Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 07:28

O h FFS. In my first line I obviously meant INclusivity.

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 07:27

There are at least a couple of aspects of singing in particular that make exclusivity important. First, it's entry level exposure to music and musicality - pretty much everyone has a voice, anyone can 'sing' in the sense of putting words to a tune. Then there's the health aspect, the awareness of body, posture , breathing it promotes. Then there's the emotional aspect - how intimate and personal our voices are to us. There's something quite uniquely crushing about being told you can't sing.

if resources in a school are such that there aren't enough for both an auditioning and a non-auditioning choir, the latter should have priority. An older, talented student could be given a chance to organise a small chamber ensemble. Pitching (ha) choral singing as an exclusively elite activity that you need to meet a defined standard for is a recipe for putting swathes of future adults off music for life. And then we wonder why people aren't culturally engaged.

usernother · 14/05/2023 07:26

When I was at primary school we each had to stand up behind our desks and sing a song solo. It was then decided who would be in the choir. I wasn't. And that's the way it was. No idea if anyone was upset by it, but there is no point in your daughter thinking she's a good singer if she isn't.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 14/05/2023 07:26

Eleganz · 14/05/2023 07:21

I suppose it is easy to say they should also run an unauditioned choir, but perhaps they don't have the time? Unfortunately, whilst it is not popular, the pursuit of excellence and complete inclusion are often at odds with each other. Do you think that the Methody College Choir who sung in Westminster Abbey alongside the Abbey Choir at the coronation were an unauditioned group?

I sing at quite a high level and in a range of unauditioned and auditioned ensembles (including conducting a few of the unauditioned ones). I love all my choirs, but the auditioned ones are clearly more challenging, tackle a wider ranger of repertoire and achieve higher standards of performance. We need both types of groups to creat a thriving musical life.

As others have said, you need to support your daughter and let her focus on other strengths she may have or look for another choir that she can join.

If they don’t have a sufficiently large music department with time to run two choirs, I think they should focus their time on running an inclusive choir, rather than an exclusive one.

Gtsr443 · 14/05/2023 07:26

Bollocks to the dreary school choir.
Find your daughter an inclusive extra curricular performance group away from school.
There are plenty of excellent arts organisations out there who are about inclusivity and fun.
Don't let this knock her confidence or interest in music and performance.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:25

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 14/05/2023 07:14

A lot of PPs have repeated the myth that anyone can be taught to sing. This is nof the case because some people are afflicted with amusia and cannot discern different pitches. Some people are also deaf or hearing-impaired.

That's a tiny proportion of people, hardly disproves the point. We evolved to sing, it's how information was passed down, go back a few generations and ordinary people would sing together without it being at all competitive.

Siriusmuggle · 14/05/2023 07:25

That’s how choirs work though, and pretty much everything in the music world. My son didn’t get in the choir in year 7 but re auditioned in year 8 and got in and stayed in until he left school. He’s now at a conservatoire and the same applies- he auditioned for the orchestra and didn’t get in, he’ll try again next September.
All kids aren’t good at everything so why do they need to think they are? They’re all good at something and that’s the thing to be celebrated.

ehb102 · 14/05/2023 07:25

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 14/05/2023 05:44

Anyone? My husband is completely tone deaf. Can tone deaf people be taught to sing if they just don't have that instinct for pitch? Doesn't matter though, he's got his own strengths.

True tone deafness - when you can't be recognise one tune from another let alone sing it - is rare. It's like a form of amnesia apparently. Most people simply get told they can't sing before they have learned to pitch. My husband is like this, has a reasonable voice but never practices so is not a singer and never improves. Yet he has excellent rhythm and an amazing ear for music, much better than me who had masses of musical education.

I say singing is like running. There are some cases when people literally can't do it, but they are rare. Mostly we say "can't" to mean "cannot do it in a way that is judged by others to be good enough". I can't run but you can better your bottom dollar if someone shouted "bomb" I'd manage a sprint!

I took lessons as an adult to learn how to use my voice effectively and I wish I had done so as a young teen. Pitch and tone are important to a singer and if the OPs daughter has pitch but hasn't learned tone or style of singing then I can see why she has been rejected. It feels harsh at that age, but this is her learning opportunity.

I go to my daughter's school to run a singing club for her year. That is all about fun and learning, no auditions. They are eight years old so we have an open enthusiastic ethos. It's hard but that's what we chose. I wouldn't expect that ethos at a secondary school level.

alwaysmovingforwards · 14/05/2023 07:25

soupmaker · 14/05/2023 05:44

It's rubbish for your DD but this is a life lesson. We need to prepare our kids for disappointment and rejection. Resilience in the face of disappointment is a key life skill.

