you have an auditioned group within the wider group and it takes up even more time to direct.

I've directed a far few choirs and the reality is that you are only able to go at the pace of your least able singers in the vast majority of cases.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:45

Berthatydfil · 17/05/2023 08:44

YABU. Do your child a favour and teach them some emotional resilience it will pay dividends in life when they suffer bigger disappointments.
However if she is really interested in singing get her signed up for some lessons from a professional singing teacher and ask their honest opinion on her ability. If they say she has some potential then she can try out again.

Yes because it’s that easy for many parents to pay for such a thing.

Also, most children want to sing in a choir with others rather than alone in a room.

Your response just illustrates your utter lack of ability to see other people’s point of view

Berthatydfil · 17/05/2023 08:44

YABU. Do your child a favour and teach them some emotional resilience it will pay dividends in life when they suffer bigger disappointments.
However if she is really interested in singing get her signed up for some lessons from a professional singing teacher and ask their honest opinion on her ability. If they say she has some potential then she can try out again.

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:44

Eleganz · 17/05/2023 08:41

Because you have to balance that against the needs of the smaller talented group of children who can flourish and potentially go on to be highly skilled musicians if they are given the right opportunities to develop and you only have limited resources at your disposal.

It is no different to any other talent-driven activity.

Yup. And in my view, the needs of the children who would like to sing are just as important. And with a good enough teacher, both can be accommodated.

Eleganz · 17/05/2023 08:41

Famzonhol · 17/05/2023 08:34

But that’s exactly my point. What’s wrong with a jolly singalong for children at school level? Why exclude the many children who would like to do precisely that very thing?

Because you have to balance that against the needs of the smaller talented group of children who can flourish and potentially go on to be highly skilled musicians if they are given the right opportunities to develop and you only have limited resources at your disposal.

It is no different to any other talent-driven activity.

Swipe left for the next trending thread