Agree.
Telling them their perfect and shielding them from reality just creates confusion for them as they become adults.

snowgal · 14/05/2023 07:23

They have to audition to be in the choir at my kids primary school, which is for year 3 and upwards, they don't all get in as they need to be at a certain standard to enter competitions etc. Unfortunately it's a life lesson as others have said, and I genuinely think dealing with rejection earlier in life makes it easier.

FeelingLikeAShitMother · 14/05/2023 07:22

My school had a choir (anyone could turn up) and a ‘senior vocal group’ (invite only). That seemed to work really well. I do think everyone should have the opportunity to sing in a group.

Hal9001 · 14/05/2023 07:22

Flibbyjibby · 14/05/2023 06:51

As a music teacher, I strongly believe that anybody can and should be allowed to sing! Being part of a musical ensemble like a choir is great for feeling a sense of belonging and community (especially important in y7) and fosters a love for music.

Yes I have pupils who struggle with pitch, intonation etc. But funnily enough, everything can be improved through practice and familiarity.

I wouldn’t dream of rejecting any child from our choirs, and I despise the elitist mentality some schools have regarding music. Private tuition is expensive and not every parent has the means or sees the value in investing in this for their child.

The bottom line is this: Music is for everyone. The school is wrong. If this is their outlook then they can’t have a particularly thriving music department.

Yes! Music is absolutely for everyone.

But not everyone can perform music.

And I believe that anyone can be taught how to sing.

As anyone can be taught to play an instrument. I love music. I have a grade 8 at violin. Am I any good at the violin? Not really, I don't have what it takes. I can do it, but I can't 'really 'play the violin', it's just not there for me in the way it is for proper musicians that have a passion for the violin.

I actually prefer singing and don't have a bad ear. Am I a great singer? No. Even though I understand and appreciate music, and can hold a note, I even have a bit of personality in the way I sing.

I'm just someone that enjoys singing.

No-one's ever wanted me in their choir.

Prisonbreak · 14/05/2023 07:22

Yabu. Would you want someone who couldn’t play the violin in the orchestra? No and they would absolutely be heard over the other musicians. She will be better at some stuff than others. Not a big deal

Eleganz · 14/05/2023 07:21

I suppose it is easy to say they should also run an unauditioned choir, but perhaps they don't have the time? Unfortunately, whilst it is not popular, the pursuit of excellence and complete inclusion are often at odds with each other. Do you think that the Methody College Choir who sung in Westminster Abbey alongside the Abbey Choir at the coronation were an unauditioned group?

I sing at quite a high level and in a range of unauditioned and auditioned ensembles (including conducting a few of the unauditioned ones). I love all my choirs, but the auditioned ones are clearly more challenging, tackle a wider ranger of repertoire and achieve higher standards of performance. We need both types of groups to creat a thriving musical life.

As others have said, you need to support your daughter and let her focus on other strengths she may have or look for another choir that she can join.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 14/05/2023 07:21

I don’t see a problem with the principle of an audition-only choir for this age group. My kids’ school - and in fact my school when I was a kid - had an audition-only choir and a choir anyone who wanted to join could join.

It’s possible to not be amazing at something but enjoy it and derive benefit from it - exercise and sport are like this and in my day so many children were deterred from exercise because school sports failed to appreciate the difference between being good at sports and still enjoying them/enjoying exercise more broadly.

Personally, I think if they haven’t got the time and resources to run both an inclusive and an exclusive one, they should just run an inclusive one.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:21

Neopolitan · 14/05/2023 07:12

You can really see the posters that are 'everyone wins a prize' type friends rather than parents on this thread. They can't see they are not preparing their child for life, they are creating anxiety. I feel sorry for their kids not being prepared for the world.

I see singing as a recreational activity, not a competitive sport. Pp have said singing lessons/reading sheet music are required - basically rich parents and a tiny handful of 11 year olds.

Nothing wrong with kids learning that things don't always go their way, they need to persevere, other people need to be considered etc.

But the 'oh well you'll be crushed by capitalism we might as well start now' mentality is terrible. There are recreational activities that are worth doing for their own sake.

The sports/competitive mentality is what put me off exercise at school - if you're not naturally good at something, you get the message not to bother. There's nothing wrong with doing something for enjoyment, without competition coming into it.

pilates · 14/05/2023 07:19

I would play it down. It’s not a big deal - you can’t be good at everything.

coretext · 14/05/2023 07:18

I work with young adults in a totally unrelated profession. For ( what it seems like) the first time in their lives I have to tell them that occasionally their skills "Need Improvement " or "wasn't up to the expected standard".
Most of them take it in the chin but occasionally I come across a mollycoddled individual who has grown up believing that they are perfect in every way because that's what they've been told or lead to believe.
The dose of reality I provide sometime doesn't go down well.

We need to encourage them to do better. I agree with that, but also teach them resilience, how to handle failure and and recover from it.

Otherwise we are just setting them up to be snowflakes!

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad

Of course we do OP. Don't make a fool of your daughter anymore. Encourage her to get a new interest or hobby

ProudToBeANorthener · 14/05/2023 07:18

Unfortunately, we can’t always have what we want. Watching our children being upset is heartbreaking but it’s a life lesson for us as well as them. We need to accept that our perfect children aren’t. Support her and love her and sing in the car; I’m sure she’ll find her niche. As others have said though, suggest that the school has a choir for children who love to sing. As she improves perhaps she’ll be able to re-audition.

Scirocco · 14/05/2023 07:18

YABU

Auditions indicate that a certain standard is needed. If your DD didn't reach that standard, then she doesn't get a place this time. It's disappointing for her, but it's how these things work, especially for clubs and teams where there's a competitive or performance element.

I remember I was 11 when I didn't get a main children's part in a play I'd auditioned for - I was disappointed, I think I even cried a bit as I loved being on stage and performing. After a hug and a good night's rest, I went in the next day and asked what was wrong with my audition - I got some feedback, made some changes and auditioned the next time, for a smaller part, which I got. The reality was that, while I enjoyed drama, I wasn't that great at it. I was good at the musical and dance bits, but for actual acting, I was ok but not good enough. Eventually, I moved over to the band/orchestra/sound effects side of things, where I was actually much happier.

It's not inappropriate for her to learn about disappointment and her own strengths and weaknesses. It's natural for us to want to protect our DC from anything that upsets them, but the world isn't going to let us. Learning about coping with disappointment from relatively safe things like not getting a place in a competitive team or group, is safer than being confronted with it when the stakes are much higher.

Model for her that it's ok to be disappointed but it's not the end of the world. To quote Bingo from Bluey: Have a little cry, dust yourself off, the show must go on.

ElmTree22 · 14/05/2023 07:16

@tigerdrew
Just because she wants to be in the choir, doesn't mean she has what it takes to do so. They have auditions for a reason, I myself am a performer and have auditioned many times for parts that I wanted but didn't get. That is life! Quite frankly it seems like a good opportunity for you to teach her some life lessons here, she's in secondary school now so she is old enough to understand that life isn't always fair.
Also you can absolutely tell a child, in a kind and constructive way that while you think she has a wonderful voice it's very competitive to get into choirs and to not be disappointed if she doesn't get a place. Otherwise you're setting them up for even bigger disappointment.
From a singer myself. If singing is something she wants to do and YOU believe she has the ability there, then YOU should facilitate this with singing lessons so she can learn how to sing properly, she may then get a chance in a choir. If you don't think her voice is worth paying for lessons, then you shouldn't think it's worth a place in a choir. Sorry, but true.

Side note...you can absolutely hear a bad singer in a group of singers! It's dreadful.

FormerlySpeckledyHen · 14/05/2023 07:15

I have a dreadful singing voice and was in the primary school choir but only allowed to mime.
I don’t think I’ve ever sung out loud around anyone since, although I do sing at home alone as I love music.

octaurpus · 14/05/2023 07:15

I've run a Junior Choir for years. Years 7 & 8. All girls It's a training choir for the upper years' choir, which is selective. Most of my girls have zero singing experience. I do run auditions, just to get a vague idea what I've got to work with. We rehearse weekely, and run an intense 3 day camp at the beginning of Term 2 to prepare for the main school music concert. I think anyone keen enough to endure an audition with a complete stranger and an accompanist deserves a place in the choir. Excellent attendance is compulsory if you want to attend camp, which is hugely popular among the students. Some years are better than others, but we all work bloody hard and by the middle of the year they are always sounding fabulous. Retention into Year 8 is over 90%, and the girls just get better and better.

It is my job to train them. Their job is to show up, and be committed to working together.

I'm very sorry for your DD's experience, OP.

littlefireseverywhere · 14/05/2023 07:15

Get her singing lessons if it’s worrying her. Or she’s very keen. Or, join an out of school more inclusive choir.

100daystogo · 14/05/2023 07:14

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

@tigerdrew im quite a sensitive parent but I had a conversation with my 5 year old last week that they could be anything they want but they can’t do everything. I explained I’m great at English but not at science.

If your DD really wants to be in the choir she isn’t at the right level, she needs singing lessons first.